Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Trade Willis!?

Featured Replies

2) Willis has pitched almost 3 full seasons, only one of which he lost 10 games. Very fallacious to say he is "gauranteed" to lose 10 games every year, or for that matter, that Beckett is gauranteed to win 15 when, in fact, he has never won 15.

 

 

You sure?

Dontrelle:

2004: 10-11

2005: 22-10

 

Beckett:

2005: 15-8

:lol :lol :lol :lol

 

:whistle

 

:thumbup

 

Seriously, you're retarded.

 

F-you man you really act childish when you get your @ss handed to you.

  • Author

It is not easier to get a solid CF than D-Train. I'm talking all star calibar....then we could have all stars in Uggla, Cabrera, CF, Hanley,and maybe Hermida for the future!

 

How many will challenge for the Cy Young at 23? Let's see....Verlander, Liriano, Josh Johnson, A.Sanchez maybe?

 

 

Would you trade Verlander or Liriano for one of those CFs you listed?

 

 

No because Verlander and Liriano are both better than Dontrelle if you ask me (and have more trade value).

I understand that I will be blasted for this.....

 

Anyway, we already have a good young pitching staff and something tells me Dontrelle will not ever have another season like he did last year. Don't get me wrong, I think he's a great young pitcher but I think he's already topped out. I know he is the face of the franchise but what happens if he gets worse every year or worst case he gets injured with that funky delivery?

 

I believe his trade value is at an all time high and we should move him now. Again, I will be blasted for this but I want a STUD CF and some other pitching prospects. The only way to get a young All-star level CF would be to trade Willis.

 

I would make D-Train available to the highest bidder....but maybe thats just me.

 

Beckett, AJ, Sheffield, Etc.....the list goes on and on....we will survive without him and I believe we COULD be a better team if we deal him for the right trade.

 

Would Milledge and Pelfrey make us a better team? I think it just might over the long haul.......

 

whats your take?

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Dont be a TOOL.

 

 

Create this thread after he has a great outing and then I will respond to it like its meritous.

 

:plain

Well I say we should leave this to the people that get paid millions to make desicions like this I TRUST IN BENIFEST :thumbup

2) Willis has pitched almost 3 full seasons, only one of which he lost 10 games. Very fallacious to say he is "gauranteed" to lose 10 games every year, or for that matter, that Beckett is gauranteed to win 15 when, in fact, he has never won 15.

 

 

You sure?

Dontrelle:

2004: 10-11

2005: 22-10

 

Beckett:

2005: 15-8

:lol :lol :lol :lol

 

:whistle

 

:thumbup

 

Seriously, you're retarded.

 

F-you man you really act childish when you get your @ss handed to you.

 

Huh?

 

I wasn't the one who said that Beckett's never won 15 or that Willis has only lost 10 once.

 

I guess my efforts fell on deaf ears.

 

Perhaps someone read, understood and internalized my efforts.

Huh?

 

I wasn't the one who said that Beckett's never won 15 or that Willis has only lost 10 once.

 

I guess my efforts fell on deaf ears.

 

Perhaps someone read, understood and internalized my efforts.

 

 

I didn't have the stats in front of me, but that doesn't change the point of what I said. Beckett has won exactly 15 games just once, yet under your formula he is guaranteed to win 15 games in a full season every year.

 

Willis has had 1 average year, so he is guaranteed to lose 10 in every full season. Your extrapolations are such BS I'm amazed that even you can believe them.

We're the luckiest team in MLB to have Willis. He's not the #1 best pitcher in MLB, but he exemplifies everything great about the game. His love of the game and his style of play(things that are great to see but also help the team) are things that come around once every 50 years. I'd trade Cabrera before trading Willis. I'd love to see him on the team for another 5 years.

 

 

 

 

 

I dont agree with the Cabrera part but the rest of your post is spot on.

 

 

Good post.

We're the luckiest team in MLB to have Willis. He's not the #1 best pitcher in MLB, but he exemplifies everything great about the game. His love of the game and his style of play(things that are great to see but also help the team) are things that come around once every 50 years. I'd trade Cabrera before trading Willis. I'd love to see him on the team for another 5 years.

 

are you sober?

Is UCF such a meh school that you have nothing better to do than sit in front of a computer spouting your nonsense? Seriously, I'd like to know, as my son got accepted into UCF and UF and he's undecided.

 

Anyone who proposes trading Willis is just too young and/or has no prespective of MLB history. A player with the talent, heart, charisma, hustle, fun to watch, personality, humbleness, etc., like Willis.....these kind of players come around once every 50 years. You just do not trade them. Consider yourself lucky that he's on your team. Period.

 

I'm fairly certain a player with talent, heart, charisma, hustle, fun to watch, personality, humbleness, etc comes around more then once every 50 years. My question to you is, who is the only other player in baseball history with these qualities because the sport has pretty much only been around only 100 years.

 

Also, I ask because I went to a meh school called UCF a few years ago and lack perspective on MLB history. btw, got into 9 of 11 law schools I applied to post graduation. I'd ask your son, do you want to pick up your kegs at Kash and Karry in Gainesville or Shamrocks liquor in Orlando?

this pisses me off a bit, talking of trading dontrelle. even though i'm open to do it. i guess it's just sad to see the entire 2003 rotation gone. that i believe would mean cabs is the only world champion fish left. if the marlins are okay w/ trading d-train (it doesn't seem like they are) i wish they would of kept beckett. if we trade dontrelle i'd want it to be a non-NL-East team ...preferably american league. i'd love to see him play for the bosox...lester and pedroia for willis ? is that fair?

i'd love to see him play for the bosox...lester and pedroia for willis ? is that fair?

 

No

NO because that would be a ripoff

2) Willis has pitched almost 3 full seasons, only one of which he lost 10 games. Very fallacious to say he is "gauranteed" to lose 10 games every year, or for that matter, that Beckett is gauranteed to win 15 when, in fact, he has never won 15.

 

 

You sure?

Dontrelle:

2004: 10-11

2005: 22-10

 

Beckett:

2005: 15-8

:lol :lol :lol :lol

 

:whistle

 

:thumbup

 

Seriously, you're retarded.

 

I like how you just pull the part of his post that has some errant facts and then completely ignore the rest of the post.

 

The name calling on this board never ceases to amaze me.. If you don't agree with my opinion, you're retarded! :rolleyes:

The question is when do you say we have the rotation we want to stick with for the next few years. Personally, I like the look of a rotation consisting of Dontrelle Willis, Josh Johnson, Scott Olsen, Anibal Sanchez and Ricky Nolasco for the next few years (at the least).

 

I guess until we have the stadium issue settled, we can expect the Marlins FO to just trade off starting pitchers once they reach about the second year of arbitration (if not earlier) and hope one of the prospects pans out. I think they may make an exception with Dontrelle at this point, but we will have to wait and see.

 

In the meantime, I think we have more than enough pitching prospects to do this AND package one or two of them with Borowski and/or Helms for a very good OF or C prospect.

i'd love to see him play for the bosox...lester and pedroia for willis ? is that fair?

 

No

lester pedroia + hansen would be closer to the worth but still wouldnt help us.

 

IF we do trade willis we need to get back an elite CF and another Good/great position prospect.

 

Really I would rather keep him but if we move him I want to fill our holes on the team for the future.

 

It doesnt matter this year, what matters is 2,3 years down the road. Willis is my favorite player but what matters is the front of the jersey not the back. Even if I would hate to see him go.

Is UCF such a meh school that you have nothing better to do than sit in front of a computer spouting your nonsense? Seriously, I'd like to know, as my son got accepted into UCF and UF and he's undecided.

 

Anyone who proposes trading Willis is just too young and/or has no prespective of MLB history. A player with the talent, heart, charisma, hustle, fun to watch, personality, humbleness, etc., like Willis.....these kind of players come around once every 50 years. You just do not trade them. Consider yourself lucky that he's on your team. Period.

 

I'm fairly certain a player with talent, heart, charisma, hustle, fun to watch, personality, humbleness, etc comes around more then once every 50 years. My question to you is, who is the only other player in baseball history with these qualities because the sport has pretty much only been around only 100 years.

 

Also, I ask because I went to a meh school called UCF a few years ago and lack perspective on MLB history. btw, got into 9 of 11 law schools I applied to post graduation. I'd ask your son, do you want to pick up your kegs at Kash and Karry in Gainesville or Shamrocks liquor in Orlando?

If I had to name one player, I'd say Willie Mays. Can you name any others? I'm sure I'm missing some, I guess. As for UCF, my question was a serious one. I wasn't casting aspersions on UCF. It's a fine school, as far as I'm concerned. I'm sure if you were so successful in being accepted into so many law schools(congratulations) your college experience went somewhat beyond what place to buy a keg. So, if you had to do it again, and you had the choice of UCF or UF as an undergraduate, what's your advice.

It is not easier to get a solid CF than D-Train. I'm talking all star calibar....then we could have all stars in Uggla, Cabrera, CF, Hanley,and maybe Hermida for the future!

 

How many will challenge for the Cy Young at 23? Let's see....Verlander, Liriano, Josh Johnson, A.Sanchez maybe?

 

Getting a little crazy there man.

 

 

Johnson has a 2.49 at age 22 on a bad team.

 

Sanchez has a 3.41 ERA at age 22 on a bad team (his era is only 1.41 as a starter).

 

What can these guys do on a good team?

 

Some of you don't understand how good these guys are.....

 

You are forgetting that Lou demands we trade Scotty O/JJ/Sanchez for a CF prospect in every other post.

 

He really doesnt appreciate them.

You are forgetting that Lou demands we trade Scotty O/JJ/Sanchez for a CF prospect in every other post.

 

He really doesnt appreciate them.

 

Josh Johnson does not get mentioned in the same sentence as Liriano or Verlander. That's just ridiculous.

 

And as I have said before, I do not care what pitcher this organization trades as long as we get back a CF of equal or greater value. We can afford to move one of the current 5 in the rotation to get this done, or we can trade 2-3 minor leaguers. We have depth. It's not a big deal. This has nothing to do with not appreciating them.

 

You know who I don't appreciate - Reggie Abercrombie.

Settle down Sally. The first part of my quote was just a joke.

 

The 2nd part was my own personal feeling.

 

And no, we really cant afford to lose any of the 5 out of our rotation, because we have no one who can take their place and be successful...Mitre, Moehler, Pinto, Petit, and Vargas are about the only options...and I dont think any one wants to replace any of the 5 we have there now with any of those 5.

Settle down Sally. The first part of my quote was just a joke.

 

The 2nd part was my own personal feeling.

 

And no, we really cant afford to lose any of the 5 out of our rotation, because we have no one who can take their place and be successful...Mitre, Moehler, Pinto, Petit, and Vargas are about the only options...and I dont think any one wants to replace any of the 5 we have there now with any of those 5.

 

does sucessful this year even matter really?

And no, we really cant afford to lose any of the 5 out of our rotation, because we have no one who can take their place and be successful...Mitre, Moehler, Pinto, Petit, and Vargas are about the only options...and I dont think any one wants to replace any of the 5 we have there now with any of those 5.

 

Mitre/Moehler/Pinto/Petit/Vargas platoon as our 5th starter > Reggie/Ross/Amezaga platoon in CF EVERYDAY

 

To each his own.

Those 5 platooning as the 5th starter...be about a lock to lose every time the 5th spot in the rotation comes up.

 

We currently dont have that problem, so why change it?

 

it's funny, last year Vargas came up and was pretty good

 

this year he struggles and he becomes a D prospect again

 

I wonder what happens if one of our 4 struggles next year

Those 5 platooning as the 5th starter...be about a lock to lose every time the 5th spot in the rotation comes up.

 

We currently dont have that problem, so why change it?

 

it's funny, last year Vargas came up and was pretty good

 

this year he struggles and he becomes a D prospect again

 

I wonder what happens if one of our 4 struggles next year

 

While I dont think it's fair to say that because Vargas struggled one of the 4 current ones will struggle...basicially because they all have much better stuff than Vargas.

 

But at the same time, I am still very supportive of Vargas. However, currently, you cant count on him to pitch effectively.

Those 5 platooning as the 5th starter...be about a lock to lose every time the 5th spot in the rotation comes up.

 

We currently dont have that problem, so why change it?

 

it's funny, last year Vargas came up and was pretty good

 

this year he struggles and he becomes a D prospect again

 

I wonder what happens if one of our 4 struggles next year

 

While I dont think it's fair to say that because Vargas struggled one of the 4 current ones will struggle...basicially because they all have much better stuff than Vargas.

 

But at the same time, I am still very supportive of Vargas. However, currently, you cant count on him to pitch effectively.

1 of the 4 will struggle at some point next year... it's going to happen

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.