July 23, 200620 yr some of you guys on this board jump on players way to quick, Willis struggled today and still had a solid outing allowing 3 runs in 6 innings with 6 K's, ERA is under 4.00. Keep him.
July 23, 200620 yr Author Willis's record every year.... 2003- (14-6) 2004- (10-11) 2005- (22-10) 2006- (6-7) I think 2005 is the best he will EVER be....Again, I may be wrong but I think he will be around 15-16 wins every year and that is nothing that Nolasco, Olsen, Sanchez, or Johnson can't do.
July 23, 200620 yr Willis's record every year.... 2003- (14-6) 2004- (10-11) 2005- (22-10) 2006- (6-7) I think 2003 is the best he will EVER be....Again, I may be wrong but I think he will be around 15-16 wins every year and that is nothing that Nolasco, Olsen, Sanchez, or Johnson can't do. WTF? 2003 wasnt his best year, 22 wins in 2005....
July 23, 200620 yr Author some of you guys on this board jump on players way to quick, Willis struggled today and still had a solid outing allowing 3 runs in 6 innings with 6 K's, ERA is under 4.00. Keep him. How did I jump on him???? He's my #1 favorite Marlin who just happens to have some of the top trade value in all of baseball. A trade for an all-star calibar CF and top good pitching prospects would MAKE our team better! I'm all about making the Marlins a better team in the long run.... Willis's record every year.... 2003- (14-6) 2004- (10-11) 2005- (22-10) 2006- (6-7) I think 2003 is the best he will EVER be....Again, I may be wrong but I think he will be around 15-16 wins every year and that is nothing that Nolasco, Olsen, Sanchez, or Johnson can't do. WTF? 2003 wasnt his best year, 22 wins in 2005.... Obviously I meant 2005 and he had a MONSTER lineup behind him. Not taking anything away from him but if these kids in our rotation had that 2005 lineup what would their records be?
July 23, 200620 yr Willis's record every year.... 2003- (14-6) 2004- (10-11) 2005- (22-10) 2006- (6-7) I think 2003 is the best he will EVER be....Again, I may be wrong but I think he will be around 15-16 wins every year and that is nothing that Nolasco, Olsen, Sanchez, or Johnson can't do. why would you look at Willis's history and assume he will regress, but look at the other 4 and assume they will all AT LEAST progress into 15-16 game winners. Do you remember Chuck Smith, Ryan Dempster, Tony Saunders, or Jason Vargas? These guys had early success and couldn't replicate it. Let's not count our chickens before they hatch.
July 23, 200620 yr Author Willis's record every year.... 2003- (14-6) 2004- (10-11) 2005- (22-10) 2006- (6-7) I think 2003 is the best he will EVER be....Again, I may be wrong but I think he will be around 15-16 wins every year and that is nothing that Nolasco, Olsen, Sanchez, or Johnson can't do. why would you look at Willis's history and assume he will regress, but look at the other 4 and assume they will all AT LEAST progress into 15-16 game winners. Do you remember Chuck Smith, Ryan Dempster, Tony Saunders, or Jason Vargas? These guys had early success and couldn't replicate it. Let's not count our chickens before they hatch. First off its all about talent. I follow the Marlins minor leagues very closely....Chuck Smith, Dempster, Saunders, and Vargas don't have half the talent these guys have. Talent....as in STUFF....as in pitches and how nasty they are.
July 23, 200620 yr How did I jump on him???? He's my #1 favorite Marlin who just happens to have some of the top trade value in all of baseball. A trade for an all-star calibar CF and top good pitching prospects would MAKE our team better! I'm all about making the Marlins a better team in the long run.... Is this what our front office has turned us into? At this point we hope to trade away our young stars that pan out for a batch of minor leaguers? Just doesn't seem like much fun to me.
July 23, 200620 yr Willis's record every year.... 2003- (14-6) 2004- (10-11) 2005- (22-10) 2006- (6-7) I think 2003 is the best he will EVER be....Again, I may be wrong but I think he will be around 15-16 wins every year and that is nothing that Nolasco, Olsen, Sanchez, or Johnson can't do. why would you look at Willis's history and assume he will regress, but look at the other 4 and assume they will all AT LEAST progress into 15-16 game winners. Do you remember Chuck Smith, Ryan Dempster, Tony Saunders, or Jason Vargas? These guys had early success and couldn't replicate it. Let's not count our chickens before they hatch. Are you calling Vargas a chicken?? :mischief
July 23, 200620 yr I still dont understand how trading the one great pitcher the marlins have for a couple of "studs" that havent proven anything makes the team better? after this big fire sale you would have to be RETARDED to want to trade willis ... regardless of his record the kid is proven winner
July 23, 200620 yr Author Hopefully we just keep DTrain and add a CF via FA next year Enough with these quick fixes....Borchard, Ross, Abercrombie, Aguila.....they are nice bench players. We don't spend money on big FAs until we get a stadium. We need an all-star type CF who is young like....Chris Young, Carlos Quentin, Carl Crawford, Lastings Milledge....etc.
July 23, 200620 yr First off its all about talent. I follow the Marlins minor leagues very closely....Chuck Smith, Dempster, Saunders, and Vargas don't have half the talent these guys have. Talent....as in STUFF....as in pitches and how nasty they are. Hindsight is 20/20....Of course it's easy to say how much more talented these guys are now. In 3 years your tune may change. Think about what you're saying. How many young stud aces are there in the majors? Maybe 5 or 6 legitimate aces? You are telling me that we just happened to go 4/4 and find baseball's next four young aces? I'd love to believe that, but history would suggest otherwise. All four of these guys have had very good first halves - they haven't even made it through a whole year yet and you are penciling them into the HOF. Counting on them as aces so we could trade Dontrelle seems a bit like gambling.
July 23, 200620 yr Author I still dont understand how trading the one great pitcher the marlins have for a couple of "studs" that havent proven anything makes the team better? after this big fire sale you would have to be RETARDED to want to trade willis ... regardless of his record the kid is proven winner So I'm retarded now? I bet every Marlin fan in their heart would have thought we were going to be a 100 loss team this year. You were asking yourself....Ricky Nolasco for Pierre? We got ripped off. Sanchez and Ramirez for Josh Beckett and Lowell? We got raped! Jacobs and Petit for Delgado? Unbelivable! Guess what buddy.....we are good! In the long run....we raped those teams. And we can be even better....
July 23, 200620 yr I never get some of you on this board..... For 5 years Beckett was untouchable. Nobody would consider trading him even for the best of packages, despite the fact he was injury prone and never touched greatness save for the '03 postseason. Willis has been a true superstar ever since he got here. He's pitched great and stayed healthy, yet everyone wants to unload him before he implodes. I don't get it. We have a 24 year old ace that is one of the faces of MLB, much less the Marlins......why do we continually feel the need to hope we can get a great package for him? The problem with Beckett was never inconsistency, it was health. The problem with Willis is inconsistency. There's a big difference and why I felt one was emminently more untouchable than the other (and, in case you're wondering, I think we picked the wrong pony). Please explain to me how Beckett is more consistent than Willis.... Beckett's stats: 2001: 2-2 (4 games as a September callup), 24 K's in 24 IP, 1.50 ERA, 1.042 WHIP 2002: 6-7, 21 starts, 113 K's in 107 IP, 4.10 ERA, 1.272 WHIP 2003: 9-8, 23 starts, 152 K's in 142.0 IP, 3.04 ERA, 1.324 WHIP 2004: 9-9, 26 starts, 152 K's in 156 IP, 3.79 ERA, 1.219 WHIP 2005: 15-8, 29 starts, 166 K's in 179 IP, 3.38 ERA, 1.181 ERA 2006 (projected): 19-8, 32 starts, 162 K's in 194 IP, 4.78 ERA, 1.214 WHIP Willis' stats: 2003: 14-6, 27 starts, 142 K's in 160 IP, 3.30 ERA 1.282 WHIP 2004: 10-11, 32 starts, 139 K's in 197 IP, 4.02 ERA, 1.376 WHIP 2005: 22-10, 34 starts, 170 K's in 236 IP, 2.63 ERA, 1.134 WHIP 2006 (projected): 10-11, 34 starts, 149 K's in 232 IP, 3.97 ERA, 1.43 WHIP Pepsi challenge those numbers, and you'll take player 1 ten times out of ten. Beckett has come close to 30 starts twice in his career and in those two seasons, he'll finish with 15 wins and a projected 19 wins. In Dontrelle's 30 start seasons, he's finished with 10 wins, 22 wins and a projected 10 wins. Then consider that Beckett sports a WHIP routinely lower that Dontrelle's (the great measuring stick for pitchers) and you see why one's superior and pitching elsewhere. I don't see how you can make the case that Dontrelle is substantially more consistent, or even more consistent, than Beckett, unless you want to make the case that he (Willis) consistently alternates good seasons and bad seasons.
July 23, 200620 yr Hopefully we just keep DTrain and add a CF via FA next year Enough with these quick fixes....Borchard, Ross, Abercrombie, Aguila.....they are nice bench players. We don't spend money on big FAs until we get a stadium. We need an all-star type CF who is young like....Chris Young, Carlos Quentin, Carl Crawford, Lastings Milledge....etc. Just another dose of reality.....none of those guys are all stars. Why would you trade a bona-fide superstar for a potentially great player that has no track record? At what point do we keep the guys we have and try to start winning?
July 23, 200620 yr I still dont understand how trading the one great pitcher the marlins have for a couple of "studs" that havent proven anything makes the team better? We've only done it with superior pitchers (Beckett, Brown, Leiter) three times before...
July 23, 200620 yr Author I still dont understand how trading the one great pitcher the marlins have for a couple of "studs" that havent proven anything makes the team better? We've only done it with superior pitchers (Beckett, Brown, Leiter) three times before... Don't forget Livan Hernandez.....omg everyone thought he would be an all star EVERY year! Sure, he's a workhorse like Willis who can have great seasons. But Livan came back down to earth based on what his TALENT showed....a good but not great pitcher. Same can be said for Willis. He reminds me of what Hideo Nomo did in the early 90s....although I do think he's better than Nomo.
July 23, 200620 yr At what point do we keep the guys we have and try to start winning? Ummm....have we ever?
July 23, 200620 yr Author Pitchers like Verlander and Liriano have ace stuff. I don't think Willis has ace stuff. Will Verlander and Liriano live up to their potential? I don't know but they have always been #1 starters in the minors. Willis was a PTBL in a trade...some of you forget that he was never a top prospect in baseball. Does that mean anything? no....but it makes you wonder if he just burst onto the scene like Livan and Nomo and is fixing to come back down to Earth......
July 23, 200620 yr Beckett's stats: 2001: 2-2 (4 games as a September callup), 24 K's in 24 IP, 1.50 ERA, 1.042 WHIP 2002: 6-7, 21 starts, 113 K's in 107 IP, 4.10 ERA, 1.272 WHIP 2003: 9-8, 23 starts, 152 K's in 142.0 IP, 3.04 ERA, 1.324 WHIP 2004: 9-9, 26 starts, 152 K's in 156 IP, 3.79 ERA, 1.219 WHIP 2005: 15-8, 29 starts, 166 K's in 179 IP, 3.38 ERA, 1.181 ERA 2006 (projected): 19-8, 32 starts, 162 K's in 194 IP, 4.78 ERA, 1.214 WHIP Willis' stats: 2003: 14-6, 27 starts, 142 K's in 160 IP, 3.30 ERA 1.282 WHIP 2004: 10-11, 32 starts, 139 K's in 197 IP, 4.02 ERA, 1.376 WHIP 2005: 22-10, 34 starts, 170 K's in 236 IP, 2.63 ERA, 1.134 WHIP 2006 (projected): 10-11, 34 starts, 149 K's in 232 IP, 3.97 ERA, 1.43 WHIP Pepsi challenge those numbers, and you'll take player 1 ten times out of ten. Beckett has come close to 30 starts twice in his career and in those two seasons, he'll finish with 15 wins and a projected 19 wins. In Dontrelle's 30 start seasons, he's finished with 10 wins, 22 wins and a projected 10 wins. Then consider that Beckett sports a WHIP routinely lower that Dontrelle's (the great measuring stick for pitchers) and you see why one's superior and pitching elsewhere. I don't see how you can make the case that Dontrelle is substantially more consistent, or even more consistent, than Beckett, unless you want to make the case that he (Willis) consistently alternates good seasons and bad seasons. You are the one telling me that Dontrelle is inconsistent and Beckett is consistent. Look at those numbers reasonably and explain to me how Beckett is more consistent. Dontrelle has been consistently good, if not great. He's been the workhorse of the rotation since he entered the league, and has always been a winner. How can you possibly say that Willis has been up and down if you wouldn't say the same about Beckett? Your argument has no legs to stand on here.
July 23, 200620 yr Author Beckett's stats: 2001: 2-2 (4 games as a September callup), 24 K's in 24 IP, 1.50 ERA, 1.042 WHIP 2002: 6-7, 21 starts, 113 K's in 107 IP, 4.10 ERA, 1.272 WHIP 2003: 9-8, 23 starts, 152 K's in 142.0 IP, 3.04 ERA, 1.324 WHIP 2004: 9-9, 26 starts, 152 K's in 156 IP, 3.79 ERA, 1.219 WHIP 2005: 15-8, 29 starts, 166 K's in 179 IP, 3.38 ERA, 1.181 ERA 2006 (projected): 19-8, 32 starts, 162 K's in 194 IP, 4.78 ERA, 1.214 WHIP Willis' stats: 2003: 14-6, 27 starts, 142 K's in 160 IP, 3.30 ERA 1.282 WHIP 2004: 10-11, 32 starts, 139 K's in 197 IP, 4.02 ERA, 1.376 WHIP 2005: 22-10, 34 starts, 170 K's in 236 IP, 2.63 ERA, 1.134 WHIP 2006 (projected): 10-11, 34 starts, 149 K's in 232 IP, 3.97 ERA, 1.43 WHIP Pepsi challenge those numbers, and you'll take player 1 ten times out of ten. Beckett has come close to 30 starts twice in his career and in those two seasons, he'll finish with 15 wins and a projected 19 wins. In Dontrelle's 30 start seasons, he's finished with 10 wins, 22 wins and a projected 10 wins. Then consider that Beckett sports a WHIP routinely lower that Dontrelle's (the great measuring stick for pitchers) and you see why one's superior and pitching elsewhere. I don't see how you can make the case that Dontrelle is substantially more consistent, or even more consistent, than Beckett, unless you want to make the case that he (Willis) consistently alternates good seasons and bad seasons. You are the one telling me that Dontrelle is inconsistent and Beckett is consistent. Look at those numbers reasonably and explain to me how Beckett is more consistent. Dontrelle has been consistently good, if not great. He's been the workhorse of the rotation since he entered the league, and has always been a winner. How can you possibly say that Willis has been up and down if you wouldn't say the same about Beckett? Your argument has no legs to stand on here. They are both inconsistent but I'd rather have Beckett in the future.
July 23, 200620 yr At what point do we keep the guys we have and try to start winning? Ummm....have we ever? You're right.....I'm already salivating at the prospect of trading Nolasco/Johnson/Sanchez/Olsen for some young studs. I can only imagine what we can get for them if they can pitch as well as Willis had. When is it too early to start the trade threads on these young guys, because you guys are getting my wheels spinning already.
July 23, 200620 yr Beckett's stats: 2001: 2-2 (4 games as a September callup), 24 K's in 24 IP, 1.50 ERA, 1.042 WHIP 2002: 6-7, 21 starts, 113 K's in 107 IP, 4.10 ERA, 1.272 WHIP 2003: 9-8, 23 starts, 152 K's in 142.0 IP, 3.04 ERA, 1.324 WHIP 2004: 9-9, 26 starts, 152 K's in 156 IP, 3.79 ERA, 1.219 WHIP 2005: 15-8, 29 starts, 166 K's in 179 IP, 3.38 ERA, 1.181 ERA 2006 (projected): 19-8, 32 starts, 162 K's in 194 IP, 4.78 ERA, 1.214 WHIP Willis' stats: 2003: 14-6, 27 starts, 142 K's in 160 IP, 3.30 ERA 1.282 WHIP 2004: 10-11, 32 starts, 139 K's in 197 IP, 4.02 ERA, 1.376 WHIP 2005: 22-10, 34 starts, 170 K's in 236 IP, 2.63 ERA, 1.134 WHIP 2006 (projected): 10-11, 34 starts, 149 K's in 232 IP, 3.97 ERA, 1.43 WHIP Pepsi challenge those numbers, and you'll take player 1 ten times out of ten. Beckett has come close to 30 starts twice in his career and in those two seasons, he'll finish with 15 wins and a projected 19 wins. In Dontrelle's 30 start seasons, he's finished with 10 wins, 22 wins and a projected 10 wins. Then consider that Beckett sports a WHIP routinely lower that Dontrelle's (the great measuring stick for pitchers) and you see why one's superior and pitching elsewhere. I don't see how you can make the case that Dontrelle is substantially more consistent, or even more consistent, than Beckett, unless you want to make the case that he (Willis) consistently alternates good seasons and bad seasons. You are the one telling me that Dontrelle is inconsistent and Beckett is consistent. Look at those numbers reasonably and explain to me how Beckett is more consistent. Dontrelle has been consistently good, if not great. He's been the workhorse of the rotation since he entered the league, and has always been a winner. How can you possibly say that Willis has been up and down if you wouldn't say the same about Beckett? Your argument has no legs to stand on here. You're clearly biased and most likely trying to make an argument to ruffle feathers. Look at the numbers again. One pitcher has improved every year while making more starts than he has in his previous season. Another pitcher hovers around the same number of starts yet fluctuates greatly on his win totals, ERA and WHIP. Willis cannot hold a candle to Beckett in terms of stuff, ability or pitching ability. Beckett's made 30 starts twice and in both cases he will win more games than he loses. Willis has made 30 starts 3 times, and in 2 of those three cases, he will lose more games than he wins. Clearly, the extreme winning season of 2005 is an aberration as Scott Olsen, Josh Johnson, Ricky Nolasco and Anibal Sanchez have proven that it's possible to have a winning record as a starter for the 2006 Florida Marlins, yet Dontrelle is late to the party. I'd say nice try on your part, but that would convey an understanding that your position made a reasonable degree of sense.
July 23, 200620 yr Author At what point do we keep the guys we have and try to start winning? Ummm....have we ever? You're right.....I'm already salivating at the prospect of trading Nolasco/Johnson/Sanchez/Olsen for some young studs. I can only imagine what we can get for them if they can pitch as well as Willis had. When is it too early to start the trade threads on these young guys, because you guys are getting my wheels spinning already. We will win the World Series in 2008 then trade those guys in 2010.
July 23, 200620 yr They are both inconsistent but I'd rather have Beckett in the future. Inconsistent relative to Nolan Ryan and Roger Clemens? You do realize that by your standard there probably are 2 or 3 consistent pitchers in the big leagues?
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.