July 23, 200620 yr Those 5 platooning as the 5th starter...be about a lock to lose every time the 5th spot in the rotation comes up. We currently dont have that problem, so why change it? it's funny, last year Vargas came up and was pretty good this year he struggles and he becomes a D prospect again I wonder what happens if one of our 4 struggles next year While I dont think it's fair to say that because Vargas struggled one of the 4 current ones will struggle...basicially because they all have much better stuff than Vargas. But at the same time, I am still very supportive of Vargas. However, currently, you cant count on him to pitch effectively. 1 of the 4 will struggle at some point next year... it's going to happen Not saying they wont. Just saying the "Vargas did so these guys will" mentality has got to go.
July 23, 200620 yr Those 5 platooning as the 5th starter...be about a lock to lose every time the 5th spot in the rotation comes up. We currently dont have that problem, so why change it? We actually have a huge problem. Marlins centerfielders are hitting .227/.299/.359, and there is nothing coming up the farm system. Also, Mitre/Moehler/Pinto/Vargas/Petit have less then stellar eras, stats, everything this season. But their win loss record is 8-14 in 28 starts. 8-14 is hardly a lock to lose every 5th time. Those last three are all 22/23 years old as well. Vargas could reemerge. Pinto could stop walking people. Petit could regroup from his first bad few outings. There is talent there, unlike CF. This isn't sending total garbage out there, and if none of those guys pan out into a solid back of the rotation starter at worst, you have Jose Garcia and Gaby coming in 1-2 years, with Volstad, Thompson, West, and Sinkbeil a year behind them. We are fine with pitching options longterm by the time we are ready to contend. We need a CF.
July 24, 200620 yr Those 5 platooning as the 5th starter...be about a lock to lose every time the 5th spot in the rotation comes up. We currently dont have that problem, so why change it? it's funny, last year Vargas came up and was pretty good this year he struggles and he becomes a D prospect again I wonder what happens if one of our 4 struggles next year While I dont think it's fair to say that because Vargas struggled one of the 4 current ones will struggle...basicially because they all have much better stuff than Vargas. But at the same time, I am still very supportive of Vargas. However, currently, you cant count on him to pitch effectively. 1 of the 4 will struggle at some point next year... it's going to happen Not saying they wont. Just saying the "Vargas did so these guys will" mentality has got to go. um ok.... that was never my intention more like what would people say next year when of the boys struggles... would they no longer be a prospect?
July 24, 200620 yr Those 5 platooning as the 5th starter...be about a lock to lose every time the 5th spot in the rotation comes up. We currently dont have that problem, so why change it? it's funny, last year Vargas came up and was pretty good this year he struggles and he becomes a D prospect again I wonder what happens if one of our 4 struggles next year While I dont think it's fair to say that because Vargas struggled one of the 4 current ones will struggle...basicially because they all have much better stuff than Vargas. But at the same time, I am still very supportive of Vargas. However, currently, you cant count on him to pitch effectively. 1 of the 4 will struggle at some point next year... it's going to happen Not saying they wont. Just saying the "Vargas did so these guys will" mentality has got to go. um ok.... that was never my intention more like what would people say next year when of the boys struggles... would they no longer be a prospect? I wasnt directing that comment at you. Those 5 platooning as the 5th starter...be about a lock to lose every time the 5th spot in the rotation comes up. We currently dont have that problem, so why change it? We actually have a huge problem. Marlins centerfielders are hitting .227/.299/.359, and there is nothing coming up the farm system. Also, Mitre/Moehler/Pinto/Vargas/Petit have less then stellar eras, stats, everything this season. But their win loss record is 8-14 in 28 starts. 8-14 is hardly a lock to lose every 5th time. Those last three are all 22/23 years old as well. Vargas could reemerge. Pinto could stop walking people. Petit could regroup from his first bad few outings. There is talent there, unlike CF. This isn't sending total garbage out there, and if none of those guys pan out into a solid back of the rotation starter at worst, you have Jose Garcia and Gaby coming in 1-2 years, with Volstad, Thompson, West, and Sinkbeil a year behind them. We are fine with pitching options longterm by the time we are ready to contend. We need a CF. The rotation we currently have could help us contend much faster. I just think you foolishly want to trade young, cheap, extremely talented pitchers that are currently getting the job done at the MLB level for guys that have never played an MLB inning. I like your idea of trading younger prospects, currently in the minors, much better. But there is no way Scotty O/JJ/Sanchez/Nolasco should be dealt.
July 24, 200620 yr 2) Willis has pitched almost 3 full seasons, only one of which he lost 10 games. Very fallacious to say he is "gauranteed" to lose 10 games every year, or for that matter, that Beckett is gauranteed to win 15 when, in fact, he has never won 15. You sure? Dontrelle: 2004: 10-11 2005: 22-10 Beckett: 2005: 15-8 :lol :lol :lol :lol :whistle :thumbup Seriously, you're retarded. F-you man you really act childish when you get your @ss handed to you. I agree with this. 2) Willis has pitched almost 3 full seasons, only one of which he lost 10 games. Very fallacious to say he is "gauranteed" to lose 10 games every year, or for that matter, that Beckett is gauranteed to win 15 when, in fact, he has never won 15. You sure? Dontrelle: 2004: 10-11 2005: 22-10 Beckett: 2005: 15-8 :lol :lol :lol :lol :whistle :thumbup Seriously, you're retarded. I like how you just pull the part of his post that has some errant facts and then completely ignore the rest of the post. The name calling on this board never ceases to amaze me.. If you don't agree with my opinion, you're retarded! I agree with this too. :thumbup BTW, some of you are missing the original point of this thread...Trading Willis for a package of what we sorely lack + some (a top 20 prospect in CF plus whatever else) might just be a good thing for the club. It's not like we can just go out and sign a Grady Sizemore. The only top FA CF is a Torii Hunter who does not fit this clubs ball plan. So to get a guy like Milledge, Young, Kemp..whatever fits this teams model. We have enough pitching in this organization to make up for the loss of a guy like Willis. If can trade high and get some of the proposed packages right now...make it happen. Those 5 platooning as the 5th starter...be about a lock to lose every time the 5th spot in the rotation comes up. We currently dont have that problem, so why change it? it's funny, last year Vargas came up and was pretty good this year he struggles and he becomes a D prospect again I wonder what happens if one of our 4 struggles next year While I dont think it's fair to say that because Vargas struggled one of the 4 current ones will struggle...basicially because they all have much better stuff than Vargas. But at the same time, I am still very supportive of Vargas. However, currently, you cant count on him to pitch effectively. 1 of the 4 will struggle at some point next year... it's going to happen Not saying they wont. Just saying the "Vargas did so these guys will" mentality has got to go. um ok.... that was never my intention more like what would people say next year when of the boys struggles... would they no longer be a prospect? I wasnt directing that comment at you. Those 5 platooning as the 5th starter...be about a lock to lose every time the 5th spot in the rotation comes up. We currently dont have that problem, so why change it? We actually have a huge problem. Marlins centerfielders are hitting .227/.299/.359, and there is nothing coming up the farm system. Also, Mitre/Moehler/Pinto/Vargas/Petit have less then stellar eras, stats, everything this season. But their win loss record is 8-14 in 28 starts. 8-14 is hardly a lock to lose every 5th time. Those last three are all 22/23 years old as well. Vargas could reemerge. Pinto could stop walking people. Petit could regroup from his first bad few outings. There is talent there, unlike CF. This isn't sending total garbage out there, and if none of those guys pan out into a solid back of the rotation starter at worst, you have Jose Garcia and Gaby coming in 1-2 years, with Volstad, Thompson, West, and Sinkbeil a year behind them. We are fine with pitching options longterm by the time we are ready to contend. We need a CF. The rotation we currently have could help us contend much faster. I just think you foolishly want to trade young, cheap, extremely talented pitchers that are currently getting the job done at the MLB level for guys that have never played an MLB inning. I like your idea of trading younger prospects, currently in the minors, much better. But there is no way Scotty O/JJ/Sanchez/Nolasco should be dealt. How else do you propose we get our CF of the future that we so badly need and will NEVER be able to compete without ? Despite how good our staff might be... For the life of me I can't understand how people can't put this together, we have a HUGE hole in CF that can only be manned right now by AA guys or 5th OF's on a competing club. We also have about 10 starting pitchers with enormous value to us and others clubs...why oh why can't we trade one of those guys to get us that elite CF we so badly need ?
July 24, 200620 yr How else do you propose we get our CF of the future that we so badly need and will NEVER be able to compete without ? Despite how good our staff might be... For the life of me I can't understand how people can't put this together, we have a HUGE hole in CF that can only be manned right now by AA guys or 5th OF's on a competing club. We also have about 10 starting pitchers with enormous value to us and others clubs...why oh why can't we trade one of those guys to get us that elite CF we so badly need ? If these guys are so enormously valuable why don't we trade a few of them for the CF of our dreams? Why do we need to trade Willis?
July 24, 200620 yr I think there is more consensus on this board then I had thought. We do need to trade for a CF..sooner than later. Definitely before next season. But we DO NOT need to trade Dontrelle to do this. I would personally prefer the lesser of JJ/Olsen/Anibel/Nolasco and/or 1 or 2 of our highly regarded SP prospects. We don't need to trade Dontrelle to get our missing piece, or pieces depending on one's perspective. (I personally like Olivo). This thread initally got me so fired up because the mere idea of actively looking to trade Dontrelle is ridiculous. If we get a too good to be true offer, then in Admin B. I trust. And good luck determining which one of our current Big 4 to trade if that's the plan...each of those guys looks so good its scary. We should be in the driver's seat here. Are you telling me Arizona wants to go into next year with too many outfielders and no pitchers outside of Brandon Webb? There is no reason we can't get a stud CF next year. Keep Dontrelle!
July 24, 200620 yr How else do you propose we get our CF of the future that we so badly need and will NEVER be able to compete without ? Despite how good our staff might be... For the life of me I can't understand how people can't put this together, we have a HUGE hole in CF that can only be manned right now by AA guys or 5th OF's on a competing club. We also have about 10 starting pitchers with enormous value to us and others clubs...why oh why can't we trade one of those guys to get us that elite CF we so badly need ? If these guys are so enormously valuable why don't we trade a few of them for the CF of our dreams? Why do we need to trade Willis? We should, I have no problem with that. Some on this board though have this notion that we need to hold on to Olsen, JJ and whoever else too though. If it takes a Dontrelle and Dontrelle only though to get us a Crawford, Milledge or Chris Young + some, I say do it.
July 24, 200620 yr Just a thought regarding a CFer and I realize this is supposed to be about trading Willis...but since Freel is on fire in Cincy, Denorfia is not getting much playing time, and it might be worth watching to see if that pattern continues up until the trading deadline. The more Freel becomes a fixture in the outfield the less important Denorfia is to their playoff efforts.
July 24, 200620 yr We should, I have no problem with that. Some on this board though have this notion that we need to hold on to Olsen, JJ and whoever else too though. If it takes a Dontrelle and Dontrelle only though to get us a Crawford, Milledge or Chris Young + some, I say do it. My question is why would you trade a star for a potential star? My take on Beinfest saying "only if we're blown away" is that the only way he's traded is if we get maybe 3 potential stars. It doesn't make sense to pawn him off for any one minor leaguer IMO, because the best they could become is essentially what we are giving the other team.
July 24, 200620 yr trade Dontrelle? Any sane FO would be thinking about signing him to a long term contract
July 24, 200620 yr I understand that I will be blasted for this..... Anyway, we already have a good young pitching staff and something tells me Dontrelle will not ever have another season like he did last year. Don't get me wrong, I think he's a great young pitcher but I think he's already topped out. I know he is the face of the franchise but what happens if he gets worse every year or worst case he gets injured with that funky delivery? I believe his trade value is at an all time high and we should move him now. Again, I will be blasted for this but I want a STUD CF and some other pitching prospects. The only way to get a young All-star level CF would be to trade Willis. I would make D-Train available to the highest bidder....but maybe thats just me. Beckett, AJ, Sheffield, Etc.....the list goes on and on....we will survive without him and I believe we COULD be a better team if we deal him for the right trade. Would Milledge and Pelfrey make us a better team? I think it just might over the long haul....... whats your take? I think the best thing would be is trade him to the Sox for Lester and other prospects. If not trade him to the Mets for Maine and other prospects.
July 24, 200620 yr Author trade Dontrelle? Any sane FO would be thinking about signing him to a long term contract I'm sure you thought the same about Beckett and that worked out pretty good....we've been trading and re-tooling for years and we've won as many rings as almost anyone. I like our strategy. I understand that I will be blasted for this..... Anyway, we already have a good young pitching staff and something tells me Dontrelle will not ever have another season like he did last year. Don't get me wrong, I think he's a great young pitcher but I think he's already topped out. I know he is the face of the franchise but what happens if he gets worse every year or worst case he gets injured with that funky delivery? I believe his trade value is at an all time high and we should move him now. Again, I will be blasted for this but I want a STUD CF and some other pitching prospects. The only way to get a young All-star level CF would be to trade Willis. I would make D-Train available to the highest bidder....but maybe thats just me. Beckett, AJ, Sheffield, Etc.....the list goes on and on....we will survive without him and I believe we COULD be a better team if we deal him for the right trade. Would Milledge and Pelfrey make us a better team? I think it just might over the long haul....... whats your take? I think the best thing would be is trade him to the Sox for Lester and other prospects. If not trade him to the Mets for Maine and other prospects. Mets would have to include Pelfrey and Milledge I believe and I doubt they would. I like Lester but I'd rather have the Dodgers, D-Backs, or Angels prospects....they are very good! I've been wating Quentin for a long time and he has 2 HRs in 8 ABs for the D-Backs already. He would fit our lineup great!
July 24, 200620 yr We should, I have no problem with that. Some on this board though have this notion that we need to hold on to Olsen, JJ and whoever else too though. If it takes a Dontrelle and Dontrelle only though to get us a Crawford, Milledge or Chris Young + some, I say do it. My question is why would you trade a star for a potential star? Because it might be the best and only way to get the elite CF that we need, while still having an above average pitching staff. Crawford is not a potential star, Milledge is as close to a sure thing as you can get in CF, and Chris Young is a top prospect plus you'd probably get another 1 or 2 top prospects from the Dbacks.
July 24, 200620 yr Anyway, we already have a good young pitching staff and something tells me Dontrelle will not ever have another season like he did last year. Don't get me wrong, I think he's a great young pitcher but I think he's already topped out. I know he is the face of the franchise but what happens if he gets worse every year or worst case he gets injured with that funky delivery? I believe his trade value is at an all time high and we should move him now. I really can't follow your line of thinking... Something tells you he won't have another season like last year? And what would that be? What makes you think he's topped out? And if he won't ever have a season like last year, how can his value right now be at an all-time high if he's having a down year as you imply? And what if he DOESN'T get worse every year? What if he DOESN'T get injured? What if the guy we get in return gets injured? What if the stud CF prospect doesn't pan out? Wheeee!
July 24, 200620 yr Author Anyway, we already have a good young pitching staff and something tells me Dontrelle will not ever have another season like he did last year. Don't get me wrong, I think he's a great young pitcher but I think he's already topped out. I know he is the face of the franchise but what happens if he gets worse every year or worst case he gets injured with that funky delivery? I believe his trade value is at an all time high and we should move him now. I really can't follow your line of thinking... Something tells you he won't have another season like last year? And what would that be? What makes you think he's topped out? And if he won't ever have a season like last year, how can his value right now be at an all-time high if he's having a down year as you imply? And what if he DOESN'T get worse every year? What if he DOESN'T get injured? What if the guy we get in return gets injured? What if the stud CF prospect doesn't pan out? Wheeee! Well, all the other prospects have worked out.....I'll trust whatever Beinfest does but we obviously need a real CF sometime soon.
July 24, 200620 yr Pitchers like Verlander and Liriano have ace stuff. I don't think Willis has ace stuff. Will Verlander and Liriano live up to their potential? I don't know but they have always been #1 starters in the minors. Willis was a PTBL in a trade...some of you forget that he was never a top prospect in baseball. Does that mean anything? no....but it makes you wonder if he just burst onto the scene like Livan and Nomo and is fixing to come back down to Earth...... Wow thats one of the stupidest comments ive ever heard. You know that Johan Santana was a Rule V draft pick. Or Albert Pujols was a 13th round pick. (BTW Willis was an 8th round pick) there are tons of cases like this. To say that the reason why he isnt going to become an ace is because a PTBNL is just flat out rediculous. Oh yea dont forget the career 2.31 era in the minors either. But no that means nothing.
July 24, 200620 yr Trade Willis? While no player is truly untouchable... it's not worth pursuing. Just keep saying no until something blows you away.
July 24, 200620 yr It is not easier to get a solid CF than D-Train. I'm talking all star calibar....then we could have all stars in Uggla, Cabrera, CF, Hanley,and maybe Hermida for the future! How many will challenge for the Cy Young at 23? Let's see....Verlander, Liriano, Josh Johnson, A.Sanchez maybe? Getting a little crazy there man. Johnson has a 2.49 at age 22 on a bad team. Sanchez has a 3.41 ERA at age 22 on a bad team (his era is only 1.41 as a starter). What can these guys do on a good team? Some of you don't understand how good these guys are..... Is UCF such a meh school that you have nothing better to do than sit in front of a computer spouting your nonsense? Seriously, I'd like to know, as my son got accepted into UCF and UF and he's undecided. Tell him to go to UF. Trust me. It is not easier to get a solid CF than D-Train. I'm talking all star calibar....then we could have all stars in Uggla, Cabrera, CF, Hanley,and maybe Hermida for the future! How many will challenge for the Cy Young at 23? Let's see....Verlander, Liriano, Josh Johnson, A.Sanchez maybe? Getting a little crazy there man. Johnson has a 2.49 at age 22 on a bad team. Sanchez has a 3.41 ERA at age 22 on a bad team (his era is only 1.41 as a starter). What can these guys do on a good team? Some of you don't understand how good these guys are..... Concept of a small sample size escapes you, eh? They're all good, very good in fact, but basing future Cy Young awards based on less than a full season of work (and in the case of Anibal, about a month's worth) is the apex of foolishness. Exactly. You don't base Cy Young deservingness on such a small period of time. Yes, both Anibal and Josh are very good but to say that they each deserve a Cy Young for what they've shown so far is indeed foolish.
July 24, 200620 yr Author It is not easier to get a solid CF than D-Train. I'm talking all star calibar....then we could have all stars in Uggla, Cabrera, CF, Hanley,and maybe Hermida for the future! How many will challenge for the Cy Young at 23? Let's see....Verlander, Liriano, Josh Johnson, A.Sanchez maybe? Getting a little crazy there man. Johnson has a 2.49 at age 22 on a bad team. Sanchez has a 3.41 ERA at age 22 on a bad team (his era is only 1.41 as a starter). What can these guys do on a good team? Some of you don't understand how good these guys are..... Is UCF such a meh school that you have nothing better to do than sit in front of a computer spouting your nonsense? Seriously, I'd like to know, as my son got accepted into UCF and UF and he's undecided. Tell him to go to UF. Trust me. Depends what he wants to major in....
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.