How are the comparisons bogus?

 

Look up like four posts.

 

Now stop trolling and stfu already.

 

Learn to accept it when someone disagrees with you.

Ok Edwin is not a good player.

 

He is just decent.

 

 

Riiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiight

 

 

 

Let's just stop the Edwin/Miguel comparisons please. We can look at a constant stat and solve the dilemma:

 

Edwin OPS--.933

Cabrera OPS--1.016

 

And Miguel's average is almost 40 points higher.

 

Again, that is not what we are talking about here.

 

 

I said their "power" numbers would be VERY SIMILAR if Edwin had played in all the games Cabrera had.

 

I never said Edwin was better then Cabs, but to say Edwin is a "decent" player and will never be at that level is insane.

 

Take a look at Cabrera's 1st full season stats (2004) and compare them to Edwin's.

 

http://florida.marlins.mlb.com/NASApp/mlb/...&statType=1

 

Ok, whats your point? You started the bogus comparisions.....Edwin plays in a bandbox....good for him and Dunn. Who's next? Dunn is better than Bonds?

Actually you started the bogus comparaisions.

 

See: the 1st post in this thread.

I hope the Reds lose!

Reds just lose please. K. Thanks. I knew you would understand.

Reds just lose please. K. Thanks. I knew you would understand.

 

BEILEVE! Im be watchin that game really close

I like our chances even better now.

Reds just lose please. K. Thanks. I knew you would understand.

 

 

Do it again please.

''We stink right now,'' left fielder Adam Dunn said.

 

 

I agree Mr. Dunn, I agree. Keep it up. :thumbup

''We stink right now,'' left fielder Adam Dunn said.

 

 

I agree Mr. Dunn, I agree. Keep it up. :thumbup

 

 

 

I guarantee the Reds will not win the wild card. Will the Marlins? Who knows....but the Reds have too many holes and everyone will watch their starters collapse down the stretch.

''We stink right now,'' left fielder Adam Dunn said.

 

 

I agree Mr. Dunn, I agree. Keep it up. :thumbup

 

 

 

I guarantee the Reds will not win the wild card. Will the Marlins? Who knows....but the Reds have too many holes and everyone will watch their starters collapse down the stretch.

You have no idea what you are talking about.

''We stink right now,'' left fielder Adam Dunn said.

 

 

I agree Mr. Dunn, I agree. Keep it up. :thumbup

 

I second Mr.Dunns statement Its going to stay that way though

How are the comparisons bogus?

Look up like four posts.

 

Now stop trolling and stfu already.

 

Learn to accept it when someone disagrees with you.

Ok Edwin is not a good player.

 

He is just decent.

 

 

Riiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiight

 

Edwin has not proven anything in the majors yet. He has some potential, and might some day be a good player. However, to compare him to Cabrera is crazy. Edwin can't hold Miggy's jock strap, and that's a fact!!! Cabrera has hall of fame potential if he stays healthy. Edwin could some day be a good player. He's not even in the top three of National League third baseman. Miggy, Wright, and Zimmerman are the top three, and then you still have Rolen and Chipper Jones, and Aramis Ramirez still ahead of him. That's just off of the top of my head... Please wait until Edwin does something worthy before putting him in this class.

''We stink right now,'' left fielder Adam Dunn said.

 

 

I agree Mr. Dunn, I agree. Keep it up. :thumbup

 

 

 

I guarantee the Reds will not win the wild card. Will the Marlins? Who knows....but the Reds have too many holes and everyone will watch their starters collapse down the stretch.

You have no idea what you are talking about.

 

 

Alrighty....4 losses in a row and counting.

How are the comparisons bogus?

Look up like four posts.

 

Now stop trolling and stfu already.

 

Learn to accept it when someone disagrees with you.

Ok Edwin is not a good player.

 

He is just decent.

 

 

Riiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiight

 

Edwin has not proven anything in the majors yet. He has some potential, and might some day be a good player. However, to compare him to Cabrera is crazy. Edwin can't hold Miggy's jock strap, and that's a fact!!! Cabrera has hall of fame potential if he stays healthy. Edwin could some day be a good player. He's not even in the top three of National League third baseman. Miggy, Wright, and Zimmerman are the top three, and then you still have Rolen and Chipper Jones, and Aramis Ramirez still ahead of him. That's just off of the top of my head... Please wait until Edwin does something worthy before putting him in this class.

 

 

Bingo. :thumbup

 

 

If Miguel played in GABP, his power numbers would be so ridiculous.

 

 

Miguel doesn't hit for power though. He'd just as much rather, by his own volition, take a ball and drive in the run with a ground ball or flyball then try to yank one out.