Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

What it would take for Crawford

Featured Replies

:lol

Not at all. You think every NL team has a lights out fifth starter? You've got to be kidding me.

 

 

The lack of offense and building the team around empty players like Lo Duca and Pierre (and of course the bullpen) is what kept the Marlins out of the playoffs.

Every NL team isn't in the playoffs. Having a guy start every 5th game with an ERA over 6 doesn't really work unless there's a good reason and you have insane offense (both which could be, in part, products of a hitters park). Lack of offense will always seem like a problem when you play in a park where you can hit a ball over 430ft and fly out. This team succeeded in 2003 because of a strong rotation and defense. I don't think the #5 guy needs to be lights out. Nolasco certainly isn't. But I'd like someone close enough to consistent to maintain an ERA below 4.50, rather than give away a young & healthy workhorse who has already realized 20-win potential and then throw in some schmuck who ends up losing twice as many starts as he wins with an ERA that resembles the price of a sausage at Dolphins Stadium.

Trade Dontrelle for Crawford, pick up a cheap 5th starter or plug Petit in the 5th spot and let's roll.

Stuffing crap into a rotation spot (Ismael Valdez, Brian Moehler) is exactly why the Marlins haven't been in the playoffs last few years.

 

You're telling me the reason we missed the playoffs in '05 was because of Moehler and his 4.55 ERA?

 

Or the 7 games Valdez started for us in 2005?

 

The World Champion St. Louis Cardinals won the World Series with 2 pitchers under a 4.5 era.

Not every team is us. They don't all play in a football stadium. We're not going to have guys hitting 40-50+ homers. The focus has to be elsewhere.

 

You're telling me the reason we missed the playoffs in '05 was because of Moehler and his 4.55 ERA?

 

Or the 7 games Valdez started for us in 2005?

I think it was a factor. I think if you had a healthy Brad Penny or a young starter of similary quality pitching those games the final results would've been different.

 

Let me put it a different way - I hope we can all agree that good pitching (with good D behind it) pretty consistently beats good hitting. More so for us in Dolphins Stadium. We can have a full 5-man rotation where it wouldn't be inconceivable for all 5 to win 15 or more games. Every one of them won 10 (including Dontrelle) or more as a rookie. I can't understand a desire to break that up to bring in a player who hasn't played full time at the position we need to fill and won't even really save us any money.

Trade Dontrelle for Crawford, pick up a cheap 5th starter or plug Petit in the 5th spot and let's roll.

Stuffing crap into a rotation spot (Ismael Valdez, Brian Moehler) is exactly why the Marlins haven't been in the playoffs last few years.

Like penguino and bob have mentioned, a lights out fifth man is not necessary for a team to make a push for the playoffs. Like you mentioned, especially in Dolphin Stadium. I think bob's idea was a pretty good one. We deal Dontrelle for Crawford or another productive CF and plug the fifth hole with a cheap, decent fifth man or even a cheap prospect which shouldn't be hard to come by and roll with it. I wouldn't, however want to use Petit as a starter for the year. Past a couple of decent outings, he hasn't exactly shown anything to deserve that spot.

If you look at most MLB teams actually you would be hardpressed to find more than a hand-full of 5th starters better than Nolasco. He won 11 games, a lot of teams didn't get that out of their 3rd starter of their rotation. I agree he had a slide at the end but he is a young pitcher and that happens, next year he will be stronger more durable and hopefully more improved

Not every team is us. They don't all play in a football stadium. We're not going to have guys hitting 40-50+ homers. The focus has to be elsewhere.

 

You're telling me the reason we missed the playoffs in '05 was because of Moehler and his 4.55 ERA?

 

Or the 7 games Valdez started for us in 2005?

I think it was a factor. I think if you had a healthy Brad Penny or a young starter of similary quality pitching those games the final results would've been different.

 

Let me put it a different way - I hope we can all agree that good pitching (with good D behind it) pretty consistently beats good hitting. More so for us in Dolphins Stadium. We can have a full 5-man rotation where it wouldn't be inconceivable for all 5 to win 15 or more games. Every one of them won 10 (including Dontrelle) or more as a rookie. I can't understand a desire to break that up to bring in a player who hasn't played full time at the position we need to fill and won't even really save us any money.

then how does a Dontrelle Willis ever get a shot?

You don't need a lights out 5th starter to make the playoffs and not having one is not what kept us from reaching the playoffs two years ago. However, if you trade Dontrelle the situation the 2007 Marlins would presumably be in is having a rotation stacked 1 through 4 with a bunch of 2nd year starters in Anibal, JJ, Olsen and Nolasco. The 5th starter would probably be a starter by committee spot consisting of Pinto, Garcia and Vargas until we found one that sticks. If we get the exact same production or better next year we got from those top 4 starters, we would be fine. We might even be able to sneak into the Wild Card spot. But I think that is asking a lot of the top 4. One or two of those starters may very well have a sophomore slump. Not to mention injuries. With Dontrelle in the rotation, a quality CF and some bullpen upgrades this team has a legitimate chance at making a playoff run next year. Without Dontrelle, a better CF (acquired through a trade of Dontrelle) and some bullpen upgrades the 2007 Marlins have a good chance of posting a record worse than they did this year.

 

For those of you concerned with stats, do you know which Marlins pitcher had the largest VORP in 2006? Dontrelle Willis. Most win shares? Same guy. Despite having a down year, he still edged out Johnson in both to top the Marlins staff.

I never said they had to be lights out. Everyone here knows that they cringed everytime Moehler started against a team with a good offense. That's what I don't want back in the rotation. We have a 1-5 where we can have a fair amount of confidence in all of them. I think if the situation becomes that we are basically expecting to lose every 5th game on account of no confidence in our starting pitcher, that's a factor. Not the end-all be-all of it.

 

Again, Crawford doesn't even play CF regularly (only twice in 2006). There is no way he is worth what Dontrelle is, even for us being stacked with pitching and starved for a CF. If it was for Nolasco or Jacobs (not even sure I would give them both), I'd consider it. But not Dontrelle.

I never said they had to be lights out. Everyone here knows that they cringed everytime Moehler started against a team with a good offense. That's what I don't want back in the rotation. We have a 1-5 where we can have a fair amount of confidence in all of them. I think if the situation becomes that we are basically expecting to lose every 5th game on account of no confidence in our starting pitcher, that's a factor. Not the end-all be-all of it.

 

Again, Crawford doesn't even play CF regularly (only twice in 2006). There is no way he is worth what Dontrelle is, even for us being stacked with pitching and starved for a CF. If it was for Nolasco or Jacobs (not even sure I would give them both), I'd consider it. But not Dontrelle.

 

:lol :lol :lol :lol :lol :lol

 

You kill me.

I never said they had to be lights out. Everyone here knows that they cringed everytime Moehler started against a team with a good offense. That's what I don't want back in the rotation. We have a 1-5 where we can have a fair amount of confidence in all of them. I think if the situation becomes that we are basically expecting to lose every 5th game on account of no confidence in our starting pitcher, that's a factor. Not the end-all be-all of it.

 

Again, Crawford doesn't even play CF regularly (only twice in 2006). There is no way he is worth what Dontrelle is, even for us being stacked with pitching and starved for a CF. If it was for Nolasco or Jacobs (not even sure I would give them both), I'd consider it. But not Dontrelle.

Wow.

Well put.

I never said they had to be lights out. Everyone here knows that they cringed everytime Moehler started against a team with a good offense. That's what I don't want back in the rotation. We have a 1-5 where we can have a fair amount of confidence in all of them. I think if the situation becomes that we are basically expecting to lose every 5th game on account of no confidence in our starting pitcher, that's a factor. Not the end-all be-all of it.

 

Again, Crawford doesn't even play CF regularly (only twice in 2006). There is no way he is worth what Dontrelle is, even for us being stacked with pitching and starved for a CF. If it was for Nolasco or Jacobs (not even sure I would give them both), I'd consider it. But not Dontrelle.

 

 

You really dont have a clue what other players around the league are valued at do you?

 

Carl Crawford is one of the most valuable players around mlb. He is a 5 Tool talent that is young and most likely on pace to someday become a 3,000 hit player. He has an arm, he has great defense, he has developing power, he has speed, he hits for average, every catagory you want to look at is going up year after year and getting better and better!

 

they would laugh at an offer of Jacobs + Nolasco

 

they would most likely not take an offer of Willis alone

 

They wouldnt most likely take an offer of Jacobs + Nolasco + a top prospect for Crawford

 

Why dont We just send Jacobs to St. Louis for Pujols and send Nolasco to Minn for Johan Santana also LOL since you seem to think we can give up crap for star players.

Can we just keep doing what we have been doing? Let's build from within, I am fine with Cody Ross! Or Even Amezaga! OR EVEN PLATOON THEM BOTH! Let's just fix our bullpen, we'll be FINE!

You really dont have a clue what other players around the league are valued at do you?

I don't care about value in a general sense around the league. We have specific needs. A corner OF bat isn't one of them, and if it was, it shouldn't cost us Dontrelle, not by a long shot.

 

And really look at Jacobs for a sec - his career 849 OPS (everyone here's favorite offensive stat) is better than Crawford has posted any season of his career. And lets be honest, we haven't seen his best yet. Give him a full season healthy before assuming his value.

 

Just because Tampa would ask for something insane for Crawford doesn't mean that he is worth it, especially to us.

 

And if we just wanted to plug a corner OFer into CF we could do Hermida again and solve RF for a lot cheaper.

 

I guess I just actually like the team we had last year (CF and bullpen aside) and would like to screw up as few of the good things (pitching rotation, 20HR hitting Rookies, etc) as possible.

You really dont have a clue what other players around the league are valued at do you?

I don't care about value in a general sense around the league. We have specific needs. A corner OF bat isn't one of them, and if it was, it shouldn't cost us Dontrelle, not by a long shot.

 

And really look at Jacobs for a sec - his career 849 OPS (everyone here's favorite offensive stat) is better than Crawford has posted any season of his career. And lets be honest, we haven't seen his best yet. Give him a full season healthy before assuming his value.

 

Just because Tampa would ask for something insane for Crawford doesn't mean that he is worth it, especially to us.

 

And if we just wanted to plug a corner OFer into CF we could do Hermida again and solve RF for a lot cheaper.

 

I guess I just actually like the team we had last year (CF and bullpen aside) and would like to screw up as few of the good things (pitching rotation, 20HR hitting Rookies, etc) as possible.

 

Small Sample Size Alert:

 

His OPS is serverly aided by his ridiculous 2005 season, where he slugged .710 in 100 at bats. In his only full season, he OPSed .798. Not terrible, but not great by any stretch, and bested by Crawford for each of the least 2 years.

You really dont have a clue what other players around the league are valued at do you?

I don't care about value in a general sense around the league. We have specific needs. A corner OF bat isn't one of them, and if it was, it shouldn't cost us Dontrelle, not by a long shot.

 

And really look at Jacobs for a sec - his career 849 OPS (everyone here's favorite offensive stat) is better than Crawford has posted any season of his career. And lets be honest, we haven't seen his best yet. Give him a full season healthy before assuming his value.

 

Just because Tampa would ask for something insane for Crawford doesn't mean that he is worth it, especially to us.

 

And if we just wanted to plug a corner OFer into CF we could do Hermida again and solve RF for a lot cheaper.

 

I guess I just actually like the team we had last year (CF and bullpen aside) and would like to screw up as few of the good things (pitching rotation, 20HR hitting Rookies, etc) as possible.

 

Small Sample Size Alert:

 

His OPS is serverly aided by his ridiculous 2005 season, where he slugged .710 in 100 at bats. In his only full season, he OPSed .798. Not terrible, but not great by any stretch, and bested by Crawford for each of the least 2 years.

 

Crawford is most certainly valued much much higher than Jacobs, and anyone who disagrees is lost. But I do agree with those that say we haven't seen the best of Jacobs yet, although I wouldn't be opposed to trading him for an OFer and at worst moving Willy to first, who will always be a much more consistent hitter and a guy who I think will play better next year, without some of the slumps he had midseason.

...

 

I wonder if any of you read anything I write.

 

I never said Jacobs was (or should be) valued higher. I pointed out a offensive stat that shows that Jacobs isn't the trash he is valued as on this board by everyone who wants trade him and move Hammer to 1st to put another hole in the OF.

 

Again Crawford doesn't bring enough. He's not even a full-time CF in the much smaller park he plays in. I guess that's better than throwing Hanley out there as some suggested a while back, but it's far from worth trading Dontrelle over.

 

If we were to send off Nolasco & Jacobs together - what's the result - we give up a lefty power bat in the middle of the order for a 2nd leadoff man (we already have one at SS), and now we either need a new 1B or we move Hammer over and we need a new LF. Except that's Crawford's actual position, so maybe he'll go there and we will still not have a legit CF. This plus giving up a 5th starter 10-15 win potential. I know there aren't very many on here with high opinions of Nolasco based on how he finished the season, but I think for any rookie to manage over 10 wins is good thing, and if that's the worst of your rotation, even better.

 

Am I missing something? There's no way both Hanley & Crawford can leadoff, so you're simply not gonna get 100+ SBs. And I'm sure some of you are fine with that. But my point is you trade off one type of offensive production for another, and still end up with a hole to fill, be it 1B or LF or CF. Crawford doesn't even represent the power bat "protection" every one wants behind Cabrera.

 

I'm not saying he's not more valuable in a general sense, or that he wouldn't command better compensation on the open market. I'm saying that we're not talking the open market. We are talking about a team that needs defensive help in CF and a bullpen, and needs it cheap.

there's so much wrong with this post that I dont have the time to point everything out. Ill just tackle one and say that Hanley Ramirez is a power hitting middle infielder and was only the leadoff man by default this year. Either of them can leadoff, it doesnt matter.

And Gonzalez evidently does NOT want Ramirez to lead off.

I'm aware of that. My point is that there isn't a desperate need for someone like Crawford offensively either.

 

Shamrock,

Hanley stealing over 50 bases in his rookie season makes him more than just a power hitting infielder. At least in my opinion, for whatever it's worth.

 

But if you're just going to generally say I am clueless, why bother posting?

And Gonzalez evidently does NOT want Ramirez to lead off.

I'm aware of that. My point is that there isn't a desperate need for someone like Crawford offensively either.

 

Shamrock,

Hanley stealing over 50 bases in his rookie season makes him more than just a power hitting infielder. At least in my opinion, for whatever it's worth.

 

But if you're just going to generally say I am clueless, why bother posting?

you make a valid point. im done now

I didn't feel like wading through three pages of posts to find it but it seemed to me someone said our new manager didn't want Ramirez leading off.

 

I'm not entirely sure that's what he said. The quote is, from the Miami Herald...

 

"...He (Gonzalez) said leadoff hitter Hanley Ramirez `is not too far away from being a middle-of-the-order hitter.' ''

 

http://www.miami.com/mld/miamiherald/sports/15672876.htm

 

As for the stolen base thing let me suggest that while stolen bases are not THE sole criteria for a leadoff hitter, it certainly is ONE criteria to be considered. Absent acquiring someone with the speed and OBP of Ramirez, I'm guessing you'll see Hanley at the top of the lineup come April 2007.

I didn't feel like wading through three pages of posts to find it but it seemed to me someone said our new manager didn't want Ramirez leading off.

 

I'm not entirely sure that's what he said. The quote is, from the Miami Herald...

 

"...He (Gonzalez) said leadoff hitter Hanley Ramirez `is not too far away from being a middle-of-the-order hitter.' ''

 

http://www.miami.com/mld/miamiherald/sports/15672876.htm

 

As for the stolen base thing let me suggest that while stolen bases are not THE sole criteria for a leadoff hitter, it certainly is ONE criteria to be considered. Absent acquiring someone with the speed and OBP of Ramirez, I'm guessing you'll see Hanley at the top of the lineup come April 2007.

 

A healthy Hermida can lead off. He is a high-OBP guy and has speed. His power would be a plus at leadoff, and the team has a couple of 5-6 hitter types to hit behind Cabrera and Hanley.

I think Crawford is an elite talent guy.

 

I seem to remember him coming off a pretty serious injury at the begining of this year, and that once he got rolling, he was putting up MVP type numbers.

 

If you look at his first month it's clear the injury hurt mostly his power stats .269 avg .340 obp .355 slg

 

If you take that out, i'm guessing his slugging is looking a bit more impressive on the year. (.505 by my Math)

 

that's pretty ridiculous for a .300 hitter who stole 58 bases and played exceptional OF defense.

 

You can't look at him and say he's a corner outfielder that's only hitting 18 hr so far. That's not his skill set.

 

There aren't any corner outfielders putting up his speed numbers. You may counter with, but he IS playing Corner OF, to that i respond, that's where they're playing him now.

 

I truly believe he's on the brink of a 25 hr 55 sb .300 year.

 

Heck, he's pretty much already done that. (a few times)

I think Crawford is an elite talent guy.

 

I seem to remember him coming off a pretty serious injury at the begining of this year, and that once he got rolling, he was putting up MVP type numbers.

 

If you look at his first month it's clear the injury hurt mostly his power stats .269 avg .340 obp .355 slg

 

If you take that out, i'm guessing his slugging is looking a bit more impressive on the year. (.505 by my Math)

 

that's pretty ridiculous for a .300 hitter who stole 58 bases and played exceptional OF defense.

 

You can't look at him and say he's a corner outfielder that's only hitting 18 hr so far. That's not his skill set.

 

There aren't any corner outfielders putting up his speed numbers. You may counter with, but he IS playing Corner OF, to that i respond, that's where they're playing him now.

 

I truly believe he's on the brink of a 25 hr 55 sb .300 year.

 

Heck, he's pretty much already done that. (a few times)

Using that kind of argument, I can talk about how if you take away Pinto's 2 appearances in July his ERA is under 1.70. And how good would Hanley's numbers be if you take away his summer-time slump? We can do this for practically anybody good enough to be full-time MLB player.

 

Again, as far as exceptional OF defense goes, he's not even the best on his own team. At least they don't think enough so to put him in CF.

 

But anyways...definately not MVP. And not worth what he would cost us. After all, this is still Tampa Bay we are talking about.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.