Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Does anyone see the lineup looking like this is the future

Featured Replies

I know Hanleys a speed demon and you'd think to put him as the leadoff man. But i think he'll generate more power numbers later in his career, plus he's a righty. If De Aza ends up being the real deal, If he can steal bases and get decent at bats, we can move Hanley into the 2. Now we have a lefty leadoff followed by a jeter type hitter. then so on...

 

L De Aza

R Ramirez

R Cabrera

L Jacobs

R Uggla

L Hermida

R Willingham

R Olivo

 

or if Hermida is as good as advertised

 

L De Aza

R Ramirez

L Jacobs

R Cabrera

L Hermida

R Uggla

R Willingham

R Olivo

I still want this lineup

 

BJ Upton CF

J Hermida RF

H Ramirez SS

M Cabrera 3B

J Willingham LF

M Jacobs 1B

D Uggla 2B

Insert Name C

D Willis SP

 

 

Of course there is no way the Drays let go of Upton now that he is murdering the ball :(

  • Author

If Hermida pans out he becomes the perfect #2 hitter...not the 5th guy

 

Number two hitter is usually high OBP little to average pop? Good batting average, line drive hitter? Thats what ive always thought of it, what are the expectations of Hermida?

If Hermida pans out he becomes the perfect #2 hitter...not the 5th guy

 

Number two hitter is usually high OBP little to average pop? Good batting average, line drive hitter? Thats what ive always thought of it, what are the expectations of Hermida?

 

great eye and OBP with good linedrive type of power. think of JD Drew, literately with the injuries.

 

He had over 100 BB one year in AA

If Hermida pans out he becomes the perfect #2 hitter...not the 5th guy

 

Number two hitter is usually high OBP little to average pop? Good batting average, line drive hitter? Thats what ive always thought of it, what are the expectations of Hermida?

pretty much exactly that. patient hitter, walks a lot, he could develop more power but probably just average pop early on.

 

 

course if he doesn't stay healthy we'll have no idea what he can do.

  • Author

If Hermida pans out he becomes the perfect #2 hitter...not the 5th guy

 

Number two hitter is usually high OBP little to average pop? Good batting average, line drive hitter? Thats what ive always thought of it, what are the expectations of Hermida?

 

great eye and OBP with good linedrive type of power. think of JD Drew, literately with the injuries.

 

He had over 100 BB one year in AA

 

But do you see Hanley leading off for much longer?

I see Hanley having much more power than Jeter. I'd say Hanley's a Nomar type hitter at his peak.

Hanley is more Miggy Tejada power wise, I think

I see Hanley having much more power than Jeter. I'd say Hanley's a Nomar type hitter at his peak.

Hanley is more Miggy Tejada power wise, I think

 

Either one is good (though Nomar is more good.)

I see Hanley having much more power than Jeter. I'd say Hanley's a Nomar type hitter at his peak.

Hanley is more Miggy Tejada power wise, I think

 

Either one is good (though Nomar is more good.)

yea, Nomar definitely... not sure what I was thinking

  • Author

I don't see De Aza in the lineup in 2 years, but that's just me.

 

I didnt expect to see Cabrera on the team two years later after his first few weeks coming out of AA , even with the walk off. But the ball jumps off De Azas bat. He seems more confident than Abercrombie or especially Reed. Yesterdays at the game in person Reed looked like a little kid, no way hes a major league starter, scared at the plate almost...

I don't see De Aza in the lineup in 2 years, but that's just me.

 

I didnt expect to see Cabrera on the team two years later after his first few weeks coming out of AA

 

Then you're blind.

 

Next...

I don't see De Aza in the lineup in 2 years, but that's just me.

 

I didnt expect to see Cabrera on the team two years later after his first few weeks coming out of AA

 

Then you're blind.

 

Next...

Blind, we called him KKKabrera

 

Then stupid and ironically bigoted too.

 

Cabrera has what's called a pedigree, De Aza does not. De Aza does not do anything exceptionally well. He has a minor league career average of .266, 12 career minor league homeruns almost a consistent 2:1 K:BB ratio a career 70% SB percentage and never more than 35 SB's in a season or 45 RBI, or had a full season average above .280.

 

So tell me one thing he's done in his minor league career that indicates he should "stick." And looking better than Reed is not one of them.

I see Hanley having much more power than Jeter. I'd say Hanley's a Nomar type hitter at his peak.

Hanley is more Miggy Tejada power wise, I think

 

Either one is good (though Nomar is more good.)

yea, Nomar definitely... not sure what I was thinking

 

I just think he's going to hit a lot more doubles than homers, like Nomar. Whereas Tejada generates most of his SLUG from home runs (For a guy with 250 career homers in 10 seasons, his .479 SP is awfully low)

  • Author

I don't see De Aza in the lineup in 2 years, but that's just me.

 

I didnt expect to see Cabrera on the team two years later after his first few weeks coming out of AA

 

Then you're blind.

 

Next...

Blind, we called him KKKabrera

 

Then stupid and ironically bigoted too.

 

Cabrera has what's called a pedigree, De Aza does not. De Aza does not do anything exceptionally well. He has a minor league career average of .266, 12 career minor league homeruns almost a consistent 2:1 K:BB ratio a career 70% SB percentage and never more than 35 SB's in a season or 45 RBI, or had a full season average above .280.

 

So tell me one thing he's done in his minor league career that indicates he should "stick." And looking better than Reed is not one of them.

 

Look at this guy.

I don't see De Aza in the lineup in 2 years, but that's just me.

 

I didnt expect to see Cabrera on the team two years later after his first few weeks coming out of AA

 

Then you're blind.

 

Next...

Blind, we called him KKKabrera

 

Then stupid and ironically bigoted too.

 

Cabrera has what's called a pedigree, De Aza does not. De Aza does not do anything exceptionally well. He has a minor league career average of .266, 12 career minor league homeruns almost a consistent 2:1 K:BB ratio a career 70% SB percentage and never more than 35 SB's in a season or 45 RBI, or had a full season average above .280.

 

So tell me one thing he's done in his minor league career that indicates he should "stick." And looking better than Reed is not one of them.

 

Of course it is not fair to compare De Aza and Miggy. Miggy was tearing up AA as a 19/20 year old. But De Aza is also very very young at 22. He has a shot to be decent, IMO.

 

Also, I am probably lost here, but what's bigotted about the statement?

Here's what I see:

 

CF rabbit

2B Uggla

1B Jacobs

3B Cabrera

SS Ramirez

LF Willingham

RF Hermida (or leadoff)

C Olivo/Treanor

P fillintheblank

 

If Hermida comes back and is the player he's touted to be and the OBP machine we all hoped, bang right to the head of the class, but otherwise, believing DeAza may not be the longterm solution (but hoping he is) we get a speedy CFer by the ASG.

 

To me that is our strongest lineup. It doesn't matter if anyone agrees or disagrees because I won't be filling out the lineup cards any time soon. :brigginbounce

Here's what I see:

 

CF rabbit

2B Uggla

1B Jacobs

3B Cabrera

SS Ramirez

LF Willingham

RF Hermida (or leadoff)

C Olivo/Treanor

P fillintheblank

 

If Hermida comes back and is the player he's touted to be and the OBP machine we all hoped, bang right to the head of the class, but otherwise, believing DeAza may not be the longterm solution (but hoping he is) we get a speedy CFer by the ASG.

 

To me that is our strongest lineup. It doesn't matter if anyone agrees or disagrees because I won't be filling out the lineup cards any time soon. :brigginbounce

 

 

for once we agree :)

The main thing how far in the future is your line-up. If the Marlins get a new stadium they'll be able to try to keep Cabrera and Willis. Two years from now that line-up first listed may be workable if your looking 4 years down the road then Hayes will probably the catcher,

Hermida will be healthy or gone, players coming up through the sysyem like Coghlan, G. Sanchez, Harvey or Campusano may have major roles. The rotation could be Volstad, Hernandez, Thompson, Tucker and A. Sanchez by 2010/11

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.