June 18, 200719 yr Miami Herald A slim Cabrera could be huge for Marlins BY ISRAEL GUTIERREZ igutierrez@MiamiHerald.com There was one thought that must have been running through the mind of anyone watching Miguel Cabrera trot around the bases for the second of his two home runs Saturday against the Royals: "He must be exhausted.'' Ah, yes, another fat joke. A cheap shot, sure, but we work with what we're given. With the Marlins hoping for their annual midseason surge to finally hit, Cabrera remains the most compelling story line on the team, both for his production and portliness. It's just too hard to ignore when just four years ago, he was a svelte 20-year-old nicknamed H-O-F because he was so obviously Hall of Fame material, and this season he's more fit for the H-F-O acronym as a Heavy Former Outfielder. The popular opinion is that the extra weight means nothing. People say that, other than a few inches on his range at third base, Cabrera has lost nothing by adding the poundage and that anyone critical of him is just nitpicking. TOO MUCH TO ASK? But is it really a crime to ask more from even the greatest of athletes? Is it really OK to feel like the best player on your team is settling just because he happens to naturally settle among the top five players in the game? Is it really that wrong to ask for long-term greatness and hope that your favorite player will eventually be considered an unquestioned all-timer? While Cabrera continues to put up stellar numbers in his first super-sized season, he also happens to be working his way out of a position. At this rate, he will be an AL-only player by the time he hits 30, with designated hitter as the only responsibility left on his gigantic plate. Wouldn't it seem like more of an accomplishment if, rather than just concede that he has outgrown his position, Cabrera becomes the best all-time hitting third baseman in the game? There is the other easy option, which is to let Miggy be Miggy (unless that phrase is already taken) and eventually move him to first base. SAFE POSITION It's plausible, but it is a shame that first has become the crutch for the full-size National Leaguers. Want some fries with that? Sure, there's always first base. Some pork rinds before the game? Sure, there's always first base. Pour some fudge in your milkshake? Sure, there's always first base. Cabrera's I-do-my-job-and-go-home response to any overweight talk is not how he feels. It's more of a defensive reaction by a great player who feels wrongly insulted. But for teammates who are envious of how easy the game is to Cabrera, watching him grow before their eyes is hardly an inspirational sight. It must have crossed the mind of at least one Marlin this year that a trimmer Cabrera could be better, which would therefore make the team better. The best players in their respective sports tend to give the impression that they're outworking everyone else. Tiger Woods doesn't need to be in great shape to be an elite golfer. Just look at the pudgy man who beat him on Sunday, Angel Cabrera (another chunky Cabrera coincidence?). But Tiger, who lately wears the snuggest of Nike tees to show off his muscles, will probably win five more majors before Angel even sniffs another one because he works on his body almost as relentlessly as he does his game. Miggy, not so much. At this pace, the only way he stays at third base past the next decade is if he's allowed to park there in a reclining chair with a fishing net as his ball retriever. He certainly hasn't dropped the weight one would assume natural after playing almost three full months of regular-season baseball (it probably doesn't help that Dontrelle Willis has opened a bodega in a locker about 10 feet from Miggy, with plenty of candy available for purchase). The worst part about the fat conversation is that it nearly is overshadowing his personality. Who else picks up his short Mexican teammate after every home run and does the quebradita? That dance comes after he shakes his wannabe dreads at his other teammates. Maybe he can incorporate some of that lovable spirit to create some creative ways to drop pounds. Maybe make him dance with Alfredo Amezaga after every batting practice home run. It wouldn't be much fun for Amezaga, but he is the team's best utility player. Anything to help take the mind off Miggy's fat and keep us focused on his bat.
June 18, 200719 yr I dont like the article, I think he is just looking for something to write about and nitpicking personally. Trying to be funny and all. He comes off sorta like an a%%%hole
June 18, 200719 yr See? This is the problem with the South Florida media. The same paper who wrote this article didn't even cover Cabrera's Player of the Week honors last week. Of course I would love for Miggy to lose some weight. It would definitely benefit him, at least defensively. But the media focus too much on it, and not enough of the fact that he's the only player in the MAJORS who's top 5 in all triple-crown categories.
June 18, 200719 yr Unless he gets an opinion from someone in the organization giving us information about the specifics of Miguels weight issues, it really doesn't do anything except marginalize our best player. This article seems more mean-spirited than anything else.
June 18, 200719 yr If it weren't a poorly written attempt to marginzalize, arguably, the best start to a season in Marlins history maybe it'd have credibility. Miggy's weight isn't a problem until it's clearly affecting him. Last I checked, he wasn't going to hit a lot of triples or steal a lot of bases, and he's on pace to hit 40 home-runs with another .330 season. Besides, he showed up in tremendous shape and only after the really bad oblique injury did he pack on the pounds. Then again, since I'm sure this guy only actually watches the team once a week and instead chooses to dine on hot-fudge sundays and hot-dogs in the press box, he had no clue about that, nor the fact that Miggy appears to have lost about 10 pounds in the last month.
June 18, 200719 yr I thought it was a good article. Good sense of humor. I liked the line about sitting on a folding chair and using a fish-net. To me, the story is like poking the Pillsbury Doughboy in the stomach so he giggles(for those old enough to rember this commercial). What do you want the guy to write about...how crappy our entire defense is? At least here he acknowledges Cabrera's immense...um, talent, and says Cabs could be an all-time great, and his weight may impede that. It's true.
June 18, 200719 yr The article speaks the truth. Cabrera is a GREAT player and if he wanted to he could be even better. No one can argue that his defense this year has taken a hit. The guy used to play short stop when he was younger and when he came into the league he was trim and light on his feet. IF he continues on the pace he is on he will be strictly a slugger when he has the potential for so much more. Some of you on this board are in Denial.
June 18, 200719 yr The article speaks the truth. Cabrera is a GREAT player and if he wanted to he could be even better. No one can argue that his defense this year has taken a hit. The guy used to play short stop when he was younger and when he came into the league he was trim and light on his feet. IF he continues on the pace he is on he will be strictly a slugger when he has the potential for so much more. Some of you on this board are in Denial. But my point was the local media ignoring his Player of the Week honors and instead writing an article about his weight. My dad was out of town for a few weeks and if it weren't for me telling him, he would have never known about Cabrera's national recognition because the local papers ignored it. And he will never be "strictly a slugger" because he is an all-around fantastic hitter who has a great approach at the plate (Andruw Jones should learn from him). With the exception of the high number of K's, he is having an Albert Pujols-like offensive season.
June 18, 200719 yr The article speaks the truth. Cabrera is a GREAT player and if he wanted to he could be even better. No one can argue that his defense this year has taken a hit. The guy used to play short stop when he was younger and when he came into the league he was trim and light on his feet. IF he continues on the pace he is on he will be strictly a slugger when he has the potential for so much more. Some of you on this board are in Denial. I have no idea what the short-stop reference was for...if everyone's gold standard for Cabrera is 2003, he was moved off of short well before because he had gotten too big. Defense was never considered his strong suit, hence a svelte Cabrera was deemed an adequate left-fielder and a slugger first, fielder second, or did you forget the whole Mike Lowell/Miguel Cabrera/Derrek Lee decision we had to make. Even at his most fit, Cabrera's defense was (at least in Beinfest's mind) not a strong enough selling point. The notion that we're being denied a "great" defensive player is laughable. Even last year, before weight was an issue, Girardi tried to put him at first before Beinfest put the foot down.
June 18, 200719 yr The article speaks the truth. Cabrera is a GREAT player and if he wanted to he could be even better. No one can argue that his defense this year has taken a hit. The guy used to play short stop when he was younger and when he came into the league he was trim and light on his feet. IF he continues on the pace he is on he will be strictly a slugger when he has the potential for so much more. Some of you on this board are in Denial. I have no idea what the short-stop reference was for...if everyone's gold standard for Cabrera is 2003, he was moved off of short well before because he had gotten too big. Defense was never considered his strong suit, hence a svelte Cabrera was deemed an adequate left-fielder and a slugger first, fielder second, or did you forget the whole Mike Lowell/Miguel Cabrera/Derrek Lee decision we had to make. Even at his most fit, Cabrera's defense was (at least in Beinfest's mind) not a strong enough selling point. The notion that we're being denied a "great" defensive player is laughable. Even last year, before weight was an issue, Girardi tried to put him at first before Beinfest put the foot down. I don't think the writer is saying that Cabrera could be great at third. He's just saying that if he manages to play the position average and stay at third then he could be the best hitting third baseman of all-time. And losing a few pounds couldn't hurt that possibility.
June 18, 200719 yr The article speaks the truth. Cabrera is a GREAT player and if he wanted to he could be even better. No one can argue that his defense this year has taken a hit. The guy used to play short stop when he was younger and when he came into the league he was trim and light on his feet. IF he continues on the pace he is on he will be strictly a slugger when he has the potential for so much more. Some of you on this board are in Denial. I have no idea what the short-stop reference was for...if everyone's gold standard for Cabrera is 2003, he was moved off of short well before because he had gotten too big. Defense was never considered his strong suit, hence a svelte Cabrera was deemed an adequate left-fielder and a slugger first, fielder second, or did you forget the whole Mike Lowell/Miguel Cabrera/Derrek Lee decision we had to make. Even at his most fit, Cabrera's defense was (at least in Beinfest's mind) not a strong enough selling point. The notion that we're being denied a "great" defensive player is laughable. Even last year, before weight was an issue, Girardi tried to put him at first before Beinfest put the foot down. I don't think the writer is saying that Cabrera could be great at third. He's just saying that if he manages to play the position average and stay at third then he could be the best hitting third baseman of all-time. And losing a few pounds couldn't hurt that possibility. Exactly, look Cabrera has never been and probably will never be a defensive force he won't be winning any Gold gloves. But a bad combination of EGO and Weight Gain has made him a liability defensively. Listen I love Cabrera he is just a Phenominal Talent but I think he could be better in all facets of the game. That is the scary part, if he worked harder on his plate dicipline he could cut down the strikeouts and I can't even imagine what his numbers would be like if he could just cut down the strikeouts by half. Also if he kept himself in shape more I think he could actually be a good defenive thirdbaseman, not great (but who knows really??). He has a Cannon for an arm and he has shown his skills with the glove with some flashes of briliance here and there. He is still very young, I would say he is too young for this discussion to even be taking place. Weight should not be an issue with a player of his caliber until at least 30. At this rate, weight might be more than just an "issue" by the time he is 30.
June 18, 200719 yr Girardi tried to put Cabrera at 1B (where he belongs) but the Third Reich put the kabosh on that. At 3B, his weight IS getting to be an issue. Its less of an issue at 1B.
June 18, 200719 yr It would be better for the team if Miggy could ultimately pull his weight, so to speak, at third base, and we had a good hitting/good fielding first base as well. Miggy has never impressed me much in his defense at third. Even in 2003, when he played his best, he would have had at least 6 errors on balls that DLee bailed him out on. But, Miggy is still young, and a tremendous athlete. I think he's the most likely player on the team to improve defensively, if only he'd lose some weight and try to be the best that he can be.
June 18, 200719 yr Author See? This is the problem with the South Florida media. The same paper who wrote this article didn't even cover Cabrera's Player of the Week honors last week. Of course I would love for Miggy to lose some weight. It would definitely benefit him, at least defensively. But the media focus too much on it, and not enough of the fact that he's the only player in the MAJORS who's top 5 in all triple-crown categories. I completely agree with you about the Marlins coverage! There are so many times they deserve the front page of the sports section for positive reasons but are upstaged by the most insignifant Dolphins non-news or some sporting event no one even cares about. I imagine Miggy will not be pleased with this article but just imagine what it would be like if he were playing in New York. He would definitely get the star recognition he deserves but he would also have to deal with those back pages and their "creative" headlines.
June 18, 200719 yr He looks like he is on roids. Yes, I said it. :| How many fatsos you know are on steroids? Please. Even guys like Canseco who never worked out where huge and cut.
June 19, 200719 yr Am I the only one who thinks that Cabrera has more value at 3B (even with his defensive issues) than anywhere else on the field?
June 19, 200719 yr Am I the only one who thinks that Cabrera has more value at 3B (even with his defensive issues) than anywhere else on the field? Yeah, a first baseman doesn't get as much credit as does a 3rd baseman defensively. Cabrera is following Manny Ramirez's footsteps from what we see.
June 19, 200719 yr Am I the only one who thinks that Cabrera has more value at 3B (even with his defensive issues) than anywhere else on the field? No, I agree, you play a quality bat at the most premium position he can handle. Until Miggy shows he absolutely cannot under any circumstance play third, he needs to remain there. Quality third baseman don't grow on trees, and those that do cost a pretty penny...ditto secondbaseman, shortstops, etc.
June 19, 200719 yr Author Sheesh, talk about piling on... Miami Herald NOTEBOOK Guillen muses on 'son' BY MIKE PHILLIPS mphillips@MiamiHerald.com CHICAGO -- Miguel Cabrera is a franchise player, a special player and a player headed for the Hall of Fame. At least that's the way White Sox manager Ozzie Guillen sees it, and there are few who know Cabrera better than Guillen, who sat in the White Sox dugout before Monday's game against the Marlins and talked about the player he looks at ``like my own son.'' Cabrera had dinner with Guillen and spent time at his home in downtown Chicago on Sunday. Guillen -- one of baseball's most outspoken figures -- pulled no punches. He told Cabrera he needed to lose weight. ''I'm a little upset with him,'' Guillen said. ``You're still young. He knows he has a problem with that. When you are young and good, you can get away with it. But when you're older and you're not hitting home runs, then they will call you a fat boy from Venezuela. ''I saw him in the spring and he was [skinny], and then I saw him again later and said, `You've been eating a lot of arepas,''' he joked. ``When your mother is Venezuelan and your wife is Venezuelan, you are going to get fat. If he keeps getting bigger, his future is in the Mexican League.'' Guillen cares about Cabrera. They are both from Venezuela and grew close when Guillen was a coach with the Marlins and Cabrera first came up with the team in 2003. They live close to one another in Miami, and during the season, they talk on the phone almost daily. ''We talk a lot, and my wife and his wife are good friends,'' Guillen said. ``Miggy could be my son. I told him, `You have to take care of yourself, because you have a chance to be one of the best players from our country.' ''He's a Hall of Famer,'' Guillen said. ``A lot of people look at [ Albert] Pujols and those guys, but you look at Cabrera's numbers and he is right there with them. It's unfortunate people don't look at that and give him the credit he deserves.'' Guillen said he has been telling Cabrera for the past two years that he is destined for Cooperstown, N.Y., but that Cabrera doesn't let the comment inflate his ego. ''When I tell him that he is going to be in the Hall of Fame, he gets shy,'' Guillen said. ``He doesn't want to hear that. He doesn't believe it. I don't think he believes in the hype. ''This kid is special,'' Guillen said. ``He can be a franchise with any ballclub. The day he showed up and we got him [with the Marlins], we knew how special he was going to be. If he was playing in New York, he would be the MVP the next day.'' Guillen believes Cabrera has to do more. ''Miggy is at a stage where he can be a superstar, but he has to be a leader. He has to help the manager win games, and help the franchise,'' Guillen said. 'It's time for him to step up and be the guy. I keep telling him, `Make sure you take those kids under your wing.' '' If Guillen managed Cabrera, he would tell him not to play winter ball. ''It's too much of a risk,'' he said. ``People in Venezuela want him to play, but if he gets hurt, no one from Venezuela is going and pay him for playing for us.'' THERE AND BACK Reggie Abercrombie is back. The Marlins sent Abercrombie to Triple A Albuquerque (N.M.) after Sunday's game in Kansas City, and then changed their minds and called him back, sending reliever Lee Gardner to Albuquerque instead. Because the Marlins are using a four-man rotation until June 30, they could use a full 13-man bench more than a 13th pitcher. ''Now we are at full strength on the bench,'' manager Fredi Gonzalez said. ``Reggie took a little trip and came to Chicago via Albuquerque.'' THUMBS UP First baseman Mike Jacobs, who has been out since May 14 because of a fractured thumb, was scheduled to play at Jupiter on Monday, and Gonzalez said he might join the team as early as Friday in Miami.
June 19, 200719 yr Am I the only one who thinks that Cabrera has more value at 3B (even with his defensive issues) than anywhere else on the field? you're not the only one, nope.
June 19, 200719 yr That article bothers me far less than the first article. It shares with us the opinion of someone with both inside knowledge of the game and inside knowledge of Miguel. The other article, like I said earlier, seems mean-spirited.
June 19, 200719 yr Sheesh, talk about piling on... Miami Herald NOTEBOOK Guillen muses on 'son' BY MIKE PHILLIPS mphillips@MiamiHerald.com CHICAGO -- Miguel Cabrera is a franchise player, a special player and a player headed for the Hall of Fame. At least that's the way White Sox manager Ozzie Guillen sees it, and there are few who know Cabrera better than Guillen, who sat in the White Sox dugout before Monday's game against the Marlins and talked about the player he looks at ``like my own son.'' Cabrera had dinner with Guillen and spent time at his home in downtown Chicago on Sunday. Guillen -- one of baseball's most outspoken figures -- pulled no punches. He told Cabrera he needed to lose weight. ''I'm a little upset with him,'' Guillen said. ``You're still young. He knows he has a problem with that. When you are young and good, you can get away with it. But when you're older and you're not hitting home runs, then they will call you a fat boy from Venezuela. ''I saw him in the spring and he was [skinny], and then I saw him again later and said, `You've been eating a lot of arepas,''' he joked. ``When your mother is Venezuelan and your wife is Venezuelan, you are going to get fat. If he keeps getting bigger, his future is in the Mexican League.'' Guillen cares about Cabrera. They are both from Venezuela and grew close when Guillen was a coach with the Marlins and Cabrera first came up with the team in 2003. They live close to one another in Miami, and during the season, they talk on the phone almost daily. ''We talk a lot, and my wife and his wife are good friends,'' Guillen said. ``Miggy could be my son. I told him, `You have to take care of yourself, because you have a chance to be one of the best players from our country.' ''He's a Hall of Famer,'' Guillen said. ``A lot of people look at [ Albert] Pujols and those guys, but you look at Cabrera's numbers and he is right there with them. It's unfortunate people don't look at that and give him the credit he deserves.'' Guillen said he has been telling Cabrera for the past two years that he is destined for Cooperstown, N.Y., but that Cabrera doesn't let the comment inflate his ego. ''When I tell him that he is going to be in the Hall of Fame, he gets shy,'' Guillen said. ``He doesn't want to hear that. He doesn't believe it. I don't think he believes in the hype. ''This kid is special,'' Guillen said. ``He can be a franchise with any ballclub. The day he showed up and we got him [with the Marlins], we knew how special he was going to be. If he was playing in New York, he would be the MVP the next day.'' Guillen believes Cabrera has to do more. ''Miggy is at a stage where he can be a superstar, but he has to be a leader. He has to help the manager win games, and help the franchise,'' Guillen said. 'It's time for him to step up and be the guy. I keep telling him, `Make sure you take those kids under your wing.' '' If Guillen managed Cabrera, he would tell him not to play winter ball. ''It's too much of a risk,'' he said. ``People in Venezuela want him to play, but if he gets hurt, no one from Venezuela is going and pay him for playing for us.'' THERE AND BACK Reggie Abercrombie is back. The Marlins sent Abercrombie to Triple A Albuquerque (N.M.) after Sunday's game in Kansas City, and then changed their minds and called him back, sending reliever Lee Gardner to Albuquerque instead. Because the Marlins are using a four-man rotation until June 30, they could use a full 13-man bench more than a 13th pitcher. ''Now we are at full strength on the bench,'' manager Fredi Gonzalez said. ``Reggie took a little trip and came to Chicago via Albuquerque.'' THUMBS UP First baseman Mike Jacobs, who has been out since May 14 because of a fractured thumb, was scheduled to play at Jupiter on Monday, and Gonzalez said he might join the team as early as Friday in Miami. There's a very similar article in today's Sun-Sentinel as well. Gees, Miggy and the fans get the point! Like I said before, these are the same newspapers who have no interest in covering his accolades (Player of the Week). :banghead Do they really have nothing better to write about? How about the fact he is 2nd in All-Star voting at 3rd (maybe it would get some fans to vote for him), or that he's top 5 in batting average, homers & RBIs? That article bothers me far less than the first article. It shares with us the opinion of someone with both inside knowledge of the game and inside knowledge of Miguel. The other article, like I said earlier, seems mean-spirited. I agree with you, Flummoxed. I just get annoyed that this is all they tend to focus on.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.