June 23, 200719 yr great Olivo's a beast dude has stone hands I know, I just thought it was cool how nobody can mow him over. It has nothing to do with him being a good catcher. His hands su*k, I agree
June 23, 200719 yr great Olivo's a beast dude has stone hands Great, he only blocks the plate when he doesn't have the ball. Throw to him wasn't the best. But I would love to see either of you two catch it with a guy that big a milisecond away from a collision. Olivo did the right thing. He made a great try while bracing himself for a hard hit. Thing is, Olivo plays tomorrow. The other guy dosen't. See, that's like a mechanic saying "I'd like to see you guys change a carborator." It's his damn JOB to CATCH the f***ING ball.
June 23, 200719 yr That's Olivo's 4th hard play ay the plate this year already. He brick-walled another player. He collided and knocked another player down with a left jab, and on an offense he came in and caught the catcher with a nice rabbit punch right hand to his head as they collided. He scored on the offensive play, and held the ball on the other 2 defensive plays. Last night the error was given by the official scorer to Hanley. Not sure why, as it looked to me like the ball was low but right on line. Maybe the officil scorer changed that initial ruling. That's a hard ball to hold on to though, with a collission with a big guy a millisecond away. Olivo has a problem catching the most routine of pitches, a fatal flaw for a catcher, but he's been overall good at plays at the plate....and entertaining. . Oh, Morneau is out for a few games with a lung contussion. Hope he gets better fast.
June 23, 200719 yr great Olivo's a beast dude has stone hands Great, he only blocks the plate when he doesn't have the ball. Throw to him wasn't the best. But I would love to see either of you two catch it with a guy that big a milisecond away from a collision. Olivo did the right thing. He made a great try while bracing himself for a hard hit. Thing is, Olivo plays tomorrow. The other guy dosen't. I'm not a professional catcher. Look, I've been on the Olivo bandwagon for as long as anyone but he is absolutely terrible at catching the damn ball. And that's kind of important for a catcher to do. Anyway, I honestly think that on plays to home, the pitcher needs to flip Olivo his glove so he can catch with it. It's hard enough as his to catch a ball with a catching mit. Then again, when Olsen/Willis are on the mound it's kind of tough to toss Miguel a right handed glove
June 23, 200719 yr It's time to add a new stat for the sabre-metric guys. The TKO. So far this year Olivo is leading the league with 4.
June 23, 200719 yr It's time to add a new stat for the sabre-metric guys. The TKO. So far this year Olivo is leading the league with 4. 4? I can only remember 2. Last night and that other catcher. I forgot what team it was.
June 24, 200719 yr great Olivo's a beast dude has stone hands Great, he only blocks the plate when he doesn't have the ball. Throw to him wasn't the best. But I would love to see either of you two catch it with a guy that big a milisecond away from a collision. Olivo did the right thing. He made a great try while bracing himself for a hard hit. Thing is, Olivo plays tomorrow. The other guy dosen't. I'm not a professional catcher. Look, I've been on the Olivo bandwagon for as long as anyone but he is absolutely terrible at catching the damn ball. And that's kind of important for a catcher to do. Anyway, I honestly think that on plays to home, the pitcher needs to flip Olivo his glove so he can catch with it. It's hard enough as his to catch a ball with a catching mit. Then again, when Olsen/Willis are on the mound it's kind of tough to toss Miguel a right handed glove Speaking of pitchers on plays at the plate, was the pitcher even backing that play up, at all?
June 24, 200719 yr yes Benitez was in line, but the ball took a side hop off of Olivo and took a detour to the dugout
June 24, 200719 yr yes Benitez was in line, but the ball took a side hop off of Olivo and took a detour to the dugout I've seen the replay a bunch of times, just didn't see Benitez in the shot, at all. Kind of irrelevant, though. Olivo is not an every day starter. Period.
June 24, 200719 yr yes Benitez was in line, but the ball took a side hop off of Olivo and took a detour to the dugout I've seen the replay a bunch of times, just didn't see Benitez in the shot, at all. Kind of irrelevant, though. Olivo is not an every day starter. Period. But yeah, Olivo should have had that.
June 24, 200719 yr Does Miguel Olivo really warrant this much discussion? yes, the starting catcher of our favorite team warrants this much discussion
June 24, 200719 yr The fact that he cant catch a baseball isnt really groundbreaking. neither is your hatred
June 24, 200719 yr But I would love to see either of you two catch it with a guy that big a milisecond away from a collision. The difference is, people on here aren't a starting catcher, which is what Olivo is suppose to be. And although I do give Olivo props for staying up, it really isn't that big of a deal. He had huge leverage on Morneau. If anybody here played offensive or deffensive line, then you'd know just how much of a big deal getting low on a guy is. The biggest thing on the line is the leverage you have on your guy. If you watch it again, expecially the last scene, Olivo went down for the ball, then as Morneau is coming in, Olivo was rising up. In the same instance, Morneau was lowering his body into Olivo. With Olivo low and rising, and Morneau high and dropping, Morneau had no shot, he's going to get creamed. It was just as much of Morneau doing something really stupid; and if the ball isn't low, I really doubt Olivo's still standing, because then he doesn't get low and get his leverage. I agree to a point. But at some point self preservation comes in. Olivo was miliseconds away from a major collision with a guy much bigger than he is. I really have no problem with him missing that ball. He was playing again Saturday night. The AL MVP??? And besides. WE WON.
June 24, 200719 yr great Olivo's a beast dude has stone hands Great, he only blocks the plate when he doesn't have the ball. Throw to him wasn't the best. But I would love to see either of you two catch it with a guy that big a milisecond away from a collision. Olivo did the right thing. He made a great try while bracing himself for a hard hit. Thing is, Olivo plays tomorrow. The other guy dosen't. See, that's like a mechanic saying "I'd like to see you guys change a carborator." It's his damn JOB to CATCH the f***ING ball. But it wasn't Hammers job to field it cleanly?? Or it wasn't Hanley's job to give a better throw?? Oh wait. Those two are MGIT. Olivo is the one that takes all the blame.
June 24, 200719 yr The fact that he cant catch a baseball isnt really groundbreaking. neither is your hatred I never get used to the exagerrations poured onto players that aren't on the kids' lists as MGs or MGITs. It's like they have no idea this is real life baseball and not some video game or fantasy baseball. Always expand the negatives and ignore the pluses. But such is life. I'm not making excuses intentionally for Olivo. I thought that ball was catchable. But I can see how the human instict of self preservation took over. He was the Saturday night for that georgous strike em out throw em out DP in the 1st. And with Louis getting a nice jump. He was also there for the only extra base hit and run scored by a Marlin Saturday night. I didn't think that error should have been on Hanley. I can't see how it could have been. He got the ball there as he was supposed to. But because Olivo got credited with the error we need to look at one of the kiddies fav players. If not for the inexcuseable dropped ball after a clean pickup by Hammer that play never even happens. Hammer should have gotten an error as well. But is that brought up??? Another way to look at it. Olivo could have pulled a Miggy. Just let the ball go by without making an attempt on it at all. "If you don't touch it, it can't go as an error." Alot like that double he let go by Saturday night. Again.
June 24, 200719 yr bottom line is if Olivo catches the ball, Morneau is out the throw from Hanley was catchable, and even though Hammer bobbled it, Morneau stopped in between 3rd and home anyway this coming from someone who actually likes Olivo.... so get this MG or MGIT or MIT or MIB sh*t out of here
June 24, 200719 yr I dont hate the guy. In fact, I dont really talk about him at all anymore. He can't catch but Treanor is a giant, gaping black hole on offense so were stuck with him for now. And Olivo is not completely worthless so give it up already with your campaign against him. He has a great arm, he's very quik and he destroys runners who try to run him over at the plate. And I repeat, he actually gets some big hits unlike Matt Treanor.
June 24, 200719 yr Staying on topic.... I saw a guy with a sign "The cut looks good, Bert!". Now I know what he was talking about.
June 24, 200719 yr Another way to look at it. Olivo could have pulled a Miggy. Just let the ball go by without making an attempt on it at all. "If you don't touch it, it can't go as an error." Alot like that double he let go by Saturday night. Again. Ah yes, the old "Miguel Cabrera doesn't like to go after balls so he doesn't get an error, and thats why he, like leads the league errors" argument.
June 24, 200719 yr He can't catch but Treanor is a giant, gaping black hole on offense so were stuck with him for now. I seriously don't understand the "Matt Treanor is a black hole in the lineup, but Miguel Olivo isn't" mindset when Treanor has a higher career OPS against RHP compared to Olivo (Against LHP it's no contest, Olivo does very well there). Yeah, Olivo has more pop, but Treanor gets on base a LOT more. And Olivo's pop doesn't mean much now that all he sees is breaking balls. That with Treanor's better glove...I don't even see how it's a contest.
June 24, 200719 yr I dont hate the guy. In fact, I dont really talk about him at all anymore. He can't catch but Treanor is a giant, gaping black hole on offense so were stuck with him for now. And Olivo is not completely worthless so give it up already with your campaign against him. He has a great arm, he's very quik and he destroys runners who try to run him over at the plate. And I repeat, he actually gets some big hits unlike Matt Treanor. Still one of if not the worst receiving catchers in baseball. And thats the biggest part of his job. I really dont hate the guy, I really dont. Hes just not a good ballplayer. Nothing wrong with that. I pretty much ignore the fact that he exists alot of the time, its zen-like. And who knows, the team could very well be better off if Treanor was the every day starter. The staff might have a little more confidence in their backstop, and there isnt as large a discrepancy in their bats as you like to suggest. Id give Treanor 5 starts in a row, see how he and the staff reacts.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.