Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Yay or Nay: Johnny Estrada

Featured Replies

Since the Mets have Schneider and Castro, and the Nats got Lo Duca, Johnny Estrada is running low on places where he can have a starting job. And since Rabelo is [probably] not the answer, especially for this 2008 season, would it be wise for the Marlins to take a chance on him? I'm not sure how much he makes, I'm just throwing it out there.

 

If the price is right, would you take him?

 

I'd feel a lot more comfortable with a veteran catcher controlling our young pitchers than a Matt Treanor or a Mike Rabelo.

  • Author

Basing this on what I saw on Rotoworld

 

 

 

---

The Mets are likely to non-tender Johnny Estrada, according to the New York Daily News.

New York acquired Estrada last month, but then made him expendable with the trade for Brian Schneider. With Washington out of the picture after signing Paul Lo Duca, Estrada's chances to land another starting gig are drying up.

  • Author

I would think by now Matt Treanor is a veteran

 

 

I wouldn't, considering he's never been a starting catcher in the big leagues. Just because he's got age on him doesn't necessarily make him a veteran

I would think by now Matt Treanor is a veteran

 

 

I wouldn't, considering he's never been a starting catcher in the big leagues. Just because he's got age on him doesn't make him a veteran

I guess...

 

We're more than likely not looking for a catcher anyway. They like Treanor/Rabelo

I wouldn't mind Estrada, and to carry three catchers, if he's cheap. He'd net us something at the trade deadline.

 

But if I have to categorize this, it would be "indifferent."

  • Author

I would think by now Matt Treanor is a veteran

 

 

I wouldn't, considering he's never been a starting catcher in the big leagues. Just because he's got age on him doesn't make him a veteran

I guess...

 

We're more than likely not looking for a catcher anyway. They like Treanor/Rabelo

 

 

True.

 

Why they like that tandem, I do not know, 'cause thats a sorry excuse for a catching tandem.

 

Estrada strikes me as a "Beinfest" type of player. We'll see if they draw interest

  • Author

Estrada made $3.4 million last year.

 

 

Ok, nevermind then...

 

:confused

Estrada made $3.4 million last year.

So?

 

He's being released and will have to accept whatever he is offered.

I hate Estrada

 

Not only do I dislike his game, but there's a reason he'll be on his 6th team before he can even hit free agency.

I hate Estrada

 

Not only do I dislike his game, but there's a reason he'll be on his 6th team before he can even hit free agency.

Why? D is sketchy, but how impactful is that? .280/.320/.406 career line is one of the better ones for catchers. Only 15 guys over 250 PA beat that last year.

 

Just think hate is to strong. I'd say he'll be relative to Pudge in 2008 for 1/10th (or even less) the cost.

I'd rather see what Treanor can do

 

3 years running his avg/obp/slg have been on a big rise

Just think hate is to strong.

 

Yeah that.

 

Plus it's not just me disliking his game but also what Ramp said.

 

Also he was non-tendered...I could be mistaken, but I believe that doesn't mean he was released in the sense that being released, he still gets paid. Being non-tendered a contract, he has NO contract to be released from, ergo, no money is owed to him. So I'm sure he'll still want money. But I could be wrong, that's just my interpretation of the wording of being non-tendered.

non-tendered in this sense means he was not offered a contract through arbitration and is due no money meaning he will want to get paid and the marlins would certainly not do that

The way the market is for catchers, Estrada has several more hefty paydays ahead of him. He will not be anywhere within marlin's price range.

I would think by now Matt Treanor is a veteran

 

 

I wouldn't, considering he's never been a starting catcher in the big leagues. Just because he's got age on him doesn't make him a veteran

I guess...

 

We're more than likely not looking for a catcher anyway. They like Treanor/Rabelo

 

 

True.

 

Why they like that tandem, I do not know, 'cause thats a sorry excuse for a catching tandem.

 

Estrada strikes me as a "Beinfest" type of player. We'll see if they draw interest

they like the tandem because they both are good at calling a game...and if they call a good game, out pitching gets better...which means we wont need to have an offensive juggernaut behind the plate

I would think by now Matt Treanor is a veteran

 

 

I wouldn't, considering he's never been a starting catcher in the big leagues. Just because he's got age on him doesn't make him a veteran

I guess...

 

We're more than likely not looking for a catcher anyway. They like Treanor/Rabelo

 

 

True.

 

Why they like that tandem, I do not know, 'cause thats a sorry excuse for a catching tandem.

 

Estrada strikes me as a "Beinfest" type of player. We'll see if they draw interest

they like the tandem because they both are good at calling a game...and if they call a good game, out pitching gets better...which means we wont need to have an offensive juggernaut behind the plate

 

 

Well that is TRUE!

I would think by now Matt Treanor is a veteran

 

 

I wouldn't, considering he's never been a starting catcher in the big leagues. Just because he's got age on him doesn't make him a veteran

I guess...

 

We're more than likely not looking for a catcher anyway. They like Treanor/Rabelo

 

 

True.

 

Why they like that tandem, I do not know, 'cause thats a sorry excuse for a catching tandem.

 

Estrada strikes me as a "Beinfest" type of player. We'll see if they draw interest

they like the tandem because they both are good at calling a game...and if they call a good game, out pitching gets better...which means we wont need to have an offensive juggernaut behind the plate

 

 

Well that is stupid in so many ways I can't even get into it.

We have to give Rabelo a chance guys. Not everyone starts off like Cabs or Pujols. Look at this franchise. We develop great players. As much as other people make fun of this team, the day that they are looking for quality players you know that the Marlins are at the top of other teams lists.

 

I have to give this kid the benefit of the doubt. No way would I take Estrada, this year, because that would mean taking time away from Rabelo behind the plate. This is the year for this kid to grab some real experience. Lets not kid ourselves. We are not going to be good this year. So lets take the time to give our team some experience.

 

Our stadium deal is near. Once that gets done then we can hopefully spend some money. This year we need to develop great players. I say keep the Treanor/Rabelo tandem.

If we're gonna be technical, none of them are kids. They're all grown men. Just thought the analogy would not have to be explained. Next time I'll try to avoid the figures of speech. Sorry.

He was talking in the baseball sense.

 

When you say "kid" you're generally talking about somebody 25 or under

 

Rabelo will be 28 next year, that's not young in baseball terms.

 

I deffinatly perfer a Rabelo/Treanor tandem though...and if it doesn't work out Treanor/Baker. In either situation you're looking at all catchers making the minimum, saving millions what you'd pay on something like an Estrada for what's essentially the same production offensively and worse defensively.

 

I really don't understand the FO's fascination with Rabelo over Treanor though. Rabelo has a history of hitting for a higher average...but Treanor has a better eye and more power. Rabelo is 4 years young, in the begining of his prime whereas Treanor is exiting it.

 

But I'm not going to bitch about Rabelo unless he does poorly next year...and from the sounds of it, Treanor should be getting more PT anyway.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.