Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Pick 5.

Featured Replies

  • Author

I just added Aaron Thompson to the list, btw. I had forgotten him. :mischief

 

You missed Chris Seddon and Daniel Barone as well.

 

:mis2

 

:lol

also my list

 

Andrew Miller

Sean West

Aaron Thompson

JJ

Volstad

 

Top 3 are only ones with #1 potential IMO, in order of I think of chance of reaching that point. Outside of them, others are either back of the rotation guys or have too many Qs (Anibal-injuries, Tucker-one pitch, Sinkbeil-unimpressive milb numbers, Allison-lots haha) although you could certainly add West to that list.

 

how does Thompson have #1 potential? Yet, Volstad doesn't??

 

 

Volstad is very valueable because it's extremely unlikely he doesn't become at worst a #3 guy, but he also doesn't have as high of a potential. Sinkerballers are only ace pitchers when they strike guys out ala Webb.

 

And I did stretch the means of Thompson but he still has 4 potential plus pitches. If all 4 get developed, he'll be better than Volstad.

also you did miss Gaby. He has a bad ERA but good periphals in AAA. His ERA is so bad because of HRs and a higher-than-should-be OAVG...imagine that where they are. 8.18 K/9 to 2.45 BB/9 is very nice.

This is a stupid question, but im young, so excuse my ignorance please. what about jacob Marceaux? he was a first round pick in 2005, along with Aaron Thompson, Christopher Volstad, Ryan Tucker, and Sean West.

This is a stupid question, but im young, so excuse my ignorance please. what about jacob Marceaux? he was a first round pick in 2005, along with Aaron Thompson, Christopher Volstad, Ryan Tucker, and Sean West.

Marceaux has actually been pitching in relief. All 30 games he pitched last year for Jupiter were in relief, and he's 2-1 with a 4.91 ERA in relief this season at AA Carolina.

also you did miss Gaby. He has a bad ERA but good periphals in AAA. His ERA is so bad because of HRs and a higher-than-should-be OAVG...imagine that where they are. 8.18 K/9 to 2.45 BB/9 is very nice.

 

Yeah, Gaby would have replaced Sinkbeil on my list, but I was working with what was given to me

This is a stupid question, but im young, so excuse my ignorance please. what about jacob Marceaux? he was a first round pick in 2005, along with Aaron Thompson, Christopher Volstad, Ryan Tucker, and Sean West.

Marceaux has actually been pitching in relief. All 30 games he pitched last year for Jupiter were in relief, and he's 2-1 with a 4.91 ERA in relief this season at AA Carolina.

 

thanx

Sinkerballers are only ace pitchers when they strike guys out ala Webb.

 

A fella by the name of Roy Halladay begs to differ.

My rotation would be

 

1.Anibal Sanchez(my boy is gonna fight back from his injury)

2.Andrew Miller

3.Josh Johnson

4.Christopher Volstad

5.Aaron Thompson

 

Ryan Tucker would be my closer, ricky Nolasco, Burke Badenhop, and Eulogio De La Cruz will be in the bullpen

Sinkerballers are only ace pitchers when they strike guys out ala Webb.

 

A fella by the name of Roy Halladay begs to differ.

 

 

Fair, but volstad also hasn't displayed that control.

  • Author

Crap, you guys are right...I forgot to put Gaby Hernandez on the list. I'll put him up, now.

  • Author

Sinkerballers are only ace pitchers when they strike guys out ala Webb.

 

A fella by the name of Roy Halladay begs to differ.

 

 

Fair, but volstad also hasn't displayed that control.

 

 

I saw Volstad pitch a ST game against the Yankees...his control is what impressed me the most, to be honest.

Sinkerballers are only ace pitchers when they strike guys out ala Webb.

 

A fella by the name of Roy Halladay begs to differ.

 

 

Fair, but volstad also hasn't displayed that control.

 

 

For their minor league careers, Halladay had a 2.94 BB9 compared to Volstad's 2.43. Volstad also strikes out more guys. Halladay also pitched 70 innings in the minors at age 24, which he obviously dominated, slightly helping his MiLB numbers.

JJ

Anibal Sanchez

Chris Volstad

Andrew Miller

Gaby Hernandez

Sinkerballers are only ace pitchers when they strike guys out ala Webb.

 

A fella by the name of Roy Halladay begs to differ.

 

 

Fair, but volstad also hasn't displayed that control.

 

 

For their minor league careers, Halladay had a 2.94 BB9 compared to Volstad's 2.43. Volstad also strikes out more guys. Halladay also pitched 70 innings in the minors at age 24, which he obviously dominated, slightly helping his MiLB numbers.

 

 

Halladay also completely revamped his game. His BB/9 numbers in his ace years are in the low to mid 1's, nearly a 2 BB drop from those milb numbers. And in most cases, bb numbers go up when players hit mlb

 

It's certainly possible that Volstad changes his game (which is also why I said displayed). But when you start talking like that, then players like Barone have ace potential. I mean yes, technically speaking, every person has ace "potential" due to the nature of what potential is. But what you do is play the percentages. It's very very very likely what Volstad becomes is what most good sinkerballers are, high 3 to low 4 ERA inning eats.

Sinkerballers are only ace pitchers when they strike guys out ala Webb.

 

A fella by the name of Roy Halladay begs to differ.

 

 

Fair, but volstad also hasn't displayed that control.

 

I wasn't necessarily comparing Volstad to Halladay, just pointing out that a ground-ball pitcher doesn't have to rack up a bunch of K's to be successful.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.