August 6, 200818 yr Does luck = skill? BTW, don't blame me it was Rab's fault he did this to me. Luck and skill are two completely different things... the playoffs are a crapshoot... fact's a fact... the best team doesn't always win... even the Pirates could win a 5 game series against the Cubs... does it make them the better team? Absolutely not... the Cubs are WAY better than the Pirates, the Pirates just benefited from luck... whether their good luck or the Cubs inevitable bad luck... Rockies last year, best team in the NL? Absolutely not... got to the World Series because the whole team got locked in at the same time and had one of the luckiest series of weeks in history... Baseball is a game where skill can only take you so far, the rest is luck... ball gets hit into humid air where normally it'd be a homer, guy misses a pitch by an 8th of an inch, goes from a walkoff homer to a flyout... I understand what your saying PWG, but I am just having trouble believing that the playoffs are 100% luck, anything can happen but I don't believe it's because of luck. The better team wins because, they are the better team. (hot or not) To add to what you were saying the Rockies were swept in the WS because the Red Sox were the better team.
August 6, 200818 yr Does luck = skill? BTW, don't blame me it was Rab's fault he did this to me. Luck and skill are two completely different things... the playoffs are a crapshoot... fact's a fact... the best team doesn't always win... even the Pirates could win a 5 game series against the Cubs... does it make them the better team? Absolutely not... the Cubs are WAY better than the Pirates, the Pirates just benefited from luck... whether their good luck or the Cubs inevitable bad luck... Rockies last year, best team in the NL? Absolutely not... got to the World Series because the whole team got locked in at the same time and had one of the luckiest series of weeks in history... Baseball is a game where skill can only take you so far, the rest is luck... ball gets hit into humid air where normally it'd be a homer, guy misses a pitch by an 8th of an inch, goes from a walkoff homer to a flyout... I understand what your saying PWG, but I am just having trouble believing that the playoffs are 100% luck, anything can happen but I don't believe it's because of luck. The better team wins because, they are the better team. (hot or not) To add to what you were saying the Rockies were swept in the WS because the Red Sox were the better team. if i recall the rockies where hot and had to wait a week? because the sox and indians weren't done with their series.....now did that have ab effect on the rockies, of course. did boston win by luck,no because they had a good team. alot of conclusions can be brought up.
August 6, 200818 yr Being good in the regular season doesn't make you the best team. Having the best record doesn't make you the best team. There's no objective way to look at it other than the World Series winner.
August 6, 200818 yr i can only agree with Colorado getting lucky even though they were the hottest team going down the stretch. However, St.Louis in 06 had the best team in the N.L with Carpenter having a strong year and having an explosive offense. Houston also had a nice offense and an amazing pitching staff. You cant blame luck for their world series appearances Absolutely not... In 2006 the Mets won 97 games, LA and San Diego each won 88 games... the Cardinals won 83(!!!) Without looking it up, Im going to guess that's one of, if not THE LOWEST regular season winning percentage for a world series champ EVER in the modern age of baseball... the Cardinals got hot and they got lucky... and I hate the Mets, but they were the best NL team that year... In Houston's world series year, they didn't even win the world series... same pitching staff ALL YEAR and to say their offense was NICE??? Rabb's a big Astro's fan and he'll tell you it was terrible... absolutely terrible... compare that to the Cardinals who actually WERE the best team that year with 100 wins, followed by Atlanta with 90. If these WERE the best teams in baseball, their record would have indicated it in the regular season... they were benificiaries of lucky playoff hot streaks... Heck, as a Marlins fan, Im front row admitting we weren't the best team in the NL in 2003... here comes the heretic chants... we just were lucky enough to have Josh Beckett establish himself as one of the best big game pitchers of all-time, and yes we did get VERY lucky in the Cubs series...
August 6, 200818 yr Heck, as a Marlins fan, Im front row admitting we weren't the best team in the NL in 2003... here comes the heretic chants... we just were lucky enough to have Josh Beckett establish himself as one of the best big game pitchers of all-time, and yes we did get VERY lucky in the Cubs series... Gotta disagree with you there. The 2003 Marlins took off in May and never looked back. They were solid and I don't think beating the Cubs was all about luck. Maybe a lucky run or two but the Marlins got a lot more than that. Steve Bartman didn't score all those runs in that inning and the Cubs choked so the Marlins were the better team. And they flat out beat the Yankees because they were the better team. That team was poised, confident and not in awe of anyone or anything. I'm not saying that because I'm a homer, I'm actually pretty critical. Those who thought the Marlins came out of nowhere in '03 were simply not watching.
August 6, 200818 yr Heck, as a Marlins fan, Im front row admitting we weren't the best team in the NL in 2003... here comes the heretic chants... we just were lucky enough to have Josh Beckett establish himself as one of the best big game pitchers of all-time, and yes we did get VERY lucky in the Cubs series... Gotta disagree with you there. The 2003 Marlins took off in May and never looked back. They were solid and I don't think beating the Cubs was all about luck. Maybe a lucky run or two but the Marlins got a lot more than that. Steve Bartman didn't score all those runs in that inning and the Cubs choked so the Marlins were the better team. And they flat out beat the Yankees because they were the better team. I'm not saying that because I'm a homer, I'm actually pretty critical. Those who thought the Marlins came out of nowhere in '03 were simply not watching. It's not so much that they came out of nowhere... certainly not at all, having watched consistently since 1998... I barely watched in 1997 and became a fan once all the good players were traded (bad timing on my part ) But... for all intents and purposes... when Alex Gonzalez screwed up not 1 but 2(!!!) plays in a game that should have ended the series... yeah, that screams luck... were we better than the Yankees? I'd say we were, but not by a lot, again... benefited from having Beckett completely own them... as well as the other players doing what they do... Also... when you say the Cubs choked... that's bad luck... it's not choking... I don't believe in "choking" at the ML level... that's me though, I think it's just terrible, terrible luck... will I say the Mets choked last year, yes, because I hate them, but not because it's true... but back to the point, one team's bad luck is another team's good luck...
August 6, 200818 yr Go back to the Major League Baseball forum, you bum! Get out of my forum! I actually made this scenario up in an IM with Rabb
August 6, 200818 yr Heck, as a Marlins fan, Im front row admitting we weren't the best team in the NL in 2003... here comes the heretic chants... we just were lucky enough to have Josh Beckett establish himself as one of the best big game pitchers of all-time, and yes we did get VERY lucky in the Cubs series... Gotta disagree with you there. The 2003 Marlins took off in May and never looked back. They were solid and I don't think beating the Cubs was all about luck. Maybe a lucky run or two but the Marlins got a lot more than that. Steve Bartman didn't score all those runs in that inning and the Cubs choked so the Marlins were the better team. And they flat out beat the Yankees because they were the better team. I'm not saying that because I'm a homer, I'm actually pretty critical. Those who thought the Marlins came out of nowhere in '03 were simply not watching. It's not so much that they came out of nowhere... certainly not at all, having watched consistently since 1998... I barely watched in 1997 and became a fan once all the good players were traded (bad timing on my part ) But... for all intents and purposes... when Alex Gonzalez screwed up not 1 but 2(!!!) plays in a game that should have ended the series... yeah, that screams luck... were we better than the Yankees? I'd say we were, but not by a lot, again... benefited from having Beckett completely own them... as well as the other players doing what they do... Also... when you say the Cubs choked... that's bad luck... it's not choking... I don't believe in "choking" at the ML level... that's me though, I think it's just terrible, terrible luck... will I say the Mets choked last year, yes, because I hate them, but not because it's true... but back to the point, one team's bad luck is another team's good luck... Our players were poised, cool, calm, collected and came to play. The Cubs were up 3 games to 1, got owned by Beckett and the next game completely fell apart in the "Bartman inning." Alou had a tantrum, Gonzalez f'd up and their stud pitcher crapped his pants. Then they lost again! In my eyes they choked and the Fish were the better team but, of course, that's a matter of opinion. Oh, and Beckett didn't get lucky he got flat out filthy nasty.
August 6, 200818 yr Our players were poised, cool, calm, collected and came to play. The Cubs were up 3 games to 1, got owned by Beckett and the next game completely fell apart in the "Bartman inning." Alou had a tantrum, Gonzalez f'd up and their stud pitcher crapped his pants. Then they lost again! In my eyes they choked and the Fish were the better team but, of course, that's a matter of opinion. Oh, and Beckett didn't get lucky he got flat out filthy nasty. Regardless of all of that... my point on the whole was that luck determines 99% of World Series champions (number's exaggerated, but luck is HIGHLY involved) I can't be convinced we were the best team in the NL in 2003, let alone the ML And if we win the World Series this year... is someone gonna claim we're the best team in baseball? Because really... we aren't... but we're good enough to be dangerous in short series's... A few notes... taken from Moneyball Pete Palmer did a study.... "The average difference in baseball due to skill is about one run per game, while the average difference due to luck is four runs a game. Over a long season, the luck evens out, and the skill shines through. But in a series of three out of five, or even four out of seven, anything can happen. In a five-game series, the worst team in baseball will beat the best team 15 percent of the time... Baseball science may give a team a slight edge, but that edge is overwhelmed by chance." And I can't find the exact quote... but Billy Beane or Paul DePodesta said it best... "The playoffs are a crapshoot, the best I can do is have three solid starting pitchers and a good offense and hope for the best"
August 6, 200818 yr I don't disagree that there is an element of luck. I disagree about the 2003 Marlins.
August 6, 200818 yr I think using the actual word "luck" is causing a misunderstanding here... While skill helps, a lot of the playoffs are won by momentum...which is why the wild card team often makes it to the world series, they ended the season with the most momentum...and that definitely explains the 07 Rockies...and in some ways the 03 Fish... Bottom line, stop saying its luck...its more like momentum... Derek Jeter himself has said the playoffs arent won by the best team, they are won by the hottest team
August 6, 200818 yr I think using the actual word "luck" is causing a misunderstanding here... While skill helps, a lot of the playoffs are won by momentum...which is why the wild card team often makes it to the world series, they ended the season with the most momentum...and that definitely explains the 07 Rockies...and in some ways the 03 Fish... Bottom line, stop saying its luck...its more like momentum... Derek Jeter himself has said the playoffs arent won by the best team, they are won by the hottest team It's more like whatever intangible term you want to throw on it... Im too lazy to look it up and I put away the book already, but "hot teams" with a lot of "momentum" tend to be MORE likely to lose on a given night... I'll confirm it tomorrow with the source/quote
August 6, 200818 yr Our style has been working, no change necessary. Yeah I kind of like the whole leading the league in homeruns, top 6 in runs scored kind of thing.
August 6, 200818 yr Ignoring the whole luck debate... This team's style isn't going to change at all, we're just going to get better starting pitching 3 out of 5 days that we wouldn't have gotten in the first half. So we're gonna get better, but not because of a different style. Last night actually pretty much looked like a typical Marlins game, the clutch hitting basically amounted to a lucky bloop by Amezaga (third baseman should have been playing further back with 2 outs) and a couple clutch hits by Hermida, one of the few guys on the team NOT known as a free swinging high strikeout power hitter. Other than that we got a sac fly, and a bases loaded walk... mostly generated by Moyer's poor control. Defensively nothing too amazing besides Willingham's catch, Hanley almost botched an easy double play early on where he got the ball right at second (the one where Rollins was trying to steal a base). Biggest difference, instead of a Badenhop or Hendrickson letting the Phillies into the game, we had JJ shutting them down. Nothing different about our style, just a better pitcher.
August 6, 200818 yr I don't know if it's so much the team should "change" as perhaps more emphasis in workouts and drills on some of the little things that improve hitting situationally - choking up on the bat (or shortening one's swing) with two strikes or a man at third with one out or less to hit the ball to the right side with an infield playing back, and even to be thinking right side in that situation, more bunting practice - whatever the list is of areas of weakness where not addressing them has an amplifying effect in a pennant race. Hanley, Dan, Cody and especially Jake (guys with "big" swings) could benefit of taking an inch off the bat which increases bat head speed while providing more control, in certain situations could make the difference in the outcome of a game especially with 50 games left. (OMG!!! 50 games left, how did that happen?)
August 7, 200818 yr Yea I think they did manage to change their style a lot of balls have been hit on the ground up the middle etc, etc. Not alot of Home Runs. Seems like we have been 2.5 games back forever.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.