February 7, 200917 yr Will Carroll uses a comprehensive system to project injuries based on a players career. You can find some vague detail about the system here: http://www.baseballprospectus.com/article.php?articleid=8410 (might be premium/subscriber only) He uses a color code for simplicity: Red = High injury risk Yellow = Moderate injury risk Green = Low injury risk Here is who is red: * Dallas McPhearson * Ricky Nolasco * Chris Volstad Some notable yellows: * Cameron Maybin * Hanley Ramirez * Andrew Miller * Jeremy Hermida Any thoughts?
February 7, 200917 yr You cant really predict injuries. Yes, some players are more prone to injury than others, however there can be many cases of freak injuries which would totally disrupt predictions etc
February 7, 200917 yr I'd put Hermida at the top just because i'm afraid he'll pull a muscle trying to swing a baseball bat like he really meant it. But in all seriousness, injuries can happen to anybody anytime. I don't see Volstad as injury prone, but who knows. Shouldn't read much into this, just because injuries are something you can't prepare yourself for.
February 7, 200917 yr Any list that doesn't have Anibal Sanchez at the top isn't worth reading. I agree with the yellows though. I think he is believing that Nolasco and Volstad are going to flame out this year. That may be true, but they concern me less than the guys that have been injured seriously before like Johnson and Sanchez.
February 7, 200917 yr You cant really predict injuries. Yes, some players are more prone to injury than others, however there can be many cases of freak injuries which would totally disrupt predictions etc It is way to hard. Prone to injuries might be easier to predict, but the chance of injuries is just way to hard to predict.
February 7, 200917 yr Author Sanchez, Baker, and Johnson are yellow as well. The formula/components of the system aren't entirely shared--so it's hard to provide a lot of detail. What I do know, though, is that he is a respected expert on baseball-player injuries, so his injury-projections are worth giving some credit to. Here are some details of his system, shared in the articled I linked to in the original post: The base of the system is an actuarial table. You can't get more boring than that, and unfortunately, it's the part I can't share with you. The table is put together by an outside entity, and is... well, let's just say it's very similar to the one used to calculate the premium on insuring player contracts and setting workman's comp payments. Like any actuarial table, it's simply a matter of presenting risk based on various categories. The most basic categories here are age and position; a 26-year-old pitcher could have a 40 percent risk for injury (these aren't the real numbers), while a 32-year-old pitcher might have a 38 percent risk. These injury risks are calculated to account for a severe injury—one that would put a player at risk of passing the elimination period of the policy, which is usually 90 days. The injury risk is also based on a three-year period. For a 29-year-old pitcher, it doesn't care if the pitcher is CC Sabathia or Jeremy Affeldt; it's a baseline risk.
February 7, 200917 yr Sanchez, Baker, and Johnson are yellow as well. The formula/components of the system aren't entirely shared--so it's hard to provide a lot of detail. What I do know, though, is that he is a respected expert on baseball-player injuries, so his injury-projections are worth giving some credit to. Here are some details of his system, shared in the articled I linked to in the original post: The base of the system is an actuarial table. You can't get more boring than that, and unfortunately, it's the part I can't share with you. The table is put together by an outside entity, and is... well, let's just say it's very similar to the one used to calculate the premium on insuring player contracts and setting workman's comp payments. Like any actuarial table, it's simply a matter of presenting risk based on various categories. The most basic categories here are age and position; a 26-year-old pitcher could have a 40 percent risk for injury (these aren't the real numbers), while a 32-year-old pitcher might have a 38 percent risk. These injury risks are calculated to account for a severe injury?one that would put a player at risk of passing the elimination period of the policy, which is usually 90 days. The injury risk is also based on a three-year period. For a 29-year-old pitcher, it doesn't care if the pitcher is CC Sabathia or Jeremy Affeldt; it's a baseline risk. Well, given that those other three are also included, I'm inclined to agree with this report although for fans like us there is nothing really new. Guys who have had a tendency for injuries in the past as well as the young pitchers who have worked or are going to work a large amount of innings are all prone.
February 7, 200917 yr What is dumb about it. Can you elaborate? Lets just say I'm not going to worry about a guy predicting injuries. Especially one predicting them, basically, from the age of a player, it seems. Anyone can do this.
February 7, 200917 yr Author There's 12 components to the system. Age is only one of them. You're certainly entitled to your opinion, but backing up your perception with something substantive would make for better discussion, imo.
February 7, 200917 yr I'm really worried about Nolasco, and I think fine 'reds' would be McPherson, Anibal, Miller, and Proctor, for all obvious injury related reasons. I'd put Johnson, Baker, Hermida, Kensing, and Pinto as yellows for nagging concerns. I have no idea about Volstad. He has been brought up pretty solid with no outrageous innings bumps, has good mechanics, and doesn't have a volatile-strikeout approach where he over throws. He understands he is all about getting the grounders. I'd venture to say he is our 'healthiest' starting pitcher entering the year.
February 7, 200917 yr The Volstad one confused me as well. Maybe it's because we cannot possibly expect him to give us a full year this year when his previous high was 152 IP 3 years ago?
February 7, 200917 yr I agree w/ Eric. This is plain silly. Predicting injuries? C'mon. What is next? Predicting car accidents, divorce, high blood pressure? These guys really have too much time on their hands.
February 7, 200917 yr Author I think it's quite necessary, actually. Teams invest more money, in one year, on one player, than 95% of the world sees in a lifetime. Maybe not the Marlins, but I digress: If I'm a General Manager of a hundred-million-dollar franchise, and my performance is measured by how efficiently I allocate the owners dollars, I'd love to have a system that forecasts a players health--so long as the methodology is sound. Will Carroll has many contacts in baseball, and is generally respected by front office executives. He makes a full time living writing a weekly column title "Under the Knife" at Baseball Prospectus, where he analyzes player injuries exclusively. He knows far more about the subject than any of us ever likely will. If you have complaints about the components of the system, that's fine. But to just conclude this is stupid/unnecessary-hogwash seems a bit short sighted to me. Especially if you don't take the time to read the article that outlines how the system works.
February 7, 200917 yr I think it's quite necessary, actually. Teams invest more money, in one year, on one player, than 95% of the world sees in a lifetime. Maybe not the Marlins, but I digress: If I'm a General Manager of a hundred-million-dollar franchise, and my performance is measured by how efficiently I allocate the owners dollars, I'd love to have a system that forecasts a players health--so long as the methodology is sound. Will Carroll has many contacts in baseball, and is generally respected by front office executives. He makes a full time living writing a weekly column title "Under the Knife" at Baseball Prospectus, where he analyzes player injuries exclusively. He knows far more about the subject than any of us ever likely will. If you have complaints about the components of the system, that's fine. But to just conclude this is stupid/unnecessary-hogwash seems a bit short sighted to me. Especially if you don't take the time to read the article that outlines how the system works. I admit to be prejudiced here as it regards the writer who I find one of those who delights in telling half-truths to make a point determined well before work on the piece began, but I have to agree that this is a necessary exercise (or something akin to it) that goes on in every MLB FO and rightfully should. These kind of decisions are part of the assessment made of every player, whether to keep him him, trade him, replace him, how to deal with contracts etc. We forget how little we know about individual ballplayers and a piece like this reminds us of that.
February 7, 200917 yr Many of you are are missing the main point. These are ratings are compiled much like the way insurance companies rate applicants for a policy. MLB teams are no different - they also take out disability insurance on their players. They want to be sure that either their "property" produces, or if not, they are not stuck paying the full salary burden to their non-functioning property, or "capital", if you like that term better. He's not trying to predict actual player injuries. Instead, he's making a probability guess. There's likely a figure something like this for each group: Yellow - [Coefficient for likelihood of multiple injuries] (% chance of injury) X (average games missed in case of injury) = Average Risk Per Player rated Yellow. Let's say the figures for the yellow group is that the average person in this groups misses 20 games (I know games are not a perfect measure for P's vs position players). All he's trying to say is that over a large sample size, the yellow's will approach this actuarially-predicted result. And you can bet your ass they will - insurance companies are extremely good at what they do, and they certainly aren't in business to lose money and have wild volatility swings (at least over the medium to long term). They group players in such a way so that insurance companies can appropriately price the risk of insuring different players salary. Obviously, the red players would have the highest disability insurance premiums, and then yellow players on down. They may even break it down into further categories, but this is the main idea.
February 7, 200917 yr Many of you are are missing the main point. These are ratings are compiled much like the way insurance companies rate applicants for a policy. MLB teams are no different - they also take out disability insurance on their players. They want to be sure that either their "property" produces, or if not, they are not stuck paying the full salary burden to their non-functioning property, or "capital", if you like that term better. He's not trying to predict actual player injuries. Instead, he's making a probability guess. There's likely a figure something like this for each group: Yellow - [Coefficient for likelihood of multiple injuries] (% chance of injury) X (average games missed in case of injury) = Average Risk Per Player rated Yellow. Let's say the figures for the yellow group is that the average person in this groups misses 20 games (I know games are not a perfect measure for P's vs position players). All he's trying to say is that over a large sample size, the yellow's will approach this actuarially-predicted result. And you can bet your ass they will - insurance companies are extremely good at what they do, and they certainly aren't in business to lose money and have wild volatility swings (at least over the medium to long term). They group players in such a way so that insurance companies can appropriately price the risk of insuring different players salary. Obviously, the red players would have the highest disability insurance premiums, and then yellow players on down. They may even break it down into further categories, but this is the main idea. +1. Good post. It is not silly, you could make a claim that predicting anything is silly, as it is just a guess, but when it is an educated guess like Will Carroll is doing here with many factors involved it makes for interesting discussion. Sure it won't and can't be 100% accurate but what prediction will be?
February 9, 200917 yr I think this is pretty...dumb. Nothing wrong with making very educated guesses.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.