August 11, 200917 yr You are giving a lot of examples, but most of those players were the exception, not the norm. In other words, you picked the very best 5-10 rookies every year to come up with that list. And look at the list you provide yourself... the "top prospects" are all below .800. All I am saying is that if you make the moves you suggest 100 times over on average we will be looking at a downgraded offense. Of course, we gotta play within our constraints. The moves you suggest are the best possible moves given our limited payroll. Still, I think it's a fallacy to believe it's more likely than not that the replacements will be sufficient to overcome the loss of those players. Could it happen? Sure. Anything's possible. First, I'm not cherry picking. That's flat out the list of all the rookies. Morrison and Maybin should not be compared to the tons of Bonifacio, De Azas, and Brett Hayes (i.e. the norm) rookies that come up every year and do nothing. These are different animals. Second, who cares if they don't hit .800. It's about what offense they need to replace - and that's about a .765 OPS cumulatively from the guys who will be going out. I think all of our rookies/second year players have the ability to hit .765, let alone cumulatively. I think we score around the same amount of runs next year if our lineup is this: R Maybin CF L Coghlan 2B/LF R Hanley SS R Cantu 3B L Morrison 1B/LF R Ross RF L Baker C R G. Sanchez 1B / Carroll LF/RF Bench - Bonifacio, Helms, Paulino, G. Sanchez/Carroll, "Veteran Bat" That's 5 spots to 1st and 2nd year players, and an additional 2, 1st and 2nd year players on the bench. But if we can't 'afford' Ross, and we have to rely on something else, like more of Carroll, Gaby, and Bonifacio subbing in, I still don't think it's going to be that big of a deal. We're in pretty good shape here. Bonifacio and Hermida are so bad, even if we come down from Uggla and Ross, it's all going to average into something replaceable. I think Hermida is easily replaceable and we already have Uggla's replacement (Coghlin). The other guy we are replacing is Bonifacio, which I think is relatively easy to do. Replacing Ross would be more dicey. I think it would be a mistake to trade Ross.
August 11, 200917 yr First off, I'd like to say thanks b/c I've been asking a lot of questions lately related to this. The only thing I didn't understand was why Leo would be getting less than Matt Lindstrom. I actually understood the Lindstrom part, but for each player, it seems the main emphasis when going to arbritration is this current year + last year. So my question is, why is Leo's money being decided on ALL his years in the big leagues (05-08)? Also, regarding Leo...it seems like he'll get the "high." I'm not sure when you began the original post (although you said it took you the Phillies series, so I'm assuming Friday)? If that's the case, you said the contract for the high would be if he got 10 more saves...since Friday he's got 3. I'm guessing he'll get 7+ in the next month in a half (the only guy the Marlins would give the role to is Lindstrom, and tonight didn't help the cause, there). Anyways, great post, and I'd like to say I hate arbritration now even more after the explanation. The arbritrators use the most overrated statistics to decide how much money a player gets (specifically with the relievers).
August 11, 200917 yr Author after watching lindstrom almost blow it again tonite if the guy gets anywhere near 1.85 million he needs to be traded. we could use money like that on veterans looking for a comback like we did with donnelly and calero Well, the Lindstrom and Nunez figures are very volatile as those projections are with the two of them splitting the saves for the rest of the year. These estimates are very preliminary. If Lindstrom doesn't close anymore, you can lop about $250,000 off of that. I'm not sure if that defeats the purpose of your post or not, but he's going to be cheaper without the magical save stats.
August 11, 200917 yr Author First off, I'd like to say thanks b/c I've been asking a lot of questions lately related to this. The only thing I didn't understand was why Leo would be getting less than Matt Lindstrom. I actually understood the Lindstrom part, but for each player, it seems the main emphasis when going to arbritration is this current year + last year. So my question is, why is Leo's money being decided on ALL his years in the big leagues (05-08)? Also, regarding Leo...it seems like he'll get the "high." I'm not sure when you began the original post (although you said it took you the Phillies series, so I'm assuming Friday)? If that's the case, you said the contract for the high would be if he got 10 more saves...since Friday he's got 3. I'm guessing he'll get 7+ in the next month in a half (the only guy the Marlins would give the role to is Lindstrom, and tonight didn't help the cause, there). Anyways, great post, and I'd like to say I hate arbritration now even more after the explanation. The arbritrators use the most overrated statistics to decide how much money a player gets (specifically with the relievers). Because Lindstrom has a better career, and I was projecting them each to get 5-6 more saves which shoots Lindstrom up. Obviously things have changed recently. You have to remember these are preliminary as the season isn't over, and certainly if Nunez gets to 20+ saves he is going to be worth more than Lindstrom. Maybe a better way to think about it in the short term is, Lindstrom and Nunez are combined going to cost about $3.25 million next year, give or take $250,000. It's just unknown how that split is going to work out depending on who gets the 8-10 more saves this team probably gets this year. I think that's a really reasonable sum.
August 11, 200917 yr First off, I'd like to say thanks b/c I've been asking a lot of questions lately related to this. The only thing I didn't understand was why Leo would be getting less than Matt Lindstrom. I actually understood the Lindstrom part, but for each player, it seems the main emphasis when going to arbritration is this current year + last year. So my question is, why is Leo's money being decided on ALL his years in the big leagues (05-08)? Also, regarding Leo...it seems like he'll get the "high." I'm not sure when you began the original post (although you said it took you the Phillies series, so I'm assuming Friday)? If that's the case, you said the contract for the high would be if he got 10 more saves...since Friday he's got 3. I'm guessing he'll get 7+ in the next month in a half (the only guy the Marlins would give the role to is Lindstrom, and tonight didn't help the cause, there). Anyways, great post, and I'd like to say I hate arbritration now even more after the explanation. The arbritrators use the most overrated statistics to decide how much money a player gets (specifically with the relievers). Because Lindstrom has a better career, and I was projecting them each to get 5-6 more saves which shoots Lindstrom up. Obviously things have changed recently. You have to remember these are preliminary as the season isn't over, and certainly if Nunez gets to 20+ saves he is going to be worth more than Lindstrom. Maybe a better way to think about it in the short term is, Lindstrom and Nunez are combined going to cost about $3.25 million next year, give or take $250,000. It's just unknown how that split is going to work out depending on who gets the 8-10 more saves this team probably gets this year. I think that's a really reasonable sum. Btw, I just noticed my question was dumb, as you did all the years for all the relievers (not just past 2 years). Again, great thread.
August 11, 200917 yr By "at the same level" I meant both level in baseball and prospect. Clearly, if you are playing well in AA as a 20 or 21 year old, you've got a great chance to do well at the MLB level regardless of your status as a top prospect. Coghlin has never been considered one of the top prospects in baseball (very good prospect, but I don't recall Coghlin ever being ranked in the top 50 in all of baseball), yet he has produced at every level and is now doing very well as a rookie for the Marlins. You are giving a lot of examples, but most of those players were the exception, not the norm. In other words, you picked the very best 5-10 rookies every year to come up with that list. And look at the list you provide yourself... the "top prospects" are all below .800. All I am saying is that if you make the moves you suggest 100 times over on average we will be looking at a downgraded offense. Of course, we gotta play within our constraints. The moves you suggest are the best possible moves given our limited payroll. Still, I think it's a fallacy to believe it's more likely than not that the replacements will be sufficient to overcome the loss of those players. Could it happen? Sure. Anything's possible. Sorry, but you're killing me here. First, Lou is doing the legwork to show you why what he is saying makes perfect, logical sense as the most probabilistic outcome. And yet you seem to want to ignore the parts that weaken your argument. As for the "top prospects", he was merely showing other top prospects who didn't perform quite as well. Just look at this year. McClutchen, Beckham, Fowler, and Gardner are all highly touted prospects, for example. And it blows my mind that you are calling something [which Lou has reasonably shown, mind you] a fallacy, yet you quote "The Law of Averages" yourself. That "law" is a crock of bull. Wikipedia it yourself if you don't believe me. It can't really be referenced to prove anything, especially in a small sample of 3, yet that is how you "proved", "statistically speaking", that [and I quote] "it is likely that only one of those replacements will end up outproducing those current three players next year."? This probably sounds harsh, but I'm not buying it.
August 11, 200917 yr By "at the same level" I meant both level in baseball and prospect. Clearly, if you are playing well in AA as a 20 or 21 year old, you've got a great chance to do well at the MLB level regardless of your status as a top prospect. Coghlin has never been considered one of the top prospects in baseball (very good prospect, but I don't recall Coghlin ever being ranked in the top 50 in all of baseball), yet he has produced at every level and is now doing very well as a rookie for the Marlins. You are giving a lot of examples, but most of those players were the exception, not the norm. In other words, you picked the very best 5-10 rookies every year to come up with that list. And look at the list you provide yourself... the "top prospects" are all below .800. All I am saying is that if you make the moves you suggest 100 times over on average we will be looking at a downgraded offense. Of course, we gotta play within our constraints. The moves you suggest are the best possible moves given our limited payroll. Still, I think it's a fallacy to believe it's more likely than not that the replacements will be sufficient to overcome the loss of those players. Could it happen? Sure. Anything's possible. Sorry, but you're killing me here. First, Lou is doing the legwork to show you why what he is saying makes perfect, logical sense as the most probabilistic outcome. And yet you seem to want to ignore the parts that weaken your argument. As for the "top prospects", he was merely showing other top prospects who didn't perform quite as well. Just look at this year. McClutchen, Beckham, Fowler, and Gardner are all highly touted prospects, for example. And it blows my mind that you are calling something [which Lou has reasonably shown, mind you] a fallacy, yet you quote "The Law of Averages" yourself. That "law" is a crock of bull. Wikipedia it yourself if you don't believe me. It can't really be referenced to prove anything, especially in a small sample of 3, yet that is how you "proved", "statistically speaking", that [and I quote] "it is likely that only one of those replacements will end up outproducing those current three players next year."? This probably sounds harsh, but I'm not buying it. To be fair, Wikipedia can be a crock of bull, as well.
August 11, 200917 yr By "at the same level" I meant both level in baseball and prospect. Clearly, if you are playing well in AA as a 20 or 21 year old, you've got a great chance to do well at the MLB level regardless of your status as a top prospect. Coghlin has never been considered one of the top prospects in baseball (very good prospect, but I don't recall Coghlin ever being ranked in the top 50 in all of baseball), yet he has produced at every level and is now doing very well as a rookie for the Marlins. You are giving a lot of examples, but most of those players were the exception, not the norm. In other words, you picked the very best 5-10 rookies every year to come up with that list. And look at the list you provide yourself... the "top prospects" are all below .800. All I am saying is that if you make the moves you suggest 100 times over on average we will be looking at a downgraded offense. Of course, we gotta play within our constraints. The moves you suggest are the best possible moves given our limited payroll. Still, I think it's a fallacy to believe it's more likely than not that the replacements will be sufficient to overcome the loss of those players. Could it happen? Sure. Anything's possible. Sorry, but you're killing me here. First, Lou is doing the legwork to show you why what he is saying makes perfect, logical sense as the most probabilistic outcome. And yet you seem to want to ignore the parts that weaken your argument. As for the "top prospects", he was merely showing other top prospects who didn't perform quite as well. Just look at this year. McClutchen, Beckham, Fowler, and Gardner are all highly touted prospects, for example. And it blows my mind that you are calling something [which Lou has reasonably shown, mind you] a fallacy, yet you quote "The Law of Averages" yourself. That "law" is a crock of bull. Wikipedia it yourself if you don't believe me. It can't really be referenced to prove anything, especially in a small sample of 3, yet that is how you "proved", "statistically speaking", that [and I quote] "it is likely that only one of those replacements will end up outproducing those current three players next year."? This probably sounds harsh, but I'm not buying it. To be fair, Wikipedia can be a crock of bull, as well. Heh, that can be true. But any legitimate link discredits the "law of averages". http://www.probabilitytheory.info/topics/the_law_of_large_numbers.htm http://www.stat.berkeley.edu/~stark/SticiGui/Text/gloss.htm
August 11, 200917 yr By "at the same level" I meant both level in baseball and prospect. Clearly, if you are playing well in AA as a 20 or 21 year old, you've got a great chance to do well at the MLB level regardless of your status as a top prospect. Coghlin has never been considered one of the top prospects in baseball (very good prospect, but I don't recall Coghlin ever being ranked in the top 50 in all of baseball), yet he has produced at every level and is now doing very well as a rookie for the Marlins. You are giving a lot of examples, but most of those players were the exception, not the norm. In other words, you picked the very best 5-10 rookies every year to come up with that list. And look at the list you provide yourself... the "top prospects" are all below .800. All I am saying is that if you make the moves you suggest 100 times over on average we will be looking at a downgraded offense. Of course, we gotta play within our constraints. The moves you suggest are the best possible moves given our limited payroll. Still, I think it's a fallacy to believe it's more likely than not that the replacements will be sufficient to overcome the loss of those players. Could it happen? Sure. Anything's possible. Sorry, but you're killing me here. First, Lou is doing the legwork to show you why what he is saying makes perfect, logical sense as the most probabilistic outcome. And yet you seem to want to ignore the parts that weaken your argument. As for the "top prospects", he was merely showing other top prospects who didn't perform quite as well. Just look at this year. McClutchen, Beckham, Fowler, and Gardner are all highly touted prospects, for example. And it blows my mind that you are calling something [which Lou has reasonably shown, mind you] a fallacy, yet you quote "The Law of Averages" yourself. That "law" is a crock of bull. Wikipedia it yourself if you don't believe me. It can't really be referenced to prove anything, especially in a small sample of 3, yet that is how you "proved", "statistically speaking", that [and I quote] "it is likely that only one of those replacements will end up outproducing those current three players next year."? This probably sounds harsh, but I'm not buying it. Chill. I said if you repeat this move a hundred times then on average it won't work. I realize a sample size of 3 will not normally produce statistically significant results. Please read my whole post carefully. I admitted it was possible that all three would produce better numbers than the guys we have now, particularly because it's such a small sample size. The numbers that Lou shows with respect to the OPS of rookies proves my point. He shows all rookies and not many OPS higher than .800 (only four or five). He also shows how the "top prospects" are OPSing - and they too are far below the .800 average. Look, young man, I don't need to go to wikipedia to know statistics. If you don't buy it, I don't really care. At least Lou responded to my comments with very good points, and I admitted that there is a decent chance the rookies would, on average, outproduce the three guys we have now.
August 11, 200917 yr By "at the same level" I meant both level in baseball and prospect. Clearly, if you are playing well in AA as a 20 or 21 year old, you've got a great chance to do well at the MLB level regardless of your status as a top prospect. Coghlin has never been considered one of the top prospects in baseball (very good prospect, but I don't recall Coghlin ever being ranked in the top 50 in all of baseball), yet he has produced at every level and is now doing very well as a rookie for the Marlins. You are giving a lot of examples, but most of those players were the exception, not the norm. In other words, you picked the very best 5-10 rookies every year to come up with that list. And look at the list you provide yourself... the "top prospects" are all below .800. All I am saying is that if you make the moves you suggest 100 times over on average we will be looking at a downgraded offense. Of course, we gotta play within our constraints. The moves you suggest are the best possible moves given our limited payroll. Still, I think it's a fallacy to believe it's more likely than not that the replacements will be sufficient to overcome the loss of those players. Could it happen? Sure. Anything's possible. Sorry, but you're killing me here. First, Lou is doing the legwork to show you why what he is saying makes perfect, logical sense as the most probabilistic outcome. And yet you seem to want to ignore the parts that weaken your argument. As for the "top prospects", he was merely showing other top prospects who didn't perform quite as well. Just look at this year. McClutchen, Beckham, Fowler, and Gardner are all highly touted prospects, for example. And it blows my mind that you are calling something [which Lou has reasonably shown, mind you] a fallacy, yet you quote "The Law of Averages" yourself. That "law" is a crock of bull. Wikipedia it yourself if you don't believe me. It can't really be referenced to prove anything, especially in a small sample of 3, yet that is how you "proved", "statistically speaking", that [and I quote] "it is likely that only one of those replacements will end up outproducing those current three players next year."? This probably sounds harsh, but I'm not buying it. To be fair, Wikipedia can be a crock of bull, as well. Heh, that can be true. But any legitimate link discredits the "law of averages". http://www.probabilitytheory.info/topics/the_law_of_large_numbers.htm http://www.stat.berkeley.edu/~stark/SticiGui/Text/gloss.htm By the way, I wasn't saying that there will be any correction. Indeed, there is nothing to correct. I was simply saying that over the long-run you are likely to get something approaching what the average is supposed to be. True, just because you have 3 guys beat the average does not mean that the next guy is likely not to beat the average in order to bring the group closer to the average. The likelihood is the same for all the players. There is a distinction. Nice way to set up a straw man, though.
August 11, 200917 yr Chill. I said if you repeat this move a hundred times then on average it won't work. I realize a sample size of 3 will not normally produce statistically significant results. Please read my whole post carefully. I admitted it was possible that all three would produce better numbers than the guys we have now, particularly because it's such a small sample size. The numbers that Lou shows with respect to the OPS of rookies proves my point. He shows all rookies and not many OPS higher than .800 (only four or five). He also shows how the "top prospects" are OPSing - and they too are far below the .800 average. Look, young man, I don't need to go to wikipedia to know statistics. If you don't buy it, I don't really care. At least Lou responded to my comments with very good points, and I admitted that there is a decent chance the rookies would, on average, outproduce the three guys we have now. I read your post carefully, and I know you admitted that it's possible. Not sure when you called it a "decent" chance they'd outdo their predecessors, but no big deal either way. I still don't see how Lou's numbers prove your point. I said this before, but most of those guys on the entire list are top prospects. He's mentioning all of them to be fair, and some of them ended up under .800 OPS. I mean, look at 2008 - Over .800 - Chris Davis, Joey Votto, Evan Longoria, Daniel Murphy,Geovany Soto, Pablo Sandoval, John Baker (
August 11, 200917 yr By "at the same level" I meant both level in baseball and prospect. Clearly, if you are playing well in AA as a 20 or 21 year old, you've got a great chance to do well at the MLB level regardless of your status as a top prospect. Coghlin has never been considered one of the top prospects in baseball (very good prospect, but I don't recall Coghlin ever being ranked in the top 50 in all of baseball), yet he has produced at every level and is now doing very well as a rookie for the Marlins. You are giving a lot of examples, but most of those players were the exception, not the norm. In other words, you picked the very best 5-10 rookies every year to come up with that list. And look at the list you provide yourself... the "top prospects" are all below .800. All I am saying is that if you make the moves you suggest 100 times over on average we will be looking at a downgraded offense. Of course, we gotta play within our constraints. The moves you suggest are the best possible moves given our limited payroll. Still, I think it's a fallacy to believe it's more likely than not that the replacements will be sufficient to overcome the loss of those players. Could it happen? Sure. Anything's possible. Sorry, but you're killing me here. First, Lou is doing the legwork to show you why what he is saying makes perfect, logical sense as the most probabilistic outcome. And yet you seem to want to ignore the parts that weaken your argument. As for the "top prospects", he was merely showing other top prospects who didn't perform quite as well. Just look at this year. McClutchen, Beckham, Fowler, and Gardner are all highly touted prospects, for example. And it blows my mind that you are calling something [which Lou has reasonably shown, mind you] a fallacy, yet you quote "The Law of Averages" yourself. That "law" is a crock of bull. Wikipedia it yourself if you don't believe me. It can't really be referenced to prove anything, especially in a small sample of 3, yet that is how you "proved", "statistically speaking", that [and I quote] "it is likely that only one of those replacements will end up outproducing those current three players next year."? This probably sounds harsh, but I'm not buying it. To be fair, Wikipedia can be a crock of bull, as well. Heh, that can be true. But any legitimate link discredits the "law of averages". http://www.probabili...rge_numbers.htm http://www.stat.berk.../Text/gloss.htm By the way, I wasn't saying that there will be any correction. Indeed, there is nothing to correct. I was simply saying that over the long-run you are likely to get something approaching what the average is supposed to be. True, just because you have 3 guys beat the average does not mean that the next guy is likely not to beat the average in order to bring the group closer to the average. The likelihood is the same for all the players. There is a distinction. Nice way to set up a straw man, though. Not trying to set up a straw man. The "law of averages" is, generally speaking, a colloquial term which is illegitimate. The juxtaposition of you saying Lou's analysis, with which I nearly 100% agree, contains a fallacy, while invoking the law of averages seemed quite ironic.
August 11, 200917 yr Chill. I said if you repeat this move a hundred times then on average it won't work. I realize a sample size of 3 will not normally produce statistically significant results. Please read my whole post carefully. I admitted it was possible that all three would produce better numbers than the guys we have now, particularly because it's such a small sample size. The numbers that Lou shows with respect to the OPS of rookies proves my point. He shows all rookies and not many OPS higher than .800 (only four or five). He also shows how the "top prospects" are OPSing - and they too are far below the .800 average. Look, young man, I don't need to go to wikipedia to know statistics. If you don't buy it, I don't really care. At least Lou responded to my comments with very good points, and I admitted that there is a decent chance the rookies would, on average, outproduce the three guys we have now. I read your post carefully, and I know you admitted that it's possible. Not sure when you called it a "decent" chance they'd outdo their predecessors, but no big deal either way. I still don't see how Lou's numbers prove your point. I said this before, but most of those guys on the entire list are top prospects. He's mentioning all of them to be fair, and some of them ended up under .800 OPS. I mean, look at 2008 - Over .800 - Chris Davis, Joey Votto, Evan Longoria, Daniel Murphy,Geovany Soto, Pablo Sandoval, John Baker (
August 11, 200917 yr I used the "law of averages" as a way of saying that the statistically expected OPS of the three rookies next year is likely inferior to the OPS of our current players. I did not mean to give it the colloquial meaning. You ascribed the colloquial meaning to what I was saying in order to make me look foolish and show how much you know. Simply put, I meant "statistically expected OPS". You can probably find this on baseballprospectus.com. I do not have access to that information, but I am pretty certain the projected OPS of the three guys we're talking about do not average this year's OPS of the current players we have.
August 11, 200917 yr If I was GM, I'd pass on Cantu (1B is is only positon now), Trade Uggla, and Maybe keep Hermida for one more year or trade him dependign on how our OF Prospects develop/Contriubute this september. Move Coghlan to 3B, Bonifacio to 2B, Call up Morrison for LF, and Slot Gaby Sanchez at 3B. Lineup Without Herm 1.Maybin CF 2.Coghlan 3B 3.Ramirez SS 4.Gaby Sanchez 1B 5.Logan Morrison LF(Might be pushing it) 6.John Baker C 7.Cody Ross RF 8.Bonifacio 2B 9. Pitcher this sounds most reasonable
August 11, 200917 yr I used the "law of averages" as a way of saying that the statistically expected OPS of the three rookies next year is likely inferior to the OPS of our current players. I did not mean to give it the colloquial meaning. You ascribed the colloquial meaning to what I was saying in order to make me look foolish and show how much you know. Simply put, I meant "statistically expected OPS". You can probably find this on baseballprospectus.com. I do not have access to that information, but I am pretty certain the projected OPS of the three guys we're talking about do not average this year's OPS of the current players we have. Feel free to think what you want, but you don't know what my intentions are/were. I most certainly was not trying to show how much I know. I'm allowed to criticize someone's postings, especially when I think they are incorrectly criticizing someone else's. That's what this board is all about. I even said "sorry if this sounds harsh". I'm just trying to form more intelligent opinions and refining information, not trying to make anyone look foolish. The few posters on this board who actually deserve that tend to do it enough themselves so that piling on certainly isn't even necessary.
August 11, 200917 yr I used the "law of averages" as a way of saying that the statistically expected OPS of the three rookies next year is likely inferior to the OPS of our current players. I did not mean to give it the colloquial meaning. You ascribed the colloquial meaning to what I was saying in order to make me look foolish and show how much you know. Simply put, I meant "statistically expected OPS". You can probably find this on baseballprospectus.com. I do not have access to that information, but I am pretty certain the projected OPS of the three guys we're talking about do not average this year's OPS of the current players we have. Feel free to think what you want, but you don't know what my intentions are/were. I most certainly was not trying to show how much I know. I'm allowed to criticize someone's postings, especially when I think they are incorrectly criticizing someone else's. That's what this board is all about. I even said "sorry if this sounds harsh". I'm just trying to form more intelligent opinions and refining information, not trying to make anyone look foolish. The few posters on this board who actually deserve that tend to do it enough themselves so that piling on certainly isn't even necessary. Sorry. I overreacted.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.