November 13, 200917 yr He's not someone I would classify as a potentially great pitcher who just needs "kinks" worked out. He doesn't have good enough secondary pitches and becomes too reliant on his fastball. Even if coaches do work on his command to prevent him from walking a baserunner or two in the bottom of the ninth, his fastball is still incredibly hittable. Lindstrom and Nunez are the two most expendable arms in the bullpen as far as I'm concerned. The only "kinks" that need to be worked out is him being healthy and participating in a full spring training. Can't throw secondary pitches very effectively if your arm isn't 100%. Every time he threw a breaking pitch he would feel a pinch in his elbow. An MRI, just 2 weeks ago, revealed an inflammed elbow with no structural damage to the tendons. The injury was a combination of lifting heavy weights and never being 100% from the WBC (in other words no spring training). His secondary pitches are good enough...he just doesn't throw them consistently. Can you be the most expendable posters on this forum? You should become just a little bit more narrow minded. I'm with Miller23...give him another year and see what happens. If not, there are 29 other teams that would love to have his arm. Hell, he might even get a pitching coach and a manager that believe in him too. There's a new pitching coach with the team this year. Just saying...if the Marlins choose to keep him and he continues his inconsistent ways, at what point do we just admit that he's just an inconsistent/average reliever? He's not getting any younger. It's now or never, for the guy who's supposed to be our dominant, lights out closer one day. I'd love to see it, but based on his track record (majors, minors, whatever), there's nothing that indicates that he'll become that great closer everyone wants him to be. So is this the year or what? Not so sure about that closer role. He seems to want that more than the coaching staff did last year. Yet to be seen from this coach. Depends on if he (and to some extent his catcher) can gain the confidence in his other pitches. Would also be interesting to see if a different grip could put some movement on that fastball without losing the velocity. If it were my $$$ being spent, I would go after a real closer. One with a track record. Have Leo, Matt, and Pinto setting up. I know Pinto isn't well liked here, but I am going on my theory that a different bullpen coach that can see the days he is off a little will make a difference.
November 13, 200917 yr [ And Nunez still gets a bad rap on these boards. Everybody gets a bad rap on these boards.
November 14, 200917 yr is that a joke? best 1/2 punch in baseball? lindstrom will never be anything more then an erratic set up man. Nunez better not be on the move but he shouldnt be a closer either actually no that isnt a joke. just because u cant see the potential doesnt mean i dont. ive seen games where lindstrom has looked great closing the 9th and also seen leo look really good as well. if they can learn from their mistakes i do think they can be a pretty a nasty 8th and 9th inning shutdown pitchers. Matt Lindstrom will be 30 next year and only has one consistent pitch, a straight as a nail fastball.
November 15, 200917 yr is that a joke? best 1/2 punch in baseball? lindstrom will never be anything more then an erratic set up man. Nunez better not be on the move but he shouldnt be a closer either actually no that isnt a joke. just because u cant see the potential doesnt mean i dont. ive seen games where lindstrom has looked great closing the 9th and also seen leo look really good as well. if they can learn from their mistakes i do think they can be a pretty a nasty 8th and 9th inning shutdown pitchers. Matt Lindstrom will be 30 next year and only has one consistent pitch, a straight as a nail fastball. Wow...tell us something that we don't know? His first 2 years in the league were pretty consistent. Makes you wonder if something might have been wrong during the 2009 season...oh yeah he had a strained shoulder at the first of the year and an inflamed elbow half way through. This probably had something to do with his unorthodox year...just a guess.
November 15, 200917 yr is that a joke? best 1/2 punch in baseball? lindstrom will never be anything more then an erratic set up man. Nunez better not be on the move but he shouldnt be a closer either actually no that isnt a joke. just because u cant see the potential doesnt mean i dont. ive seen games where lindstrom has looked great closing the 9th and also seen leo look really good as well. if they can learn from their mistakes i do think they can be a pretty a nasty 8th and 9th inning shutdown pitchers. Matt Lindstrom will be 30 next year and only has one consistent pitch, a straight as a nail fastball. Wow...tell us something that we don't know? His first 2 years in the league were pretty consistent. Makes you wonder if something might have been wrong during the 2009 season...oh yeah he had a strained shoulder at the first of the year and an inflamed elbow half way through. This probably had something to do with his unorthodox year...just a guess. Not really.
November 15, 200917 yr His first 2 seasons were pretty good. He only had one month where he pitched 5+ inning where his ERA was over 5. And he only had 2 months where he pitched 5+ innings where his ERA was over 4. That's pretty consistent for a reliever. His K/BB was only great in the 2nd half of 2007, though: 4.43, wow. But I have to lean toward uberschnell here. As an aside, wasn't he one the main pickers-on-Jeremy-Hermida-ers? Because Lindstrom had a great 2nd half of 2007 just like Jeremy, and has been roughly average, with flashes of better, since then. Kinda ironic iyam.
November 15, 200917 yr His first 2 seasons were pretty good. He only had one month where he pitched 5+ inning where his ERA was over 5. And he only had 2 months where he pitched 5+ innings where his ERA was over 4. That's pretty consistent for a reliever. His K/BB was only great in the 2nd half of 2007, though: 4.43, wow. But I have to lean toward uberschnell here. As an aside, wasn't he one the main pickers-on-Jeremy-Hermida-ers? Because Lindstrom had a great 2nd half of 2007 just like Jeremy, and has been roughly average, with flashes of better, since then. Kinda ironic iyam. His overall #'s weren't bad his 2nd year, but he was so bad at one point that he was sent down to the minors. He just pitched really well when he came back up. That's not "consistency." As for the Hermida comparison...Hermida was once a top prospect who dominated AA (Lindstrom wasn't). Hermida's about 5 years younger. Lindstrom isn't young anymore. He's going to be 30 this upcoming year. If he's going to be really good, as some expect him to be, I would say the time is now.
November 15, 200917 yr That has nothing to do with the Hermida comparison I made. I'm saying it was funny for uber to pick on Jeremy by saying that he only was great for one-half or one season, the 2nd half of 2007, when you could easily argue the same for lindstrom, since it was the only time his K/BB was over 2.5 (I believe).
November 15, 200917 yr That has nothing to do with the Hermida comparison I made. I'm saying it was funny for uber to pick on Jeremy by saying that he only was great for one-half or one season, the 2nd half of 2007, when you could easily argue the same for lindstrom, since it was the only time his K/BB was over 2.5 (I believe). Gotcha.
November 15, 200917 yr I don't think that ERA and (to a lesser exent) K/BB are the best statistics to be used when evaluating a reliver. If you look at Lindstrom's WHIP monthly splits for 2007 and 2008, he was very inconsistent. This was especially true for 2008 where it ranged from sub-1.0 to plus-1.5 without any real regularity. I think it's also interesting that Lindstrom pitched an awesome August 2009 after coming back from the injury but then ending up sucking in September. One could argue that montly splits are arbitrary, but in Lindstrom's case, they typically describe how well he pitched on average for any 7-12 inning stretch. He has shown the ability to be an acceptable reliever, but he's not someone I would characterize as being consistent.
November 15, 200917 yr They all suck as far evaluating monthly consistency, IMO, since he often pitched only 10 innings, where 1 extra hit or walk is already .1 difference in WHIP. But ERA certainly has similar problems. I did think it was interesting how his ERAs were reasonably consistent by month, because I didn't expect it. I guess you have to use a combination of a few stats with memory to best evaluate consistency, but it's tough with relievers. I'm not sure what consistency "means" anyway [to a player's value], relative to fluctuations in variance [especially on a month-to-month basis] [especially for a reliever], but that's another topic for another day....
November 15, 200917 yr That is an issue of "uncertainty" or standard deviation. That's not the criticism I'm making. I'm referring to the fact that ERA completely ignores the issue of inherited runners (that either Lindstrom or someone else leaves on base). There is going to be some "uncertainty" in monthly splits due to limited innings pitched but WHIP is nevertheless an infinitely better statistic to be using.
November 15, 200917 yr This is a point about Marlins pitching stats, moreso relievers than starters, but is general not specific to any one pitcher. The point about inherited runners is a good one and I'd add as long as defensively the team continues to give four outs or more to opposing teams with frustrating regularity, either by error or just plain poor play (not hitting the cut-off man, throwing to the wrong base, not backing someone up, getting to the appropriate base to cover, the list is endless) pitcher's ERAs and other stats are suspect or at least not much more than half-truths. I'd say if there was one thing that needs addressing this year in regards to protecting pitchers (and getting the most out of them when they do pitch) it's keeping innings to three outs, in short playing sound fundamental baseball throughout each game. No one is perfect but I think we all saw too many times where guys should have already been in the dugout instead of still on the mound throwing their 29th pitch of the inning.
November 15, 200917 yr 2003, that is a fair point, but at the same time, one should have to make the a priori expectation that bad defense is a constant. If you make that assumption, Lindstrom was still terribly inconsistent, which was the only "fact" anyone was trying to verify.
November 17, 200917 yr is that a joke? best 1/2 punch in baseball? lindstrom will never be anything more then an erratic set up man. Nunez better not be on the move but he shouldnt be a closer either actually no that isnt a joke. just because u cant see the potential doesnt mean i dont. ive seen games where lindstrom has looked great closing the 9th and also seen leo look really good as well. if they can learn from their mistakes i do think they can be a pretty a nasty 8th and 9th inning shutdown pitchers. Matt Lindstrom will be 30 next year and only has one consistent pitch, a straight as a nail fastball. Wow...tell us something that we don't know? His first 2 years in the league were pretty consistent. Makes you wonder if something might have been wrong during the 2009 season...oh yeah he had a strained shoulder at the first of the year and an inflamed elbow half way through. This probably had something to do with his unorthodox year...just a guess. Not really. Yeah really. "pretty consistent" was the phrase you misinterpreted...happens a lot with you.
November 18, 200917 yr Yeah really. "pretty consistent" was the phrase you misinterpreted...happens a lot with you. He was not "pretty consistent" in year 2. Sorry, that is false.
November 19, 200917 yr Yeah really. "pretty consistent" was the phrase you misinterpreted...happens a lot with you. He was not "pretty consistent" in year 2. Sorry, that is false. False in your opinion...very true in mine. Sorry but we don't think alike.
November 19, 200917 yr Yeah really. "pretty consistent" was the phrase you misinterpreted...happens a lot with you. He was not "pretty consistent" in year 2. Sorry, that is false. False in your opinion...very true in mine. Sorry but we don't think alike. How was he consistent in his 2nd year in the big leagues?
November 20, 200916 yr Yeah really. "pretty consistent" was the phrase you misinterpreted...happens a lot with you. He was not "pretty consistent" in year 2. Sorry, that is false. False in your opinion...very true in mine. Sorry but we don't think alike. How was he consistent in his 2nd year in the big leagues? I'm just comparing the end result from his rookie year to what he did in his second year. Might not be the best way to judge consistency but that's what I was thinking...probably looking more at era than anything else. This is not taking injuries into consideration either. Perhaps one could look at his second half stats and conclude that he was consistent. Now I'm thinking out loud. What are your thoughts?
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.