Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Jayson Stark on Baseball Financials

Featured Replies

I think Stark is missing a lot of information that prevents his case from being convincing.

 

For example, he is making accusations (indirectly) but he provides no accounting information for other operating expenses outside of team payroll. He likely doesn't have access to this, nor should he. It seems like he's supeficially assuming that the team is handed $80 M from the league, earns several million in ticket sales, pays out $30-$40 million for talent and pockets the rest. The Marlins have to fund an entire minor league system, pay Dolphin Stadium rent, airfare, hotels, etc. This in itself is probably in the tens of millions of dollars.

 

This is a pretty bad accounting exercise. It's the same reason why those yearly Forbes studies for the "most profitable" franchises is nonsense.

 

 

You and 2003 are on target. But there are those that will read articles like this and take it as the gospel. The same ones that say this ownership has done nothing but lie to us since they took control, and yet can't/won't give any specifics on those lies. Dosen't it make you wish you had bought stock in Reynolds Wrap? Conspiracy theorists always make me chuckle.

Because I mean, the farms do bring in ticket revenue too which has to be added to the pot making them kind of neutral.

 

 

Could be mistaken but I'm pretty sure that owners of minor league teams are responsibile of stadium upkeep ect, so they make the money from revenue from the the MILB team. It's more-so a trade off, the MLB team pays players to play for the MILB team in exchange for having a league for the players to learn in.

 

if wrong someone correct me though

 

The MLB team also pays the medical staff and the coaching staff of the minor league affiliate. Among other things. But I believe you are correct in saying the minor league owner reaps the profits from his club. They aren't there just to funnel $$$ to the parent club, they are there to make a $$$.

I think the problem is that people are making assumptions without having seen any of the actual financial information (that Loria has no obligation to divulge to the public).

 

If you want to engage in accounting exercises based upon data made available, I would consider the 2003-2005 years. The Marlins were actually signing veteran players to multi-year deals (Lowell, Castillo, Gonzalez, Lo Duca, Delgado) and payroll rose to around $60 million. The Delgado signing indicated that Loria did want to win and was willing to spend money to do it.

 

However, don't forget that after 2005 the Marlins were reporting nearly $20 million in losses which is what provoked the "market correction." Did Loria suddenly become black-hearted overnight (leading him to sell off the veteran talent and cut payroll) or could there actually have been budgetary needs?

 

I think that entire scenario (regarding Delgado) is an indication that the Marlins just don't have the revenue coming in (by their own hand or the MLB) in order to sustain a payroll above the $40 million range and not operate at a loss.

 

The only thing that confuses me is why Loria did not foresee a shortfall and went to the trouble of signing Delgado long-term (raising the payroll to $60 million) in the first place. My guess is that this was somehow tied to the gloomy stadium situation at the time.

 

 

I also believe he was going by the "build it (a team) and they will come" attitude. He did and they didn't. If we had been putting an average of 30K or so into the seats in those days we wouldn't be having this discussion now. I fully believe in that.

2005 happened because a certain city of Miami City manager killed the stadium plan in place because once the deal was sealed he wanted the Loria and partners to sell the team to a foreign national connected to city hall at what was tantamount to a loss. Ownership said "ah no" and with it went any dreams of future cashflows. A couple or three hurricanes in 2004 - 2005 didn't help either for those who remember the Marlins playing home games in Chicago. Post the WS the next two seasons seemed snake bit.

the Marlins just don't have the revenue coming in (by their own hand or the MLB) in order to sustain a payroll above the $40 million range and not operate at a loss.

 

I think you're correct and further that it's not at all necessary to know the numbers behind any given team (good thing, too, since there's no way we'll ever know them in any detail.)

 

Ink-stained wretches like Stark love obvious, cheap, bash-the-rich shots like "$90 million-plus before they open their ticket windows." Except that about half of all MLB teams have a payroll of about 80 million or less. That fact alone makes it clear that actually operating a MLB franchise is a very expensive proposition, over and above player costs.

 

The real value of a MLB franchise is the long-term value built over time. Over 20 years, it can be in the HUNDREDS OF MILLIONS of dollars.

 

Many owners are in hock up to their eyeballs for the money used to buy their team. That means that massive yearly operating losses (in some cases, ANY operating loss) can't be tolerated. Since it's in the interest of every owner to maximize team value, every one of them has VERY strong incentives to spend as much as possible to that end without putting themselves in financial jeopardy. And, so they do, within their individual constraints and appetites for risk, whatever they may be. Some are better at it than others.

 

But, to think that ANY owner will act contrary to their own interest in achieving that overall goal is nothing short of idiotic. To think that half or more of them would do so is totally delusional.

 

great post, and hopefully people reading this thread can see there are plenty of people NOT running around yelling about Loria and conspiracies. It isn't Marlins2003 vs the world.

 

I'm sort of surprised Stark would write something like this (though maybe I shouldn't be). Scoring cheap points with obvious half-truths and only presenting part of the picture.... not doing any great service to your readers there.

 

(That's not meant to paint some rosy picture of Loria or any other ownership group by the way because they all have have plenty of issues.)

Would this be possible before Sarbanes-Oxley? Possibly and only then.

 

Nope. Sarbox has nothing to do with this, Sarbox applies to publicly-traded securities. The Marlins are not a publicly held company, they issue no equity securities required to be registered and, just like every other private company, they are not required to provide any financial reporting whatsoever to the public.

 

They are a private company, which is why Stark has no idea about what he is yapping about as he has no financial information other than basic revenue-sharing data that MLB has chosen to make public. Just as the various know-nothings on this board who scream "Loria is pocketing millions" have no idea what they are talking about.

 

SOX is used by all major companies now. Just because it is written for publicly traded companies doesn't mean the Big4 do not require it for all their audited companies. It has also spread heavily into the NPO world--no longer is the 990 enough.

I think Stark is missing a lot of information that prevents his case from being convincing.

 

For example, he is making accusations (indirectly) but he provides no accounting information for other operating expenses outside of team payroll. He likely doesn't have access to this, nor should he. It seems like he's supeficially assuming that the team is handed $80 M from the league, earns several million in ticket sales, pays out $30-$40 million for talent and pockets the rest. The Marlins have to fund an entire minor league system, pay Dolphin Stadium rent, airfare, hotels, etc. This in itself is probably in the tens of millions of dollars.

 

This is a pretty bad accounting exercise. It's the same reason why those yearly Forbes studies for the "most profitable" franchises is nonsense.

 

 

Well if he wanted to do actual reporting he could request an audited report. Anyone can call and ask for an audited report. Also, to support Marlins if you do not know about accounting it is hard to justify what you are saying. Would this be possible before Sarbanes-Oxley? Possibly and only then. I am sure any of Deloitte, PwC, E&Y or KPMG are doing their personal books and would not risk the backlash to help out Loria. None of the Big4 want to end up like Arthur Andersen.

 

Like stated earlier, retaining some of those earnings is possible, but unless they are a consolidated/affiliated group they are paying ridiculous high taxes for retained earnings that are higher than the allowable threshold.

 

edit: Spike, figured if you didn't know SOX you could read up on it. So I added the link : http://www.gpo.gov:80/fdsys/pkg/PLAW-107publ204/html/PLAW-107publ204.htm

 

So many experts. Sure, for a private company like the Marlins, just call up their auditors and ask for a copy of the financials. OK, who is in line for a lawsuit for releasing confidential client information. End of that theory. Maybe you think you can call the IRS and get a copy of the tax audit-NO.

 

Next, as I have read, the Marlins are a partnership and Loria is the "managing partner". Guess what, there is no tax on partnerships, only the partners based on the partnership agreement as to the method of allocation of taxable income, assuming there is partnership income. If there is a loss, the partners then report the loss based on the agreement, not even necessarily on their proportionate ownership interest. Whether they "retain" the earnings in the business or distribute it to the partners does not matter for tax purposes. Thus, the statement about "riduculously high taxes" is totally false in the context of a partnership.

I think Stark is missing a lot of information that prevents his case from being convincing.

 

For example, he is making accusations (indirectly) but he provides no accounting information for other operating expenses outside of team payroll. He likely doesn't have access to this, nor should he. It seems like he's supeficially assuming that the team is handed $80 M from the league, earns several million in ticket sales, pays out $30-$40 million for talent and pockets the rest. The Marlins have to fund an entire minor league system, pay Dolphin Stadium rent, airfare, hotels, etc. This in itself is probably in the tens of millions of dollars.

 

This is a pretty bad accounting exercise. It's the same reason why those yearly Forbes studies for the "most profitable" franchises is nonsense.

 

 

Well if he wanted to do actual reporting he could request an audited report. Anyone can call and ask for an audited report. Also, to support Marlins if you do not know about accounting it is hard to justify what you are saying. Would this be possible before Sarbanes-Oxley? Possibly and only then. I am sure any of Deloitte, PwC, E&Y or KPMG are doing their personal books and would not risk the backlash to help out Loria. None of the Big4 want to end up like Arthur Andersen.

 

Like stated earlier, retaining some of those earnings is possible, but unless they are a consolidated/affiliated group they are paying ridiculous high taxes for retained earnings that are higher than the allowable threshold.

 

edit: Spike, figured if you didn't know SOX you could read up on it. So I added the link : http://www.gpo.gov:80/fdsys/pkg/PLAW-107publ204/html/PLAW-107publ204.htm

 

So many experts. Sure, for a private company like the Marlins, just call up their auditors and ask for a copy of the financials. OK, who is in line for a lawsuit for releasing confidential client information. End of that theory. Maybe you think you can call the IRS and get a copy of the tax audit-NO.

 

Next, as I have read, the Marlins are a partnership and Loria is the "managing partner". Guess what, there is no tax on partnerships, only the partners based on the partnership agreement as to the method of allocation of taxable income, assuming there is partnership income. If there is a loss, the partners then report the loss based on the agreement, not even necessarily on their proportionate ownership interest. Whether they "retain" the earnings in the business or distribute it to the partners does not matter for tax purposes. Thus, the statement about "riduculously high taxes" is totally false in the context of a partnership.

 

Companies have to release their audited reports done by the auditee of their accounting firm. You cannot call the IRS and ask for their audit.

 

And as for the retained earning tax... read up on Accumulated Earnings... http://www.irs.gov/publications/p542/ar02.html And if they are an LLC, LLLC, LLP, LLLP etc... they cannot just whip out retained earnings because of allocation. Read the Anderson v. Anderson case (required that whoever received the retained earnings had to claim that source of income---So if he did that would be obvious that he was pocketing any money in excess of ordinary salary)

a winning ballclub and getting cash from the big boys. sounds like smart business to me.

I think Stark is missing a lot of information that prevents his case from being convincing.

 

For example, he is making accusations (indirectly) but he provides no accounting information for other operating expenses outside of team payroll. He likely doesn't have access to this, nor should he. It seems like he's supeficially assuming that the team is handed $80 M from the league, earns several million in ticket sales, pays out $30-$40 million for talent and pockets the rest. The Marlins have to fund an entire minor league system, pay Dolphin Stadium rent, airfare, hotels, etc. This in itself is probably in the tens of millions of dollars.

 

This is a pretty bad accounting exercise. It's the same reason why those yearly Forbes studies for the "most profitable" franchises is nonsense.

 

 

Well if he wanted to do actual reporting he could request an audited report. Anyone can call and ask for an audited report. Also, to support Marlins if you do not know about accounting it is hard to justify what you are saying. Would this be possible before Sarbanes-Oxley? Possibly and only then. I am sure any of Deloitte, PwC, E&Y or KPMG are doing their personal books and would not risk the backlash to help out Loria. None of the Big4 want to end up like Arthur Andersen.

 

Like stated earlier, retaining some of those earnings is possible, but unless they are a consolidated/affiliated group they are paying ridiculous high taxes for retained earnings that are higher than the allowable threshold.

 

edit: Spike, figured if you didn't know SOX you could read up on it. So I added the link : http://www.gpo.gov:80/fdsys/pkg/PLAW-107publ204/html/PLAW-107publ204.htm

 

So many experts. Sure, for a private company like the Marlins, just call up their auditors and ask for a copy of the financials. OK, who is in line for a lawsuit for releasing confidential client information. End of that theory. Maybe you think you can call the IRS and get a copy of the tax audit-NO.

 

Next, as I have read, the Marlins are a partnership and Loria is the "managing partner". Guess what, there is no tax on partnerships, only the partners based on the partnership agreement as to the method of allocation of taxable income, assuming there is partnership income. If there is a loss, the partners then report the loss based on the agreement, not even necessarily on their proportionate ownership interest. Whether they "retain" the earnings in the business or distribute it to the partners does not matter for tax purposes. Thus, the statement about "riduculously high taxes" is totally false in the context of a partnership.

 

Companies have to release their audited reports done by the auditee of their accounting firm. You cannot call the IRS and ask for their audit.

 

And as for the retained earning tax... read up on Accumulated Earnings... http://www.irs.gov/publications/p542/ar02.html And if they are an LLC, LLLC, LLP, LLLP etc... they cannot just whip out retained earnings because of allocation. Read the Anderson v. Anderson case (required that whoever received the retained earnings had to claim that source of income---So if he did that would be obvious that he was pocketing any money in excess of ordinary salary)

Other than a few people, we are about to put everyone to sleep. Your reference to publication 542 is specific to corporations-again, contrary to the matter about partnerships. And of course, if Loria was taking distributions that were in excess of what was called for in the partnership agreement, then he would have an issue. I was not really discussing anything to do with a partner violating his fiduciary responsibility, simply indicating that there is no tax at the partnership level for retaining the earnings, as was implied. There is no excess retained earnings tax in a partnership-you can accumulate all the earnings you want if whatever amount without ever spending it, at least for tax purposes. The other partners may want to see some cash if it is available, especially since they are taxed on the earnings even if they do not get it. Semantically, there is no such thing as "retained earnings" in a partnership either, that is a corporate term. The code deals with it specifically for corporations.

I think Stark is missing a lot of information that prevents his case from being convincing.

 

For example, he is making accusations (indirectly) but he provides no accounting information for other operating expenses outside of team payroll. He likely doesn't have access to this, nor should he. It seems like he's supeficially assuming that the team is handed $80 M from the league, earns several million in ticket sales, pays out $30-$40 million for talent and pockets the rest. The Marlins have to fund an entire minor league system, pay Dolphin Stadium rent, airfare, hotels, etc. This in itself is probably in the tens of millions of dollars.

 

This is a pretty bad accounting exercise. It's the same reason why those yearly Forbes studies for the "most profitable" franchises is nonsense.

 

 

Well if he wanted to do actual reporting he could request an audited report. Anyone can call and ask for an audited report. Also, to support Marlins if you do not know about accounting it is hard to justify what you are saying. Would this be possible before Sarbanes-Oxley? Possibly and only then. I am sure any of Deloitte, PwC, E&Y or KPMG are doing their personal books and would not risk the backlash to help out Loria. None of the Big4 want to end up like Arthur Andersen.

 

Like stated earlier, retaining some of those earnings is possible, but unless they are a consolidated/affiliated group they are paying ridiculous high taxes for retained earnings that are higher than the allowable threshold.

 

edit: Spike, figured if you didn't know SOX you could read up on it. So I added the link : http://www.gpo.gov:80/fdsys/pkg/PLAW-107publ204/html/PLAW-107publ204.htm

 

So many experts. Sure, for a private company like the Marlins, just call up their auditors and ask for a copy of the financials. OK, who is in line for a lawsuit for releasing confidential client information. End of that theory. Maybe you think you can call the IRS and get a copy of the tax audit-NO.

 

Next, as I have read, the Marlins are a partnership and Loria is the "managing partner". Guess what, there is no tax on partnerships, only the partners based on the partnership agreement as to the method of allocation of taxable income, assuming there is partnership income. If there is a loss, the partners then report the loss based on the agreement, not even necessarily on their proportionate ownership interest. Whether they "retain" the earnings in the business or distribute it to the partners does not matter for tax purposes. Thus, the statement about "riduculously high taxes" is totally false in the context of a partnership.

 

Companies have to release their audited reports done by the auditee of their accounting firm. You cannot call the IRS and ask for their audit.

 

And as for the retained earning tax... read up on Accumulated Earnings... http://www.irs.gov/publications/p542/ar02.html And if they are an LLC, LLLC, LLP, LLLP etc... they cannot just whip out retained earnings because of allocation. Read the Anderson v. Anderson case (required that whoever received the retained earnings had to claim that source of income---So if he did that would be obvious that he was pocketing any money in excess of ordinary salary)

Other than a few people, we are about to put everyone to sleep. Your reference to publication 542 is specific to corporations-again, contrary to the matter about partnerships. And of course, if Loria was taking distributions that were in excess of what was called for in the partnership agreement, then he would have an issue. I was not really discussing anything to do with a partner violating his fiduciary responsibility, simply indicating that there is no tax at the partnership level for retaining the earnings, as was implied. There is no excess retained earnings tax in a partnership-you can accumulate all the earnings you want if whatever amount without ever spending it, at least for tax purposes. The other partners may want to see some cash if it is available, especially since they are taxed on the earnings even if they do not get it. Semantically, there is no such thing as "retained earnings" in a partnership either, that is a corporate term. The code deals with it specifically for corporations.

 

You are correct since a partnership is a passthrough entity, but the point still holds that any excess earnings would be seen. So if he were taking the excess income and not distributing properly it would bring about red flags.

 

What I am not sure about is whether or not they are part of an affiliated group, if they are and the parent/brother company then it would be different. For example, the Red Sox have an ownership group, but it is a subsidiary of the larger corporation that owns the Boston Globe and a part of the NY Times. If they are strictly a partnership then what you say is completely right, I was just throwing out the corporation side of the argument.

The Marlins are a limited partnership and the general managing partner is an entity called Double Play of which Loria is Chairman and D Samson is President.

 

Sunbiz.org is a beautiful thing :brigginbounce

^Unless I am looking in the wrong place it says according to their Annual Report that they are a for-profit corp. with a Loria CEO and Samson as president. That is their 2009 filing.

 

Also, on an offnote I can't believe how many inactive Double Play entities their are in florida.

Why shouldn't the entity be "for profit"? Not being a lawyer I would assume the entity exists in part to shield the officers of the company from personal liability. I would guess a number of the limited partners also hold their interest in similar vehicles for just the same reason.

Why shouldn't the entity be "for profit"? Not being a lawyer I would assume the entity exists in part to shield the officers of the company from personal liability. I would guess a number of the limited partners also hold their interest in similar vehicles for just the same reason.

 

 

not talking about the for-profit section, but the annual report lists them as a for-profit corporation. It doesn't say lp, llp, llc etc...

  • Author

Looks like I set off a powder keg. Not surprising, I suppose, given how controversial this subject has been in the past.

 

It seems there are three main groups here: those who believe Loria and company are turning a hefty profit and Loria is going around buying Picassos with the proceeds (Out of the Past); those who suspect there may be profits being made but need more information (MarlinsLou); and those who dismiss Stark and the article out of hand and defend the FO, guns blazing (Marlins2003 et al).

 

The latter group, by far the most vocal of the groups here, has launched an assault on anyone who would dare believe in the slightest anything Stark wrote. They are basically calling them tin-foil-hat-wearing village idiots while they are presumably the wise sages setting the record straight.

 

The problem is with the secretive nature of MLB and all MLB teams when it comes to money being spent and made, these denunciations and lectures have no more credence in my eyes than those who scream "loria is buying a fleet of ferraris with revenue sharing!!111!!1" So unless you work for MLB or the Florida Marlins, don't act like you have all the facts.

 

That said, some facts about baseball financials have been leaked piecemeal in the past. And based on what I have seen and read about the MLB central fund, revenue sharing, and local TV/radio/cable contracts in the past - the $80+ million figure Stark is putting out there that some teams take before a ticket is sold seems sound. And for all the huffing and puffing going on here, I haven't seen one argument put forward that discredits these numbers.

 

Are there more costs involved in running a MLB franchise other than player payroll? Of course there are. If you had bothered to read Stark’s whole article – and I doubt a number of you did – you would have seen he got a few words from MLB's chief labor negotiator, Rob Manfred, that were pretty revealing.

 

Manfred said, in part, that MLB teams, "have the cost of their player-development system, which averages $15 million [per team] a year. They have the cost of acquiring [amateur] players through the [June] draft and internationally, which averages $9 million [per team] a year.�

 

So there are a couple of numbers we can put into the equation to guess at what the Marlins have left over before they sell a ticket. I read the $15 million for the “player-development system� as being all of the costs involved with the minor leagues – from coaches salaries to players salaries to whatever other costs that are not covered by the owners of minor league affiliates. This would also cover international camps and the like – which the Marlins do not have last I checked.

 

We can take the $9 million figure as is for quick math, or you can add up how much the Marlins actually spent signing players past drafts for an exact figure. We haven’t made a big splash with an international signing in some time. Either way, those numbers are out there and this can be quantified exactly.

 

My guess is that those two costs are the biggest ones involved in running a MLB franchise outside of player payroll, since it was the numbers Manfred used to try and discredit the $80+ million number. Logically, it makes sense that they are the biggest costs involved outside of player payroll – to me at least.

 

We can guess at a number of other costs the Marlins undoubtedly have, but how much they actually are is hard to say. Front office pay, Marlin’s staff pay (even Fredi’s salary is secret I believe), insurance, and hotel and travel costs are probably the biggest other costs involved.

 

And what the $80+ million leaves out of course are all the other money the Marlins make before and after tickets are sold – merchandising revenue and gate/stadium revenue being the biggies here.

 

This will probably set off another round of smear attacks and innuendo, but hopefully we’ll hear more reasoned voices instead of just the partisan hatchet jobs from here on out.

This will probably set off another round of smear attacks and innuendo, but hopefully we’ll hear more reasoned voices instead of just the partisan hatchet jobs from here on out.

 

 

And of course this post wasn't isn't a smear attack or a partisan hatchet job :brigginbounce

This would also cover international camps and the like – which the Marlins do not have last I checked.

 

From a Frisaro article in '07:

 

The most dramatic upgrade is the Marlins' new academy that is nearly completed in the Dominican Republic. By October or November, the facilities being leased in Boca Chica should be complete. Having a strong presence in the Dominican Republic is crucial in the organization's quest to sign rising talent in the Caribbean.

 

The Marlins' new facility includes a dorm that will house 40 players and coaches. It has two fields, batting cages, and lights, so workouts can take place day or night.

 

Gonzalez describes it as being basically like a college dorm. It will be open for 10 months, closing in December and most of January. Players will be fed three meals a day plus a snack. English classes also will be taught.

 

 

That academy has now been open for a couple of years. I don't know how much the Marlins spent, but the Mets spent $8 million on their academy.

 

The Marlins also have an academy in the Netherlands, from whence VanDenHurk came.

 

But, details of this, that or the other expense simply don't matter because owners operate in their own long-term best interest by putting the best product on the field that they can consistent with their financial circumstances and willingness to take risk, regardless of how many dollars are in the till before they sell a ticket.

 

Baseball owners are competing for discretionary entertainment dollars. Markets work, much as people like Stark and others would like to believe that they don't or want to disbelieve the results.

  • Author

This will probably set off another round of smear attacks and innuendo, but hopefully we’ll hear more reasoned voices instead of just the partisan hatchet jobs from here on out.

 

 

And of course this post wasn't isn't a smear attack or a partisan hatchet job :brigginbounce

 

I have no axe to grind. I did come down on those who would try and shut down all talk on this subject by insulting posters or would-be posters who might disagree with their stance. It bothers me when someone puts on airs of superiority in a debate when they don't have all the facts, and then act like people are simpletons that don't agree with their uninformed opinions.

 

Only people that work for MLB or the Marlins have all the facts and figures. The rest of us have to piece together what we can from what is leaked to the public. And from what I have seen that has gotten out about the MLB central fund, revenue sharing, and local TV/radio/cable contracts - Stark's numbers appear to be sound.

  • Author

This would also cover international camps and the like – which the Marlins do not have last I checked.

 

From a Frisaro article in '07:

 

The most dramatic upgrade is the Marlins' new academy that is nearly completed in the Dominican Republic. By October or November, the facilities being leased in Boca Chica should be complete. Having a strong presence in the Dominican Republic is crucial in the organization's quest to sign rising talent in the Caribbean.

 

The Marlins' new facility includes a dorm that will house 40 players and coaches. It has two fields, batting cages, and lights, so workouts can take place day or night.

 

Gonzalez describes it as being basically like a college dorm. It will be open for 10 months, closing in December and most of January. Players will be fed three meals a day plus a snack. English classes also will be taught.

 

That academy has now been open for a couple of years. I don't know how much the Marlins spent, but the Mets spent $8 million on their academy.

 

The Marlins also have an academy in the Netherlands, from whence VanDenHurk came.

I stand corrected on the international academies. I remember talk of camp shutdowns in the past - perhaps in Venezuela - and didn't take note of developments in recent years. I also note that the Marlins, with MLB help, are developing an academy in Hialeah. Regardless, I think you can still apply that $15 million average cost figure put out there by the MLB rep, as I don't believe the Marlins camps or minor league operations are out of line with most of MLB.

 

But, details of this, that or the other expense simply don't matter because owners operate in their own long-term best interest by putting the best product on the field that they can consistent with their financial circumstances and willingness to take risk, regardless of how many dollars are in the till before they sell a ticket.

 

Baseball owners are competing for discretionary entertainment dollars. Markets work, much as people like Stark and others would like to believe that they don't or want to disbelieve the results.

 

 

All of this minus the last line - which I am having a hard time translating - says nothing new. Of course owners will put their best interests first. There is nothing wrong with Loria or any other owner turning a profit. The problems arise when the Marlins cry poor mouth while collecting this money, money that is supposed to be used to make sure the underperforming teams (financially and on the field) can compete with the teams that routinely sport $100+ million payrolls.

I don't think anyone is questioning his revenue sharing figures. The concern is that he might not be sufficienty accounting for other expenses.

 

I would like to see someone from each "side" provide hypothetical accounting estimations to see how much Loria is actually profiting.

 

On top of payroll and minor league operating expenses, how much does the team need to pay out in payroll (employer) tax and insurance? I would guess this amount easily exceeds $10 million.

 

What about stadium rental fees, maintenance, and employee wages? Front office and executive salaries? Marketing? Equipment? I don't think it's a stretch to assume that this in the tens of millions of dollars.

anyone know how much money the marlins pay to use dolphin stadium and how much money they get from ticket sales? curious

 

 

Well the ownership always complains about the amount, yet never once has shown us a number to back up how supposedly onerous this amount is. We should take their word ? You really trust what Loria has to say ?

 

2003, over the years I have concluded you are either :

 

1) Loria himself (LOL) or

2) A Marlins PR rep or

3) someone that took a lot of drugs in the 1990's

 

1st off, Loria owns 90% + of the Marlins, because of the debacle by the now silent partners when the group of them was still the ownership in Montreal. I believe they have to remain silent by rules of the ownership or risk losing that to Loria. So why spill any beans about the way the team is being run when you are making at least a couple of million of $ a year for doing nothing ?

 

You always say that no one ever cares about how much money it takes to run an MLB organization. Well don't you think all 29 other MLB franchises have the same expenses ? No matter what you think it costs, it doesn't cost more than $ 10 million. It certainly can't be going to minor league payrolls, since its well known most minor leaguers make in the hundreds of $ a month, not the thousands or millions. And the Marlins aren't responsible but for just a portion of those payrolls, if any at all. Those minor league teams pay most of them. If that isn't the case then sign me up for ownership for a minor league team, because its almost all profit, all the time. Same goes for the minor league coaches, paid by the minor league team for the most part. If not, then its looking even better to be a minor league owner.

 

Scouting you say costs millions.....really ? Your going to pay an MLB scout just as much or more than MLB coaches make ? I've known a couple of MLB scouts, because of going to U of Miami Hurricanes games for more than a few years, and boy if those guys are raking in the big bucks they sure did fool me. Most of them I talked to acted like they were not much better off than most of the rest of us. One I know lived in an area of South Miami (hence the reason he scouted every Hurricanes game) and unless he was just pocketing huge amounts for retirement, had a rather modest home for someone making these big bucks you say it costs the franchise to run an MLB team.

 

So is the money going to scouting in the Dominican or others places ? You really want us to believe it costs more money to run a baseball camp in the Dominican than a MLB team in the US ?

 

2003, just get over it, Loria has a plan, and that plan all along has been to save the money from revenue sharing and make the other owners (through their fans) pay for his part of the new stadium. That is where the Marlins "share" of the stadium money is coming from. And even with that, the Marlins aren't paying a lot of that money up-front, but are getting to distribute their contribution over a number of years. The up-front money for the stadium is coming from the government.

 

My hat is off to Loria, for bamboozling 2003, the government entities involved in the stadium, but I give him most credit to his fooling his fellow MLB owners into paying for his stadium. That is pure genius.

2003, over the years I have concluded you are either :

 

1) Loria himself (LOL) or

2) A Marlins PR rep or

3) someone that took a lot of drugs in the 1990's

 

 

 

It was the sixties and god it was great!!!

 

As for the rest of your diatribe it's one factual mistake piled on top of another so why bother...the one thing I agree with you on is that over the last three or four years they have been amassing a significant portion of their contribution towards the new stadium. I've said that myself many times and it's reasonable to do so given the rest of their financial situation. You see that as some kind of sin, I don't, we'll just have to disagree but I will say I suspect it's being done with the tacit approval of MLB and the majority of owners who want to keep baseball in South Florida.

2003, over the years I have concluded you are either :

 

1) Loria himself (LOL) or

2) A Marlins PR rep or

3) someone that took a lot of drugs in the 1990's

 

 

 

It was the sixties and god it was great!!!

 

As for the rest of your diatribe it's one factual mistake piled on top of another so why bother...the one thing I agree with you on is that over the last three or four years they have been amassing a significant portion of their contribution towards the new stadium. I've said that myself many times and it's reasonable to do so given the rest of their financial situation. You see that as some kind of sin, I don't, we'll just have to disagree but I will say I suspect it's being done with the tacit approval of MLB and the majority of owners who want to keep baseball in South Florida.

 

If Loria has been saving the revenue sharing money to put towards the stadium, isn't that the best possible thing he could have done for the franchise? It's not as if the on-field results are unacceptable. If the choice was to spend an extra $10 million on payroll with no assurance of more wins or saving the future of the franchise in South Florida, I don't see why anyone would have a problem with that.

2003, over the years I have concluded you are either :

 

1) Loria himself (LOL) or

2) A Marlins PR rep or

3) someone that took a lot of drugs in the 1990's

 

 

 

It was the sixties and god it was great!!!

 

As for the rest of your diatribe it's one factual mistake piled on top of another so why bother...the one thing I agree with you on is that over the last three or four years they have been amassing a significant portion of their contribution towards the new stadium. I've said that myself many times and it's reasonable to do so given the rest of their financial situation. You see that as some kind of sin, I don't, we'll just have to disagree but I will say I suspect it's being done with the tacit approval of MLB and the majority of owners who want to keep baseball in South Florida.

Wow, I think we agree on this. I think he has stuffed his pockets with revenue sharing money since the '06 season to the tune of ~$100 million and I think he'll probably use that money to help pay for his share of the stadium.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.