December 15, 200916 yr Wow, I think we agree on this. I think he has stuffed his pockets with revenue sharing money since the '06 season to the tune of ~$100 million and I think he'll probably use that money to help pay for his share of the stadium. What I don't like is your choice of words and maybe it's more me than you, but I'm offended by phraseology like "stuffed his pockets" because it has a connotation that I think doesn't apply here. To me stuffing ones pockets implies doing something illegal or nefarious or looting and I don't believe even you are suggesting he is doing any of those when you use that phrase, at least not from what you wrote. They could easily be using gate attendance revenue or from a combinations of sources outside what is commonly lumped together as "revenue sharing" dollars and at least for me that would be a prudent thing to do considering how important a new stadium is to the life of the franchise. That's why i think you haven't heard MLB chiming in and complaining they aren't spending their $$$ properly because whatever they are squirreling away is outside the perview of their fellow owners. And remember this is all a by-product in the first place of the lousy lease the estimable John Henry signed in his rush to get his hands on this team.
December 16, 200916 yr So basically, if we use the PBC figures (from Stark) that running the farm and signing draft picks averages $24 million, lopping that onto payroll, the Marlins are running say, $50-55 million in "player expenses" this entire year. Then sure, what's Beinfest making, Gonzalez (he got a 3/$2 deal, so Freddy is around $700,000), Hill, Samson, middle management, ticket guys, then insurance, legal fees (even though Marlins have in house they still have to get outside counsel for say, when Scott Olsen gets tazed), etc etc. I'm fine with this being "tens of millions" like Penguino says. That's very reasonable. If they are getting $80, and then another $30ish from selling 1.3 million tickets. $110 - ($55 + "tens of millions") = profit. If running the business costs something crazy, like $35 million dollars (which I am making outrageously high on purpose), there is clear 'profit' here to the tune of $20 million. And what about that one year payroll was $15 million? We're talking $45 million. I find it very reasonable to think Loria has been "pocketing" this money to apply to the stadium. What's the big deal, and why is there so much fighting? Like PBC said, someone disprove that $80 revenue sharing figure. If it's $40, a lot of things change here and we really are probably scraping by. But if it's $80, even in a hypothetical scenario making huge monetary values for the farm and organization infrastructure, you can clearly see these numbers don't all add up to zero anyway you look at it. There is a clear surplus with this level of revenue sharing. Where that money goes? I hope it's to the stadium like a few of you have said. They should be pretty damn close to paying their share by this point. Personally, I say Loria's track record of approving Pudge, Delgado, Leiter, aggressive trades at times with Preston Wilson/Charles Johnson/Mike Hampton, I don't see a guy hellbent on making this just about money. This guy wants to win, and I think he figures the only way to do that was to first get a stadium. Maybe you want to point fingers he should have just fronted the $400 million in 2005 to build the thing and then slowly recoup over the life of it, but I can't blame him for not outlaying that much cash when other cities build stadiums for owners as well. What can you say? Your infrastructure is fixed. Your payroll is variable. And there you go. It's really that easy. Occam's razor. You know when we'll know the answer to all of this? Pretty much next year. Because a year from the stadium to start building hype, and then the stadium itself. If they don't start signing even Ross Gload level free agents, let alone say you need a 3B in 2 years because Dominguez didn't work out, that's when I'm going to have a problem. I understand the bad lease. I understand revenue issues, even if all of the above is true and they are "pocketing" $20-40 million a year to put towards a stadium. What I will not understand is if they do not immediately rev things up and fix holes on this team with names other than Emilio Bonifacio, Brett Carroll, Tim Wood, and Chris Leroux (and I'm not knocking them, I kind of like all of them in their own special bench/back of the bullpen way. But you keep those guys in AAA if all it takes is $2 million to keep Calero, etc). If that crap continues in 2012, then clearly 03 is wrong and this is a profit seeking venture only and we're all a bunch of shmucks. But I really don't expect that. Until then, DO WHATEVER. You better god damn restore confidence in players immediately once that thing is built as your excuse train as run out permanently. And this might even include signing Josh Johnson to a reasonable 4/$40 deal, because with a stadium you can risk that god damn payroll in 2012 and 2013. And now I'm angry about JJ again great.
December 16, 200916 yr When the new stadium opens you can bet your butt that payroll will always be $45-$55 million.Nothing significant is going to change as long as Loria is the owner.
December 16, 200916 yr When the new stadium opens you can bet your butt that payroll will always be $45-$55 million.Nothing significant is going to change as long as Loria is the owner. I'll put you into the, "you think we're all shmucks" category.
December 16, 200916 yr I believe the team suffered losses after 2005 and that was why the payroll was virtually at the minimum in 2006. If you are applying the formula of something like "$110-($55+extra)" I don't anticipate there being a wide profit margin, especially if there are some stadium related expenses being tied up over these last couple of years. I'm still hoping that someone will provide insight on what the tax obligations are for running a MLB franchise. As I said, this burden tied with insurance could easily be in the tens of millions of dollars alone. I do think that Loria will loosen the payroll as soon there is legitimate revenue coming in that isn't consumed by stadium related expenses. This can't happen until he generates actual revenue from concessions, parking, and luxury boxes while no longer having to pay a rent to the Dolphins. The Marlins "lease" for the new stadium is supposed to be less than $2 million. If the revenue skyrockets with the new stadium and Loria isn't having to pay large installments for stadium funding, then I think payroll will start to increase. I would be shocked if it doesn't happen. For the record, I'm no Loria fan. I don't like his ownership but that is mostly for baseball reasons. I don't like their business model even with the budget constraints. I just happen to think that people are making wild accusations with regard to the low payrolls. For example, I think Johnson could have and should have been signed to a four year deal, even with lower than average revenues.
December 16, 200916 yr 2003, over the years I have concluded you are either : 1) Loria himself (LOL) or 2) A Marlins PR rep or 3) someone that took a lot of drugs in the 1990's It was the sixties and god it was great!!! As for the rest of your diatribe it's one factual mistake piled on top of another so why bother...the one thing I agree with you on is that over the last three or four years they have been amassing a significant portion of their contribution towards the new stadium. I've said that myself many times and it's reasonable to do so given the rest of their financial situation. You see that as some kind of sin, I don't, we'll just have to disagree but I will say I suspect it's being done with the tacit approval of MLB and the majority of owners who want to keep baseball in South Florida. If Loria has been saving the revenue sharing money to put towards the stadium, isn't that the best possible thing he could have done for the franchise? It's not as if the on-field results are unacceptable. If the choice was to spend an extra $10 million on payroll with no assurance of more wins or saving the future of the franchise in South Florida, I don't see why anyone would have a problem with that. Its wrong because you have a chance to make the playoffs the last two years or at least try to make the playoffs, with a big move and you failed. There are ZERO assurances that in the future the Marlins, even in a new stadium, and with a bigger payroll, will have that chance. You have to take your opportunities when they are given, and not sit around and think they will happen in the future. This ownership failed its players and fans, because of the greediness of the owner to make sure he has a new stadium in place when he sells the team in a few years. Because that will happen, its as assured as the sun will rise tomorrow. By 2013 the Marlins will have new owners.
December 16, 200916 yr a winning ballclub and getting cash from the big boys. sounds like smart business to me. there was only one winning ballclub last year, and that was the Yankee's. Being satisfied with anything less, means you don't understand what competing is all about.
December 17, 200916 yr Since nobody else has done it, pursuant to someones request for details, here's my guesstimate of the Marlins finances: '09 Marlins income (millions): 40 central fund (Stark) 35 revenue share (Stark) 12 local radio/tv (Stark) 21 gate (Forbes) (27 based on 19.06 ave ticket and 1,464,109, but that assumes they get 100%) Other stuff - totally unknown, probably not insignificant 108+ Total '09 Marlins expenses (millions): 36.8 player payroll (MLB) 15.0 player-development system (Manfred) 9.0 cost of acquiring players through draft/internationally (Manfred) 7.0 interest on debt to acquire team (87 mill according to Forbes, I assume an 8% interest rate) 4.4 addition to sinking fund to retire debt to acquire team assuming 20 year term (my estimate) 5.0 MLB pension fund (Stark) 5.0 MLB operations fund (Stark) 5.0 advertising/promo (my estimate) 3.0 stadium lease (my estimate) 2.7 front office (1.5 Beinfest .2 Hill .5 Freddi, secretaries/support .5) (my estimate) 2.0 15 players on the 40-man roster who are not in MLB (my estimate) 1.5 hotel and per diem for road games (my estimate) 1.2 coaches: bench, hitting, pitching, 3B, 1B, bullpen, tot 6 coaches .2@ (my estimate) 1.1 chartered airplane 10-12k/hr, 10 hrs flying time on 10 road trips (my estimate) (737-800, 75 mill new) 1.0 lawyers/CPAs (my estimate) 1.0 general liability insurance (my estimate) 1.0 ushers/security/ticket takers/misc ballpark expenses (my estimate) 0.7 1.45% medicare FICA on entire payroll (my est 45 million) (IRS) 0.6 6.2% on 107K social security FICA (my estimate assuming 60 ees making 107K and 60 ees making 50K) 0.6 health ins 5K@ for 120 employees (my estimate) 0.5 10 clubhouse/equipment/videotape guys (my estimate) 0.2 office space for 100 employees (my estimate) 0.1 baseballs, bats, uniforms (my estimate) 1.0 miscellaneous crap I haven't thought of (my estimate) 105.4 total Having only devoted about an hour to trying to list expenses, I'm sure that I've missed a lot more than 1 million, but, in any case, it's obvious why the Marlins payroll is what it is, give or take 5 mill. I'll guess that any excess revenue from "other stuff" has been allocated to pay the Marlin's 150-160 million contribution to a stadium that they won't own. With any luck, the "Loria is a cheapskate and a thief" crowd will now choke on their bile, but somehow I doubt it.
December 17, 200916 yr the employer taxes are FICA and then FUTA and SUTA. Also, if they are an LLP it is a pass-through entity so they will not pay any taxes, but the partnership will file a K-1 for each partner and the partner then pays the taxes on their individual 1040. Now if it is a Corp, which was on their annual report with the state (but again - I am not 100% sure because it wouldn't make much sense for them to file that way) they would pay corporate taxes.
December 17, 200916 yr Wow, I think we agree on this. I think he has stuffed his pockets with revenue sharing money since the '06 season to the tune of ~$100 million and I think he'll probably use that money to help pay for his share of the stadium. What I don't like is your choice of words and maybe it's more me than you, but I'm offended by phraseology like "stuffed his pockets" because it has a connotation that I think doesn't apply here. To me stuffing ones pockets implies doing something illegal or nefarious or looting and I don't believe even you are suggesting he is doing any of those when you use that phrase, at least not from what you wrote. I know the way I phrase it has a negative connotation but it's not because I think Loria is doing anything illegal or unethical. He's trying to maximize his profits and there's nothing wrong with that. However, as a fan I would prefer if he spent the revenue sharing money on improving the team rather than profit accumulation. I would prefer an owner that put winning ahead of profits.
December 18, 200916 yr I don't understand why MLB has revenue sharing if owners like Loria are allowed to pocket the money rather than spending it on payroll and player-development. Probably, because they aren't. If you think those are the only two things baseball teams spend money on then you're part of the problem and not part of the solution. 80 million dollars BEFORE A TICKET IS SOLD. That covers payroll and a good part of operating expenses if not all. No wonder Loria won't let go of this team even though he could give a crap about baseball
December 18, 200916 yr I don't understand why MLB has revenue sharing if owners like Loria are allowed to pocket the money rather than spending it on payroll and player-development. Probably, because they aren't. If you think those are the only two things baseball teams spend money on then you're part of the problem and not part of the solution. 80 million dollars BEFORE A TICKET IS SOLD. That covers payroll and a good part of operating expenses if not all. No wonder Loria won't let go of this team even though he could give a crap about baseball STOP TALKING OUT OF YOUR ASS! DISPUTE SOMETHING IN "..."'s POST OR GTFO.
December 18, 200916 yr I don't understand why MLB has revenue sharing if owners like Loria are allowed to pocket the money rather than spending it on payroll and player-development. Probably, because they aren't. If you think those are the only two things baseball teams spend money on then you're part of the problem and not part of the solution. 80 million dollars BEFORE A TICKET IS SOLD. That covers payroll and a good part of operating expenses if not all. No wonder Loria won't let go of this team even though he could give a crap about baseball STOP TALKING OUT OF YOUR ASS! DISPUTE SOMETHING IN "..."'s POST OR GTFO. When I stop talking out of my ass you can kiss it and I say it with all due respect...which if this may be confusing to you in your limited reading comp level is actually none
December 18, 200916 yr 2003, over the years I have concluded you are either : 1) Loria himself (LOL) or 2) A Marlins PR rep or 3) someone that took a lot of drugs in the 1990's It was the sixties and god it was great!!! As for the rest of your diatribe it's one factual mistake piled on top of another so why bother...the one thing I agree with you on is that over the last three or four years they have been amassing a significant portion of their contribution towards the new stadium. I've said that myself many times and it's reasonable to do so given the rest of their financial situation. You see that as some kind of sin, I don't, we'll just have to disagree but I will say I suspect it's being done with the tacit approval of MLB and the majority of owners who want to keep baseball in South Florida. If Loria has been saving the revenue sharing money to put towards the stadium, isn't that the best possible thing he could have done for the franchise? It's not as if the on-field results are unacceptable. If the choice was to spend an extra $10 million on payroll with no assurance of more wins or saving the future of the franchise in South Florida, I don't see why anyone would have a problem with that. Its wrong because you have a chance to make the playoffs the last two years or at least try to make the playoffs, with a big move and you failed. There are ZERO assurances that in the future the Marlins, even in a new stadium, and with a bigger payroll, will have that chance. You have to take your opportunities when they are given, and not sit around and think they will happen in the future. This ownership failed its players and fans, because of the greediness of the owner to make sure he has a new stadium in place when he sells the team in a few years. Because that will happen, its as assured as the sun will rise tomorrow. By 2013 the Marlins will have new owners. If you are talking about off-season moves, was their an impact player or a difference maker we were pursuing that was priced out of our range? If you are talking trades during the season, the money alone isn't the issue, it is what we are willing to give up to get a player. Don't forget, a few seasons ago we were in trade talks to get Manny Ramirez, so again, in-season moves don't seem to be about money as much as one would think. We are at least open to fielding offers. There is zero assurance that one player would have pushed us over the threshold and got us into the playoffs. I think even if we had the payroll of the Yankees, Beinfest and company would still not pursue "big names" all the time. Their philosophy has seemed to be get more bang for your buck, no matter what the buck price is. There will always be players we, as fans, think the FO should have gotten to get us to the promised land, no matter the budget.
December 18, 200916 yr 2003, over the years I have concluded you are either : 1) Loria himself (LOL) or 2) A Marlins PR rep or 3) someone that took a lot of drugs in the 1990's It was the sixties and god it was great!!! As for the rest of your diatribe it's one factual mistake piled on top of another so why bother...the one thing I agree with you on is that over the last three or four years they have been amassing a significant portion of their contribution towards the new stadium. I've said that myself many times and it's reasonable to do so given the rest of their financial situation. You see that as some kind of sin, I don't, we'll just have to disagree but I will say I suspect it's being done with the tacit approval of MLB and the majority of owners who want to keep baseball in South Florida. If Loria has been saving the revenue sharing money to put towards the stadium, isn't that the best possible thing he could have done for the franchise? It's not as if the on-field results are unacceptable. If the choice was to spend an extra $10 million on payroll with no assurance of more wins or saving the future of the franchise in South Florida, I don't see why anyone would have a problem with that. Its wrong because you have a chance to make the playoffs the last two years or at least try to make the playoffs, with a big move and you failed. There are ZERO assurances that in the future the Marlins, even in a new stadium, and with a bigger payroll, will have that chance. You have to take your opportunities when they are given, and not sit around and think they will happen in the future. This ownership failed its players and fans, because of the greediness of the owner to make sure he has a new stadium in place when he sells the team in a few years. Because that will happen, its as assured as the sun will rise tomorrow. By 2013 the Marlins will have new owners. If you are talking about off-season moves, was their an impact player or a difference maker we were pursuing that was priced out of our range? If you are talking trades during the season, the money alone isn't the issue, it is what we are willing to give up to get a player. Don't forget, a few seasons ago we were in trade talks to get Manny Ramirez, so again, in-season moves don't seem to be about money as much as one would think. We are at least open to fielding offers. There is zero assurance that one player would have pushed us over the threshold and got us into the playoffs. I think even if we had the payroll of the Yankees, Beinfest and company would still not pursue "big names" all the time. Their philosophy has seemed to be get more bang for your buck, no matter what the buck price is. There will always be players we, as fans, think the FO should have gotten to get us to the promised land, no matter the budget. Don't forget though that the Red Sox were going to pick up almost all or all of his contract for that trade. Plus he only had club options left so it would of been a half season and gone.
December 18, 200916 yr When I stop talking out of my ass you can kiss it and I say it with all due respect...which if this may be confusing to you in your limited reading comp level is actually none I don't even think I need to respond. Your post speaks for itself. Again, very impressive.
December 18, 200916 yr If you are talking about off-season moves, was their an impact player or a difference maker we were pursuing that was priced out of our range? If you are talking trades during the season, the money alone isn't the issue, it is what we are willing to give up to get a player. Don't forget, a few seasons ago we were in trade talks to get Manny Ramirez, so again, in-season moves don't seem to be about money as much as one would think. We are at least open to fielding offers. There is zero assurance that one player would have pushed us over the threshold and got us into the playoffs. I think even if we had the payroll of the Yankees, Beinfest and company would still not pursue "big names" all the time. Their philosophy has seemed to be get more bang for your buck, no matter what the buck price is. There will always be players we, as fans, think the FO should have gotten to get us to the promised land, no matter the budget. Don't forget though that the Red Sox were going to pick up almost all or all of his contract for that trade. Plus he only had club options left so it would of been a half season and gone. True, but that doesn't mean the Fish aren't looking for ways to improve themselves, even if a player in question would have a hefty paycheck. They are willing to run the race, but not blow out their knees for uncertain push towards the finish line, The Marlins have shown they are active in going after players, but just because a deal falls through or we don't get Player X in the off-season, doesn't mean it was solely a money issue, in terms of this player is definitely worth this much, but it is too expensive for the Marlins. We all know that sometimes the talent level doesn't match the paycheck and the Marlins, along with other teams, will not break the bank on these types of players. One may also point to the "special" money Loria gave to Pudge and the deal with Delgado that Loria and the FO are willing to spend money to lure players here. However, the FO has to view them as special and worth it.
December 18, 200916 yr Its wrong because you have a chance to make the playoffs the last two years or at least try to make the playoffs, with a big move and you failed. There are ZERO assurances that in the future the Marlins, even in a new stadium, and with a bigger payroll, will have that chance. You have to take your opportunities when they are given, and not sit around and think they will happen in the future. This ownership failed its players and fans, because of the greediness of the owner to make sure he has a new stadium in place when he sells the team in a few years. Because that will happen, its as assured as the sun will rise tomorrow. By 2013 the Marlins will have new owners. If you are talking about off-season moves, was their an impact player or a difference maker we were pursuing that was priced out of our range? If you are talking trades during the season, the money alone isn't the issue, it is what we are willing to give up to get a player. Don't forget, a few seasons ago we were in trade talks to get Manny Ramirez, so again, in-season moves don't seem to be about money as much as one would think. We are at least open to fielding offers. There is zero assurance that one player would have pushed us over the threshold and got us into the playoffs. I think even if we had the payroll of the Yankees, Beinfest and company would still not pursue "big names" all the time. Their philosophy has seemed to be get more bang for your buck, no matter what the buck price is. There will always be players we, as fans, think the FO should have gotten to get us to the promised land, no matter the budget. One of the things often reported during last summer's trading period was (virtually) every Marlins' proposal was responded to with the words "Mike Stanton". In that kind of environment it's understandable why little movement occurred. it also appears if the numbers above are even remotely close, there isn't a whole lot of money to go out and make the "big deal" for an impact player other than as a short term rental. As for PSM's delusional comments (paraphrasing) Loria doesn't want to win, doesn't care about the fans, etc etc, that's an opinion I would disagree with but it's his right to express. Is there really people here who think we should have traded Mike Stanton for two months of Manny Ramirez? Really? We tried trading Hermida a couple of years in a row, heck we even allegedly tried trading Coghlan in at least one trade rumor the year before, we're open to a lot of offers but I have yet to hear a valid argument made that Mike Stanton is worth a rental, any rental, including Manny. People so often ignore that if ownership is so obsessed with making money that it would be in their selfish interests to make as much as they possible can and the best and easiest way to accomplish that when you're in a position to contend, is by winning. The Marlins were already in a position where making the playoffs was within sight. Imagine the revenues this franchise would've seen and the goodwill a WS victory brought, the merchandising dollars, the increased seat and skybox sales in the new stadium, the advertisers lining up to sign longterm contracts in the new facilities, the bump up in fees for naming rights for the stadium housing a world championship team. You can cut out or save $10 million by making or not making deals at the deadline but the upside from winning means a factor of five or six or ten times more profit which if ownership is so greedy one would think would be the rational course of action. Ownership is not blameless nor are they without sin. There isn't a person here who doesn't wonder why they either made or didn't make a certain deal, or appear engaged in the trading or contract signing process. Holding onto this coach or that, electing to start Saturday games ten minutes later so they didn't fall under the Fox blackout rules, or decide to play Sundays at 1pm. There isn't an area of the game on or off the field where they can't be criticized. I just think one isn't their desire to win. but that's me.
December 18, 200916 yr a winning ballclub and getting cash from the big boys. sounds like smart business to me. there was only one winning ballclub last year, and that was the Yankee's. Being satisfied with anything less, means you don't understand what competing is all about. wonder if you understand what running a business is about...
December 18, 200916 yr I know the way I phrase it has a negative connotation but it's not because I think Loria is doing anything illegal or unethical. He's trying to maximize his profits and there's nothing wrong with that. However, as a fan I would prefer if he spent the revenue sharing money on improving the team rather than profit accumulation. I would prefer an owner that put winning ahead of profits. And then, like the Rangers, have some of your operations taken over by the league because you are financially unsound.
December 20, 200916 yr a winning ballclub and getting cash from the big boys. sounds like smart business to me. there was only one winning ballclub last year, and that was the Yankee's. Being satisfied with anything less, means you don't understand what competing is all about. wonder if you understand what running a business is about... I understand completely and it gets straight to the point, and that is making profits IS more important to Loria than winning. If the Marlins win too much it means heftier arbitration salaries for those involved and that means less profit. He'd rather the Marlins come close and tease, which might keep more fans interested the whole season, but not good enough to push his arbitration players salary demands too high. Getting that one player that could put them over the top is never going to be on the table for this franchise as long as Loria owns the team.
December 20, 200916 yr a winning ballclub and getting cash from the big boys. sounds like smart business to me. there was only one winning ballclub last year, and that was the Yankee's. Being satisfied with anything less, means you don't understand what competing is all about. wonder if you understand what running a business is about... I understand completely and it gets straight to the point, and that is making profits IS more important to Loria than winning. If the Marlins win too much it means heftier arbitration salaries for those involved and that means less profit. He'd rather the Marlins come close and tease, which might keep more fans interested the whole season, but not good enough to push his arbitration players salary demands too high. Getting that one player that could put them over the top is never going to be on the table for this franchise as long as Loria owns the team. Then he wouldn't have signed Hanley to a long term deal.
December 20, 200916 yr He signeed Hanley long term because he had to. They needed to see some kind of commitment to keeping an MLB caliber team. But at the same time they refused to give him a no trade clause, so, who knows what they really have in store.
December 20, 200916 yr a winning ballclub and getting cash from the big boys. sounds like smart business to me. there was only one winning ballclub last year, and that was the Yankee's. Being satisfied with anything less, means you don't understand what competing is all about. wonder if you understand what running a business is about... I understand completely and it gets straight to the point, and that is making profits IS more important to Loria than winning. If the Marlins win too much it means heftier arbitration salaries for those involved and that means less profit. He'd rather the Marlins come close and tease, which might keep more fans interested the whole season, but not good enough to push his arbitration players salary demands too high. Getting that one player that could put them over the top is never going to be on the table for this franchise as long as Loria owns the team. Then he wouldn't have signed Hanley to a long term deal. The Hanley contract only came about because it was necessary for the stadium deal to get done. Which again is all about profits and not winning. Who knows how long Hanley remains with the team now that the stadium deal is done. Loria may just wish to go back to a 2006 payroll, with virtually all players making the minimum. We do have 3 ½ months before the season starts for him to get his profit margins increased.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.