Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Does this list seem surprising to anyone?

Featured Replies

I know most of you guys will disagree with this but I say we trade Hanley next year. His contract is over when, in 2013?? Is there any realistic possibility that we resign him after that? I highly doubt it. He's going to ask for a ton of money and I think we can all sense that his heart isn't with the Marlins anymore. I'm not saying he's giving up, he's still giving 100% effort. But once that passion is lost and you're playing more from a business perspective, your numbers will naturally go down. Honestly the season Hanley is having this year, I really don't see him performing much better in the years to come. .290, 25 homers, 95 RBI's. IF we trade him, we can definitely get some high profile prospects along with some big names out there. I say the front office pulls the trigger. I think it will be best for Hanley and the Marlins.

 

 

:rolleyes:

 

How can you sense it? He's giving 100%, but his heart isn't in it? This also makes no sense.

 

 

100% effort is using all your talent and natural ability to preform. 110% effort is adding heart and passion to the mix. We're getting the former from Hanley now. 2-3 years ago, we were getting the latter. That's all I'm saying, and I think most people here on MarlinsBaseball can agree with that.

  • Author

It's about optimizing net production from each and every player on the field.

 

Trading some offense for pitching would only be beneficial if (roughly and mathematically-speaking):

 

[New Pitcher] - [Old Pitcher] > [Gaby] - [Gaby's Replacement]

 

With trading for or signing pitching.....getting a middle-of-the-rotation type won't impress me personally, because it's quite possible that Volstad/West figure out how to be that soon enough. If we're making a move, I'd want it to be big for a #2 or better starter. I know these are tough to come by, but if we can't get someone like that, then I would stand pat (with the possible exception of a veteran #5 for cheap, but if that's going to turn out like Nate Robertson, then I'll pass).

 

The same thing with defense, of course. Hanley is a net superstar at SS, regardless of fielding. If we can find average production at 3B, the roughly comparable situation would be Hanley as an above-average 3B and finding another net well-above-average SS. That will be difficult.

 

Even stretching the effects of better/worse defense and saying it allows our pitching staff to throw fewer pitches, I still think the organization would have to be void of 3B options (we shouldn't be by 2012 because of Dominguez), and have a really strong option to replace Hanley at SS.

 

At this point, Ozzie Martinez doesn't project as an above-average starter, and Matt Dominguez does. And decent 3B come at much less of a premium than decent SS, if memory serves.

 

My point is that Hanley's defense is destroying his net worth because the defensive weight of SS is so large. We can get a guy who doesn't hit well above average but plays stout D and retains an average net worth AT SHORTSTOP. Then at the same time giving Hanley a better net worth than before because instead of being a liability at SS he's a strength at 3rd base, even the average production at third base is higher.

 

You can justify it through saber metrics all you want, but the fact is that the defense is a big liability for the Marlins, and SS is such a huge position. Uggla, Ramirez, Maybin up the middle is not playoff caliber up the middle.

Except that plus-minus and UZR do compare a player to the average player AT HIS POSITION. And WAR takes those into account. And he's still 3rd in baseball as a SS despite a down year both offensively and defensively.

  • Author

Except that plus-minus and UZR do compare a player to the average player AT HIS POSITION. And WAR takes those into account. And he's still 3rd in baseball as a SS despite a down year both offensively and defensively.

 

 

I know UZR wise Hanley is -9 for his career, He's had good defensive years, and he's had bad ones. But -9 career doesn't lie, it seems as though he was getting better until this season.

 

I no longer have a subscription to BillJames. Whats Hanley's +/- look like this season and his career?

I know most of you guys will disagree with this but I say we trade Hanley next year. His contract is over when, in 2013?? Is there any realistic possibility that we resign him after that? I highly doubt it. He's going to ask for a ton of money and I think we can all sense that his heart isn't with the Marlins anymore. I'm not saying he's giving up, he's still giving 100% effort. But once that passion is lost and you're playing more from a business perspective, your numbers will naturally go down. Honestly the season Hanley is having this year, I really don't see him performing much better in the years to come. .290, 25 homers, 95 RBI's. IF we trade him, we can definitely get some high profile prospects along with some big names out there. I say the front office pulls the trigger. I think it will be best for Hanley and the Marlins.

 

 

:rolleyes:

 

How can you sense it? He's giving 100%, but his heart isn't in it? This also makes no sense.

 

 

100% effort is using all your talent and natural ability to preform. 110% effort is adding heart and passion to the mix. We're getting the former from Hanley now. 2-3 years ago, we were getting the latter. That's all I'm saying, and I think most people here on MarlinsBaseball can agree with that.

 

Oh. I see..............

I know most of you guys will disagree with this but I say we trade Hanley next year. His contract is over when, in 2013?? Is there any realistic possibility that we resign him after that? I highly doubt it. He's going to ask for a ton of money and I think we can all sense that his heart isn't with the Marlins anymore. I'm not saying he's giving up, he's still giving 100% effort. But once that passion is lost and you're playing more from a business perspective, your numbers will naturally go down. Honestly the season Hanley is having this year, I really don't see him performing much better in the years to come. .290, 25 homers, 95 RBI's. IF we trade him, we can definitely get some high profile prospects along with some big names out there. I say the front office pulls the trigger. I think it will be best for Hanley and the Marlins.

 

 

:rolleyes:

 

How can you sense it? He's giving 100%, but his heart isn't in it? This also makes no sense.

 

 

100% effort is using all your talent and natural ability to preform. 110% effort is adding heart and passion to the mix. We're getting the former from Hanley now. 2-3 years ago, we were getting the latter. That's all I'm saying, and I think most people here on MarlinsBaseball can agree with that.

 

 

 

"I'll take dumb cliches for 500 Alex."

Except that plus-minus and UZR do compare a player to the average player AT HIS POSITION. And WAR takes those into account. And he's still 3rd in baseball as a SS despite a down year both offensively and defensively.

 

 

I know UZR wise Hanley is -9 for his career, He's had good defensive years, and he's had bad ones. But -9 career doesn't lie, it seems as though he was getting better until this season.

 

I no longer have a subscription to BillJames. Whats Hanley's +/- look like this season and his career?

 

I don't have access either. They tend to match up pretty well, usually AFAIK, but I can't say for sure.

  • Author

I know most of you guys will disagree with this but I say we trade Hanley next year. His contract is over when, in 2013?? Is there any realistic possibility that we resign him after that? I highly doubt it. He's going to ask for a ton of money and I think we can all sense that his heart isn't with the Marlins anymore. I'm not saying he's giving up, he's still giving 100% effort. But once that passion is lost and you're playing more from a business perspective, your numbers will naturally go down. Honestly the season Hanley is having this year, I really don't see him performing much better in the years to come. .290, 25 homers, 95 RBI's. IF we trade him, we can definitely get some high profile prospects along with some big names out there. I say the front office pulls the trigger. I think it will be best for Hanley and the Marlins.

 

 

:rolleyes:

 

How can you sense it? He's giving 100%, but his heart isn't in it? This also makes no sense.

 

 

100% effort is using all your talent and natural ability to preform. 110% effort is adding heart and passion to the mix. We're getting the former from Hanley now. 2-3 years ago, we were getting the latter. That's all I'm saying, and I think most people here on MarlinsBaseball can agree with that.

 

 

 

"I'll take dumb cliches for 500 Alex."

This made a room full of people crack up at my place

Except that plus-minus and UZR do compare a player to the average player AT HIS POSITION. And WAR takes those into account. And he's still 3rd in baseball as a SS despite a down year both offensively and defensively.

 

 

I know UZR wise Hanley is -9 for his career, He's had good defensive years, and he's had bad ones. But -9 career doesn't lie, it seems as though he was getting better until this season.

 

I no longer have a subscription to BillJames. Whats Hanley's +/- look like this season and his career?

Well, a big part of that is that ridiculous 2007 when we didn't even have infield practice. (Seriously, thinking back how the hell did the organization let that happen?)

Except that plus-minus and UZR do compare a player to the average player AT HIS POSITION. And WAR takes those into account. And he's still 3rd in baseball as a SS despite a down year both offensively and defensively.

 

 

I know UZR wise Hanley is -9 for his career, He's had good defensive years, and he's had bad ones. But -9 career doesn't lie, it seems as though he was getting better until this season.

 

I no longer have a subscription to BillJames. Whats Hanley's +/- look like this season and his career?

Well, a big part of that is that ridiculous 2007 when we didn't even have infield practice. (Seriously, thinking back how the hell did the organization let that happen?)

 

Samson the weasel slithered into Loria's brain and convinced him to try and make sure the team missed the playoffs so that he could keep payroll down. Obv.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.