Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Samson on 790

Featured Replies

Would you rather lose with a high payroll or win with a low payroll?

 

How about just win regardless of how much we pay these f***ers?

That's what I want. WINNING!

EXACTLY! this whole payroll thing is ridiculous.

This low payroll team is not going to win next year though so it's irrelevant.

 

Will Stanton even get a plate appearance next year? If I was the other team, I'd just intentionally walk him on four pitches every time.

If ever there was a reason to veto the trade, that interview was it.

 

No commitment to re-investing money.

Henderson Alvarez = Anderson Perez. If you're gonna make a trade like this, at least get the players' names right, asshole.

 

He isnt really a baseball guy so its not a big deal to not know the name. Now if it was beinfest that would be one thing but he already said he isnt a baseball guy and trusts his scouts.

 

He's still representing the team.

 

No offense, but can even you, off the top of your head name all 7 players we got back?

Will Stanton even get a plate appearance next year? If I was the other team, I'd just intentionally walk him on four pitches every time.

 

From what I've learned over the years, any time you step up to the plate counts as a plate appearance barring an inning-ending pick-off or caught stealing. :p

Will Stanton even get a plate appearance next year? If I was the other team, I'd just intentionally walk him on four pitches every time.

 

From what I've learned over the years, any time you step up to the plate counts as a plate appearance barring an inning-ending pick-off or caught stealing. :p

One at bat campaign for Stanton now?

If ever there was a reason to veto the trade, that interview was it.

 

No commitment to re-investing money.

Henderson Alvarez = Anderson Perez. If you're gonna make a trade like this, at least get the players' names right, asshole.

 

He isnt really a baseball guy so its not a big deal to not know the name. Now if it was beinfest that would be one thing but he already said he isnt a baseball guy and trusts his scouts.

 

He's still representing the team.

 

No offense, but can even you, off the top of your head name all 7 players we got back?

Alvarez, Nicolino, Marisnick, DeSclafani, Escobar, Mathis, Hechavarria.

 

I just wanted to see if I could. :D

Will Stanton even get a plate appearance next year? If I was the other team, I'd just intentionally walk him on four pitches every time.

 

From what I've learned over the years, any time you step up to the plate counts as a plate appearance barring an inning-ending pick-off or caught stealing. :p

One at bat campaign for Stanton now?

YES! We should do that. Standing ovation after he K's swinging.

As for the false question - win with a low payroll or lose with a high payroll

 

define "win" & "lose"

 

I would rather see an organization with a compass that is founded on providing a good product to their community, become integrated within their community and work for the long term success of the franchise within the community ....... don't make yourself a side show, don't proclaim you're one thing and then immediately proclaim your something different

 

there are so many degrees to things ....... i'd like to see a team that makes sound financial decisions, using FAs to fill gaps, retains their top talent and provides a foundation for long term success

 

If you are a consistent playoff team at $50m in payroll, that would be great .... however, no fan would be happy if they were a piece away and you didn't try to pay for it and bump that payroll up to $70m to grab a championship while raking in all that additional revenue

 

You could have that same annual playoff contender with a $150m payroll, the organization tried to add pieces, have held guys and are now looking at the choice of either retooling and driving the payroll down to $100M or keeping the status quo and driving the payroll up to $180m .... again, I don't think the fans would hold a grudge if you said "we gave it a go, but can't pay more for the same expected result - we need to tweak the design and try something different"

 

Those would all be normal reactions ....... this team doesn't think like that though ....... it's more of a mentality of "why pay $80M to win 70-80 games when we can pay $30M to win 50-60 games and make a whole lot more money"

 

It's smart for their short term pockets - but horrible for the future of baseball in south Florida with collateral damage thrown throughout the entire league

If ever there was a reason to veto the trade, that interview was it.

 

No commitment to re-investing money.

Henderson Alvarez = Anderson Perez. If you're gonna make a trade like this, at least get the players' names right, asshole.

 

He isnt really a baseball guy so its not a big deal to not know the name. Now if it was beinfest that would be one thing but he already said he isnt a baseball guy and trusts his scouts.

 

He's still representing the team.

 

No offense, but can even you, off the top of your head name all 7 players we got back?

 

I forget the 7th guy's name (Descalawhatever), but the first six aren't difficult to remember. At least get the guy's on the big-league roster next year, correctly. Is that so difficult? Henderson Alvarez has actually pitched in the big leagues for about two years now.

they also reminded us that Nolasco and Stanton are pretty close, might've been one reason to keep him around. I can't think of any other reason.

 

he said "unless something crazy happens," aka: no one wants him

he's getting $11.5m next year :confused

I think it would be mildly amusing if Stanton was walked every single plate appearance - at least in Miami - let the other organizations state that the only marketable player on the team will have zero home highlights or impact with his bat ..... stay at home kids, giancarlo isn't going to make the monstrosity sing tonight

If ever there was a reason to veto the trade, that interview was it.

 

No commitment to re-investing money.

Henderson Alvarez = Anderson Perez. If you're gonna make a trade like this, at least get the players' names right, asshole.

 

He isnt really a baseball guy so its not a big deal to not know the name. Now if it was beinfest that would be one thing but he already said he isnt a baseball guy and trusts his scouts.

 

He's still representing the team.

 

No offense, but can even you, off the top of your head name all 7 players we got back?

 

I forget the 7th guy's name (Descalawhatever), but the first six aren't difficult to remember. At least get the guy's on the big-league roster next year, correctly. Is that so difficult? Henderson Alvarez has actually pitched in the big leagues for about two years now.

 

exactly - when you are the representative of a team and you know you're going to be answering questions about a trade, you know you need to defend the trade and will be talking about the future of the team - at least know the players names - especially those who are MLB ready that you are going to tout as starting talent for next years team

 

being prepared isn't that difficult

 

guy should listen to some of the radio interviews from Derrick Hall out here in AZ - that's a guy, who although "not a baseball guy" absolutely owns his radio spots and does an incredible job at reaching out to the community ..... a big part of Samsons role and something he just doesn't give a crap about

they also reminded us that Nolasco and Stanton are pretty close, might've been one reason to keep him around. I can't think of any other reason.

 

 

Nolasco also had 12 wins last year and we're all about winning. I mean, JJ only had 8 as Samson said. Who's better? NOLASCO, bro.

Has anyone considered rickys feelings in all of this?

 

He has more wins or strikeouts than any of pitcher in Marlins history - has seen the players he came over with jettisoned - has seen this team work to remove pretty much any tradeable piece and then some .... yet no one wants to trade for him

 

I'm sure he's screaming at the wall - "why or why won't anyone trade for me ... what is wrong with me!!!"

LO f***ING L

"we had four guys in the rotation for 7 years and we tried to work with that. Johnson, Nolasco, Sanchez, and uh.... ..... I forgot"

 

Probably meant Volstad.

and by 7 years I'm counting the 4 games by johnson in 2007, the 14 in 2008 and the 9 in 2011

 

I'm also counting the 6, 10 & 16 game seasons for Sanchez between 07 and 09

 

nolasco only had 1 season where he didn't pitch much - but with his escalating WHIP, decreasing strikeouts and enormous contract we are going to make him the cornerstone pitcher - anyone remember 2009, opening day starter - beat the nats (look how good they are) 1-0 ........... 34,323 in attendance and the team won 87 games ........ that is what I'm talking about - ricky absolutely stays

 

my god - i never realized Volstad had 102 starts as a Marlin ........ yikes

I liked when Samson kept saying he trusts his baseball guys on this trade. That the prospects we got back have the right tools and project to be mlbers. But those same baseball guys have failed over and over again to build a team capable of competing. f***ing guy won't fire them.

 

Beinfest has been with Loria + Samson since day 1. he's obviously part of the big ol' money making scheme

I liked when Samson kept saying he trusts his baseball guys on this trade. That the prospects we got back have the right tools and project to be mlbers. But those same baseball guys have failed over and over again to build a team capable of competing. f***ing guy won't fire them.

 

Beinfest has been with Loria + Samson since day 1. he's obviously part of the big ol' money making scheme

 

Agreed. I especially dislike the justification of "These group of scouts were instrumental in winning the 2003 World Series". Yes, I have no doubt that they were a grand part of that. However, that doesn't mean they should be entitled to lifetime immunity from criticism if their recent moves don't pan out.

 

Think of it like a player. Let's say this player wins the World Series MVP but then has terrible season after terrible season. Would he still be around on the same club 9 years later? At a certain point, in the true interest of winning, ties will have to be severed.

  • Author

I liked when Samson kept saying he trusts his baseball guys on this trade. That the prospects we got back have the right tools and project to be mlbers. But those same baseball guys have failed over and over again to build a team capable of competing. f***ing guy won't fire them.

 

I just heard the replay of Samson on day 2 of 790. This continues the greatest problem for me. On some level I really can't blame the Marlins for blowing up the team, but it frustrates the hell out of me that the FO clearly made a ton of mistakes (mistakes that were obvious when they were being made) and yet they are not on the hot seat. Samson even admits that the organization made a bunch of errors and was "flat out wrong" and yet still says that he "trusts" his baseball people.

 

I think that Beinfest is butt buddies with Loria/Samson and that's all there is to it. They've been together since Montreal. Loria is clearly impulsive (he's blown up 2 cores of players now and fired 2 managers after only 1 season), but has never thought about making the rash move of blowing up his front office people.

 

If the Marlins completely purged their front office and "baseball people" and started from scratch, I would be pretty cool with this this Toronto trade and desire to hit the "reset" button on last offseason's signings.

  • Author

I liked when Samson kept saying he trusts his baseball guys on this trade. That the prospects we got back have the right tools and project to be mlbers. But those same baseball guys have failed over and over again to build a team capable of competing. f***ing guy won't fire them.

 

Beinfest has been with Loria + Samson since day 1. he's obviously part of the big ol' money making scheme

 

Agreed. I especially dislike the justification of "These group of scouts were instrumental in winning the 2003 World Series". Yes, I have no doubt that they were a grand part of that. However, that doesn't mean they should be entitled to lifetime immunity from criticism if their recent moves don't pan out.

 

Think of it like a player. Let's say this player wins the World Series MVP but then has terrible season after terrible season. Would he still be around on the same club 9 years later? At a certain point, in the true interest of winning, ties will have to be severed.Dombrowski's draft picks won 2003. And then Loria said f*** a duck.

If you look at the WAR share for the 2003 team, Dombrowski and Beinfest are pretty close to even. Beinfest deserves some credit for that, but I definitely think it's important to say that he's never built a playoff team entirely on his own terms.

 

I still think Beinfest is an average GM (not terrible), but for a team that makes bold decisions when it doesn't win, they need to replace him.

I think beinfest is somewhat at fault, but the entire scouting department needs to go.

 

Look at the cardinals and the other successful teams in the league and they are great year in and year out because they draft well. Our drafts are consistently terrible and our scouting of other players in trades isnt great either.

 

You can;t go 10 years with hermida/volstad as your best draft pick. you simply can not do that.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.