Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

School shooting in Conn

Featured Replies

Excuse my ignorance, but isn't Asbergers considered more of a learning disability instead of a mental illness?

It's a syndrome which in all entails social ineptitude, if you will. Mental illness, learning disability, whatever you want to call it. I'd call it a disability more than an illness though. People with Asperger's are not ill, just disabled. They can live in society just fine, it's just hard for them.

 

But I could see a side effect of it making someone ill for sure.

I can see it too- especially if someone like a family member insists on treating them differently like they are retarded and incapable of beig normal. Think bully or over caring parent.

 

I really don't want to read the facts on this but it's looking more and more like I might have to.

 

My ex girlfriend had a sister with Autism , but it seems like it might have been Asbergers. She would seem normal and do her schoolwork and play like a normal 12 or 13 year old but when you ask if she needs help or would she like a hand she would snap and get violent, even if she needed the help when she got stuck on say a math problem for an hour.

 

She's got to be a young adult now, I wonder how she's adjusted to life.

Its a disability but its tough for them to adjust to social life especially as adults because as children they are almost literally led by the hand in everything they do. Some then can't adjust to adulthood and being forced to do things on their own. It doesnt directly lead to violence but I can see how a more angry and troubled adult in this situation can use violence as a way to release their frustration. And a lot of times these troubled people are left alone, thinking they cant harm anyone. And they can.

Here is a thought. How about we stop trying to have perfect security. Prison cannot even provide perfect security.

Here is a thought. How about we stop trying to have perfect security. Prison cannot even provide perfect security.

There is no such thing as perfect security- only more.

 

The hope in any security force is their mere presence will dissuade intruders or attackers.

 

If they attack anyway, you can take them down as quickly as possible with the least amount of casualties.

Here is a thought. How about we stop trying to have perfect security. Prison cannot even provide perfect security.

Well the short term solution is more security. The long term solution is either gun banning or methods to bar certain individuals from having access to weaponry. I fear in a situation like this recent one, his mother legally had the weapons and no amount of stopping Adam Lanza from owning a gun will ever stop his mother from being insecure with her weaponry. Unless we start to search firearms like they're fire alarms (get it?) and make sure everything is up to code... but that's going a bit too far I'd say.

Was he mentally ill or was he mentally retarded?

 

All we know is that he was a jersey collector.Seriously, what the fuck is your problem?

  • Author

Here is a thought. How about we stop trying to have perfect security. Prison cannot even provide perfect security.

Well I don't know who said anything about perfect, but just because we can't stop everything doesn't mean it's pointless to make some efforts.

'Some efforts'?

 

We are groped at airports, strip off much of our clothing, and get x-ray'd.

 

The FBI checks us for mental health issues and crimes and then we have to wait 3-5 days to purchase a tool.

 

There are cops, in our schools, to "protect" our children from each other.

 

We have warning labels on hot beverages telling us the hot beverage might be hot.

 

The default position of law is very quickly becoming "if it is not expressly permitted, then it is banned"

  • Author

Well I'm not getting into the other stuff, but

 

The FBI checks us for mental health issues and crimes and then we have to wait 3-5 days to purchase a tool.

So... they shouldn't check for these things upon purchasing a gun? I dunno, I mean that sounds about right to me. You find that extreme?

What more do you want? The FBI checks out every buyer, and it does not eliminate this kind of event. It is because this kind of event cannot be eliminated. There will always be persons that either do not understand or do not care about the consequences, and all the law creates is consequences.

 

There have been tragedies. We have been asked to surrender freedoms to prevent them. There are further tragedies, and we are asked to surrender more freedoms. There will be even further tragedies and we will be asked to surrender even more freedoms.

 

Mass shootings are rare. The number of US deaths to such events is tiny. Less than lightning, less than dog attacks, less than bathtub drownings, less than dying from exposure to hot tap water, less than accidentally strangling yourself with your bedclothes.

 

It is a confirmation bias driven by the vividness of the example. People fear to fly, even though they are more likely to die travelling to the airport because air tragedies are horrifying and covered extensively, thus they remember it more vividly than auto accident reports.

There really isn't a realistic solution to prevent this kind of thing from happening. The problem lies mostly within the mental instability of certain individuals, but there really isn't much more we can do about that other than make sure people get the treatment they need. That isn't easy.

Treatment has become a problem since the almost total deinstitutionalization of the mentally ill which started in the early '60s and was largely complete by the '80s. It's the reason so many of the homeless wander around muttering to themselves.

 

Without the ability to commit the ill, "getting the treatment" they need isn't going to consistently happen, our experience over the last 40-50 years bears that out. Voluntary outpatient treatment too often winds up with the patient starting out taking the meds and later deciding that they're just fine and don't need them anymore, and things go downhill from there.

 

Unfortunately, commitment procedures aren't likely to change significantly. (I read that this kid found out that his mother was trying to have him committed, and that that may be what set him off.)

 

There is one thing that can help and that's allowing licensed concealed carry in "gun free" killing zones. The mere possibility that someone might be armed has a good possibility of changing the potential killer's calculus. If it doesn't, any armed opponent in the 5 to 20 minutes before the cops arrive has resulted in far fewer casualties in at least a half dozen instances, sometimes without firing a shot.

 

In most schools, there is probably at least one teacher/administrator/other employee who is licensed and trained and who would be willing to carry. No compulsion, no requirement, strictly voluntary. With a requirement that any weapon always remain on their body and concealed, removing the possibility that anyone else can get their mitts on it.

 

In this case, had there been one armed person ready to present some opposition when this kid shot his way into the school, the incident might have been ended before he got anywhere near any children.

  • 3 weeks later...
  • 2 months later...

Remember the discussion about teachers carrying guns in school----

 

Front page of today's herald says they either approved it or are about to vote on it. I didn't buy the paper, but saw it as I was walking out of CVS.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.