June 10, 201313 yr To me he looks like a utility infield but if he has to play every day I don't expect him to be better then 230 to 250 average with maybe 10 home runs but that is about all. He will probably go to the bench or 3 rd base when Solano comes back. He has a little more power then Solano but Solano is a better player overall especially when factor in the defense. ehe. Solano is awful defensively, cant hit, and has no power. Solano is a 0 tool player. As bad as the Marlins are, its a stretch to say that Solano even has enough talent to be a bench player on the worst team in 100 years. It was downright embarrassing that he was starting games for a major league team. He wouldnt even make the bench on the other 29 teams.What you say here is redicilous. Solano hit almost 300 last year and his average was on the rise when he went on the DL. He has way more range then Dietrich and softer hands to. Solano makes errors sometimes because he try's to get everything and touches more balls then most other players because he has good range. His arm is as strong as Dietrich maybe stronger the only thing he doesn't do as good is hit home runs and his batting average makes up for it he isn't here to put the ball over the wall. When he comes off the DL I see diteich going to the bench and maybe even triple a if his average doesn't improve by the time coghlan comes back from DL. Bad players come up and hit all the time...until other teams see them a time or two. Solano was arguably the worst player in baseball for the first 25 games of the year, with an OPS around .540, its hard not to have your average on the rise when you are that terrible. Despite what you think, he has no range, and he has stone hands. Solano was a bad player in minor league baseball. Against minor league pitching. He couldnt hit a lick. He got released by the St. Louis Cardinals as a minor leaguer, and at the time the Cardinals had among the weakest middle infield depth of any farm system in baseball(this was before the emergence of Kolton Wong and Carpenter was still a corner infielder). Solano is a terrible baseball player in every single way. I guess we will have to wait and see. I hope Beinfest does the right thing and allows him to start when he returns because Dietrich has not done enough to take the job from him. Except play better offensively and defensively....
June 10, 201313 yr I think both should share time depending on matchup. I would be ok with a platoon between them.
June 10, 201313 yr Not I. Dietrich needs all the at bats he can get. Solano has no future in major league baseball, all taking away at bats from Dietrich to give to Solano is stunting the development of a Dietrich, a player who actually has the talent and upside to play at the MLB level.
June 10, 201313 yr Not I. Dietrich needs all the at bats he can get. Solano has no future in major league baseball, all taking away at bats from Dietrich to give to Solano is stunting the development of a Dietrich, a player who actually has the talent and upside to play at the MLB level. We will let Beinfest and Redman decide. Hopefully they make the right choice. Solano is to valuable to sit on the bench and needs to be in the lineup every day.
June 10, 201313 yr We will let Beinfest and Redman decide. Hopefully they make the right choice. Solano is to valuable to sit on the bench and needs to be in the lineup every day. I don't think Mark Redman's opinion should really matter.
June 10, 201313 yr We will let Beinfest and Redman decide. Hopefully they make the right choice. Solano is to valuable to sit on the bench and needs to be in the lineup every day. I don't think Mark Redman's opinion should really matter.Sorry I meant Mike Redmond (the manager.) My bad.
June 10, 201313 yr Not I. Dietrich needs all the at bats he can get. Solano has no future in major league baseball, all taking away at bats from Dietrich to give to Solano is stunting the development of a Dietrich, a player who actually has the talent and upside to play at the MLB level. We will let Beinfest and Redman decide. Hopefully they make the right choice. Solano is to valuable to sit on the bench and needs to be in the lineup every day. How is he too valuable?? Ignoring the fact that Solano cant hit, and that Dietrich hits lefties better thus negating any reasoning for a platoon...Solano, up until the point he got injured, was one of the worst defensive 2B in the majors. Donovan Solano is the exact opposite of good. He is terrible. And taking at bats away from Dietrich to give to a bad player who has no future as a major league ballplayer is absurd.
June 10, 201313 yr We will let Beinfest and Redman decide. Hopefully they make the right choice. Solano is to valuable to sit on the bench and needs to be in the lineup every day. I don't think Mark Redman's opinion should really matter. I think we should get Redman's opinion on this issue.
June 10, 201313 yr 2013 Solano: .278 AVG | .286 wOBA | 78 wRC+ | -1.68 WPA/600 PA | -1.02 fWAR/600 PA | -0.0 rWAR/600 PA Dietrich: .229 AVG | .307 wOBA | 93 wRC+ | 0.92 WPA/600 PA | 0.51 fWAR/600 PA | 0.51 rWAR/600 PA DEFENSE Solano: 0.0 DPR | 1.1 RngR | -2.4 ErrR | -1.4 UZR | -6.8 UZR/150 | -0.1 dWAR (b-ref) Dietrich: -0.6 DPR | -2.5 RngR | 1.6 ErrR | -1.4 UZR | -5.2 UZR/150 | -0.2 dWAR (b-ref) Ironically, both have EXACTLY the same number of plate appearances this season (118)
June 10, 201313 yr 2013 Solano: .278 AVG | .286 wOBA | 78 wRC+ | -1.68 WPA/600 PA | -1.02 fWAR/600 PA | -0.0 rWAR/600 PA Dietrich: .229 AVG | .307 wOBA | 93 wRC+ | 0.92 WPA/600 PA | 0.51 fWAR/600 PA | 0.51 rWAR/600 PA DEFENSE Solano: 0.0 DPR | 1.1 RngR | -2.4 ErrR | -1.4 UZR | -6.8 UZR/150 | -0.1 dWAR (b-ref) Dietrich: -0.6 DPR | -2.5 RngR | 1.6 ErrR | -1.4 UZR | -5.2 UZR/150 | -0.2 dWAR (b-ref) Ironically, both have EXACTLY the same number of plate appearances this season (118) So what this means is Solano's average is meaningless and Dietrich is certainly the better hitter... Good to know.
June 10, 201313 yr Not I. Dietrich needs all the at bats he can get. Solano has no future in major league baseball, all taking away at bats from Dietrich to give to Solano is stunting the development of a Dietrich, a player who actually has the talent and upside to play at the MLB level. We will let Beinfest and Redman decide. Hopefully they make the right choice. Solano is to valuable to sit on the bench and needs to be in the lineup every day. Solano optioned to AAA. Good has triumphed over evil.
June 10, 201313 yr Solano optioned to AAA. Good has triumphed over evil. Maybe there is a God after all.
June 10, 201313 yr Solano optioned to AAA. Good has triumphed over evil. Maybe there is a God after all. Or more importantly, someone who actually knows about baseball in the marlins FO
June 10, 201313 yr Solano optioned to AAA. Good has triumphed over evil. Maybe there is a God after all. Or more importantly, someone who actually knows about baseball in the marlins FO I prefer the idea of there being an epic celestial battle between good, evil, God and pineapples about Donovan Solano. That's certainly more intriguing and interesting then watching the guy try and play Baseball. [twitter]@DonovanSolano17[/twitter] God knows why these things happen .. God is just and I will have something prepared!! You keep telling yourself that, mate.
June 10, 201313 yr 2013 Solano: .278 AVG | .286 wOBA | 78 wRC+ | -1.68 WPA/600 PA | -1.02 fWAR/600 PA | -0.0 rWAR/600 PA Dietrich: .229 AVG | .307 wOBA | 93 wRC+ | 0.92 WPA/600 PA | 0.51 fWAR/600 PA | 0.51 rWAR/600 PA DEFENSE Solano: 0.0 DPR | 1.1 RngR | -2.4 ErrR | -1.4 UZR | -6.8 UZR/150 | -0.1 dWAR (b-ref) Dietrich: -0.6 DPR | -2.5 RngR | 1.6 ErrR | -1.4 UZR | -5.2 UZR/150 | -0.2 dWAR (b-ref) Ironically, both have EXACTLY the same number of plate appearances this season (118) So what this means is Solano's average is meaningless and Dietrich is certainly the better hitter... Good to know.How can you say that when he is hitting 50 points higher. A 229 average in the MLB is not acceptable and that is the reason why Dietrich will go to the bench when Solano returns. Solano will end the year at 300 or higher and a couple of home runs that Dietrich might hit more then Solano doesn't make up for the low low low low low average. Batting average is still the most important statistic for a hitter and Solano is so much better then Dietrich in that department and it is not even close. It's no secret that I am very high on Solano I think he is going to be a great player for us or whatever team he goes to. I don't understand the hate that some people have for him. I know some of you are just as high on him as me but I don't get the few members that just don't like him for no reason atall. Sending him to aaa is not fair and its not what is best for the team. Definitely they made the wrong decision. God does have a plan for him and he will be back soon and the team will be better from it. Rediculois decision by the front office. They really dropped the ball by sending him to aaa if it is true.
June 10, 201313 yr Batting average is still the most important statistic for a hitter http://gagniernation13.blogspot.com/2011/05/is-batting-average-really-as-important.html Just one example that could be posted on why people disagree with this.
June 10, 201313 yr 2013 Solano: .278 AVG | .286 wOBA | 78 wRC+ | -1.68 WPA/600 PA | -1.02 fWAR/600 PA | -0.0 rWAR/600 PA Dietrich: .229 AVG | .307 wOBA | 93 wRC+ | 0.92 WPA/600 PA | 0.51 fWAR/600 PA | 0.51 rWAR/600 PA DEFENSE Solano: 0.0 DPR | 1.1 RngR | -2.4 ErrR | -1.4 UZR | -6.8 UZR/150 | -0.1 dWAR (b-ref) Dietrich: -0.6 DPR | -2.5 RngR | 1.6 ErrR | -1.4 UZR | -5.2 UZR/150 | -0.2 dWAR (b-ref) Ironically, both have EXACTLY the same number of plate appearances this season (118) So what this means is Solano's average is meaningless and Dietrich is certainly the better hitter... Good to know.How can you say that when he is hitting 50 points higher. A 229 average in the MLB is not acceptable and that is the reason why Dietrich will go to the bench when Solano returns. Solano will end the year at 300 or higher and a couple of home runs that Dietrich might hit more then Solano doesn't make up for the low low low low low average. Batting average is still the most important statistic for a hitter and Solano is so much better then Dietrich in that department and it is not even close. It's no secret that I am very high on Solano I think he is going to be a great player for us or whatever team he goes to. I don't understand the hate that some people have for him. I know some of you are just as high on him as me but I don't get the few members that just don't like him for no reason atall. Sending him to aaa is not fair and its not what is best for the team. Definitely they made the wrong decision. God does have a plan for him and he will be back soon and the team will be better from it. Rediculois decision by the front office. They really dropped the ball by sending him to aaa if it is true. I don't hate Solano nor have anything against him. He is not a MLB player and starting him with his .650 OPS ceiling over Dietrich is just stupid. The FO was 100% right in their decision.
June 10, 201313 yr Batting average is still the most important statistic for a hitter and Solano is so much better then Dietrich in that department and it is not even close. Can't this guy just go away already? Enough is enough.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.