Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Marlins trade/FA talk

Featured Replies

I have a feeling that no matter what the Marlins get for Morrison, it isn't going to be enough for most of the guys on this board. It seems that some of you guys think that Morrison has Stanton's value in the trade market. He just has not proven to be anything more than a very below average offensive player at either 1B or the OF.

What do you want for Morrison Wild Card? Mark Trumbo? LOL!

 

I think LoMo and a C arm could get Will Middlebrooks, and anything less than that caliber of player would make zero sense. I think Ben Francisco is worse than Derek Dietrich, and if we were to acquire him, we should just give it to the guy that's already here and under club control for a lot longer and playing for pennies.

Why would the Red Sox want Morrison? They just re-signed Napoli. So wake up because you're dreaming Wild Card.

How could you say that without seeing Dietrich play even half of a full season

 

Because he got progressively worse every month until he was sent to AAA. His homers is the only stat in which he did well, like so many of you like to point out with Francisco.

Well DD at least has a time to develop, he just turned 24 while Fransisco is turning 27. Also Fransisco is a career .234 hitter with only 32 HR's in 5 seasons (771 PA's) so he's clearly not a better option as of now.

How could you say that without seeing Dietrich play even half of a full season

 

Because he got progressively worse every month until he was sent to AAA. His homers is the only stat in which he did well, like so many of you like to point out with Francisco.

It was 215 ABs. There is nothing to discern from that few ABs at this point. He still struck out 11% less than Francisco

I have a feeling that no matter what the Marlins get for Morrison, it isn't going to be enough for most of the guys on this board. It seems that some of you guys think that Morrison has Stanton's value in the trade market. He just has not proven to be anything more than a very below average offensive player at either 1B or the OF.

You're exaggerating everything we say.

I bet if you asked the Marlins' scouts (who I trust a lot more than pencil pushing nerds in an office), they would take Francisco over Dietrich 10 out of 10 times.

The thing with Morrison is that you don't want to get lowballed for him on a year where he's finally %100 healthy going into Spring Training and has been a good player when healthy.

I bet if you asked the Marlins' scouts (who I trust a lot more than pencil pushing nerds in an office), they would take Francisco over Dietrich 10 out of 10 times.

 

LOL WUT

I have a feeling that no matter what the Marlins get for Morrison, it isn't going to be enough for most of the guys on this board. It seems that some of you guys think that Morrison has Stanton's value in the trade market. He just has not proven to be anything more than a very below average offensive player at either 1B or the OF.

You're exaggerating everything we say.

Maybe a little bit, just to prove my point. He has very limited trade value.

I bet if you asked the Marlins' scouts (who I trust a lot more than pencil pushing nerds in an office), they would take Francisco over Dietrich 10 out of 10 times.

 

Clearly not because they didn't make an attempt to sign him when he was DFA's last year

I bet if you asked the Marlins' scouts (who I trust a lot more than pencil pushing nerds in an office), they would take Francisco over Dietrich 10 out of 10 times.

 

LOL WUT

You heard me! LOL!

What do you want for Morrison Wild Card? Mark Trumbo? LOL!

 

I think LoMo and a C arm could get Will Middlebrooks, and anything less than that caliber of player would make zero sense. I think Ben Francisco is worse than Derek Dietrich, and if we were to acquire him, we should just give it to the guy that's already here and under club control for a lot longer and playing for pennies.

Why would the Red Sox want Morrison? They just re-signed Napoli. So wake up because you're dreaming Wild Card.

I edited my post. That is an example of the kind of value I believe LoMo has, obviously that trade would no longer make sense UNLESS a third team got involved. If the Sox re-sign Drew, the Marlins could ship LoMo to a third destination, the Sox send Middlebrooks here, and another team ships something to Boston. That could absolutely happen.

I bet if you asked the Marlins' scouts (who I trust a lot more than pencil pushing nerds in an office), they would take Francisco over Dietrich 10 out of 10 times.

 

Clearly not because they didn't make an attempt to sign him when he was DFA's last year

They should have tried.

I bet if you asked the Marlins' scouts (who I trust a lot more than pencil pushing nerds in an office), they would take Francisco over Dietrich 10 out of 10 times.

 

Clearly not because they didn't make an attempt to sign him when he was DFA's last year

They should have tried.

I actually won't disagree with this, they should have tried to get him and maybe they did. But getting him FOR FREE and getting him for LoMo are two VERY different scenarios buddy.

What do you want for Morrison Wild Card? Mark Trumbo? LOL!

 

I think LoMo and a C arm could get Will Middlebrooks, and anything less than that caliber of player would make zero sense. I think Ben Francisco is worse than Derek Dietrich, and if we were to acquire him, we should just give it to the guy that's already here and under club control for a lot longer and playing for pennies.

Why would the Red Sox want Morrison? They just re-signed Napoli. So wake up because you're dreaming Wild Card.

I edited my post. That is an example of the kind of value I believe LoMo has, obviously that trade would no longer make sense UNLESS a third team got involved. If the Sox re-sign Drew, the Marlins could ship LoMo to a third destination, the Sox send Middlebrooks here, and another team ships something to Boston. That could absolutely happen.

That could happen. I do like Middlebrooks a lot more than Francisco. To me, the Marlins just want to unload Morrison for whatever they can get. I don't think that's too smart, but free agency is flooded with 1B and that doesn't even take into consideration better players than Morrison (like Mark Trumbo) are available.

I bet if you asked the Marlins' scouts (who I trust a lot more than pencil pushing nerds in an office), they would take Francisco over Dietrich 10 out of 10 times.

 

Clearly not because they didn't make an attempt to sign him when he was DFA's last year

They should have tried.

I actually won't disagree with this, they should have tried to get him and maybe they did. But getting him FOR FREE and getting him for LoMo are two VERY different scenarios buddy.

By the way, I never said I would make that deal straight up. I would want a little bit more from the Brewers.

By the way, I never said I would make that deal straight up. I would want a little bit more from the Brewers.

I'm confused though. If us "pencil pushing nerds" are wrong about LoMo being better than Francisco, why would the Brewers send more with Francisco for LoMo?

Wouldn't any astute GM try to get as much as he can? I think Morrison is no better than Jeremy Hermida, so why not take advantage of the situation, if possible. Morrison is younger, which is what I would try to push.

What do you want for Morrison Wild Card? Mark Trumbo? LOL!

 

I think LoMo and a C arm could get Will Middlebrooks, and anything less than that caliber of player would make zero sense. I think Ben Francisco is worse than Derek Dietrich, and if we were to acquire him, we should just give it to the guy that's already here and under club control for a lot longer and playing for pennies.

Why would the Red Sox want Morrison? They just re-signed Napoli. So wake up because you're dreaming Wild Card.

I edited my post. That is an example of the kind of value I believe LoMo has, obviously that trade would no longer make sense UNLESS a third team got involved. If the Sox re-sign Drew, the Marlins could ship LoMo to a third destination, the Sox send Middlebrooks here, and another team ships something to Boston. That could absolutely happen.

That could happen. I do like Middlebrooks a lot more than Francisco. To me, the Marlins just want to unload Morrison for whatever they can get. I don't think that's too smart, but free agency is flooded with 1B and that doesn't even take into consideration better players than Morrison (like Mark Trumbo) are available.

The market is flooded with 1B that nobody wants. LoMo is a commodity.

 

I personally think his value has to be higher than most of us are assuming, other teams AND the Marlins are not blind to the situation or the stats or the projections. Clearly LoMo is better suited for a new home (numbers wise) and he has more value to another team than he does to us for that reason. But you cannot forget this is a guy that has produced when healthy, when he was less experienced, when he was playing out of position. He has THREE YEARS of club control left going into his prime. This guy has value.

Whatever the new GM does, I'm going to give him the benefit of the doubt until he's proven or not proven himself. I like the moves he has made so far this year. At least he isn't going to trade Morrison for a bag of garbage like the Marlins did when they traded Miguel Cabrera. Trading Morrison isn't a money move, it's because he has shown no improvement.

What do you want for Morrison Wild Card? Mark Trumbo? LOL!

 

I think LoMo and a C arm could get Will Middlebrooks, and anything less than that caliber of player would make zero sense. I think Ben Francisco is worse than Derek Dietrich, and if we were to acquire him, we should just give it to the guy that's already here and under club control for a lot longer and playing for pennies.

Why would the Red Sox want Morrison? They just re-signed Napoli. So wake up because you're dreaming Wild Card.

I edited my post. That is an example of the kind of value I believe LoMo has, obviously that trade would no longer make sense UNLESS a third team got involved. If the Sox re-sign Drew, the Marlins could ship LoMo to a third destination, the Sox send Middlebrooks here, and another team ships something to Boston. That could absolutely happen.

That could happen. I do like Middlebrooks a lot more than Francisco. To me, the Marlins just want to unload Morrison for whatever they can get. I don't think that's too smart, but free agency is flooded with 1B and that doesn't even take into consideration better players than Morrison (like Mark Trumbo) are available.

The market is flooded with 1B that nobody wants. LoMo is a commodity.

 

I personally think his value has to be higher than most of us are assuming, other teams AND the Marlins are not blind to the situation or the stats or the projections. Clearly LoMo is better suited for a new home (numbers wise) and he has more value to another team than he does to us for that reason. But you cannot forget this is a guy that has produced when healthy, when he was less experienced, when he was playing out of position. He has THREE YEARS of club control left going into his prime. This guy has value.

So what is his value? If I'm another GM and tell you that I could just sign Kendry Morales or Corey Hart for just money. How would you convince me to give you something of real value for Morrison. When push comes to shove, he is a .249 career hitter with a .764 OPS and those are weak numbers for a 1B.

Joe Frisaro @JoeFrisaro

In their third base search, #Marlins have had internal talks about #Rays Sean Rodriguez joefrisaro.mlblogs.com

Joe Frisaro @JoeFrisaro

In their third base search, #Marlins have had internal talks about #Rays Sean Rodriguez joefrisaro.mlblogs.com

 

NO!!!!! Don't do that! You stat heads can't like that.

Joe Frisaro @JoeFrisaro

In their third base search, #Marlins have had internal talks about #Rays Sean Rodriguez joefrisaro.mlblogs.com

 

slim pickins out there. At least he can play D. I'd take him over Francisco in a heartbeat

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.