Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Marlins trade/FA talk

Featured Replies

please god i hope TB isn't interested. That would mean we made a huge mistake in giving up on lomo.

 

He's exactly the kind of player they WOULD be interested in, too. I already think we're probably making a mistake dealing LoMo, but whatever, not my team. Just get Middlebrooks and I'm cool with it.

Morrison for Middlebrooks would be a good trade for both teams.

If Boston wants Lomo Will Middlebrooks and another player would work

 

No. If the Marlins want Middlebrooks, LoMo and another player would work. LoMo's value is lower than Middlebrooks.

If Boston wants Lomo Will Middlebrooks and another player would work

 

No. If the Marlins want Middlebrooks, LoMo and another player would work. LoMo's value is lower than Middlebrooks.

No problem. Give them a minor league player too, just not a top prospect.

If Boston wants Lomo Will Middlebrooks and another player would work

 

No. If the Marlins want Middlebrooks, LoMo and another player would work. LoMo's value is lower than Middlebrooks.

No problem. Give them a minor league player too, just not a top prospect.

I think a mid-level arm would suffice. I wouldn't give up anything better than DeSclafani or Urena.

Jones has been worth 1.5 WAR over the last 2 seasons, if you average fWAR and rWAR. An $7.5M deal is reasonable for that production, if he can replicate it. I do hate to trade away Morrison at such a low value, though. And the Marlins maybe can't afford to pay market rate for wins, as they don't have a big enough budget.

 

Just because Jones was non-tendered, that doesn't mean that he sucks. He just wasn't worth the $5M projected arbitration salary, in the Piractes' opinion. Whether he sucks is a somewhat separate question.

 

I do like the flexibility this deal gives. Jones is a player who can play multiple positions -- even if he's not much of a fielder -- which allows them to see what come of a Morrison trade and/or the development of guys like Ozuna, Dietrich, Marisnick.

In what bizarre world is Gerett Jones an improvement over Morrison, The Marlins have more than enough outfielders all better defensivelyWhere did I say that he's an improvement over Morrison [in a vacuum]?

The perfect platoon partner at 1B for Garrett Jones would be Jeff Baker. Baker would be in the Marlins' price range and he destroys lefty pitching!

If Boston wants Lomo Will Middlebrooks and another player would work

 

No. If the Marlins want Middlebrooks, LoMo and another player would work. LoMo's value is lower than Middlebrooks.

No problem. Give them a minor league player too, just not a top prospect.

I think a mid-level arm would suffice. I wouldn't give up anything better than DeSclafani or Urena.

I think that's an overpay for Middlebrooks.

The perfect platoon partner at 1B for Garrett Jones would be Jeff Baker. Baker would be in the Marlins' price range and he destroys lefty pitching!

That would be a good move. Let's hope the FO is thinking along those lines.

The perfect platoon partner at 1B for Garrett Jones would be Jeff Baker. Baker would be in the Marlins' price range and he destroys lefty pitching!

Why not Mark Canha, like I mentioned earlier? Also plays first base and OPSed over .900 against lefties in AA. Would come much cheaper.

If the Marlins could somehow trade LoMo+ for Garin Cecchini, I would be ecstatic. That would make all of this worth it. That kid's something to get excited about.

The perfect platoon partner at 1B for Garrett Jones would be Jeff Baker. Baker would be in the Marlins' price range and he destroys lefty pitching!

Why not Mark Canha, like I mentioned earlier? Also plays first base and OPSed over .900 against lefties in AA. Would come much cheaper.

Major league pitching is a lot better than AA pitching. Baker puts up numbers like that against major league pitching.

I'm still holding out hope that Ken Rosenthal made some spelling error and instead of writing Garrett he meant to say Chipper.

The perfect platoon partner at 1B for Garrett Jones would be Jeff Baker. Baker would be in the Marlins' price range and he destroys lefty pitching!

Why not Mark Canha, like I mentioned earlier? Also plays first base and OPSed over .900 against lefties in AA. Would come much cheaper.

Major league pitching is a lot better than AA pitching. Baker puts up numbers like that against major league pitching.I know this. But he's been consistent as a hitter down in the minors, and he's 24 now, so why not give him a shot?

The perfect platoon partner at 1B for Garrett Jones would be Jeff Baker. Baker would be in the Marlins' price range and he destroys lefty pitching!

Why not Mark Canha, like I mentioned earlier? Also plays first base and OPSed over .900 against lefties in AA. Would come much cheaper.

Major league pitching is a lot better than AA pitching. Baker puts up numbers like that against major league pitching.I know this. But he's been consistent as a hitter down in the minors, and he's 24 now, so why not give him a shot?

I'd also be open to Kyle Jensen as I've mentioned before...

 

Nvm, for a right handed power hitter, he doesn't hit lefties. Weird...

The perfect platoon partner at 1B for Garrett Jones would be Jeff Baker. Baker would be in the Marlins' price range and he destroys lefty pitching!

Why not Mark Canha, like I mentioned earlier? Also plays first base and OPSed over .900 against lefties in AA. Would come much cheaper.

Major league pitching is a lot better than AA pitching. Baker puts up numbers like that against major league pitching.I know this. But he's been consistent as a hitter down in the minors, and he's 24 now, so why not give him a shot?

I'd also be open to Kyle Jensen as I've mentioned before...

 

Nvm, for a right handed power hitter, he doesn't hit lefties. Weird...

If he can't hit lefties, he would not be a good platoon partner for Jones.

The perfect platoon partner at 1B for Garrett Jones would be Jeff Baker. Baker would be in the Marlins' price range and he destroys lefty pitching!

Why not Mark Canha, like I mentioned earlier? Also plays first base and OPSed over .900 against lefties in AA. Would come much cheaper.

Major league pitching is a lot better than AA pitching. Baker puts up numbers like that against major league pitching.I know this. But he's been consistent as a hitter down in the minors, and he's 24 now, so why not give him a shot?

Because Baker is a sure thing. He rips lefty pitching.

Guys...Ed Lucas is OPS'ing over .880 against LHP in both his minor league and major league career. Platoon him at 1B or do it at 3B, but Ed Lucas should DEFINITELY be starting against any and all lefty pitchers next season.

 

And BenderRobot, the Marlins didn't protect Mark Canha in the Rule 5 Draft, so he'll either go to another team or be stashed back into the minor league system for next season.

If the Marlins could somehow trade LoMo+ for Garin Cecchini, I would be ecstatic. That would make all of this worth it. That kid's something to get excited about.

 

Red Sox said they're not trading prospects (and specifically mentioned Cecchini.

 

Plus, it would take more than Morrison to get Cecchini. The Sox would want a major league starting pitcher in return for a good prospect like Cecchini if they even were considering trading him.

Guys...Ed Lucas is OPS'ing over .880 against LHP in both his minor league and major league career. Platoon him at 1B or do it at 3B, but Ed Lucas should DEFINITELY be starting against any and all lefty pitchers next season.

 

And BenderRobot, the Marlins didn't protect Mark Canha in the Rule 5 Draft, so he'll either go to another team or be stashed back into the minor league system for next season.

Isn't this old news?

Lucas or Canha? I just mentioned Canha because the Marlins not protecting him shows they don't see Canha as having any real future with the team.

If the Marlins could somehow trade LoMo+ for Garin Cecchini, I would be ecstatic. That would make all of this worth it. That kid's something to get excited about.

 

Red Sox said they're not trading prospects (and specifically mentioned Cecchini.

 

Plus, it would take more than Morrison to get Cecchini. The Sox would want a major league starting pitcher in return for a good prospect like Cecchini if they even were considering trading him.

Hence the 'LoMo+'

 

Either way, they signed Napoli so there's no chance now.

Well the + in that scenario is more important than the LoMo. So it would be something like "Eovaldi or Henderson Alvarez+"

I didn't know that about Lucas. I really hope that that's the Marlins plan. It could definitely work out short-term.

Well the + in that scenario is more important than the LoMo. So it would be something like "Eovaldi or Henderson Alvarez+"

 

LoMo was the topic of the discussion. I'm aware of LoMo's value.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.