Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

9/5 Postgame

Featured Replies

  • Author
Omg the hindsight on this board is hilarious. Not everyone. But a lot. It's hilarious how great we supposedly were in June but now everyone swears they knew this shit was coming all season long.

 

I did.  And if you checked the posts you'd see I am on record for saying so.

 

Both were idiotic trades based on expected performance. Of course, we didn't get that. But you can't say in hindsight they were bad trades. Because anyone with half a brain who understands baseball could see they were stupid trades.

 

 

  • Author
Because anyone with half a brain who understands baseball could see they were stupid trades.

 

Good way to debate, insult people who disagree with you.

 

I was fine with the Rodney trade so I guess I only have half a brain at most and I don't understand baseball guys.

 

 

  • Author
Good way to debate, insult people who disagree with you.

 

It's more or less what you yourself did after the Rodney trade.  You insulted Polly and others who thought the Rodney trade was stupid.

 

 

  • Author
It's more or less what you yourself did after the Rodney trade.  You insulted Polly and others who thought the Rodney trade was stupid.

 

No I didn't.

 

Did I insult you that day [uSER=5078]@pollyvonwog[/uSER]?

 

Did I insult you that day [uSER=860]@el penguino[/uSER]?

 

I liked the trade, they didn't but I did not insult them. I don't stoop to your level.

 

 

I did.  And if you checked the posts you'd see I am on record for saying so.

Oh that's right. You did. I do remember you saying things like you wouldn't make those trades and other related things because we were bound to fail anyways, even though we had held wild card spots back when that happened. You'd make an amazing GM... either that or an amazing fortune teller.
  • Author
Oh that's right. You did. I do remember you saying things like you wouldn't make those trades and other related things because we were bound to fail anyways, even though we had held wild card spots back when that happened. You'd make an amazing GM... either that or an amazing fortune teller.

 

I've been saying for years that we are bound to fail with Loria as the owner. This is true.  

 

He has angered the baseball gods and we will all feel their wrath.  

 

 

  • Author
I think you love polly more than he loves himself.

 

Sadly, I love the Marlins more. I'm like you with Alison Brie.  We both know we have no shot at happiness but continue to waste valuable energy pursuing something that will never ever happen.

 

Actually, you might have more of a shot at Brie than the Marlins have at winning another title under Loria. 

 

 

For what it's worth, it might not seem like it because I haven't been annoying about it, but I hated the Cashner deal when it happened. 

 

I didn't think Rodney would be this bad and I was fine with that deal. 

 

 

  • Author
For what it's worth, it might not seem like it because I haven't been annoying about it, but I hated the Cashner deal when it happened. 

 

I didn't think Rodney would be this bad and I was fine with that deal. 

 

You and I are so alike. Whether its failures with women or Marlins trades.

 

 

Look I know it's easy to hate because we gave up too much for a questionable rental and because he has done virtually nothing for us but how would you all feel if Cashner had come through and helped us hold a wild card spot in mid September? I feel like too many are ripping on the trade mostly because of the results. Then again this is tough to call because what we gave up is so bad that it's so easy to hate the trade regardless.

 

 

Cashner Thread: 

 

 

 

 

 

Fernando Rodney Thread:

 

 

 

 

 

Didn't get to write about Paddack when the trade occurred but I've talked about him previously. He was putting together an incredible four of five start stretch where he looked like a superstar. The videos I'd seen of him pitching made him look like a top prospect, but he wasn't there yet in terms of longevity. 

 

In terms of where Rodney was at the time, Paddack actually was a good price, possibly even a low value for a player who was an All Star this year. People on the board seemed upset with the trade because it was apparent we traded for a guy at his peak value and a heavy decline was inevitable. In terms of pure value at the time of the trade, Paddack for Rodney made sense. Thinking long term, Paddack had big potential value and Rodney was due for regression. 

 

The discussion is a bit funny since Paddack is now getting TJ surgery and may be out at least half of next season. He likely won't make the majors until he's in his late twenties, serving him useless until the core team (Stanton/Fernandez/Ozuna) are traded and gone anyway.

 

Team went for the win this season. Was Rodney the right decision? No. But the idea was correct. Just execution was flawed. 

 

 

And trust me I loved Paddack. Couldn't stop raving about him this season. But he has no major league value for another three years. He's much more valuable to a team like the Padres, who are planning a long term rebuild, than a Marlins squad that went all in for 2015/2016 and will have to re-prioritize things going into next season. 

 

 

  • Author

One of the reasons why I despised the Rodney trade when it happened was because I thought that Paddack was one of the only intriguing trade pieces that the Marlins had and I thought that they needed a starting pitcher before they needed a 39 year old reliever with a volatile past.

 

So I don't think that the "idea" was correct, either, necessarily.

 

 

One of the reasons why I despised the Rodney trade when it happened was because I thought that Paddack was one of the only intriguing trade pieces that the Marlins had and I thought that they needed a starting pitcher before they needed a 39 year old reliever with a volatile past.

 

So I don't think that the "idea" was correct, either, necessarily.

 

The idea was to go for the win this season. The farm system was flawed enough that this was the year. And a closer putting up pre All Star break Rodney numbers would have the Marlins over .500 right now. 

 

Again, thought process was correct, like many of the trades and signings the Marlins have made since 2014, but all those ideas have been put in the hands of people who can't make the RIGHT decisions. 

 

 

You and I are so alike. Whether its failures with women or Marlins trades.

 

<3

 

 

  • Author
The idea was to go for the win this season. The farm system was flawed enough that this was the year. And a closer putting up pre All Star break Rodney numbers would have the Marlins over .500 right now. 

 

Again, thought process was correct, like many of the trades and signings the Marlins have made since 2014, but all those ideas have been put in the hands of people who can't make the RIGHT decisions. 

 

At that point in the season I wasn't opposed to "going for it" but I strongly disagree that acquiring Rodney was going to do much to improve the Marlins competitiveness. It was pretty obvious that his Padres numbers weren't going to be sustainable.

 

Basically that trade just limited their options when they actually did make an effort to get a SP. The thought process was totally wrong because they were trading away one of their most valuable trade pieces by buying high for a volatile reliever whose regression was inevitable. 

 

 

Thus why I said the idea was greater than the execution. The front office knew the closing window and saw a resource available in Rodney. They went for a trade that a team that isn't competing wouldn't think of doing. 

 

I also argue against Paddack being our top trade chip. He was good, but he was 20 years old in low A ball with 6 starts. Paddack was also an 8th round pick, so it isn't like he started out with 1st round value. I'm actually surprised at the time of the trade that Paddack alone was able to net Rodney in an All Star year. But then again the Padres knew Paddack probably had long term value.

 

Then again, they didn't account for his hard throwing inevitably leading to arm problems and TJ surgery. 

 

Like I said, bitch about this trade all you want but it doesn't make a difference now. Paddack won't pitch again until likely 2018 and won't see the majors until 2020 at the earliest. More likely 2021. Does this front office even have a plan for 2021? Are we even sure this front office will be around to see 2021 if they didn't win this season? 

 

I followed Paddack's short minor league career more than most here, and I think he has a bright future, but the trade wasn't bad at the time for what Paddack was at the time of the trade and what Rodney was at the time of the trade. And now with Paddack injured, both the Marlins and the Padres suffered from making that trade. There are no winners here and isn't worth complaining about. We didn't lose it because Paddack's value diminished (similarly to how Domingo German's value died after we traded him to the Yankees and he hurt his arm). Based on NOW value, it's a net gain of zero and a net loss of zero.

 

Cashner is one worth complaining about more given the fact that Naylor and Capps will be playing next season. Plus the way this board talks about Capps you would think he saved 50 games this season and had an ERA under 1. He's a greatly talented player with a unique delivery that lends itself to arm problems and inconsistencies. He's great value for a team but also an incredible risk. That said I didn't like the trade.

 

 

Before opening this season, I couldn't imagine our roster is not enough to manage just 1 season long. I said again, all these disaster caused by OP prez Mike Hill. He must be fired. 

 

 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.