Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

2017 Winter Meetings Thread

Featured Replies

Chen on the other hand did not have surgery.  But nobody will touch him now anyway.  The dream scenario with him would be a miracle first have that stirs up some interest at the deadline but in no way is that ever happening.  He feels like the classic example of someone who should have had surgery but didn’t and will end up having it this coming summer anyway.

 

No reason to sweat the guys on one year. Prado is an interesting case which could make for some interesting banter and number crunching.  Freaking Chen though….that was is a real kick in the groin.

 

 

This is probably misguided but I’m getting a little excited about what a return on Ozuna from St. Louis could look like.

 

 

This is probably misguided but I’m getting a little excited about what a return on Ozuna from St. Louis could look like.

 

not just STL.  Any team we deal him to we are going to get a really nice boost to our farm system.  After that trade and then Straily after him, we should have a really good farm system for the first season of a rebuild.  If we start to invest in the draft and IFA, look out.  Go look at the cubs and astros farm systems from their first years, it was nonexistent.  in that way we have a heads up on most rebuilding teams.

 

 

not just STL.  Any team we deal him to we are going to get a really nice boost to our farm system.  After that trade and then Straily after him, we should have a really good farm system for the first season of a rebuild.  If we start to invest in the draft and IFA, look out.  Go look at the cubs and astros farm systems from their first years, it was nonexistent.  in that way we have a heads up on most rebuilding teams.

 

Oh absolutely!  Fangraphs had Houston dead last during the winter when Luhnow was hired.  Difference though is that they hired Jeff Luhnow to run the rebuild, whereas we have Jeets and Michael Hill.  Fingers crossed guys!  Look at the Dave Cameron write up from 2011

 

https://www.fangraphs.com/blogs/2011-organizational-rankings-30-housto/

 

Theo went to Chicago that same year.  The Cubs were middle of the pack at 19

 

https://www.fangraphs.com/blogs/2011-organizational-rankings-19-chicago-cubs/

 

FWIW we were # 27.  Not that these rankings are official or anything but they are an interesting way to get an idea of where teams stand.

 

 

Look at this line from the Astros write-up

 

" For instance, they’re paying Roy Oswalt $7 million this year to pitch for the Phillies, and Carlos Lee is earning $19 million in the hopes that he might return to being an average player. That’s $26 million that is basically wasted money off their 2011 payroll, so their actual amount of money to build value with is smaller than it might appear on the surface."

 

In case anyone needs reminding the Marlins traded for Carlos Lee that year (granted Houston paid almost his entire salary) but still.  Furthermore the Marlins then tried to unload him before the deadline. 

 

 

Oh absolutely!  Fangraphs had Houston dead last during the winter when Luhnow was hired.  Difference though is that they hired Jeff Luhnow to run the rebuild, whereas we have Jeets and Michael Hill.  Fingers crossed guys!  Look at the Dave Cameron write up from 2011

 

https://www.fangraphs.com/blogs/2011-organizational-rankings-30-housto/

 

Theo went to Chicago that same year.  The Cubs were middle of the pack at 19

 

https://www.fangraphs.com/blogs/2011-organizational-rankings-19-chicago-cubs/

 

FWIW we were # 27.  Not that these rankings are official or anything but they are an interesting way to get an idea of where teams stand.

 

That's why i think all the talk of not getting enough for Stanton is a little misguided.  anything we get for any of these guys is a great head start on a rebuild.  The majority of our work should come over the next 2-3 years via the draft and hopefully IFA.  Anything on top of that is icing on the cake.  That is why my overall timeline is probably a lot faster than most, with the condition that its all about whether we spend on IFA and the draft.  

 

The astros and cubs had almost nothing in their system at the time they started their rebuild and they didnt have all these Ozuna, Yelich, and Straily type assets to trade to kick off their rebuild.  That's why i think we are in better shape than most people realize. 

 

But again, this is literally ALL conditioned on the fact that we need to spend in the draft and IFA.  not doing that makes the rebuild pointless and mroe of the same and will lead me to flip 100% in my optimistic look towards Jeter and the new ownership group.

 

 

While I do share in your optimism I’m a little guarded in light of the debt issue on the balance sheet which seems to be a major priority. Jim Crane “only” spent $610 million on the Astros.

 

 

While I do share in your optimism I’m a little guarded in light of the debt issue on the balance sheet which seems to be a major priority. Jim Crane “only” spent $610 million on the Astros.

 

What a bargain!

 

 

 

 

This is interesting. Marlins might be shooting themselves in the foot by pushing Ozuna before Yelich. 

 

Hi guys!  Been a while since I last posted but I tend to disagree that they would be shooting themselves in the foot here.  Wouldn't it make sense to publicly state that you want to move Ozuna and feign lack of desire to deal Yelich in hopes that some team goes over the top and offers the moon for Yelich? Then the "consolation" prize of Ozuna is there to still get a boatload for.  Just a thought but its good to be back.

 

 

Plus may I add he is the type of player I would like to see go down as a Marlins lifer.

 

I sympathize with that wish but his value is precisely what will being the necessary pieces to restock the system which is so depleted right now. Unfortunately.  

 

 

Why would they trade Yelich or Ozuna for that matter (this year)

 

Keeping Ozuna makes zero sense. You said it yourself, they have nothing in the system. To speed up the rebuild, we need good prospects and he will bring them. He's gone after 2019 anyway and his value may never be higher than it is right now. We won't win with him or without him in 2018.

 

 

  • Author

Trading both Ozuna and Yelich now speeds up the rebuild that many of you don't want. If you hated the Stanton trade and are furious that Jeter wants to rebuild, ironically you should be seriously rooting for Ozuna and Yelich to go too because that's pretty much the closest thing to a "shortcut " to contention. 

 

 

Baseball, sports is about competing, right now, every time you step on the field. Not about making money or planning 10 years in the future. Jeter hould know that. As you all well know, most of these prospects turn out to be duds. Even No. 1 drafted players. You have to build on what you have and as time goes on.

 

you show a fundamental lack of knowledge on the way just about every team is choosing to rebuild in modern baseball and sports in general for that matter.

 

 

  • Author
Baseball, sports is about competing, right now, every time you step on the field. Not about making money or planning 10 years in the future. Jeter hould know that. As you all well know, most of these prospects turn out to be duds. Even No. 1 drafted players. You have to build on what you have and as time goes on.

 

Well that's stupid and short sighted. Teams should look at themselves realistically and if they can't contend "right now" then yes they should plan for the future of else you'll continue to not contend year after year. The Marlins have been a perfect example of that for the last 14 years. 

 

And as for most prospects turning out to be duds? Yes that's correct which is why the method is stockpiling as many potentially good prospects as possible so that you have enough that are a success and then compliment them with signings and trades when the time is right. 

 

The strategy itself is more basic and simple than people realize. 

 

 

One all star player is worth 10 top level prospects.  The latter are like Lotto tickets. The former is money in the bank.

 

And the former is completely useless on a team that has zero chance of competing in the next 2 years. He'll leave as a free agent after 2019 and we will have nothing to show for it.

 

 

One all star player is worth 10 top level prospects.  The latter are like Lotto tickets. The former is money in the bank.

 

1) No its not.

 

2) You seem to not understand the salary ramifications for people with 6+ years of MLB service time and how that bloated salary in turn affects your way to spend in other areas.

 

3) Cheap cost controlled good talent is better than expensive borderline all star players.

 

 

The stupid ones are those watching AAA baseball next season and looking to the rosy future.

 

as opposed to the 8 straight years of under .500 baseball we've just watched and the 14 straight years of playoffless baseball that we've just watched?

 

 

For anyone wanting to hold onto one player look no further than Mike Trout.  The Angels organization is nothing without him and it shows.  If a club with loads of money can’t compete with the best player in the world right now what makes you think the marlins will be able to if they hold on a guy who is good but he’s not mike trout 

 

 

Baseball, sports is about competing, right now, every time you step on the field. Not about making money or planning 10 years in the future. Jeter hould know that. As you all well know, most of these prospects turn out to be duds. Even No. 1 drafted players. You have to build on what you have and as time goes on.

 

Professional sports are about making money.  Sorry to destroy anyone's rose colored glasses but it is the truth.

 

 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.