Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

2017 Winter Meetings Thread

Featured Replies

Not sure why anyone would want to trade Yelich over Ozuna if you were given the option to keep one, but maybe I'm just misunderstanding what some people in this thread have said.

 

Yeah definitely would prefer to keep Yelich over Ozuna but I'm ok with trading both if some team offers a shitload for Yelich. Ozuna HAS to go.

 

 

Not sure why anyone would want to trade Yelich over Ozuna if you were given the option to keep one, but maybe I'm just misunderstanding what some people in this thread have said.

 

I think people are saying to trade both. 

 

 

  • Author
Yeah definitely would prefer to keep Yelich over Ozuna but I'm ok with trading both if some team offers a shitload for Yelich. Ozuna HAS to go.

 

Yea this. Ozuna must go because he won't be here whenever we contend but if we can rob a team for Yelich now (arguably not even a robbery because Yelich is so good) then I say do it too. But I wouldn't wanna trade Yelich and keep Ozuna. That's backwards thinking and I think the Marlins are thinking the same way. 

 

 

I’ve been on the trade everyone wagon but MarlinsLou makes a very strong case.  Mattingly draws an Altuve comp for Yelich, which is also interesting but Altuve was a 21 year old rookie when the Astros started their tear down.  Yelich is further along on the curve.  Also I’m not excited about the pitching depth on the farm either so maybe I think there is more work to be done than MarlinsLou thinks.

 

 

If your plan is to be competitive in 3 years, you keep Yelich.

 

He's a sure thing. 

 

Not saying i agree one way or the other but what if the only way you are competitive in 3 years is to deal him?  I think this is the question the FO is asking themselves.

 

 

  • Author
If your plan is to be competitive in 3 years, you keep Yelich.

 

He's a sure thing. 

 

 

 

Not saying i agree one way or the other but what if the only way you are competitive in 3 years is to deal him?  I think this is the question the FO is asking themselves.

 

This is the thing with Yelich. It's a fair argument on both sides of the equation. Keep him to be the centerpiece of the rebuild... or trade him and maybe even "complete" the rebuild even sooner. 

 

 

The Cardinals and Marlins are “making progress” on a deal that would send outfielder Marcell Ozuna to St. Louis, according to Ken Rosenthal of The Athletic (via Twitter). These organizations have been tied in chatter of one kind or another for much of the offseason.

 

We heard yesterday that the Cards were the favorites to land Ozuna. As of that time, though, there were multiple other suitors reportedly still involved and the Cardinals were also eyeing fellow Miami outfielder Christian Yelich.

 

It is still unclear just how things might come together, but there are quite a number of possible ways the sides could line up. The Cardinals have a host of young outfielders, potentially offering Miami a direct replacement with greater future contract control, along with the sort of youthful pitching that the Marlins covet.

 

As for Ozuna, he’d be the major stick the Cardinals have sought all winter. While he’s not at the level of former teammate Giancarlo Stanton, he did post an excellent .312/.376/.548 slash with 37 long balls in 2017. And Ozuna is also much friendlier to the checkbook, as he’s projected to earn $10.9MM in his second-to-last season of arbitration eligibility. That relatively light payroll hit might leave the Cards with capacity to make some other impact additions via free agency.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Flaherty, Alcantara, Piscotty who we then flip, and another prospect.

 

 

Sorry but I don't see the need to flip Piscotty who signed a 6-year extension back in April. If you keep Yelich you have 2/3 of your outfield locked up for the next 5 years. That is a good problem to have.

 

Here is the contract breakdown:

 

Piscotty breakdown: $2M signing bonus, salaries of $1M, $1M, $7M, $7M, $7.25M, $7.25M, $15M option or $1M buyout.

 

 

Sorry but I don't see the need to flip Piscotty who signed a 6-year extension back in April. If you keep Yelich you have 2/3 of your outfield locked up for the next 5 years. That is a good problem to have.

 

Here is the contract breakdown:

 

Piscotty breakdown: $2M signing bonus, salaries of $1M, $1M, $7M, $7M, $7.25M, $7.25M, $15M option or $1M buyout.

 

Piscotty wants to go home to the bay area because his mom has ALS and we have interest in oakland prospects.  I think if STL doesnt do the right thing and help him out we will if we get him in the trade.

 

 

Piscotty wants to go home to the bay area because his mom has ALS and we have interest in oakland prospects.  I think if STL doesnt do the right thing and help him out we will if we get him in the trade.

 

The offer from Oakland would need to be extremely good IMO.

 

 

No questioning that his mom has ALS but the other stuff.

 

been fairly widely reported that he is trying to get traded to the bay area to be near family.

 

 

Done deal guys....

 

there we fucking go.  about to acquire the guy who will be our top prospect now.  Likely to be Flaherty and then Alcantara or Hudson as the 2nd piece.  Look out for a guy named Gomber as another potential arm in this deal.

 

 

Again where are you getting this info from? It sounds like you are pretending to be an insider or something.

 

we shall see.

 

 

Sad seeing Ozuna break out and then he is gone. Fuck man. What a team to be a fan of. 

 

They better have pillaged the Cardinals. 

 

To play devils advocate, he never put up a year anywhere near what he did last year and is 2 years from free agency with scott boras as his agent.

 

 

Again where are you getting this info from? It sounds like you are pretending to be an insider or something.

 

Bob Nightengale‏Verified account @BNightengale 28s28 seconds ago

 

More

 

The #Marlins need pitching and the #Stlcards have plenty of it with talks focusing on Flaherty and Alcantara this week

 

:10_wink:

 

 

I am not impressed by Alcantara's numbers at all and he definitely has issues with walks. 

 

agreed, but people were absurdly high on him in the AFL and he has top of the rotation talent.

 

 

I am not impressed by Alcantara's numbers at all and he definitely has issues with walks. 

 

I’ll definitely take him, just hopefully not as the main prospect in the deal. 

 

 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.