Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Puk traded

Featured Replies

On 7/26/2024 at 4:55 AM, fish53 said:

Based on the numbers and the strikeout rate, we basically traded for another version of Griffin Conine, who we already have and severely weaken our bullpen. Of course we're not winning anything, so what does it matter as long as we can save the money. To me this is just another version of, let's wait a few years before we tell you to wait a few years.

Tears for this post and whoever gave it a thumbs up.

If u r seriously comparing ddls to Griffin conine I encourage you to read some books 📚 n baseball.

 

One is 21 one is  27. End of discussion.

30 minutes ago, TheMarlinsProject said:

As far as signing free gents, majority are awful investments long term. Would love to hear who you would go after though?

Appreciate your thoughts.

 

this last year i really wanted Teoscar as I felt he'd have been a great upgrade with Soler leaving....but all of that said, it's literally pointless looking to see who is going to be a UFA this or upcoming seasons until we see Bruce actually spend on a bigger additions (NEVER happening)

I'll post on here but I'm only casually following since ownership clearly doesn't give a damn about the fans.  I haven't watched a game since May and don't have any plans to watch any again this year and maybe not next year unless they actually show signs of life. 

And who on earth wouldn't be a pessimist with this group?  Our owner has not shown one tiny iota of caring about how the team.  The moment one of these guys gets good and his arbitration numbers get too high?  GONE.  i 100% expect it to happen over and over again.  These two trades seem pretty decent with what they got back but honestly, we're talking 2026 at the earliest probably - and the starting pitchers will be getting pricey for Bruce.  So another rebuild once again.  It's not really pessimism when that's how it's played out over and over.  It's just reality.

1 minute ago, TheMarlinsProject said:

Do not disagree, but we are in a much better place than last week. Until someone buys the team, we need to win to get the fan base behind us.

winning last year, along with a what, 25% attendance increase?, still did not spur Bruce to spend on anything to fix some glaring holes going into this season.  Those two things were pretty significant for this franchise - certainly enough that should have triggered some level of appearing to want to build upon that and yet...NOTHING.  Until Bruce is gone (and assuming MLB doesn't approve the sale to another deadbeat because some former player wants to play executive) no matter of fandom is going to help. 

But sure, our farm system is in much better shape.

Yes and no. It would be moronic to spend on this year when sandy and eury went down. 

Also it would be moronic to spend on free agents over 30 like avi.

Also Sherman is the second worst owner in MLB  behind Fisher.

But if bendix an turn chicken sh*t  into chicken salad, we may have something going forward 

 

1 hour ago, TheMarlinsProject said:

Yes and no. It would be moronic to spend on this year when sandy and eury went down. 

Also it would be moronic to spend on free agents over 30 like avi.

Also Sherman is the second worst owner in MLB  behind Fisher.

But if bendix an turn chicken sh*t  into chicken salad, we may have something going forward 

 

It would not have been moronic to have spent this past offseason at all. Playoff season with rising attendance for the first time in forever? That's exactly when you do want to spend. He could have signed one of the FA starters who ended up getting a one or two year deal to fill the void and we also had Max Meyer to call up to fill one of those slots. It was a monumentally stupid time to not finally make a splash and spend some money.

 

Not saying this with any animosity towards you at all either.  Scouts honor!

He's failed to spend both times after PO appearances so he's clearly just never going to spend.

Edited by hovertical

2 hours ago, TheMarlinsProject said:

Yes and no. It would be moronic to spend on this year when sandy and eury went down. 

Also it would be moronic to spend on free agents over 30 like avi.

Also Sherman is the second worst owner in MLB  behind Fisher.

But if bendix an turn chicken sh*t  into chicken salad, we may have something going forward 

 

We've been saying this since Larry Beinfest and nothing ever changes.

Literally every exec we have had has had some sort of a clue (other than maybe Jennings who was pretty bad). Beinfest, Hill and Ng all at least had an eye for talent. The problem was that Loria (and now Sherman) didn't spend the money the executives needed to actually improve the team.

The jury is still out on Bendix. He seems to have gotten decent returns for Puk and Jazz, but the Arraez trade was a catastrophic disaster that smelled more of ego than anything else. Bendix was so desperate to make this "his team" that he traded Arraez nearly three months before he had to and accepted a pitiful return as a result.

Like, imagine if Bendix would have done the actual sensible thing and waited until the deadline to trade Arraez? Arraez would have easily been the best hitter on the market. Bendix could have gotten a TON for him. Instead he traded him for a few guys we will probably never see (maybe Head can become something but he's probably four or five years away from being ready [if ever is]).

19 hours ago, hovertical said:

Oh i'm pretty sure this is going to be a total rebuild.  I fully expect Sandy and Luzardo gone next season for sure if they're both healthy. 

Now, if we knew Bruce was the type of owner who would be willing to sign a couple of the premier UFA's in the offseason? I might agree with you that they could turn this around really effing fast but there's been zero indication that he will do that so we'll have an unproven starting rotation next year (again, Sandy and Lizard will be gone and Eury will def be on an innings limit), an unproven bullpen, and a weak lineup as I doubt most of these guys we'll get back will be MLB-ready.

Yeah, I agree, I have zero faith that he'll spend on anything.  We'll get the usual beyond finished retreads and they'll be shocked when it doesn't work.

 

15 hours ago, TheMarlinsProject said:

Ever the pessimist. Our rotation is loaded if everyone comes back healthy if they don't it's still loaded if half of them return.

The hit side will be immensely improved, albeit may take a few years for the core to peak, but I'll take six years of de los Santos, Ramirez, Ramirez, mesa, sanoja,x man over  bell delacruz Sanchez Otto etc 

And if when sandy nd lizard go we have noble and white ready and hopefully Ethan Holliday or Jace laviolette if we can get done lottery luck. 

Draft and intl signings still the key but we are in a way better position than in the past lol the way back to 2016.

As far as signing free gents, majority are awful investments long term. Would love to hear who you would go after though?

Appreciate your thoughts.

 

Except we're a couple of years off, and by the time the bats will be ready, this crop of arms with either be gone, or too expensive and out the door.

There have been plenty of options the last few years where if Bruce would spend just a little bit, it'd tremendously help us for years.

 

14 hours ago, hovertical said:

this last year i really wanted Teoscar as I felt he'd have been a great upgrade with Soler leaving....but all of that said, it's literally pointless looking to see who is going to be a UFA this or upcoming seasons until we see Bruce actually spend on a bigger additions (NEVER happening)

I'll post on here but I'm only casually following since ownership clearly doesn't give a damn about the fans.  I haven't watched a game since May and don't have any plans to watch any again this year and maybe not next year unless they actually show signs of life. 

And who on earth wouldn't be a pessimist with this group?  Our owner has not shown one tiny iota of caring about how the team.  The moment one of these guys gets good and his arbitration numbers get too high?  GONE.  i 100% expect it to happen over and over again.  These two trades seem pretty decent with what they got back but honestly, we're talking 2026 at the earliest probably - and the starting pitchers will be getting pricey for Bruce.  So another rebuild once again.  It's not really pessimism when that's how it's played out over and over.  It's just reality.

He's said he'll spend when it's "time".....yet didn't spend a dime after 2 separate playoff appearances...why should any of us believe him that he'll spend?  If you don't spend then, when else would you?

Yeah, unfortunately, we're setting up for a Rays-like revolving door......which, if we win 90 games yearly may not be so bad, but still...

 

13 hours ago, TheMarlinsProject said:

Yes and no. It would be moronic to spend on this year when sandy and eury went down. 

Also it would be moronic to spend on free agents over 30 like avi.

Also Sherman is the second worst owner in MLB  behind Fisher.

But if bendix an turn chicken sh*t  into chicken salad, we may have something going forward 

 

Moronic?  Absolutely not.  If anything, it's moronic not to spend now when payroll is low.  You do realize that signing a quality player (something the Marlins never do, so it's understandable we wouldn't get it) requires multi-year contracts, right?


You sign a key guy or two with a forward-looking vision for another year or two or three down the road, so that when everyone is "ready", you have one less hole to fill.  Instead, we're constantly left with 5-7 blanks on the roster every year because it's not "the" year???  That's incredibly stupid.

Obviously he may not have singed here, but let's just say that we actually went after Realmuto a few years ago after the 2020 season.  He didn't cost that much, and we'd have been set for catcher for years.  We'd have been that much better the last few years, including last year's playoff appearance.  By your logic, we weren't ready to be good in 2021, so eh, let's not even try.

 

Signing a good key player now will help us in another year or two when we are trying to be good again (if we are lol).

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.