Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Puk traded

Featured Replies

7 minutes ago, DTrainSTA said:

I like the return, seems like a pretty fair trade.  Now let’s move Scott, Jazz, Bell, and DLC and get our farm system into the top 15!

Yes!  High farm rankings for the win!  Who cares about the actual team!

 

(I know what you mean).

I hate endless rebuilds but I am actually excited for this. I'm bored of the current roster and the trades give me something to watch. Yeah I know these guys we're getting will head out the door in a few years too if they produce, but at least it gave me something to briefly care about again.

2 hours ago, fish53 said:

Based on the numbers and the strikeout rate, we basically traded for another version of Griffin Conine, who we already have and severely weaken our bullpen. Of course we're not winning anything, so what does it matter as long as we can save the money. To me this is just another version of, let's wait a few years before we tell you to wait a few years.

You pretty much answered your own point here.

We're not winning anything. Who cares about trading a 29-year-old relief pitcher who isn't all that good anyway?

7 minutes ago, rmc523 said:

Yes!  High farm rankings for the win!  Who cares about the actual team!

 

(I know what you mean).

Then once all of the guys the Marlins acquire get up to the majors in a few years, we can trade them again and become a TOP 10 farm system in baseball!

Edited by Valid

Just now, Admin said:

I hate endless rebuilds but I am actually excited for this. I'm bored of the current roster and the trades give me something to watch. Yeah I know these guys we're getting will head out the door in a few years too if they produce, but at least it gave me something to briefly care about again.

Agreed, as fun as last year was this was never gonna be a great team unless we had a ownership willing to pay big time guys and make big trades.  So time to have fun following the developments of young guys again and seeing what we can get for the guys we do have.  There’s no one so awesome on this roster that they should be untouchable, so burn it down.  At least these guys we are trading for will be here for years cheap so we may get a few fun years from some of these guys before they are gone.

6 minutes ago, Admin said:

I hate endless rebuilds but I am actually excited for this. I'm bored of the current roster and the trades give me something to watch. Yeah I know these guys we're getting will head out the door in a few years too if they produce, but at least it gave me something to briefly care about again.

I want to feel like this, but I don't think I'll ever care the same again.

 

Sure i'm interested to see how it turns out in a few years, but I'm just meh about following another rebuild process.....why should I believe this one will go any different?  We'll do better and then dump everyone again.

10 minutes ago, rmc523 said:

I want to feel like this, but I don't think I'll ever care the same again.

 

Sure i'm interested to see how it turns out in a few years, but I'm just meh about following another rebuild process.....why should I believe this one will go any different?  We'll do better and then dump everyone again.

It won't be any different but if you're going to follow the Marlins this is about all you can ever get excited for - the deadline is basically our postseason.

 

 

OK, convinced.  Took a better look at the overall stats.  De Los Santos is better than Conine, younger also.  Like many, just tired of the rebuilds just to rebuild again.  Teams rebuild and then lock in.  We are a minor organization in all ways.  So, we won't win anything now, but maybe I get ill thinking of the return of Anthony Maldanado and watch the rest of the year losing by 6 every game with Puk gone and Scott gone and we cannot shut anyone down.  

14 minutes ago, hovertical said:

It won't be any different but if you're going to follow the Marlins this is about all you can ever get excited for - the deadline is basically our postseason.

True, it was weird last year being on the opposite side of things.

I invested in the last rebuild, though, I won't invest as much into this one.

 

13 minutes ago, hovertical said:

ESPN did not like what we got back for Puk lol. Dbacks got a B+ on this deal and we got a C+

The Athletic guys gave the Dbacks B+ to A-, our rating was B or B- across the board.

Fantastic trade. Dude didn't make any sense in this league anyway because they play with baseballs, not hockey Puks.

Return was fine for Puk.  Was never going to get a prized prospect for him.

This will rely on the player development team of the Marlins working out De La Santos's swing and making him far less all or nothing essentially.  

Luckily they have some time on him.

Pintar is so who cares that he is nothing more than really a sentence in talking about him.  He is a prospect (kinda), he is old for his level and he isnt that good.

But this return is all about De La Santos.  They turn him into a guy that can hit 25-30 hr while still hitting 25 hr and not striking out 40% of the time and this has the chance to really work out.

 

5 minutes ago, Admin said:

You have really improved your game

Thanks, I stopped drinking so much and now my brain works a lot better.

1 minute ago, Das Texan said:

Wrong approach to take if watching Marlin games however.

I have watched (1) marlins game in the last calendar year, am I doing it right?

Edit: I lied, I did watch the godawful wild card series against the Phillies, so that's what, 4 games total?

Edited by mrchainsaw

Fantastic upside for Delossantos.  Don't think we've had a power prospect like him in a long, long time.  Yes, he has many holes in his swing but getting that potential for a guy about to turn 30 and is essentially a spare part for the Marlins at this point is pretty incredible. People are getting caught up in the Rule 5 thing and initially when we traded with the Snakes my first thought was I hope we get Ivan Melendez finally.  Turns out we have a younger version at a higher level.

I don't think a lot of people understand that being a 21 year old in AAA makes a player pretty much a top prospect.  His numbers may be slightly inflated because of playing in Reno but here is a list of all the 21 and younger players that started the year in AAA.  (some like De Los Santos and top prospect Sanoja were called up mid-season).

 

Here is the entire list of players 21 or younger that started in AAA:

Jackson Holliday - consensus #1 prospect in baseball

AJ Smith-Shawver- #23 or #66 overall top prospect by FanGraphs and MLB

James Wood- #2 overall prospect

Ricky Tiedemann-  #44 overall, TOR #1 pitching prospect

Owen Caissie- #34 overall,, Cubs top 3

Paul Skenes- you may have heard of him.

Christian Mena- #11 Dbacks prospect, traded from WSox, deceiving ERA and electric stuff

Max Muncy- the one with the A's, former 1sr round pick, #7 A's prospect

Jonatan Clase- #10 Mariners prospect, great minor #'s, struggle in first MLB cup of coffee

 

That's it, that's the list.  I don't have data for mid-season AAA call ups but guessing it's not a big bunch either.

6 of 9 are top 50 overall prospects and all have superstar potential.

We should be over the moon we got a player of this caliber for a guy who outside of 2 months the beginning of last year has been a teeth-grinding gopher ball giving up nightmare most of the time.  

If we can get anywhere close to this return for guys like Delacruz, Sanchez, Bell, etc then we should pull the trigger like yesterday.

I think everyone forgets that next year we will have Alcantara, Eury, Luzardo, Weathers, and Garrett all returning on the staff (the entire rotation is basically out for this year).  That's not injuding Trevor Rogers, Edward Cabrera, Max Meyer all available.  None of the random computer generated named pitchers will be around next year.  The bullpen is also young and solid even if Tanner Scott leaves (hello Max Meyer, closer?).

So it is essential to shore up the hitting and defensive sides of the ball.  Pretty sure Scott, Jazz, and the aforementioned guys can bring in a young haul and it should be concentrated on bats.

This isn't a total rebuild and we may not be as far away as some think.

 

 

 

De Los Santos homered in his 2nd at bat in the Marlins org. Struck out in the first at bat.

Edited by FishFan95

On 7/25/2024 at 10:11 PM, rmc523 said:

I’m stealing a joke from the other place….

 

when do we acquire Nightvision de los Santos ?

What other place ? I demand to know

On 7/26/2024 at 1:52 PM, TheMarlinsProject said:

This isn't a total rebuild and we may not be as far away as some think.

 

 

 

Oh i'm pretty sure this is going to be a total rebuild.  I fully expect Sandy and Luzardo gone next season for sure if they're both healthy. 

Now, if we knew Bruce was the type of owner who would be willing to sign a couple of the premier UFA's in the offseason? I might agree with you that they could turn this around really effing fast but there's been zero indication that he will do that so we'll have an unproven starting rotation next year (again, Sandy and Lizard will be gone and Eury will def be on an innings limit), an unproven bullpen, and a weak lineup as I doubt most of these guys we'll get back will be MLB-ready.

3 hours ago, hovertical said:

Oh i'm pretty sure this is going to be a total rebuild.  I fully expect Sandy and Luzardo gone next season for sure if they're both healthy. 

Now, if we knew Bruce was the type of owner who would be willing to sign a couple of the premier UFA's in the offseason? I might agree with you that they could turn this around really effing fast but there's been zero indication that he will do that so we'll have an unproven starting rotation next year (again, Sandy and Lizard will be gone and Eury will def be on an innings limit), an unproven bullpen, and a weak lineup as I doubt most of these guys we'll get back will be MLB-ready.

Ever the pessimist. Our rotation is loaded if everyone comes back healthy if they don't it's still loaded if half of them return.

The hit side will be immensely improved, albeit may take a few years for the core to peak, but I'll take six years of de los Santos, Ramirez, Ramirez, mesa, sanoja,x man over  bell delacruz Sanchez Otto etc 

And if when sandy nd lizard go we have noble and white ready and hopefully Ethan Holliday or Jace laviolette if we can get done lottery luck. 

Draft and intl signings still the key but we are in a way better position than in the past lol the way back to 2016.

As far as signing free gents, majority are awful investments long term. Would love to hear who you would go after though?

Appreciate your thoughts.

 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.