Everything posted by Marlins2003
-
Serious discussion : Where is this franchise going ?
The one thing I find funny, and this is not a flame, is that the Loria apologists put little factual information out there, instead just telling everyone they are wrong. And there are only two people on this board that think Loria is a good owner. Of course you're flaming, just by referring to anyone who doesn't agree with your POV as an apologist. There is zero information available on the finances of the Marlins including Forbes, which by their own admission is without access to any MLB or team numbers and is purely based on supposition. Worse they continue to use the same model year after year for continuity sake, which in itself is a horrible mistake. Does it make for a good read? Sure. Should you bet the ranch on their conclusions? Only a fool would. That there's zero confirmable information out there exactly my point. If the franchise or Loria and company were doing any of the things people so cavalierly accuse them of without an ounce of proof (as opposed to suspicion), my contention is it would demand a huge conspiracy of slience involving many hundreds of people and by now one of them would have said something. You want me and others to prove a negative, like "Do you still beat your wife?", it's impossible. You don't have to agree with my position but the fact that there may be a greater number of people who believe Loria is doing this and that doesn't make it so. The fact that nothing has come out to the contrary I believe speaks volumes. To me that is the smoking gun. You don't have to agree but to continue to accuse with no proof is reprehensible.
-
Serious discussion : Where is this franchise going ?
Accounting is real. But the question brings up another fallacious belief. People will say something like "well he has all this depreciation that hiding this big pot of dough, or some other write-off but generally it's just like owning a rental unit and getting depreciation on it. You can use that depreciation now and pay less taxes this year and much more in taxes when you sell, or you can let the depreciation accumulate and use it when you sell the property to offset what was a much bigger gain. What I think you're really thinking of is "cash" vs "accrual" accounting, two (IRS) legitimate ways of accounting for your transactions. I forget this moment which MLB uses but there's nothing unique or nefarious about how the Marlins keep their books, MLB and the IRS make sure of that. If you think they are making $30 million and hiding it somehow because of their accounting methods, you're wrong, again for all the reasons above (see why conspiracies fail).
-
Serious discussion : Where is this franchise going ?
Loria is not "pillaging" the franchise, it's his team. He is the owner and chooses to run it on a profit margin, that is his right. What is shameful is that he pockets the revenue sharing funds without investing it into operations, for which it meant to be used. That was meant to allow smaller market teams to be able to fairly compete against larger markets, not as a bonus to greedy owners. I am not gonna call Loria greedy but certainly he is not spending the money on the franchise, nor is willing to do so anytime soon. His pockets are being lined handsomely and conveniently, may I add, this is leading the league to consider a minimun payroll on all franchises. You've missed the point completely. Or points, more accurately. The Marlins claim through their own words that they are running at break-even or "revenue-neutral". Anything to the contrary, would be viewed as a lie and a major news story since the Marlins position has been made before, and quoted and requoted many times, in the press. In short it would give everyone who would want to the perfect excuse to brand him a liar. Your comment "it's his team. He is the owner and chooses to run it on a profit margin, that is his right. What is shameful is that he pockets the revenue sharing funds..." is without an proof whatsoever which was the point I made above. All you're doing is slurring the guy. He has a number of partners in this venture, you really think it all goes to him and they are left out in the cold? ***(This paragraph was poorly phrased on my part so I am adding this: There are no profits so there is nothing to pocket, and even if there was he'd be one of many standing in line for their cut. As general partner he has a fiduciary responsiblity here, but since there isn't it's moot)*** You do understand Loria does not take a penny in salary or other compensation from the team. You're saying "he pockets the revenue sharing funds", to me that's the equivalent of pillaging. You're also contending in regards to revenue sharing "he not spending the money on the franchise" while the team's contention is every penny (in the figurative sense) goes into baseball operations. You started out by saying Loria wasn't pillaging the franchise but three times in your response you make remarks to the contrary, the last one being "His pockets are being lined handsomely and conveniently...". What insider information do you have? I suspect zero, nada, none. What evidence is there? None. You and others have a belief system based on a false premise because collectively you cannot conceive of how expensive it is to run a major league baseball team and a minor league operation, international scouting, etc. vs the revenue coming in. Were it otherwise, were a story to break tomorrow with aquote from someone in the finance department, or from the county, some credible source to the contrary I would be Loria's most vocal critic. But as long as those who would wish him ill can't find any evidence of wrongdoing or poor shepardship of this franchise the rational thing is to believe is what they are saying is what they are doing, running the franchise at break-even.
-
Serious discussion : Where is this franchise going ?
The stadium will be the property of the county and the marlins will have to pledge the franchise against their contractural thirty years of rent due. It will be hard to sell the team with that encumberance on it.
-
Serious discussion : Where is this franchise going ?
Anyone who believes someone on this board who claims he or she knows that ownership is pillaging this franchise, pocketing tons of dough, or this franchise is wildly profitable while holding back the team from contending, should have their heads examined. The Marlins position (and I'm talking about the last two years under the current ownership) is they are running a revenue neutral organization after losing tens of millions of dollars from 2002-2005 (let's remember they spent $130 million between 2004 and 2005 JUST on onfield payroll), and there is not a single person on this board who has a clue nevermind a fact to prove them wrong. Forbes is guesses piled on top of more guesses, compounding each year because they refuse to adjust their formulas to keep up with the changes in the game for fear that they would no longer be able to compare year to year as they do. Zimbalist's credibility went out with platform shoes. And wouldn't you think by now some enterprising reporter would have exposed Loria and company if they were lying? Some whistleblower wouldn't have come forward because they didn't like the size of their Christmas bonus? These kinds of things require a huge conspiracy. A huge conspiracy of silence. Of lawyers, accountants, of CPAs, (all with their good names and careers on the line not to mention things like disbarment, jail time, etc.) willing employees in numerous departments from bookeeping to dispersements, minority partners, banks, the county, the bond underwriting community, the city, their minor league affiliates and all their employees, the list is literally endless yet not one person has stepped forward to say that the Marlins are being run any way other than the way they claim it is. Certainly if the minority partners (who at best could be called "unfriendly") even suspected Loria and others were colluding against their best interests (and "Loria is putting the money in his pocket" would run counter to their best interests to be sure) they wouldn't remain silent, not after the way they wound up minority partners here in the first place. They'd have forensic accountants up Loria's a**hole every day of the week. They'd be back in court or being quoted in every newspaper in the country. Yet none of that happens. All this poison falls apart under the weight of scrutiny and the single undeniable truth - conspiracies never work. Someone always gets bent out of shape and spills the beans. Every single f***ing time. And the reason you haven't heard about it is because it isn't happening. For some here there is no smear too great, no lie too big, no venom too voluminous to spread because they aren't fans, they are provocateurs masquerading as fans. So before you listen to any more of this bulls*** being spread ask yourselves why no one has ever pointed a finger. Why a scumbag like Joe Ariolla didn't spill the beans (the city and the county intimately understand the Marlins financial situation and have for years) when he was trying to force Loria to sell out for pennies on the dollar to a foreign national who just happened to be a big political contributor. All he had to do was slip it to any one of a number of reporters at the Herald and Loria would have been up sh*t creek without a paddle, and run out of town to boot. Or maybe you think the Herald and the Sun-Sentinel and the Palm Beach Post are in on it too? Don't you think Huizenga and company who are closest to what's happening in their stadium would have used even a hint of malfeasance to destroy the franchise once and for all and be rid of baseball and the threat it poses as a legitimate alternative for hundreds of millions if not billions of sports entertainment dollars if the Marlins are successful in getting their own venue? Nevermind the fact that Wayne's personal "Mainfest Destiny" is to prove himself right that baseball won't work in this market? It becomes like a lynch mob here sometimes with everyone wanting to be the first guy to throw that noose over the tree branch... "I hear he's stealing a million a year"..."no, no it's ten million a year he's putting in his pocket"..."No it's $30 million a year they're making". This is a limited partnership If this franchise made $30 million last season don't you think the limited partners would be screaming for their piece? Does anyone stop and think how hard it is to steal (pocket, divert to your own purposes, whatever word or phrase you want to use) a million dollars, nevermind $30 million a year. You really think Bud Selig walks up to some bookkeeper in the offices of Major League Baseball and says "Oh by the way, make out that $30 million revenue sharing (or Luxury Tax) check for the Marlins in the name of Jeffrey Loria c/o account # 7492e23hg8 at the First Bank of the Grand Caymans? Think. Use the brains God gave you. You're all smarter than that to be manipulated by these haters and rumor mongerers. You can argue with the way the franchise is run, you can argue about how player personnel decisions are made, there's lots to be unhappy about after a season like this, but don't think for a minute this franchise is awash in dough or the owner is a thief because there is not a shred of evidence to conclude that. Too many people with their own agendas want this franchise to fail without something getting out, and to this moment not a word to the contrary has been spoken. The reason MLB supports what's going on with the franchise is because Loria isn't amassing $30 million a year as some would have you believe. Clearly they believe in this market, they have enough confidence in the owner to not fine him as they did the Pirates or throw him out as they've done with other owners before. And it isn't about rich vs poor owners because the way the math works in baseball there is plenty to go around and more coming. (Wait until you have a 24 hour MLB cable channel next year (I believe it's '08) and then watch the money really start pouring in) Or the notion that a richer owner would be willing to lose tens of millions a year in support of the team as if millionaires like losing money anymore than the rest of us do. Unless you have some gazillionaire out on Dan Marino Blvd handing out $20 bills to everyone attending the game every night accept the fact that without corporate clients and the casual fan having abandoned a wretched Dolphin Stadium experience, nothing changes until cashflow changes and that means a new venue. The economics of the stadium drives everything. Frankly we're lucky we still have a franchise here. Thank God no one has an empty stadium in a major market ready for occupancy or we'd be screwed But back to the subject at hand, this belief that the team is awash with dough or worse as some think the owner is pocketing it for himself. The facts speak for themselves. There is no conspiracy of silence allowing those things to be true because there's nothing to conspire about.
-
#1 Draft Pick Race Division
I think so highly of Hanley and I've been so disappointed that Cabrera hasn't been able to get into playing shape all season (at least for his position, but I'm not trying to move this thread to the Cabrera to first thing), if he comes into camp next spring after the ton of money he'll get in arbitration or through a contract still looking like the Pillsbury doughboy, if the deal were right, I would at least listen with an open mind. Cabrera, SFX and the Marlins I hope get on the same page regarding Cabrera's off-season conditioning regimen and the team's expectations for one of the game's best talents. I say this as as big a fan of the guy as there is. I can't speak for him, I wouldn't dare to, but I have to wonder if he feels any embarrassment about how he let his weight dictate his play this season. In my mind, a fit Miguel Cabrera could be next guy to have a legitimate shot at the .400 BA mark and only God knows how many homeruns he's capable of, so good are his skills. Watching him trudge down to first base this season has been painful to watch.
-
Conine's Last Home Game
I was unhappy with the way he chose to leave the Marlins but that's behind us and I'll somewhat begrudgingly give him a standing ovation today because regardless of everything else, it's the right thing to do. It's a rationalization but I think you go back to 1993 and 1997 and 2003 you have to say "thanks". In a perfect world things might have been different but nothing is ever perfect.
-
Sophomore Slump
That anyone would try to excuse away the horrendous defense this season because pitchers have given up too many walks (and they have but that's not the point) is really mind-blowing and without credibility. Zero. Poor defense doesn't always show up as errors, nor is its impact on the game only displayed in unearned runs. Poor defense is poor defense and it can't be ignored, not by the lowliest Marlin and not by the team's superstars. There's been a lot of bad baseball played out there this year. To make a case it hasn't had a cause and effect on pitching or on the team's performance is laughable. Earned runs as a stat don't necessarily take into account poor play, just bad enough play that an error was called. We've had a season of watching better and lesser teams (not necessarily in the standings but in talent) put on clinics on how baseball should be played defensively and yet some still think that the only thing that matters is protecting the annointed even if that means conveniently forgetting baseball has an offense and a defensive component. It also points out once again the saying "a little knowledge is a dangerous thing" was never truer than when some try to use stats to make a point they weren't meant to make.
-
The scouts are saying...
If Kranitz stays I'm okay. If Wiley were to return, I'm okay with that too. I wonder if Fredi and Wiley have any history together in the minor leagues? The players are paid to play, I don't think a change would necessarily help or hurt anything, both are consummate baseball people.
-
Sophomore Slump
good stuff and plausable theories Thank you, and thank you for recognizing them for what they are, theories. I don't purport to have insider knowledge nor do I claim infallability, but for me that's how the pieces fall together. :thumbup
-
Sophomore Slump
Sophomore slump, it's been more of a meltdown. And while we're casting around for all manner of reasons why, heaven forbid we should ever mention the woeful defense we've seen this year. The team played badly from the start of the year, and yes injuries certainly were a major cause of where we are, but just using last night's game as a prime example, eight freakin' unearned runs, Scott Olsen finally goes out there shows he still has it in him, his demons put aside and the team lays down behind him. And it's been this way all season. I happen to agree basically that innings pitched would appear to be a big issue, but just as much so, if not more has been pitches per inning, and per consecutive inning, that took it's toll on a lot of young arms. Whether it was their fault - too many walks and long counts - or the defense giving opposing teams four, five, six outs an inning, the 30+ pitch innings were as much to blame for the Marlins DL parade as anything else. In another thread there's this debate going on about Wiley vs Kranitz (re:Willis and the staff generally) but if you go back and research what Wiley was saying back in 2005, he was a proponent not coddling young pitchers and having them go out and throw 180-200 innings to build up arm strength. So be careful what you wish for. To quote Mr. Wiley, ""You learn in the big leagues by being out there consistently," says Mark Wiley, the team's new pitching coach. "You learn the most, probably, when you have your first 200-plus-inning year."" So I don't see how people can argue for Wiley's return (and against the 2006 MLB Pitching Coach of the Year) when Wiley's philosophy runs counter to what the same people are saying is the root cause of the problem. I have my own belief, I make no claim that I am right, no words of declaration that what is really nothing more than a theory is absolute or fact, but I believe that a number of the young pitchers we see on the DL now had injuries they hid from their manager and coaches in 2006, in the belief that the off-season would give them the chance to get well and no one would ever know. But instead they came into camp still hurt, and in some cases only made matters worse for themselves by again refusing to acknowledge they were hurt until it became impossible for them to perform. I believe that they made their own personal choice to hide their injury and instead of a four week stint on the DL, sitting out because of tendonitis or whatever malady, rather they lied to anyone who asked and tried to mask the problem(s) with different pitches or mechanics and made matters worse, in some cases (figuratively) blowing out elbows trying to hide a sore shoulder. And the product of that is what you see today. I'd go one step further. I think Willis is doing the same thing. Whether it's his shoulder (my core belief) or his pitching hand that he hurt at first base, I do not believe he is 100% healthy. I have no knowledge any of that is true. I don't know if anyone saw DW throwing a warmup pitch in the dirt and then shaking his pitching hand (I read somewhere this morning he says it was a cramp), but I suspect he's another guy who thinks the right thing to do is go out there and try to help the team, a laudable endeavor, but if he is in fact ailing, perhaps it's misguided too. This theory about 2006 and 2007 came after the whole Anibal Sanchez affair with him underperforming, being sent down, then finally admitting he was injured, ultimately undergoing surgery, and that the reason the Marlins FO handled it the way they did was to send a message to the rest of their young arms - the ones they are counting on for our future - that "if you're hurt, don't be a hero go tell someone!". If it takes you an extra six months or even a whole season to make it to the major leagues because you have to rest a tired arm or sore shoulder, better you do that and have a career in the bigs than fake it until you've blown out your arm and out of baseball. And for the record if anyone wants to go back into the 2005-2006 off-season archives I was a proponent of keeping most the young arms down for the year and essentially building a staff ala the Nationals in 2007. I don't know that the result would have been as exciting in August and early Sept of 2006, but I suspect we'd have most if not all those young arms healthy or at least healthier right now. As a person who some here would brand an apologist for the FO I thought it was a mistake then and I still do. As Don Sutton said young pitchers (physically) mature at different ages, just because MLB is ready for you doesn't mean you're ready for MLB. I think there's lots of blame to go around and it isn't just the manager or pitching coach or the front office, it's in some cases the players, it's their agents, it's the MLBPA as well, they are all at fault here. And do I have to disagree with the notion "we" knew anything about Dan Uggla's future. We may have suspected, September may have hinted at what this season would bring but there's a core of people here who like to say how average is the last stat you look at when someone is making an argument regarding a player not well respected by them, there's another side to that coin, Uggla leads ALL MAJOR LEAGUE 2B in homeruns and doubles, and is 2nd in Total Bases to Brandon Phillips. Can his average and some imputed stats be higher, absolutely, but playing major league average or better defense and leading in those three real world, tangible categories says to me that Dan Uggla was not the problem in 2007. They'll fix that tick in his swing and I suspect you'll see his BA rise in 2008. You saw a glimpse of it a couple of times this season when Presley got him to keep his bat still and much, much more upright and he was staying behind the ball far better and hitting to all fields, but he keeps falling back into that old Gary Sheffield-like habit of cocking, cocking, cocking the bat and it hurts him with certain types of pitchers who use it against him. Long post. Probably too far afield of the subject at hand and for some a chance to take potshots. But I think what happened this year can't be laid at the feet of any one coach, or the manager exclusively, there have been a number culprits here and not the least of which is some of the players. There's lots of blame to go around.
-
Mets @ Marlins 9/21
gotta love puns :brigginbounce
-
Mets @ Marlins 9/21
I think what MVP is alluding to is the willingness on the part of some to name-call and belittle anyone who doesn't get into lockstep with their "stats are the only thing that matters" mantra. More and more I find value in baseball stats but I refuse to discard, or allow someone brand as worthless, the knowledge base I have having attending over 2,500 MLB games and watched everyone from Ted Williams and Joe DiMaggio and Bob Gibson to today's ballplayers. Some things are just not quantifiable.
-
Mets @ Marlins 9/21
Hey ! Play Ball !!!!
-
Mets @ Marlins 9/21
"Meaningless" may be too strong if we're parsing words but certainly there's been a belief system alive on this board among some, more this summer than I've ever seen before, that defense just isn't that important in today's brand of baseball. I certainly don't agree but it's there and I've taken my share of sh*t for not buying in.
-
Mets @ Marlins 9/21
8 unearned. :lol Many people would have you believe that defense is meaningless Putting the ball in play is meaningless too.
-
Mets @ Marlins 9/21
I'm back. I plead guilty I bailed tonight. Enough with the f'ing rain. What a #%^&@ embarrassment that was. I've never really been a Scott Olsen groupie but man I felt sorry for him tonight. They're still in a rain delay I see.
-
Dan Uggla says the Marlins don't like the Phillies
As a Marlins fan there's no "ideal" National League East outcome that doesn't include the Fish but for me the closest would be the Mets and Phillies both go cold, the Braves win the division and the Padres wind up with the wildcard.
-
cuban "hr king" defecting?
I would imagine once he has established his DR residency he'll probably play the first half (at least) of the winter leagues as well as doing tryouts for any number of Latin American scouts, including our own. I remember there were a couple of people here who followed Cuban baseball religiously, perhaps we'll hear from them.
-
I LOVE THE MARLINS
Night's like this make it all worthwhile. I can't wait for tomorrow night. I thought for a minute out there the guys were going to pants Uggla :lol
-
One of Beinfest' worst moves
And of course you're still wrong the core issue and ignoring why and how you were wrong. But keep trying to deflect the fact you were caught in another of your untruthful statements, it's so predictable. "Delgado's value to last year's team should not be overstated. He decided the division." Your words. His line for September .253 .326 .458 .784, with 4 home runs. The facts. Mets clinched on Sept 19th, from Sep 1 thru the 19th, Delgado hit .236 with an OBP of .300*. His numbers actually went up for the month AFTER the Mets clinched. More facts. What's next your patented name-calling? * OBP for the period Sep 1- 19th was calculated by adding hits and walks and dividing by plate appears. Did not factor in sacrifices or HBP.
-
One of Beinfest' worst moves
Of course you disagree...but that's you. Take a look at Helms/Jacobs combined numbers for 2006 and you'll be every surprised how they stack up against Delgado, not equal but actually better in some stats, not so in others. Delgado had 38 HRs for example, combined Helms/Jacobs 30. It's reasonably easy to do the math since Helms played most games at first and E*S*PN has the splits. But just keep disagreeing, it's so cute. You just make stuff up and state it as fact. I know it frustrates you when people actually look up stuff you say. Both his average and OBP were the lowest (in 2006) in almost a decade, only once since 1997 was his OPS+ been lower, his SLG was the third lowest since 1997. He no more decided the division than the sun rises in the west. And for the record his line for September - 253 .326 .458 .784, with 4 home runs, hardly earth-shattering. See, that'd be great if Helms and Jacobs played in a platoon at first base, but they didn't Jacobs played when his health allowed, Helms played whenever we needed a bat off the bench. It wasn't as if it was a true platoon. We tried getting Jake in there as much as possible (469 AB's) and that's fine, that was the right thing to do. To go back and suggest that two players production exceeded the production of one player, well, I'd sure hope so. The thing is, that Marlins 2006 team should have had Delgado and Helms, and that'd have been peach keen. Jacobs and Helms combined for 709 AB's and 276 games. I'd sure as hell hope that'd outproduce a single player with 524 AB's in 144 games. Here's a fun stat, Carlos Delgado's OPS+ in 2006: 134. Jacobs: 106. Details, details... This is going to be another thread where you just can't accept you're wrong, but let me *be* clear going forward, so you know. I was very busy all summer but my contract is over and I'm back and every single thing you post will come under scrutiny. Everything. You had your fun at my expense this summer while I was essentially not here by taking things out of the thread context in which they appeared and took every opportunity you could to ridicule me. My turn. Oh and btw the comment you made was how Delgado carried the Mets to the playoffs, ("Delgado's value to last year's team should not be overstated. He decided the division.") not how he stacked up against a guy playing on a broken ankle who could barely walk nevermind run or even a tandem of Jacobs and Helms. Delgado's numbers are down, you can't rewite that, you can't change them (like you do your posts to cover your mistaken tracks). Nowhere did I try to make a case of equivalency between Jacobs and Delgado in 2006 and I have been very careful to make the point that Mike Jacobs cannot at this point be compared on a career basis with Carlos Delgado. My comparison is 2007 vs 2007. Live with it. Keep changing the subject all you want to cover your butt but it won't help you anymore. I'm back.
-
One of Beinfest' worst moves
Of course you disagree...but that's you. Take a look at Helms/Jacobs combined numbers for 2006 and you'll be every surprised how they stack up against Delgado, not equal but actually better in some stats, not so in others. Delgado had 38 HRs for example, combined Helms/Jacobs 30. It's reasonably easy to do the math since Helms played most games at first and E*S*PN has the splits. But just keep disagreeing, it's so cute. You just make stuff up and state it as fact. I know it frustrates you when people actually look up stuff you say. Both his average and OBP were the lowest (in 2006) in almost a decade, only once since 1997 was his OPS+ been lower, his SLG was the third lowest since 1997. He no more decided the division than the sun rises in the west. And for the record his line for September - 253 .326 .458 .784, with 4 home runs, hardly earth-shattering.
-
One of Beinfest' worst moves
Not to continue this debate, but it seems to me that people are forgetting the goal, after the stadium deal was destroyed by Joe Arriola, was payroll reduction and to that end $$$ was saved by jettisoning Delgado with little or no loss in productivity, certainly this season. Having Delgado last season would have been a waste of $$$, the team wasn't going to the playoffs with or without him. Between a decent season last year from Helms and Jacobs/Boone this season while some would argue we didn't get enough for Delgado, net we saved roughly $30 million and got and paid Jacobs, ultimately Kim, Helms and Boone.
-
One of Beinfest' worst moves
I believe the published reports say $7 million. http://sports.espn.go.com/mlb/news/story?id=2234421 http://www.cbc.ca/sports/story/2005/11/23/delgado051123.html http://www.sportsline.com/mlb/story/9059180 But ever the stickler for accuracy you were not entirely incorrect - according to MLB4U it confirms the above $ 7 million figure BUT you were correct that the payments are staggered - "as part of trade that sent him to NYM, the Marlins pay the Mets a total of 7M in payments of 1M in 2006, 2M in 2007 and 4M in 2008". So that would make the cost (and let's just assume that Jacobs is worth TWICE the other guys - $500k Psomas, $500k Petit, $1 million Jacobs) comparison Carlos Delgado net $12.5 million for same output as Mike Jacobs at $1.38 million or roughly nine times more. And if you wanted to do the same thing next year (2008) Jacobs would be roughly $2.5 million and Delgado $14.5 million.