Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Marlins2003

Members
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Marlins2003

  1. But if you remember Delgado was only making $4 million the first year of his deal with the Marlins and (someone correct me if I'm wrong but) the commissioner's office when ruling on the trade (because it was over $1 million) made the Marlins pay it in a lump sum in 2006. That said, if you want to prorate it over the three years with the Mets not to mention the 4th year that will cost them a minimum of $4 million if his option isn't picked up, either roughly $2.3 million per or $1.75 per over 4. And that was for three players not one. You forget that Petit at the time of was highly ranked. Baseball America had him ranked as the number two prospect in the Mets organization in Nov 2005 AHEAD of Mike Jacobs (4th). So its incorrect to lay $7 million at the feet of Mike Jacobs.
  2. Respectfully Pengy, I have to disagree with a number of things you've said. Jacobs is at this point probably a better first baseman than Delgado. Delgado's numbers are getting worse by the year, he is obviously in decline as he salary escalates. To say the Marlins "got nothing" is just wrong. I understand you don't to compare year to year because it blows your argument out of the water but you don't have to demean the improving performance by ballplayers in order to do so either. I think that the ultimate result of the deal was ten of millions in savings, equivalent performance and probably better defense, plus a pitcher who's 8-3 for the Fish in a losing season. Maybe that wasn't the plan (it was Petit) but that is the result. Here's their respective espn pages, look for yourself, but before you do read again where I say that Mike Jacobs cannot be compared to the career Carlos Delgado has had. I'm not demeaning Delgado to make my point. It's just math. In 2007, for the $$ Jacobs is the better player. delgado = http://sports.espn.go.com/mlb/players/profile?playerId=3020 jacobs = http://sports.espn.go.com/mlb/players/stats?playerId=6385
  3. I'm not sure how either the Jacobs/Delgado or by extension the Petit for Julio for Kim can determined to be (what was phrased as "infinitely worse" than what the thread starter considered "One of Beinfest's worst moves") bad trades per se. For $14.50 million dollars this is what the Mets have gotten from Carlos Delgado in 2007: BA .255 OBP .329 SLG .455 HR : 22 / 501 ABs / 129 Gms / 1 HR every 22.7 ABs / 8 errors OPS .774 For $380,000 this is what the Marlins have gotten from Mike Jacobs in 2007: BA .271 OBP .327 SLG .468 HR : 16 / 371 ABs / 101 Gms / 1 HR every 23.5 ABs / 5 errors OPS .795 As for the Petit/Julio/Kim series of trades ask yourselves whether you would rather have had Kim or Petit this summer. The answer is obvious. Jacobs is improving defensively and at the plate. Delgado will never be a better defensive player than he has shown 2005-2007. (Both players spent time on the DL in 2007) None of the above is meant to say Mike Jacobs is yet playing at a level that equals Carlos Delgado's career numbers because he isn't, and may never. But looking at 2007 it appears the Marlins certainly got the better of that trade without even including the Petit/Kim factor. And next year Mike Jacobs will cost around $450,000 - Carlos Delgado $16 million. One player is 26, the other 35 years old. For Delgado it is the third consecutive year his OBP/SLG/OPS numbers have declined. For the 2007 trading away Delgado (with 1/2 season's salary thrown in) has worked to the Marlins advantage on the field as well as the pocketbook.
  4. Baseball games are not won with pitching and defense. The 2004-2005 Marlins are the perfect example of this. Baseball games are won with pitching, defense, and the three run homer. The 2007 squad is missing two of the three ingredients. Thank you Earl Weaver :notworthy
  5. God I hope they don't let him pitch both ends of winter ball again this off-season.
  6. Before I forget, the new Herald beat writer for the Marlins has an unhealthy obsession with mentioning small crowds in every write-up. Huh? Do you mean Mike Phillips because if you do he's been there for probably at least ten years bashing the Marlins. After Bush was replaced as sports editor and Jeff Miller was given the boot for his "most vile parasite" comment, Baxter and Spencer took over as the full time beat reporters while Phillips was exiled to write a weekly (Sunday) general sports/baseball piece. But after Baxter decided to split to LA (where he has been promsing Angels fans all season that the Marlins will be trading Miguel Cabrera like tomorrow...sheesh), Phillips went back to being a lowly beat reporter.
  7. Has anyone here actually seen Pudge play more than a game or two this season? I know I haven't. I ask the question only because as we all know catchers get the livin' crap kicked out of them season after season and eventually it takes its toll. We all remember the Pudge of 2003 and maybe a glimpse last season in Detroit's run to the World Series, and I'm not questioning what he has left in the tank, because I don't know. Can anyone speak with some authority (closet Tigers fan out there perhaps???) about his overall play in 2007? On the face of it it's not the worst idea, but the first thing I think of when I think of negotiating with Pudge is Scott Boras, and I don't think I have to say more on that subject. Personally I'd be worried about a mutli-year deal but at the right price, and with the right terms, and without looking at who might also be available, sure go for it.
  8. There is no Miami Arena site, that is unless you want to spend $40 million to buy the building, many millions to demolish it and as much in cartage and dumping costs, and wind up with a site that is still too small for baseball.
  9. Pudge came to Florida for one reason. We were the only team willing to take a chance on him at his asking price, $10,000,000. If I remember correctly he spent most of spring training unemployed. And with Jeff Torborg at the helm this team sure didn't look like winners.
  10. Everyone seems to forget, or it is barely ever mentioned, that Mitre spent the winter unable to even throw, nevermind pitch, and the uncertainty about his readiness for 2007 was one of the things that hampered Beinfest's options in being more aggressive on the trade front. In hindsight the Marlins should have more severely limited his innings this season as a number of people have said, my hope is he's shut down for the remainder of the year. If he can bring that sinker back and make 25 starts next season this team will be a lot better prepared to contend in 2008.
  11. Joe Borchard will have an opportunity to win a spot with us or someone else next spring, or perhaps overseas, but there is no rush to put him on the the 40 man roster even if it means we lose him in the upcoming Rule 5 draft (anyone know if he's eligible???). He's a good ballplayer but unfortunately not good enough, the story of so many players with talent but not the extraordinary skills needed to stick in the major leagues.
  12. I've believed for awhile that Hanley has a chance to become the greatest player to ever wear a Marlins uniform, and that includes Miguel Cabrera and Gary Sheffield. Assuming he can improve the other half of his game there appears nothing in his way to becoming a huge force in major league baseball for a decade or longer. I couldn't help but notice a line in the story that confirms he's been playing hurt all season and perhaps it explains his lack of mobility, especially to his right (it is after all his left/glove shoulder that is problematic and going to his right means extending and possibly hyper-extending his left shoulder across his body) may in fact be instructions from management (onfield or upstairs) to not extend himself in fear of exacerbating that injury. If you notice when he ranges to his right it is almost always by circling the ball as if to keep his glove in front of him. He does move fairly well to his left, which only reinforces my suspicion. Earlier I thought he might be our centerfielder of the future (something some thought absurd but I'm not afraid to be criticized for thinking outside the box) but I also wonder whether his future could at third where there may be less demand on his surgically repaired shoulder. Even though I'm not ready to jettison Jacobs were Cabrera to wind up at first and a healthy Hanley at third, filling the shortstop position might be an easier task than some alternative scenarios. And even though I'll be bashed again, I wouldn't rule out him moving to the OF depending on how his surgery goes, thinking of Soriano's move as the most obvious example. In any event his ascendancy to superstardom seems inevitable if he isn't there already. It's great to see him get the acknowledgment he so richly deserves. If this isn't a guy who should be locked up and quickly for as long as possible I don't know who is. I'll leave it to others to calculate what the deal would look like but it has to happen sooner rather than later. Let's hope this is just the beginning of more and more national recognition for the kid, he deserves it.
  13. At this point, signing Pudge in the offseason would basically just be putting boobs on a corpse. It was "breast implants on a corpse..." referring to DLB's 2003 comment regarding the Pudge signing and one that he's been reminded of a thousand times. But good catch. :thumbup
  14. The second half of the season a person would have to blind to *not* see the improvement Jacobs has shown. He is still a work in progress and I wouldn't debate that but now that he's healthy and not up every night with his new kids (remembering what D Lee looked like after the birth of his) I see, and I think the numbers lately show there is something there worth holding onto at least into the near future. To call him the worst first baseman in the NL insulting and wrong. He's hitting lefties like crazy this season (.354) which was of course the big complaint last season, since the ASB his numbers are up, his he's gotten settled in after returning from injury and going through the transition to father, his numbers are up in almost every offensive category, he's hitting .311 over the last thirty days, his OPS for the period is over .800 and his defense is greatly improved. Swift, this is not me looking for a fight but sometimes there is value in looking at both sides of the coin and recognizing when a player, especially one who played almost an entire season hurt in 2006 and then was injured again in 2007 (plus the kids) is showing improvement. Improvement is a good thing. Improvement should be recognized. Since settling in and putting a couple of bad (offensive) streaks behind him he's trending up. In the long run I can't say you'll be proven wrong but I submit you are off-base (no pun intended) by being ready to throw him out with the bath water. This is a much improved player than we saw last season and let's at least see what the remainder of September brings before we rush to judgment.
  15. Lets bring back our 2003 man, the great WAYNE ROSENTHAL!! A blast from the past
  16. This ridiculous whining about Jacobs' defense day after day doesn't make the notion valid. Jacobs' defense this season, especially since he came back from his injury has been the most improved on the team. If he can stay healthy (which to me is a far bigger concern and a reason to consider finding a replacement) there's no reason why he can't a good (not great, not all-star) major league first baseman. We all know where the biggest defensive shortcomings are on this team and they aren't at first or second base. At least not this season. Going forward both players have to improve, but there's any number of players whose needed improvement is far greater than theirs.
  17. Yeah, Matt Bush was a very surprising pick when he went #1. He has already failed as an infielder, and has started to take up pitching. So what you're saying is when the off-season "trade Dontrelle/Miggy" hysteria begins Matt Bush will be a popular name among Padres fans to centerpiece a trade for either Marlins player.
  18. Apparently though, he ***Baker*** isn't a "Beinfest guy".... so who knows with him anymore Well he must be someone's guy in the FO because they went out and traded/picked him up twice in two years. I don't know if it's Fleming, Hill or whoever but someone pulled the trigger on those moves. Could it be he was/is in Dean Treanor's doghouse? You would think that if Treanor, who from everything I've read is the consummate FO guy, had lobbied for his callup, it would have happened. It does get curiouser and curiouser.
  19. Marlins2003 replied to a post in a topic in Miami Marlins
    It's sad, because we are better than several of those teams ahead of us. Especially Washington, Pittsburgh, Cincinnati, San Fran, and Houston. Unfortunately we haven't been playing better than them, and recently we have been getting beat up by several of those teams. I am not sure how fair it is to say "we are better than..." but, "we haven't been playing better". As much as I hate the way the Fish are performing, if they are not playing better than ther others, they simply cannot be seen as being better. :thumbup What we as fans want the team to be and what it is, unfortunately are two different things. Frankly I think the Nationals' organization has put together a very interesting team that will result in more off-season trade options than we have. I congratulate them. I'm happy for them. That doesn't mean I'm not a Marlins fan through and through or that I am envious or dispirited. Things are what they are. Sometimes you get the bear and sometimes the bear gets you. Next season could see a complete reversal for the Marlins. Nor does it mean that the Nats GM or better than the Marlins'. Who knew da Meathooks would have the year he had or any number of other players would be playing at this level based on their past performances? While not fun for us (Marlins fans) it is what makes baseball "fun". The Nationals are respectable again. I say good job.
  20. Well, my guess would be (since he's not currently on the 40 man) that they don't want him cluttering the 40 man if he doesn't make the 25 man next year, but also don't want to risk him to waivers. They(his fam) is hoping he gets drafted in the RuleV There is going to be a bumper crop for Rule 5 players in 2008. Moving the eligibility date back a season as they did in the last collective bargaining agreement sets this year up have lots of choices at any number of positions. If he is Rule 5 eligible perhaps the Marlins already know what they have in him and don't need to be showcasing him when the outcome (2007 season) isn't going to change. Just guessing. Is Dean Treanor coming up to the Fish as well?
  21. Hey I'm just postulating because (as a fan) it doesn't make a lot of sense. Considering the Marlins have gone out and gotten the guy TWICE you have believe he interests them. I wasn't surprised Hoover was called up but if what you're saying is Baker is definitely not being called up (or the Marlins haven't indicated anything ala the AFL is in his future) you really have to wonder. If you hear more I'd like to know as much as the next guy. Thanks BTW for the heads up.
  22. There could be a number of factors why Baker wasn't or hasn't been called up yet. I don't think there's any grand conspiracy or incompetence on the part of the FO, in fact you would think the opposite. After all, Your current catcher is making $2 million and headed either out of town or to arbitration, and Baker would make a fifth or less of that were he to show he was able to step in, so for all you people who are always complaining the Marlins are skin flints they would of course be looking at the guy if there was/is a reason to do so. More likely, and there is a number of reasons why (???) he isn't with the team ths morning, including exhaustion, family matters (I don't know if he's married but he may have asked go home for a few days), injury (catchers do get banged over the course of a season even in the minors) or a dozen others unthought of, including the Marlins are satisfied with scouting reports and the thoughts of Dean Treanor and already know what they have in him. Or they want him to take some time off and evaluate him further in the AFL. From a fan perspective, sure there's interest in seeing who this guy is and how sharp are his tools, etc. Maybe Ramp can find out, I thought I would check with someone later in the week but while I'm a little disappointed (I admit to never have seen him play) these things have a way of working themselves out.
  23. And that is why Cody Ross isn't starting. Zero contact in the at bat after the count was 3-0.

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.