Everything posted by Marlins2003
-
There's a CFer out there
There is a big reason why this guy was one of the most hated players in Tigers history.... 820728[/snapback] And that reason is ?????
-
There's a CFer out there
Not only did he have good numbers at Tampa Bay in the first few months 2005, in 2004 at Detroit he played in 79 games, had 300+ ABs and batted .322. He's not without his flaws, but nowhere can I find a negative comment with his arm, although I doubt he's a Vlady, his defensive problems seem to be that he gets poor jumps on the ball and takes meandering routes from time to time. But let's face it, we're more interested in his bat than anything else. BTW, to dispel the notion this season is a flash in the pan, he's a career .297 hitter.
-
There's a CFer out there
Personally I'm not of a mind to jettison JP for Alex Sanchez. At least not yet. But acquiring Sanchez and seeing what he can do makes alot of sense to me (with my limited knowledge of the guy) for a number of reasons, all of which I've mentioned here and in previous posts.
-
There's a CFer out there
From what I've read the reasons the Rays dropped him were three-fold, maybe four-fold. First, he wanted to play everyday and not DH, and was vocal about it. Second, the Rays thought when they cut him they had Baldelli coming back and then oops, two days later, they found out Baldelli WASN'T coming back and it was too late, and third they wanted Gomes up who was setting AAA on fire and to his credit has continued to do so since being called up. There was also the question in TB of who would leadoff, which by everyone's admission is Sanchez's best spot in the lineup, but Pinella preferred to lead-off with Crawford, only frustrating Sanchez more. There were questions about his occassional defensive lapses in CF, the Rays preferring to play him right, but we all know who they have in right field and he isn't going to be moved (position-wise). Clearly Sanchez dug his own grave in Tampa Bay with the steroid thing and mouthing-off but heck, the man can hit. In fact in the month of May he set the all-time monthly BA record for TB hitting .372. Gimme some of that I say. As for why he hasn't been signed yet, tomorrow he becomes an unrestricted free agent. The Rays, like the Reds with Danny Graves, couldn't get anyone to bite knowing he was about to be a FA, and my guess is he'll be somewhere soon.
-
There's a CFer out there
...who needs to redeem himself in the eyes of the baseball community, who was hitting .346 when he was cut loose, who's from Miami, and could, at least in the short term, provide the spark at the top of the lineup this team needs to get back into contention. Of course I'm speaking about Alex Sanchez, he of the failed steroid test, he of the sullied reputation, who could be had for virtually nothing and who in case you're interested will be an unrestricted free agent tomorrow. And since the Devil Rays are on the hook for his contract a look see would cost the Marlins only about $200,000 for the rest of the year. Now no one is a bigger fan of JP than I am but right now, today, I'll take that 100 point differential in BA (.346 vs .249) in front of a red-hot Luis Castillo, Miguel Cabrera and Carlos Delgado and see if that's the spark we need to jumpstart this offense and start scoring runs. Sure his defense isn't on a par with Pierre's and when you look up Alex Sanchez in the dictionary there's a big, big question mark there, but hell someone tell me what other .350 hitter is out there for $200k? I say sign him. Hold your nose. Don't think twice about it. The worst he can do is not do better than JP has been doing and the upside for this team is enormous.
-
Rumor
I'm still confused that we sold Miadich's contract to Japan. 820258[/snapback] You know I am too. I asked three people and got two responses, one of whom is often quoted here as an expert on minor league ballplayers. His answer was the usual non-answer answer, that Miadich had failed in the bigs before and that his performance in Albuquerque was an aberration. The other answer was that it was Miadich who asked to go to Japan seeing little chance of making back to the MLs.
-
Travis Smith on Saturday
For the life of me I don't understand the unending negave comments aimed at Travis Smith. He's had by my count one bad outing which was more Smith taking one for the team, and overall he's provided reasonable innings, as he did tonight, when called upon. Don't get me wrong. Travis Smith is not Nolan Ryan. Nor am I saying he's a great pitcher. He's closer to Moehler than he is AJ to be sure, he's a guy who has to work to get outs, but I don't think he's the bum some here are hinting at.
-
6/21 Florida Marlins @Atlanta Braves -- 7:35
Anyone watching PAX just saw a wonderful piece with Lenny "the Hitman" Harris. What a tremendous interview and great insight. :thumbup
-
Could and Should the Marlins hire......
"...If Gullett can make chicken salad from chicken sh*t - he wouldn't have gotten fired!!" 819201[/snapback] Best line of the day ! :thumbup (making a note to use it myself one day hehehe)
-
Dillon at Third next two games???
Agreed. I don't think salaries are the overriding concern, but I think they at least play a part. I think you're right about the established players for several reasons. You know what you're getting with them, they're proven winners, and the organization would take a massive PR hit if they start dumping starters. Too many people would interpret it as a white flag or a fire sale. That said, I think they need to make some kind of move with the offense, whether its moving Enc, Pierre, or Lowell, or just changing hitting coaches. I'm against calling up a minor leaguer if they aren't going to play him. Either call them up and give them a shot, leave them in the minors to get more experience, or trade them to improve the club. They're only hindering their development by calling them up and sitting them for weeks at a time. Better to go with guys like Cangelosi, Eisenreich, or Harris who know their roles, accept them, and can be productive. 819158[/snapback] :thumbup
-
Dillon at Third next two games???
Folk, I'm not saying this to be argumentative, but I don't think it's the money per se, but rather the thought that "who would you rather have down the stretch and into the playoffs, guys who have been there and know what's expected of them to win or kids who don't"? Say what you want about a Jeff Conine or a Mike Lowell but you know that they are winners and as we learned in 2003, they know how to win.
-
Dillon at Third next two games???
And yet Miguel Cabrera was promoted from AA and put in the lineup. Given all the rumors swirling about Enc being offered to the Nationals, the most likely answer is that Enc is being played to showcase him for a trade. Whether that means Conine would start or they'd call up Willingham or someone else remains to be seen. To say Jack doesn't play rookies requires you to explain why Cabrera was starting instead of Encarnacion at the end of 2003. It also ignores the front offices' part in determining who plays as well as the impact salaries can have on that decision. I do question the idea of calling up young guys who sit on your bench and never play like Aguila. They usually don't have the patience or mindset to handle that role like an older player (Lenny) who knows his limitations and is comfortable coming off the bench. They'd be better off playing regularly in the minors. 819032[/snapback] The difference (between Cabrera being called up and used vs. others not getting playing time) is, at least to me, two-fold. First Cabrera's skills were almost legendary by the time he made it to the show, and second the Marlins were not in contention, or were not thought of being in contention when Cabrera came up. It would be much more risky, considering the high expectations for the 2005 Marlins, to bring up and play a defensively untested Willingham (or to a lesser degree, Aguila or fillintheblank) in the outfield. I'm not saying I agree with all these decisions being made but this is how I see it. Were it not for the questions surrounding the stadium, the obvious problems confronting the team's pitching corps in 2006, and the need to continue to build the fan base, just for the fun of watching young kids mature, I wouldn't mind seeing the team blown up and guys like Willingham and Aguila (since those are the two we're discussing here) playing everyday. But in order to do that you need to move Lowell and several others in the starting lineup and that just isn't going to happen I don't believe.
-
Dillon at Third next two games???
We're all amazed that Willingham hasn't be tutored and given a chance to play the OF this season, but he has hasn't. I don't know what other conclusion you can come to (regarding the thnking of the Marlins FO) except that they see him exclusively as tradebait and believe with a ton of good OF prospects in the minors (on every team) that a big-bopping catching prospect has inherently more value on the open market and they're grooming him for just that eventuality. It also seems clear the Marlins have Hermida penciled in as their outfielder of the future and that may further block Josh. While I understand and share your frustration, from what I can see they have a plan and they're sticking to it. As for Aguila vs Willingham, which in itself may be an unfair comparison, I think you'd have to agree Aguila is the more complete (major league ready) ballplayer right now. If Encarnacion was traded and the next day Conine tore a hamstring, I'd bet Aguila would playing RF before Willingham.
-
Deal with the Devil
I think it was Boog who was opining that Mota has pitched a tremendous number of innings over the past few years (and I suppose I should look it up before I continue this post but I'm not) and may be suffering from "tired arm". As Rferry suggests, the same may be true of Gordon. If both are correct, all the Marlins are doing is jumping out of the frying pan and ino the fire.
-
Dillon at Third next two games???
For the life of me I don't understand why so many people here think Josh Willingham "deserves" (operative word in this post) anything, nevermind being catapulted over established major league players to start in right field when he isn't getting a second's playing time at that position at Albuquerque. By now some people reading this are fuming, so be it. I'm not anti-Willingham, and the guy is doing an extraordinary job at AAA this season, but he doesn't "deserve" to be on the major league active roster anymore than anyone else who is playing well, for example Chris Aguila who is outhitting him by 30 points and has proven he can play the position "deserves" to be. The Marlins have made their decision about who will be catching now and in the future, it's Paul LoDuca and Matt Treanor. There's no room for Willingham for the foreseeable future. Better to let him continue to put on the offensive display he has so far this season at Albuquerque (although he's showing signs of cooling off, batting .167 in his last five games) where he may draw interest from a ML GM in search of a backup catcher who he believes he can mold him into a future everyday player, and hence have value, than to be the number three guy for the Fish or worse, come up, play out of position, struggle at the plate and ruin any chance the Marlins have of trading him for someone of value. I used Chris Aguila as an example (above) for a reason. He should be a good example to all of us, batting .368 since returning to the PCL, that hitting in the bigs and hitting in AAA are two entirely different things. I like both players but unless Admin Beinfest plans on blowing up the Fish and starting over, neither are going to get any significant playing time here in 2005 (or at least until the September call-ups). It isn't that Jack misuses rookies, it's just (assuming Encarnacion is gone at the time one of the kids come up) in a choice between either and Jeff Conine in right field, Niner is going to win out regardless of who the manager is. The same is true of Dillon. There isn't a manager in baseball who is managing a contending team, who would sit down Lowell and not put Cabrera at third before Joe Dillon. Just isn't going to happen. And it isn't going to happen for Willingham either, certainly not in right field. And probably not in left either.
-
Marlins are 2 games back!!
Boy this series with the Braves is becoming all important as we move further and further back not just in the standings but in games played. We're now four games behind Philly and the Nats in games played. When crunch time comes and we have to make up those games we need to have a lead in the division or September is going to be ugly around here.
-
Deal with the Devil
Good addition JJ. With Kotsay and Preston Wilson out there, more in the mold of Yankees personnel, it seems, at least to me, JP would at best be a third place choice.
-
Chances of Steve
There's conflicting reasons why starting Conine could be good and bad for the club. If the objective is to trade Encarnacion for the best possible player in return, then in the short term it may be better to play him and give him a chance to redeem himself, not in our eyes or fans generally, but rather in the eyes of professional scouts and GMswith whom we ultimately want to deal. With roughly a hundred games to go (and a pretty good idea already what the pluses and minuses are with Jeff Conine) playing Enc, while risky, may be the right way for the team to go in the long run. 817761[/snapback] And what if Encarnacion continues to play poorly and have his average drop even more in the next few weeks? I don't think other GMs would appreciate that. I say decrease his starts now before he hits the wall and teams stop showing interest in him. 818565[/snapback] I alluded to the risk of Encarnacion underperforming if he's showcased but after his performance in LA every GM in baseball has already discounted his value. I doubt it could be diminished further so most of the opportunity (to increase his trade value) is on the upside.
-
Jack Forgetting Names
Can some Mod please put this thread out of its misery and lock it? Sheesh. :thumbdown
-
Dillon at Third next two games???
I have no problem with Dillon at third TONIGHT seeing as it is an off day 818355[/snapback] Finally.
-
What are our Trading pieces?
The next six games will help determine how the FO approaches the upcoming trade deadline. If the team returns to South Florida four or more games above .500 (which would mean winning two more than we lose of the next six), thus having an overall successful roadtrip, then I doubt you'll see much interest in making a blockbuster (read trading one of our "star" players) move. If on the otherhand if we return sporting a .500 record for the trip, or worse, big changes may be at hand. While I remain not in the "trade Enc" camp I can see where he is a likely trade candidate as is Willingham, Mota and potentially others. I find it difficult to believe AJ will be traded if we're in a competitive position, especially with Beckett and Leiter iffy for their respective reasons. I can't imagine Dillon stays with the club much longer without being given a chance to contribute more. That roster spot needs to be made more productive. And as much I like the Joe Dillon story, there's no trade value there. Harris continues to do his thing and such will remain for the rest of the year. Perhaps Damion Easley (getting on my flack jacket) would pique the interest so some GM, but at what price to the bench? If trading Easley meant acquiring a missing component, I'd be for it. At this point, having heard nothing to the contrary, I think it's safe to conclude Tim Spooneybarger won't be contributing this season. Let's hope Alfonseca can. So in the end, unless you want to drop a bomb on the team and blow it up, it looks like Damion, Enc, Willingham and perhaps Olsen are our four best pieces of tradebait. The rest of our minor leaguers, if used, will be add-ins on trades as window dressing.
-
Beckett DL, Bump back
I still don't understand the support for him. There are hundreds of relievers out there that can match his skill. 817784[/snapback] While I think your number is an exaggeration (to make a point), that is what Nate Bump is, an average, going to do well one day, not the next, can't really handle pressure cooker well, but won't humiliate himself either, pitcher. They come, they go. They are interchangeable on this team and every team in baseball. The game can't survive without them. Imagine how boring the game would be if every pitcher was Bob Gibson incarnate. Or Lee Smith.
-
Jack Forgetting Names
Both you...(looking sternly)...go to time out ! :nono
-
Jack Forgetting Names
I'm familiar with the Christian Science Monitor, and their reputation for non-sensationalism, but to say it's not biased is a bit ridiculous. It is still fiscally responsible to the church. 817819[/snapback] Ridiculous? Their coverage of world and national events is at the pinnacle of unbiased news reporting. If you knew anything about the church or the newspaper you would know that they are about unbiased as any publication that exists. They carefully separate anything that has to do with the church from event-driven news so there is never a question about their integrity. Go to csmonitor.com and see for yourself. You really have to search the website (or the newspaper) to find any hint that they are parented by a church. As a news organization they are probably more independent from their financial backing than say Richard Bush is at the Miami Herald.
-
Jack Forgetting Names
The Christian Science Monitor happens to be a great and highly ethical international newspaper with a stellar record of reporting (and for the record I'm neither a Christ Scientist nor have I ever been affiliated with the paper) and breaking important stories of world-wide import. I used their name for a purpose. Laugh if you will but scandalized papers like the Miami Herald could learn alot from the standards set at that newspaper. I may be mistaken but I believe Boog made some mention regarding this last week, referencing in passing the inappropriate (he didn't call the reporter a de facto liar) comment that appeared and then spread throughout the media like so many rumors are spread by lazy and by my standards inept reporters who populate far too many newsrooms and media outlets in America today. We've all seen how a Mike Berardino slur or "trade" circulates and becomes "fact" within days. Most reporters will take other reporters word for it instead of checking the facts themselves. Such is life in the 24 hour news business today. So, while I cannot put to bed, or give definitive evidence of what transpired perhaps someone else out there can second what I believe Boog said. Otherwise let's all drop this.