Everything posted by Marlins2003
-
Bonifacio
He's also tied for most errors by NL thirdbaseman this is the first time he's played 3rd. I'm sure it's a very hard position to learn on the fly. I agree with everyone that he is not our best option at 3rd base but I think with a little bit of tinkering mixed with some hard work and dedication on Boni's part he can be a great player. He doesn't even have a full season worth of work yet, it's not like he's been around since 2006 and still can't put it together. I have to believe even his biggest detractors (haters) had to see how good he looked at shortstop, a position he's had previous experience at. And if that's the case there's no reason to believe that with experience he can't become a very competent third baseman. I know this might not mean much to those who ignore Chipper Jones has thirteen errors as well or David Wright and Ryan Zimmerman are right behind him with twelve each, but I find some comfort in the fact his errors are pretty evenly split between fielding and throwing. If for example all or most of his errors were fielding that implies an inability to field the position or if most were throwing errors I'd say he doesn't have the arm to play there but the fact that more than halfway through the season he only misplayed six or seven balls put in play doesn't concern me, nor that six or seven times in 90 games he's made a bad throw at a position he never played before. Bonifacio has a long way to go before he earns the respect of his detractors and even some of us who say give the guy a chance to succeed before you brand him a failure, but he does seem to be "getting it" and I'm hoping he can build on what he's accomplished in June and July when the second half of the season restarts on Thursday night.
-
Ayala Gets the Call, Anibal Moved to 60-Day DL
Whether it happens or not he'll be eligible to pitch again the end of the first week in August. He originally went on the DL the first week of June so it's already been roughly five weeks. Re: Ayala. While his stay with NOLA was brief he performed well in this three one inning appearances giving up no runs and a single hit with three strikeouts.
-
Lindstrom Update
This is a great example of the front office knowing so much more than we do here especially in light of Joe Frisaro's recent comments that we were questioning what they meant just last night and this morning. It certainly puts Ayala, Donnelly and Williamson signings in perspective, especially the latter who hadn't pitched since 2007.
-
Marlins "Want to Add"
I'm confused. These statements seem contradictory to me. I believe paragraph two (Beinfest quotes) refers to the immediate short term and the opening one (Frisaro's thoughts) to the remainder of the season.
-
Marlins "Want to Add"
I suspect at this point, with the stadium deal now online, as unsavory as it might be the Marlins may look at good hitters with bad contracts where taking on the financial liability translates into minimal compensation going to the other side. Player X is owed $30 million over the next three years and is playing well, but not $30 million "well". Plus all he's doing is holding back someone in their minor league system that they'd like to bring up. Where in the past if the Marlins were interested in Player X they would want his existing club to pick up most of what he's owed and compensate them with prospects, this go around they'll pick up $20 million of the $25 still owed in hopes he plays well and they can move him this offseason even if it costs them another $5 million to do so knowing they can be on the hook for everything if they're wrong. Scouting reports indicate a change of scenery and a bit more protection in the lineup can make Player X significantly more productive. This is a big departure from their usual business plan but if the playoffs are the goal they'll have to take risks they were never willing to take before.
-
Marlins "Want to Add"
So... do you trade Sean West (I suspect even though he's hit this rough patch he has big time value on the trade market)? do you trade Aaron Thompson? do you trade Cristhian Martinez? do you trade Chris Coghlan (His MLB progress report probably looks a lot better than his stats would indicate)? do you trade Rick VandenHurk? If you're "adding" it's those above + Class A and High A prospects. There's isn't much left at AAA/AA after the guys mentioned above.
-
Hermida for Capps?
i HAVE TO RUN, i'M LATE BUT A) i JUST PLAIN FORGOT TO MENTION bONIFACIO'S OFFENSE (OOPS) B) the age thing wasm't even a factor in my thinking, rather MLB experience time. But you're points are valid.
-
Hermida for Capps?
Wait, hold on a second. You're telling me Hermida, who is 25, is FAR removed from the learning curve, but Bonifacio isn't? Bonifacio is 24 years old. And if you bring up the fact that he is actually hitting the ball now, let me remind you about 2007. You know, when Hermida was 22 years old, and was good for more than 2 weeks. If Hermida is gone because he isn't producing and is far from the learning curve, then Bonifacio should have been gone the first day of June. It always comes down to this and it makes zero sense. Comparing two players who share little in common. Hermida was a high draft pick and from day one on the fast track thru the minors to MLB. He's playing his position of choice, he makes millions of dollars (which is the root problem, performance vs pay), has four years experience which translates into making millions more in upcoming years. Justifiably, he's held to a higher standard, more is expected of him. Worse for him, he had a period of eleven weeks in 2007 when he played incredible baseball and since then perhaps unfairly, he's been judged by that summer as the standard of play expected. If he had turned what started out to be a lousy year for him (2007) into a good but not spectacular one (say he wound up hitting .279 that season instead of .299) fans would have said he had a good year and expected less the next. He's become a victim of his own success. Hermida fans seem compelled to trot out 2007 as the answer to every complaint or comment they don't like about their favorite player. "Look what he did in 2007" is a line repeated in one form or another here a thousand times at least. I think it's actually detrimental to their case. This is after all about expectations. The guy who hits ten homeruns in a month is expected to hit ten homeruns EVERY month. Bonifacio is in his first year in the bigs, he makes the minimum or close to it and he's playing out of position by necessity not choice. There's a guy already playing where he should be playing that's pretty good and the manager said "go play there" so he did. It's on the job training for him and he's under a microscope, the product of an unpopular trade involving a popular Marlin (or two depending on your POV) and so many here prejudged him from the beginning staking out positions that demanded he fail so they could be right before they could even pronounce or spell his name. Having never played the position before he is on a steep learning curve, I don't know how anyone can deny that or hold that against him. Two players could not have begun their first seasons with the Fish more differently and with more different fan expectations. And as for where they are on their respective learning curves, one has been playing his position more or less his entire career and the other for roughly three months. Comparing the two is ridiculous, suggesting their learning curves are similar is ridiculous as well. Hermida's woes have as much to do with the salary structure in MLB as anything else, what he may need, here or elsewhere is to get off the arbitration merry-go-round and sign a reasonable multi-year deal he can live up to and then go about having a career. Unfortunately that probably isn't going to happen here so that's one of the reasons he stands a good chance of being traded by the deadline or after the season ends.
-
7/9 Post Game
I just happened upon this and thought it deserved at least an acknowledgment: "The Florida Marlins just keep coming. The Marlins, which actually appear to be some manner of angry marlin-piranha hybrid, simply do not give up. And the second that you doubt this team or think that they will go belly-up they Unleash The Fury and lay a Moby-Dick-on-Captain-Ahab beat down on your ass." by Robert Ferringo - 07/10/2009 http://www.docsports.com/2009/florida-marlins-042.html (edit) and from my Marlins sales rep: The Marlins trailed the Diamondbacks in the sixth inning, 7-0, but came back to win, 14-7. Only two other teams in Major League history have won by seven or more after trailing by seven or more in the sixth inning or later: the Cardinals in 1911 against the Reds (trailed 8–0, won, 15–8) and the Indians in 1999 against the Devil Rays (trailed 10–2, won, 20–11). Elias Sports Bureau
-
Hermida for Capps?
What if he has another great 2nd half? Then what, everyone will want him to stay and the second he doesn't do great he's a bust and a waste of money. Let's hope he does. This lineup needs another consistently productive bat in the lineup and it might as well be Hermida as anyone else.
-
Hanley's Status
...Retire the tin-foil hats. :thumbup lololololololololololol
-
Hermida for Capps?
It's BS though. Hermida is 25 years old. He had an . 870 OPS TWO YEARS ago. You can't just give up on him. Hermida is currently not playing up to, nevermind exceeding, his contract. Next season he'll receive at least a million more, maybe two solely based on service time. In 2007 he was making chump change so getting hot for eleven weeks after missing the first month and a half of the season and putting up some phenomenal numbers in the process is great but this is 2009 and he's not. Nor is there any evidence he'll perform better in 2010. Someone can correct me but the closest to catching fire offensively this year was one five game streak. Otherwise his numbers have trended down for two months (more or less). This is not a matter of "giving up" on anyone, it's solely a matter of moving on without a player who can't perform up to the level expected for what he's being a paid. There isn't a single person on this board who doesn't want Hermida to go on another eleven week ball bashing marathon but recognizing that he's looking less and less capable of that is just being realistic.
-
Hermida for Capps?
...Second, they haven't been trying to trade Hermida for a year. More like the past month (unless if you're talking about the Manny Ramirez rumors last year, which is insane. If anything that says something for certain clubs believing in Hermida's potential...that's not just trading him for nothing). And a lot of that has to do with him underachieving this year, yes...also has a lot to do with his contract, and the fact he'll likely not be here next year. I'll leave to others to decide what's insane and what is idolatry. http://www.mlbtrader...-ramirez-3.html links to a dozen or so legitimate pieces on the subject not Tim Deirkes editorializing http://www.fangraphs...y-hermida-deal/ a favorite website here http://sports.espn.g...tory?id=3511804 http://fantasysports...884&line=245556 USA Today recap there are quotes in the above from virtually every reporter from Gammons to Olney to Rosenthal to Salibury referencing Hermida being part of that trade so please try to not tell me otherwise. The Marlins have been trying to trade Hermida for a year...live with it. That's great. Too bad you can't read. Either that, or you completely ignored what I wrote in parenthesis on the post you quoted. By "insane" I didn't mean they were insane rumors. I meant it's insane to think the Marlins were just trying to get rid of Hermida last year, considering they wanted Manny Ramirez back in return. Y'know...the same Manny Ramirez who's one of the best hitters in baseball? Those offers have nothing to do with trying to deal Hermida. More like sending Hermida in a package b/c you have to give to get. I realize it's difficult for you to admit you're ever wrong Erick but trying to disguise what you said doesn't cut it. This is not the Politburo where words don't mean the same thing today they did yesterday. You do that all the time try to explain your way out of what you said. No soap. Let me repeat myself, the Marlins have been trying to trade Hermida for a year. End of story.
-
Hermida for Capps?
...Second, they haven't been trying to trade Hermida for a year. More like the past month (unless if you're talking about the Manny Ramirez rumors last year, which is insane. If anything that says something for certain clubs believing in Hermida's potential...that's not just trading him for nothing). And a lot of that has to do with him underachieving this year, yes...also has a lot to do with his contract, and the fact he'll likely not be here next year. I'll leave to others to decide what's insane and what is idolatry. http://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2008/07/manny-ramirez-3.html links to a dozen or so legitimate pieces on the subject not Tim Deirkes editorializing http://www.fangraphs.com/blogs/index.php/the-manny-hermida-deal/ a favorite website here http://sports.espn.go.com/mlb/news/story?id=3511804 http://fantasysports.usatoday.com/content/player_news.asp?sport=mlb&id=1884&line=245556 USA Today recap there are quotes in the above from virtually every reporter from Gammons to Olney to Rosenthal to Salibury referencing Hermida being part of that trade so please try to not tell me otherwise. The Marlins have been trying to trade Hermida for a year...live with it.
-
Hermida for Capps?
I know you believe you are smarter than the collective wisdom of the Marlins front office but let's see what they come up. I go with the flow, figuring they know things none of us do. Catcher is one thing but you can't have platoons at every position, you run out of roster spots and game options pretty quickly doing that. Sooner or later one guy needs to trot out to right field every night and that's his position, especially in a pennant race. Why do you think they have been trying to trade Hermida for a year?
-
BJ Ryan
There is a huge red flag here. Ryan has to be seriously used goods here. At least Donnolly was performing in AAA. To just release this future all star, something isn't right. I think we have enough options without him. When you say something isn't right, don't immediately assume he's hurt. Remember when the Jays released Frank Thomas just before he hit one of the milestones in his contract. This could be something like that. Cot's doesn't have any details on incentives in Ryan's contract, but that doesn't mean that there aren't any. From what Cot's says, and it can be incomplete, Ryan gets paid regardless and without any additional incentive clauses.
-
Hermida for Capps?
If we trade Hermida for Capps, who the hell replaces Hermida? Obviously the front office is not too worried on that score after all they've been trying to trade the guy since last summer and no takers. I would guess A) they have another trade they can do B) they're will willing to give Carroll a real shot as an everyday player because of his superior defense or C) Maybin comes up or D) any of three candidates at AAA or E) anyone with a pulse. Seriously, no one is going to lose a minute's sleep worrying about who to replace Hermida with. They've had a year to plan for that eventuality. In truth though, I don't know whether Capps is the right guy here, regardless of who we might trade for him.
-
BJ Ryan
I just had to put this somewhere and I didn't think it deserved its own thread so for your reading pleasure: This is what passes for expert opinion in the blogosphere. "Over in the National League the Philadelphia Phillies, the Milwaukee Brewers, and the Florida Marlins are all weak pitching ball clubs that would improve their playoff chances significantly if they added Halladay to their roster." Whose chances wouldn't improve with Halladay...duh. http://www.crunchsports.com/category/MLB/MLB--Roy-Halladay-Trade-Rumors-200907080004/ "The Marlins have signed well-traveled relievers Luis Ayala and Brendan Donnelly to boost their injury-wracked bullpen, although it’s unclear if they’ll be able to make any splashier additions before the trade deadline. Word is any moves they make must be revenue-neutral, or at least come at minimal cost. What else is new? …" http://www.athlonsports.com/baseball/17029/nl-notes-braun-calls-out-pitching-staff "Yesterday afternoon, rumors spread that the Pirates are not done cleaning house and that they may make closer Matt Capps available in a trade for a power arm. The first team that came to mind was the Marlins who are back in the NL East race even though closer Matt Lindstrom is on the DL. The Marlins have a couple of pitching prospects in Ryan Tucker and Jose Ceda who they could trade to get Matt Capps. Here is what John Sickels from www.minorleagueball.com had to say about Tucker and Ceda: Ryan Tucker, RHP, Grade B: He needs another pitch if he wants to start, but the ceiling stands out as excellent. Jose Ceda, RHP, Grade B: Yet another high ceiling arm with command issues. Also has to watch weight. The Marlins would use Capps to close with Leo Nunez and Dan Meyer handling the setup duties. In return, the Pirates would get one of Tucker, who should start at the major league level or Ceda, who could replace Capps as the Pirates closer in 2010." http://www.faketeams.com/2009/7/2/935161/mlb-trade-rumors-matt-capps-to-the I just love research because you have to know BOTH are on the DL. You want them, they're yours.
-
Hermida for Capps?
Exactly. He's unlike other players and the circumstance around him coming up are much more complex than for others. Personally I'd like him to stay in AAA all season or until it's just plain embarrassing to have him there.
-
Hermida for Capps?
Just keep in mind there are not an unlimited number of roster spots.
-
Hermida for Capps?
(I'm asking rhetorically) Why not? If you're a decision-maker in a front office and you have knowledge your closer may not be coming back as soon as anticipated or his ailment isn't as "temporary" as the outside world thinks, regardless of the thoughts on this board that anyone can close, and you want one guy for the rest of the season you can go to night after night, I don't see why an outfielder is by definition not a suitable trade candidate. Forget who that player is, it's unimportant here. At this time of the season competitive teams have to make trade-offs in personnel if the playoffs are the organizational goal and this is just an example of that. Keep in mind it's the Marlins who are offering Hermida and not the other way around. We traded Jacobs for Nunez. We can trade Hermida for Capps except the other side isn't interested. This is after all the team that killed the Manny to the Marlins deal last season by demanding Stanton along with I believe Hermida, and the latter certainly hasn't improved his worth in 2009 with a big raise and weakening output. Talent-wise, I'll let others decide whether the deal makes sense because admittedly I don't know enough about Capps to form an opinion but I'm suggesting these hard and fast rules are made to be broken if the team gets better because of it. edit: I just noticed that Henry Owens is back on the DL again with a sore shoulder. I mention this only in the context of one less projectible summer callup arm they might have been counting on.
-
Hermida for Capps?
according to foxsports: Sources: Marlins still working to get Pirates closer by Jon Paul Morosi...is a national MLB writer for FOXSports.com. In need of bullpen help, the Marlins have maintained contact with the Pirates about closer Matt Capps, sources said Wednesday. But the sides aren't close to a deal, in large part because Pittsburgh seems to have little interest in outfielder Jeremy Hermida, one of Florida's primary trade chips. The Marlins have already included Hermida in an offer for Capps, sources said, but the Pirates declined. It's not clear if other players were involved on either end. Financially, at least, the two players would have made for a straightforward 1-for-1 deal: Capps is earning $2.3 million this year, Hermida $2.25 million. Both players are on track to enter free agency after the 2011 season. With closer Matt Lindstrom on the disabled list, the Marlins would like to stabilize their bullpen. Capps, who has converted 19 of 21 save opportunities this year, is one of their top choices. He is 1-4 with a 4.71 ERA in 31 appearances. Pittsburgh is still sorting through suitors for Capps, although one source said the Pirates don't appear entirely certain that they will move him before the July 31 trade deadline. Hermida's slugging percentage has declined since last year, although he remains a formidable left-handed hitter with a .249 average, eight home runs and 30 RBIs. He's become more expendable recently because of Brett Carroll's development in the big leagues and Cameron Maybin's presence at Triple-A. http://msn.foxsports.com/mlb/story/9787154/Sources:-Marlins-still-working-to-get-Pirates-closer
-
Tim Wood optioned to AAA
I could be confusing Sanchez with someone else but wasn't there an issue regarding him not being a good candidate for the bullpen because it takes him so long to get ready and once he's warmed up he has to pitch or the effort was wasted for a couple of days?
-
BJ Ryan
Since money won't be the issue and you have to think the only teams seriously considering signing the guy are all contenders, the question for Ryan becomes who will sign him to a major league contract and who will send him to the minors and make him show he belongs in the show. The Marlins may not want to upset a bullpen that's working and with Kiko coming back, to make room for a guy who needs to prove himself, and is effective only in limited situations. They may want him to go to NOLA first and that may be a deal-killer. Let's face it, they can't keep Ayala, Donnelly AND Ryan all happy and all at the ML level without making a lot of moves in the current bullpen and ruffle a lot of feathers.
-
Scott Williamson
Do you think the Marlins are taking a look at him? I honestley wouldn't mind him on the Marlins. I wouldn't mind either but not for big money. I believe plenty of teams would be interested in him and would probably give him better offers. He was released. For the remainder of the time on his contract Toronto is on the hook for everything except the pro-rated amount of the league minimum due this year and the minimum in 2010 and beyond (I didn't bother to look up how many years remain). Are you sure he only gets the pro-rated next season? That's not what I said. This season the acquiring team is only responsible for the pro-rated minimum. Next season, 2010, the acquiring team is responsible only for the ML minimum. Think Damion Easley.