Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Marlins2003

Members
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Marlins2003

  1. Teams Hot After Heath By Eddie Schmid [July 29 at 10:44pm CST] Echoing Buster Olney's earlier reports, Ken Rosenthal and Jon Paul Morosi at FOX Sports are saying that the Marlins are indeed the most aggressive of 10 to 15 teams looking to add Heath Bell. The Marlins have the prospects to get a deal done and "could easily absorb" the $400k left owed to Bell this season. However, the Padres are said to want the Marlins' top pitching prospects in Sean West and Andrew Miller if such a deal were to happen, a high price to pay. Probably more bad syntax than anything else, "and" becomes "or" in a quick rewrite and confusion reigns until it gets sorted out. Frankly I see the need for at least another arm at the ready down the stretch but someone has to go to AAA to make room, or a trade then you're where you are, they might be better this with a Rhodes (who I've mentioned before and only will again because the Reds have lost eight of their last ten). Not that I see Rhodes and Hermida as equivalents because I don't but it did dawn on me last night watching Hermida's long out to right center how much better a career he might have in Cincy than Miami.
  2. Wells was one of those guys who was huge here, he and Rios, neverending chatter on MB>com about trading for him years ago but as NNy that it never happened was a good thing. As for Ross I can't imagine them trading him unless there's a big upgrade coming back in another move, that is if you believe the Fish are contending and it's hard to see them not, at least for the foreseeable future. We can kill two birds with one stone this weekend with the Cubs coming to town.
  3. I'm not sure why in this economy "renting" isn't the way to go. With two months left roughly two-thirds of a player's contract for the season has already been paid and the acquiring team has had enough time to gauge what they're getting based on the player's performance to date. Things really seem to be heating up too. It looks like there's a chance we might even wind up with a flood of transactions after all. Congrats to Tim Dierkes and MLBTR, he's taken the Drudge Report model of aggregating rather than trying to be his own source, ala Rotoworld, and has created a really valuable resource. He's really come a long way in a year.
  4. I'm really amazed at how many teams appear to have a legitimate interest in Ross. That's not in any way a disparaging comment about him, I'm just surprised at the level of interest.
  5. Please Lou, you're just embarrassing yourself. It's good to see in print that you are doing this with malice of forethought and that when I say for example "$3million +/-" you are willing to just lie through your teeth and pretend that means $5 million so you can make some spurious argument based on what you say I said rather than what I actually said. And now you are the victim...god you are sad. Me thinks you doth protest too much.
  6. Idk if you guys have read this, but the yanks are after snell supposedly.. Here's a piece from the article: Two others in Indianapolis, starters Ian Snell and Tom Gorzelanny, are drawing interest. Snell had another strong start yesterday, and his ERA after six starts is 0.96. The New York Yankees have watched Snell in his past two starts. Gorzelanny has a 2.46 ERA after 14 starts there and, most important, has shown improved aggressiveness and velocity of late. -- Pittsburgh Post-Gazette .....Ben's Take: NYC tabloids would have a field day with Ian Snell's name. Actually, and don't take this the wrong way, I read it and laughed...the idea that he'd survive better in NYC than Pittsburgh is gallows humor. Is the bronx really where you'd choose to go for a mental health break? :brigginbounce I feel tremendously sorry for the guy as I do for Allison and Greinke and Ankiel and Zotto and the rest who for one reason or another just can/could not cope with a life most of us would think would be a glorious ride. It was one of the reasons that I thought perhaps a place like Miami might be a good landing spot for him, or Gorzelanny, both of whom I find interesting.
  7. Wow. You've forgotten more about baseball than I've ever known. Is that right? Get over yourself bro. Your pathetic. Wrong and pathetic. Most of what you've suggested I said is a flat out lie, but not surprising because that's the only way you roll. I never said for example the Pirates would eat his entire salary in a trade, prorata minimums aside, but I guess your argument only works if you say that's what I said. I said it was about risk management. It's the same old same old with you. The hate. The bullying. The absolutism. The demand everyone agree no matter how off-base you are. You haven't changed one bit since you slithered in here. We'll see as Ian Snell's career plays itself out who was closer to the truth. But if people actually went back and read what I said they'll see very little of it has anything to with your usual hate-filled tirade. What Pittsburgh does about it is certainly not a lock. That team, especially with all the turmoil they've undergone internally may opt to get out from under the totality of that obligation and figure that since he is by every description damaged goods eating $3+/- million and getting a John Raynor (please don't fixate on the name, let me rephrase, a good projectible prospect) in return represents less risk and the potential for a higher reward than a guy who tells the media (paraphrasing) "I'm not interested in pitching for them again". I mean, your own post last page defeats your own post here. This is why I love you. You are so predictably inconsistent. This is what I'm calling you ridiculous for. Even hinting Pitt is going to eat serious money on Snell is beyond ridiculous and you know it. This is not Boston and Julio Lugo. This is Pittsburgh. There are no lies. I'm not putting any words in your mouth. I'm honoring your request not to make fun of your John Raynor example (which I most certainly would because it's horrible). I'm flat out saying, your suggestion of Pittsburgh eating a substantial amount of money on Ian Snell for a relative non-prospect type player is idiotic. Feel free to disagree, but you're wrong. And if/when they move him, they will not be picking up significant amounts of his contract unless they are getting something significant back. I'm going to say it again. Ian Snell is an asset despite whatever mental condition he is in. Pittsburgh is a small/mid market team and cannot afford to simply give assets away. Baseball is a business, and despite the assumption Snell mentally cannot play for them anymore, doesn't mean they will simply give him away. Everyone always needs pitching. He would be an instant DFA claim if released, and half the teams in baseball would offer some sort of package, and accept large portions of his contract, to get a 27 year old starter a year removed from a 1.33 whip/177 K season and obliterating the arguably most competitive minor league division. This is easy. As I said before, it's a good suggestion. It's a clear buy low. That's how the Marlins roll. It is not a buy nothing however. And that's it. You do this to yourself, you realize this. I guess math isn't your strong suit. You seem to think I'm saying they eat his entire obligation for a projectible minor league prospect that you don't care for regardless of what others think of him (middle of the road guy, may or may not have an MLB future, with some tools). What I said, and thank you for quoting it, was they might opt to eat around $3 +/- million of the roughly $5.25 million they are still on the hook for plus a prospect in effort to at least save themselves $2 million if they feel their position is hopeless and right now Snell is telling them he affirmatively doesn't want to be in Pittsburgh after he feels he was treated by people there. You want to disagree, that's fine, but at least stop the insults and bullying and mischaracterizations of what was said. Arguing that something another person allegedly said and didn't just on the face of it doesn't make a lot of sense nor does it accomplish in the end, anything. as I said to your young friend, let's see where this winds up when the dust settles, I'm comfortable with my stance, not the one you're trying to paint, but what I really said, because it's just common sense that if they have limited options, and a suicidal ballplayer who sent himself back to the minors just to get out of Pittsburgh would seem to limit their options, saving a couple of million is better than not saving a couple of million.
  8. You just proved nothing. Lou wasn't questioning whether or not he had depression, he was questioning whether or not Pittsburgh would be willing to pay his salary, as you said. That article states absolutely nothing whatsoever about that. His depression, *his* demons, his suicidal thoughts are the reason risk management becomes an important component in weighing his market value. That and the fact he says he doesn't want to pitch in or for Pittsburgh anymore. Either you didn't bother to read what was posted before this or you are just looking for an excuse to be you, I don't know, but it was cute, not very accurate but cute. The only thing that's "cute" is suggesting that the Pirates would eat 3+ million and get a John Raynor type prospect, and then after being called out on it, you decided to insult MarlinsLou (which you later said he hasn't changed with the insults, etc...that's not a double standard or anything), and you posted an article proving nothing (b/c no one was doubting that he was having depression problems. The only thing being questioned was whether or not the Pirates were willing to take most of his remaining salary). PS - Believe it or not, you're not the only person who has Google and knows how to use it. For some reason, you think "your" research is superior to everyone else's. It's not. So I guess that means you didn't read what I wrote. I didn't think so. As for insulting Lou what you mean is it's okay for Lou to attack me repeatedly in both an insulting and disparaging manner but if I say anything then Lou is the victim. Interesting. Hypocritical but interesting perspective. What you continue to ignore (or just didn't bother to read) was the Pirates ALREADY ARE on the hook for 100% of what he's owed. And of course that he has wildly underperformed his contract to date. I understand you have to ignore that and the rest of the facts at hand otherwise it would look like you had an agenda here but I doubt Pittsburgh has many options or Snell many suitors willing to pick up his contract at anywhere near it's face value and possibly compensate the Bucs with a player for the opportunity to do so. I'm perfectly willing to see how it all plays out and revisit the subject when there's some kind of conclusion and see who was closest in their analysis. I'm comfortable with my position, my real position not the one you and Lou have tried to paint because the truth is alien to you both, and since my words are memorialized, here no matter how many times to you try and claim I said something different, you can neither change what I said or how I said it.
  9. Henry Owens for 50 games for drug policy. Our bat boy for taking Brad Penny milk drinking bet. I think a few years ago the Marlins also suspended Olsen on there own. Olivo also got suspended due to his showdown with Jose Reyes at the end of the season. Which he served his suspension the next year with the royals. They sent Burnett away before the end of the season just to be rid of his cancerous self. Not exactly a suspension, just a "don't let the door smack you in the a** on the way out".
  10. You just proved nothing. Lou wasn't questioning whether or not he had depression, he was questioning whether or not Pittsburgh would be willing to pay his salary, as you said. That article states absolutely nothing whatsoever about that. His depression, *his* demons, his suicidal thoughts are the reason risk management becomes an important component in weighing his market value. That and the fact he says he doesn't want to pitch in or for Pittsburgh anymore. Either you didn't bother to read what was posted before this or you are just looking for an excuse to be you, I don't know, but it was cute, not very accurate but cute.
  11. First of all, I never contested or questioned the fact that Snell hates it in Pitt, has depression, is sad, or whatever. Articles add nothing to the point at argument, and brings up the recurring theme of you don't have any sort of reading comprehension, and then blame others for not understanding your point. Secondly, I've forgotten more about baseball than you've ever known, so please spare me educational talk. And name-calling defense? If we catalogued all your posts where you blast everyone nonsensically on this board because of their age, intelligence, creed, whatever, we'd be able to fill the Great Library of Alexandria. Trading low is one thing. Paying the remainder of 2009's salary is another. Paying $3.8ish (contract minus pro rated minimum) for him to pitch elsewhere next year, where Pittsburgh is a low/mid market franchise at best, where Snell is a relatively/sort of proven MLB starter, and now absolutely dominating AAA, is a completely different thing. I have no doubt Pittsburgh will move him if it is that bad, I simply question your lackadaisical comments suggesting Pittsburgh is going to bend over backwards and take it simply to accommodate a guy because he doesn't want to be there. This is clearly the first time one of those situations has arisen. Like you say, but still do not grasp. This is a business. Snell is an asset. Pittsburgh does not have many assets. They are not going to move him for a "john raynoresque" property and keep paying him a significant salary. Why would they? That does not help them in any way, shape, or form. Pitching is always in demand. Pittsburgh is not desperate to move him as they still control his rights for a significant amount of time. This can be a buy low. Absolutely. And the funny thing is, I think this could be a good idea, but your presentation of thinking Pitt is going to take whatever and qualifying it with, "we'll see how low Pitt will go," is simply wrong. This is not going to be "buy nothing." That is all I'm saying. Stop getting pissy when confronted with rationality. Wow. You've forgotten more about baseball than I've ever known. Is that right? Get over yourself bro. Your pathetic. Wrong and pathetic. Most of what you've suggested I said is a flat out lie, but not surprising because that's the only way you roll. I never said for example the Pirates would eat his entire salary in a trade, prorata minimums aside, but I guess your argument only works if you say that's what I said. I said it was about risk management. It's the same old same old with you. The hate. The bullying. The absolutism. The demand everyone agree no matter how off-base you are. You haven't changed one bit since you slithered in here. We'll see as Ian Snell's career plays itself out who was closer to the truth. But if people actually went back and read what I said they'll see very little of it has anything to with your usual hate-filled tirade.
  12. Congratulations Fredi :thumbup You too Hopper...
  13. "...But after his outing Sunday, Snell told WTHR-13 he has been battling depression and considered drastic measures about a month ago due to the growing negativity surrounding his struggles in Pittsburgh. He was 2-8 with a 5.36 ERA in 15 starts with the Pirates this year. "Sometimes people do stupid stuff and I had to fight it, not to do something stupid and take my life for myself and from my family and my parents," Snell told the station. The demons, Snell called them..." http://www.indystar.com/article/20090702/SPORTS18/907020405/Indians++Snell+deals+with+depression
  14. Maybe you missed the part where he makes it clear he doesn't want back in a Pirates uni. What Pittsburgh does about it is certainly not a lock. That team, especially with all the turmoil they've undergone internally may opt to get out from under the totality of that obligation and figure that since he is by every description damaged goods eating $3+/- million and getting a John Raynor (please don't fixate on the name, let me rephrase, a good projectible prospect) in return represents less risk and the potential for a higher reward than a guy who tells the media (paraphrasing) "I'm not interested in pitching for them again". If Ian Snell weren't Ian Snell and he was of sound mind and body your scenario might play out, but he's not, or at least there's no conclusive evidence, so the risk in any transaction has to fall predominantly on the Bucs. So because Snell doesn't want to be a Pirate, Pittsburgh will eat $4-5 million in salary and take a C+ prospect. That's stupid even for you. They aren't going to sell low on an asset. The name-calling when people make you look silly is your trademark. When you're wrong, try being a man about it and stop acting like a child. Ian Snell is damaged goods. Try doing just five minutes of research for once. The risk is high and therefore the price will be low. And for the Bucs that equates to how much risk they are willing to take. The business of baseball, especially this time of the year is just like any other business and the same rules apply. Just because you haven't learned them yet doesn't mean they aren't valid. Just to back up what I'm saying... Ian Snell Says Depression, Thoughts of Suicide Led to Self-Demotion to Minors Posted Jul 01, 2009 6:32PM By Pat Lackey There have been very few stranger soap operas in baseball this year than the Ian Snell saga in Pittsburgh. Expected to be one of the Pirates' top starters after signing a contract extension before the 2008 season, Snell has struggled on the mound in the past two seasons, posting 5.00-plus ERAs and struggling with his control. It all came to a head about a week ago when Snell asked the Pirates to be demoted, then gave a strange impromptu press conference where he lashed out at reporters and bloggers and talked about his need to get away from the negative atmosphere of Pittsburgh. On Sunday, Snell struck out 17 hitters in seven innings in his first start back in Triple-A. Wednesday, he talked to Indianapolis TV station WTHR and revealed that he's been battling depression and actually contemplated suicide about a month ago. He says he wanted the trip to Indianapolis to help clear his head because it's somewhere he's always liked pitching, having thrown a no-hitter with the Indians back in 2005. As a Pirate fan and as one of the bloggers that Snell lashed out at (I'll certainly admit to being critical of Snell on my own personal blog), hearing this from Snell is a pretty sobering thing. It's always easy to read quotes from players, watch them perform, listen to them talk, and assume that you know what's going through their minds. That's certainly not always the case. Snell is the fourth big-league player to openly admit to dealing with these sorts of issues this year, with Khalil Greene, Dontrelle Willis and Joey Votto spending time on the disabled list for stress and anxiety reasons. In the end, Snell's relationship with the Pirates may be damaged irreparably, and he may or may not ever pitch for them again. Whatever the case, I hope this trip to the minors helps him clear his head a little bit. It's always scary to hear of anyone dealing with the issues he has.
  15. Speaking of Ryan Tucker, is it good news that he and Chris LeRoux just came off the DL in time to be tradebait as needed? I think so.
  16. The reason I think they won't go for the "big" deal, especially that involves significant l/t money is to not bruise Hanley's ego or offend him in any way. No evidence, just a suspicion, they don't want to go there. They have a good deal with him and don't want to mess with it.
  17. There's a number of unrealistic players the Marlins (or more specifically, us fans) might want in return for Ross were he to wind up in Detroit, but realistically what could the Tigers offer that would make the Marlins a better team in 2009? Personally, as long as we're in contention I don't see how we're good trading partners.
  18. Ian Snell makes $4.25 million in 2010. ...and the Pirates are on the hook for every penny of it. The question becomes how much is the prospect they'd be getting in return be worth to them that would offset them picking up a big piece of his remaining contract? If they keep him in the minors and they don't trade him they remain stuck for the whole enchilada so it all depends on how much of a haircut they'd be willing to take. Pitt isn't going to eat any substantial cash, ESPECIALLY not for next year. If anything, you get the remaining contract value this year above the prorated minimum. It's in their best interest to reestablish him in the bigs, and their front office is not dumb anymore. This is just not a real possibility. Maybe you missed the part where he makes it clear he doesn't want back in a Pirates uni. What Pittsburgh does about it is certainly not a lock. That team, especially with all the turmoil they've undergone internally may opt to get out from under the totality of that obligation and figure that since he is by every description damaged goods eating $3+/- million and getting a John Raynor (please don't fixate on the name, let me rephrase, a good projectible prospect) in return represents less risk and the potential for a higher reward than a guy who tells the media (paraphrasing) "I'm not interested in pitching for them again". If Ian Snell weren't Ian Snell and he was of sound mind and body your scenario might play out, but he's not, or at least there's no conclusive evidence, so the risk in any transaction has to fall predominantly on the Bucs.
  19. Ian Snell makes $4.25 million in 2010. ...and the Pirates are on the hook for every penny of it. The question becomes how much is the prospect they'd be getting in return be worth to them that would offset them picking up a big piece of his remaining contract? If they keep him in the minors and they don't trade him they remain stuck for the whole enchilada so it all depends on how much of a haircut they'd be willing to take.
  20. It is one of those "tree falling in the forest" things but if you think about, simultaneously reaching base, at least the way the rule is being offered here and I have no reason to disbelieve this interpretation, suggests that since the runner was not out when he reached base (because the defensive player didn't touch the base ahead of him or he would be out, logic would suggest he's therefore "not out", or safe in this case.
  21. Interesting tidbit on Ian Snell who is eating hitters alive in AAA (in the Int. league, baseball's toughest AAA league) and does not want to rejoin the Pirates. Of course it's not his choice but when a minor leaguer gets quoted as such it speaks volumes about his availability and perhaps his mental health. I wonder what Ronnie Paulino thinks of his work? Could be a fifth/emergency/Badenhop replacement/etc. guy at the rate he's getting guys out. A couple of things maybe (there's an understatement) working against him though is he appears to have trouble getting past six or seven (in a stretch) innings an outing AND perhaps more importantly his bouts with depression and suicidal thoughts, but at least for me, if he can deal with them and be effective, who am I to judge the guy, or any of us for that matter? The other Pirate AAA arm of interest is Tom Gorzelanny who has been stellar this year in the same rotation as Snell. Both guys seem well suited for Landshark Stadium. These guys appear, at least superficially as the starter equivalents of Donnelly and Ayala and could each make excellent insurance policies. Just thinking out loud.
  22. the marlins need to wake up and do osmething like stop being stingy loria and get us something, a lee and martinez would be awesome, gives us that lefty starter we need and a catcher we need, i wouldnt mind arthur rhodes back either I doubt it's a matter of being stingy so much as the other side reasonably wanting a certain level and number of quality players back in return. In the case of the Indians whatever they asked for would probably be justified as opposed to the orioles, at least from what I've read, who are completely out in space as to what they want for Sherrill. Rhodes is a good choice because he'll neither break the bank nor require some outlandish prospect compensation, it would only be a matter if the Reds feel they are no longer contenders. Cincy has lost six in a row and is falling further and further back as the deadline approaches and while they saw themselves as "in it" a week ago, I don't know that they can justify that to themselves much longer.
  23. I don't know whether it's true or not but I've thought for quite a while that separating the two (Hanley, then Uggla) has been part of Uggla's problem, that hitting him down in the lineup was a mistake. (As sort of an experiment) I've been hoping that for whatever reason they found themselves reunited with Cantu hitting behind Dan to see what happened. edit: and I have no problem with Bonifacio hitting ninth, as we saw Pierre doing and obviously is happening in St. Louis.
  24. I'd still like to have Arthur Rhodes and Josh Willingham back for their play and their affordability, and it's not sour grapes or anything like that, I just think they both, for unique reasons, would be good fits down the stretch for the Marlins. And it appears they are both available to one degree or another.
  25. First of all it's crazy talk to suggest that Bonifacio has an arm too weak to play either third or the outfield. I bet I watched 30 (admittedly 2" x 2") feeds from Licey this winter most w/EB in right field and he's somewhere between Hermida and not near as good as Carroll. I think Bob's point was you wouldn't send him out to the outfield as a project knowing he had a weak arm, and clearly by now the FO has had the time to weigh his strengths and weakneses. It is another thing completely to trade for a Juan Pierre as part of a bigger, more important to the franchise, move knowing what can be expected from him in the field and at the plate. No one in the Marlins organization I suggest was surprised by Pierre's throwing ability the first time they saw him in centerfield sporting a Marlins uniform. The idea that EB doesn't have the arm also speaks poorly of Licey, one of the best winter league teams there are year in, year out, a team that would have sported Hanley Ramirez had the Fish allowed him to play. (He still worked out with the team frequently.) There was a lot of talent on that team, and a lot more that didn't make the cut, this isn't like the Panamanian or PR winter leagues where some teams needing to field a full squad were calling around looking for players or running tryouts for walk-ons a week before the season started. Playing for Licey in the DR is prestigious, and there shouldn't be an argument about the level of play there. It may not be MLB but on the world stage DR baseball and Licey in particular is consistently some of the best. Besides we've seen Bonifacio make enough plays at third (including last night) to know he can make the play, right now he has to learn "how to" consistently make the plays required of him. I suspect like Cantu the errors will fall off as the season goes on. At the same time I'm not convinced he's the third baseman much longer as it is a natural spot to look for more production and there are some third baseman being chatted up right now but were the Fish to play musical chairs I wouldn't be surprised to find him in left or right field come August 1st. And Erick I have to say your revisionist history is hilarious. When it comes to Bonifacio it's become a joke. The ball was bounced in the grass not in the dirt and it was done on purpose, it's a throwing technique you see everyday in MLB. I mean really. The ball wasn't dug out of the dirt in fact the ball was ascending and while low, Cantu didn't appear to have to struggle to make the play. It's getting pathetic the lengths you haters have to go to find something ugly to say about Emilio Bonifacio. For those who missed it or want see it again MLB titled that video clip "Bonifacio's Strong Throw" ( http://mlb.mlb.com/search/media.jsp?game_pk=245631&text=bonifacio%20third&start=0&hitsPerPage=12&hitsPerSite=10 ) you might want to listen to the Dodger's legendary broadcaster Vin Scully on the play and learn something, that is unless you think you know more about baseball than him too.

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.