Everything posted by jonnylons
-
Miguel Cabrera
It is funny how high everyone is on Cabs. I think you got it right Arnie - Cabrera's poise sold me. I knew the hype, had for some time. But when I saw this guy play, it was his poise at the plate that screamed star. He knows what he doing out there, and will only get better. This is kind of a non issue, until stats were used to show how good Cabs is in comparison to other notable 20-year old call ups. But Miggy has not had nearly as much hype as ARod recieved, or even as much as Sheff got when he came up at 19.
-
Rosters Expand Next Monday
You call up Stratton, you have power on your bench. We dont necessarily need that, but it is always valueable. Allen may get a call, especially since he lost his job (basically) to Cabrera. But I dont think we will see both these guys, one or the other. We have H-Worth who is getting more money and you have to be smart with the cash. I think we wont really be heavy with pitcher call ups either. Our staff is pretty dominant and when we get to the playoffs, we dont need that 5th starter. So you need to go with a lefty (Alvarez...?) or do you go with someone who is putting up good numbers. This is a good thread, and frankly, I dont see the Marlins doing a whole lot because they dont really have any immediate needs. I think Abe Nunez should get a call and leave Allen and Stratton down if that is what has to happen. That guy could spell any OF'er and give us a quality speed/power combo. He needs the experience too, as his average has never been too good in the bigs.
-
Offense slumping or great Rockie pitching?
I havent seen the games, but I have seen the scores. Now is not a good time to have the offense hitting the brakes, but it is by no means the end of the world. What do those of you who have seen the games think?
-
MLB on FOX
I'll be in Chicago this weekend, but I wont be thinking about the Marlins...got a lady friend waiting for me... :thumbup :mischief
-
Who is the Marlins top prospect?
I am going with our most vital prospect, and that would be Stokes. His development will be key to whether we keep Lowell or not. That being we might have to lose Castillo and Lee in order to sign him, and Stokes' emergence will be all that more important. I know that is not going to answer your question, but it is one way for me to decide. Ed, I am curious about this deal with LA. There are KC players involved, so I guess it would have been a three way deal. Who would LA have given up to KC? I dont think that we could have afforded to trade away Lowell, he is important for developing our future fan base (I feel kind of like Conine was with the early Marlins) and has been vital for winning. Interesting post though.
-
Thank God we didnt get DL Drew
I think Drew's injuries are mental. This guy could be healthy, but has no reason to stay healthy. Oblique injury? Please... Besides, it we got Drew it would have been for minor leaguers - none of which figure into current team success. I think if we really had the chance to get Drew we would have - and should have. You risk injury, and that is too bad, but the guy still has big time ability.
-
Ken Rosenthal to join the drool fest?
This is what winning does. Enjoy it. Because every year a team comes out like this, these 'experts' muse about their own blindness like it is something to be admired. They never learn, do they.
-
Long-Term Deals
I think as good as it would be to keep Pudge, we really shouldnt. Let him go on and get big money - in the AL. We keep Castro, he will cost us less money. We need to re-sign Lowell and Burnett. Yes, Burnett. If we have to lose Castillo or Lee, that is ok. I am willing to live with that. Castillo is going to be too expensive for us and Pierre will do the job just fine. Lee is above average, but we could better spend the money allocated to him at another position and just sign someone to hold over 1B until Stokes comes up. (See Braves with Fick - all you need is a guy who is solid with good defense).
-
From a Denver Newspaper
Why was that article written, now, and published in a Colorado newspaper. That is the question I want to have answered... :mischief2
-
LeBatard jumps on the bandwagon.
Le Retard still though wants to say something negative about this team. He cant, but he still tries to find ways. It is funny how he makes D Train out in his toilet paper - er, I mean column. Screw this guy, he thinks we actually need his opinion. If he had any kind of dignity, he would stand by what he wrote earlier in the year. But he cant, and I dont respect him then nor now. Same goes for Berardinosaur. Another guy who had to write something today in order to cover his butt.
-
How Many Polls will Nielsosky Make
Great post, this is what winning does. Makes us all a big ol disfunctional family... :laugh :jump I love you guys...
-
Todd Zeile released from Yankees?
There seems to be plenty of options available out there for the stretch run. I like this idea Ramp, but I think 83Gator got it right with, who do you drop to get him? I think this team is good enough as it is, but this sure is tempting to go out and get a 'former' Marlin.
-
LeBatard jumps on the bandwagon.
Le Retard still cant give credit. The guy is just a hack of a writer, in love with how he says things more than what he is actually saying. Geez, anyone, and I mean that in a bad way - like a monkey in an alligator suit or a yeti or some other animal - could do his job.
-
The Conflict of Interest Theory is now....
I am not a fan of replay either. It is still evidence that has to be interpreted by one person - in this case, an umpire. But it does 'standardize' the point of view for judgement, in that everyone, including the person making the judgment (umpire) has the same evidence to work with. If that is the case, then why is there a discrepancy still when one particular piece of evidence is presented to many people? For that, just have everyone watching vote for the call, that way MLB raises the stakes a little for everyone to be involved. But that is all ridiculous. There is no perfect system, period. Instant replay is ridiculous because it undercuts the authority of the judges on the field in the first place. If any ruling they make can be overturned because of what the cameras saw, then why not just have instant replay make all the calls? Why even have umpires in the first place. No, I think we need to evaluate the men/women doing their jobs and make sure the best are in place. This requires competition. This also requires that unions stop trying to cement people into their positions and promote competition within the organizations they supposedly protect. Have MLB evalutate the umpires, but have the Ump Union decide who to keep/fire, etc. Or reverse so that way there is a check and balance. Very interesting debate though.
-
Should Redman have talked to the press?
Johnny, There is supposed to be a figure head, the MLB office. The problem is that they don't have enough control over those umpires. They had to actually argue with a court that Ques-Tec was legal in the contract. The results are Ques-Tec in some ballparks and not others. I say make life a living hell for those umps who make mistakes. Umps are human, that's why they shouldn't be the only authority to call games. We need the ability to have a video challenge. So then, the problem is not the MLB office, but the Umpire's Union which is too powerful to allow MLB to intervene with new evaluating tools? I dont know if this is such a bad thing though either, but if MLB had any brains, they would divert the attention to the head of the Umpire's Union (there is such a thing...right?) and put the pressure on them. MLB should be the sovreign over all matters related to baseball, but it seems that the game has become too fragmentary in its infrastructure to protect its own interests. As a result, there is too much job security and not enough competition (and innovation) perhaps. Interesting side issue to all of this, but it still does not have to do directly with the Wolf situation.
-
Should Redman have talked to the press?
I think you are right CitanX, there has to be some figurehead to hold accountable for the actions of the umpires. I think this would help get things done by presenting the public with at least a face to go with the organization. I think the key thing with this Wolf fiasco is the perception though, not his missing calls. That is too subjective to make a judgement one way or the other.
-
The Conflict of Interest Theory is now....
Ramp, I hate to say it, but your ego is running wild here at the forum. You still cant admit that there is at least a perception problem with the Wolf thing? Hell, I said this back on the other thread - something no one seemed to notice - then Redman said the EXACT SAME THING. He is right, and, well to indluge my ego - so am I :shifty . There is a problem with perception, and it is ashame that Wolf the umpire's dream comes at the expense of his brother's dream. Wolf cannot be allowed to ump games that could possibly effect the Phils' chances. He has to be placed in the AL. Simple as that, and that is something MLB would have to make an exception for because the umpiring system is not AL/NL only squads anymore. Oh, and screw instant replay. We are not perfect, our games our not perfect, so lets not try and pretend that our instant replays will allow for perfection because the whole thing smacks with imperfection anyway! Let the people who play, play and let the people who judge/witness do their thing. And let the performance of those individuals determine whether they have a job or not.
-
Should Redman have talked to the press?
I am going to say this, but no one will read my damn post anyway. Redman is right on because he qualified his statement with a key word no one in here has even mentioned (other than myself) - perception. The perception is that Wolf is brother to Randy Wolf, another player on a team in heat of battle. To have an arbiter be blood related only puts forth a perception that there could be a problem. It is a tough thing for Wolf the Umpire to go through and MLB should be aware of this and try and keep him in AL games only (although this is no longer an option because umps now arbitrate for both leagues, not one or the other).
-
Mark Redman
Redman has put together an excellent season. I think most of us here have recognized that and I also think that we have also noticed the dearth of recognition he has attained in the media. Some guys are like that though, and I dont think Redman has a problem with that. Remember when we made this move? We dealt Gary Knotts away and sent Millar to Japan (that fiasco, thanks Red Sox) to get H-worth and Redman. No one in the media really even commented on it. I felt that Redman could be very good with us. His ERA was very solid with the Tigers, but he suffered from no offensive support. You can basically bet on a pitcher's ERA dropping anywhere from a .5 to 1 run less when they cross over to the NL from AL. Last year, his ERA was 4.21, so that means he is right on pace (at least for me). The surprising thing is, how did no other teams recognize the value of a guy who threw 200+ innings and had a solid ERA with the Tigers? Redman is going a fine job, give he and Beinfest credit for making this happen. But is he at the end of his career? NO! Look at where Leiter was when we got him - I think Redman is in a similar position. His career is just starting. I think he didnt make the All-star squad because he was injured at the time, if I remember correctly.
-
Today's First Base Umpire is the brother...
DOES ANYONE READ MY POSTS! DAMN... :banghead :w00t
-
Wayne Rosenthal
Here is Hyde's article in the Sun-Sentinel. It portrays Rosenthal with quirky color, and gives him some much needed credit. Enjoy: HYDE: Do you believe in magic? Marlins coach does his part Published August 15, 2003 He takes a seat on the dugout bench exactly 45 minutes before every game. He puts a pinch of tobacco dip in his lower lip precisely when that day's starting pitcher begins warm-ups. He sits on the dugout stool as each game starts. If you're trying to explain this funhouse of a Marlins season, there are worse ways than noting how pitching coach Wayne Rosenthal wears low-top shoes if that day's pitcher previously performed well when Rosenthal wore low-top shoes. If not, he wears high-top shoes. And he has been known to change shoes in mid-game. Ditto for socks, by the way. Double-ditto for the T-shirt under his uniform. When the opposing team scores its first run, he must leave the stool to either stand or seat himself as the third person from the clubhouse-end of the bench. And he must throw out the dip. If he visits a pitcher on the mound, he must jog from the dugout to the foul line and walk the rest of the way. On the way back to the bench, he must jog from the mound to the warning track just before the dugout. How did all these rituals start? Well, they started like all superstitions do. Something worked, just once, like when a Texas Rangers fan threw him a pack of orange Bubblicious gum in 1991 and Rosenthal plopped three pieces in his mouth while in the bullpen that night. Then he went in and had a good game. It was three pieces of orange Bubblicious from then on. To the normal person, all this would be quite a burden, you know. Sitting exactly here at this time. Jogging just to this point. Checking shoes and socks to see how they did last time out. Which isn't to say Rosenthal isn't normal. For instance: "Probably not," he answers, when asked if he thinks any of this actually helps. "But it makes me feel better." This makes him feel better still: Braden Looper is throwing a split-finger fastball. Oh, not often. And not totally how he wants it. But on May 11th, when Rosenthal came aboard and the Marlins season was in free-fall, Looper didn't have a split-finger fastball. A couple weeks ago against Montreal, the right-handed Looper threw it to back-to-back left-handers and got two groundouts. "To have something like that against tough lefties is something I need," the Marlins closer said. "It gives them something to think about besides the fastball." Then, asked whose idea it was, Looper answered with what might be the real magic of Rosenthal's work thus far. "It was my idea," Looper said. "No, it was his. Maybe. I'm not sure, to be honest. I think it was mine." For two weeks after joining the Marlins, Rosenthal said nothing to his staff. Some, like Dontrelle Willis and Carl Pavano, knew him from past dealings. Most didn't. Plus, he had never been a major league pitching coach before. And, well, it was the middle of the season. It's a touchy issue, being a pitching coach. Some players want feedback on every mechanical twist. Others don't want to hear anything. With still others, you have to suggest an idea and let it fertilize for a while, see if it takes hold. But just as manager Jack McKeon brought an intangible tone to this team -- something the statistic-laden sport of baseball can't measure, something he once used to turn around the Padres and Reds -- Rosenthal's impact is there, too. You can look it up. Before he arrived, the Marlins starters had a 9-15 record and 4.12 earned-run average. Since then: a 40-26 record and 3.86 ERA, though, sure, Willis's mid-May emergence skews those results. Then there's the relievers. They're crucial, because the difference between most contenders is a difference in bullpens. Richer teams can afford middle relief. Marlins' relievers had a 4.54 ERA on May 11. They clipped a half-run off that in the first six weeks and are at 4.09 now. Ugueth Urbina sure helps, and in the past 16 games the Marlins bullpen has a 1.09 ERA. But it's not just Looper and Urbina. It's Nate Bump. It's Michael Tejera. It's even Chad Fox. Do you realize Boston, a team desperate for relief help, dumped Fox? Fox became a Marlin on Tuesday and has since pitched three scoreless innings. How do you explain that? Or that Mike Mordecai has twice pinch run for Mike Lowell and then hit a winning home run? Or no Marlin is having an off season? Something is afoot this season. And Rosenthal, who once spent three years sending out resumes to hook up with a major league organization, wants to do his bit not just with the pitchers but the general karma. "When I started here, we lost six games and the goatee got shaved off," he said, stroking it like a rabbit's foot.
-
Today's First Base Umpire is the brother...
I like your attempt here, Juanky, and it is valid. But a more tangible illustration could be perception - this is always a serious matter to consider when questioning an individual's behavior. Who is perceiving what exactly? Forget the metaphysics of this, it might be overthinking the matter. For one, who says Wolf has positive memories of he and his brother?
-
Today's First Base Umpire is the brother...
There seems to be some backtracking, by the fraternity of umpires. But that is not what is in question - Wolf's integrity. What is in question is perception, MLB should be on alert that there is a conflict of interest - whether implicit or not - that is perceived by fellow players on teams in the pennant race.
-
Today's First Base Umpire is the brother...
Good post, Juanky. It is bad when parapsychology and baseball start getting mixed, but I am all about this sort of thing. I think you can also approach this at not so quite a deep level. Let's talk about perception - whether or not Wolf is making calls for his brother is irrelevant. And I dont think there has to be a conspiracy here, just human nature. This is a conflict of interest, plain and simple. To help illustrate our point, against those nay-sayers, here is something from the Herald about our topic: Redman: Conflict of interest for ump? Questionable call made by Phillies pitcher's brother BY CLARK SPENCER cspencer@herald.com Marlins pitcher Mark Redman didn't go so far as to blame what he felt was a bad call by first-base umpire Jim Wolf on brotherly love. But Redman did say the fact Wolf and Philadelphia pitcher Randy Wolf are brothers does create a perception problem, especially considering the Marlins and Phillies are battling for the National League wild card. ''I guarantee that crosses every player's mind,'' Redman said after the Marlins dropped a 6-4 decision to the Los Angeles Dodgers on Thursday. ``You hope he doesn't do that [allow his family connection to influence calls], but it does cross people's minds.'' Jim Wolf was involved in three close plays Thursday, the first when Rickey Henderson was ruled safe on a pickoff attempt in the third, the second when Shawn Green beat out an infield hit in the third inning, and the third when Jeromy Burnitz was called safe on another infield hit in the fourth. Redman didn't have a beef with the first two calls. But he said replays showed that first baseman Derrek Lee's foot appeared to touch the bag before Burnitz's did. ''They are close calls,'' Redman said. 'But I told [Wolf], `You're better than that' [after the third play]. I don't think he liked it too much.'' Burnitz stole second, then scored on Jolbert Cabrera's double to cut the Marlins' lead to 3-2. Wolf declined to comment. But crew chief Admin Young defended his colleague, who usually works Triple A games. ''That's something I guess the players are going to have to deal with themselves,'' Young said of any perception problems. ``That goes to integrity, and [Wolf] has great integrity.'' Young said it's not the first time brothers have worked in the league as player and umpire, pointing to the Haller brothers -- umpire Bill and catcher Tom. ''[Wolf] doesn't perceive it to be a problem, and I do not, either,'' Young said. ``He could care less about the pennant race.''
-
Today's First Base Umpire is the brother...
Rune, Ramp, you are both losing sight of something here. I agree with Cape & others that there is a conflict of interest here. If you went to court, and say, you and your lawyer were going after someone and his brother was the judge, wouldnt you be at least a little suspicious? I am not saying there is a conspiracy here, but I can tell you, these guys are human. Wolf could be calling games in the AL, he doesnt have to be in the NL. (I know they have that rotating umpire thing now, but still, cmon...)