Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

dim

Members
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by dim

  1. dim replied to a post in a topic in Sports
    This hurts to watch.
  2. No. The World Series is the goal. While I'd love a more consistent team, it eventually means nothing if you can't reach the end goal. You are basically asking if you want to be a Marlins fan, a team who has only gone to the playoffs once in the last 18 years but has won a World Series, or a Dodgers fan, a team that's been to the playoffs 7 times in that period but haven't won a World Series since 1988. When put that way it becomes interesting. However, I promise you that if you ask Dodgers fans if they'd trade all their playoff appearances for a World Series within the new millennium, they'd take the World Series.
  3. Yeah what Admin said makes the most sense. I have to believe he'll catch on somewhere fairly quickly.
  4. No, but I have no idea why you're calling me out to say so
  5. Yelich is just one of those guys I watch in the field and don't marvel at his work. He's competent and gets the job done, and every so often he makes a nice sliding catch. However, he's got an average throwing arm and covers slightly above average ground on fly ball outs. Again, he's been a nice plus and much better than expected given the fact he was drafted as a 1st baseman. But I have to imagine there are at least 5-7 better defensive outfielders in the game than Yelich.
  6. Not sure why BA goes out to list KJ Woods as our top 1B option but not put him in the top 10. Jordan Holloway has a single season of Batavia to his name (decent season though), Isael Soto is 18 and has limited AB's so who knows what he is just yet, Isaiah White was just drafted 3rd round this past season and didn't exactly light the world on fire in the GCL (good contact, very low power), Austin Dean definitely needs a big year in Jacksonville to become a legitimate major league prospect again (will be 23 and only has 1 good season in GBoro to really hang back on), Brian Anderson suffered a big case of the Jupiter blues (.644 OPS) and doesn't have nearly the momentum he had coming off a near .900 OPS in GBoro (although still decent hopes for him). Garrett and Naylor have been good in super low levels, Kolek is looking worse and worse by the start, and Garcia/Flores don't project as more than #4/5 starters at the major league level (although props to Garcia for stepping up last season. I'll ignore his few poor Jax starts and focus on him looking great in Jupiter this year). The fact that so many of our top 10 prospects are guys very recently drafted and many of them not even putting up good stats at these low levels is incredibly alarming. Flores and Garcia are probably the only prospects who could probably have any kind of staying power in the majors down the line (although Kolek could magically light the world on fire). The last few drafts have left us with very very little in the system, as basically no players have broken out and become even top 100 prospects. Yes we traded a lot of top prospects to put together the 2015 team, but it's unacceptable to be fielding a system as weak as this one and should lead to some firings within the scouting department.
  7. Not sure how Yelich keeps getting nominated. His defense is good but back to back Gold Gloves seems wrong for him. Gordon has been gold glove caliber this year. Hech has been just as good as last year but had a better offensive season giving him more attention.
  8. It is kind of bad practice to hire him while the World Series is still going on.
  9. Oh didn't see this is money not being an issue. David Price is my guy with price being irrelevant. But as always price matters.
  10. I've been team Zimmermann/Samardzija since the start.
  11. He's already pitched in AAA. He would've started next year at AAA, and with a good season there and some injuries (Of course that is the only way he'd get some starts, but that can be said with most of our pitchers), he'd get a look. Mitchell isn't even an option until 2019 if he ever becomes an option at all. I don't know why I'm supposed to be excited about this. You guys have got me talking about this trade far more than I anticipated caring about it.
  12. Sorry if I haven't found time to drive to Jacksonville to watch his games. No real reason to be a dick with that comment. Not saying I'm a scout, but I've got a decent idea of the kind of pitcher he is at the moment.
  13. I find it funny your comeback is always "oh man we traded away a future Cy Young winner waaah". You are completely ignoring any argument I'm making because you absolutely do not want to hear any of it. I've followed Williams career for a while, and I've said my opinion on him. I group him with the rest of the guys we have who aren't good enough to be on a playoff team's starting rotation, but he put up decent enough numbers to continue giving him looks, and there was a chance of him seeing some starts in the majors this upcoming season. Mitchell won't see the majors until 2019 if he ever sees it at all. This trade sucks, and seems more like compensation for taking Benedict away than anything else.
  14. In that thread I said that he was a #5 at best. In this thread I said that he's a #5 at best. I still believe that he is likely a #4/5 at best. Right now we have no idea what the other guy can be, and his numbers are mediocre at a much lower level. I can be somewhat down on Williams and still say that he has a higher likelihood of contributing anything at the major league level than the guy we got.
  15. Well this thread is filled with some dumb comments.
  16. Can't tell if it's sarcasm or not. I'm not looking to trash every move that ever happens, but this one just doesn't make sense.
  17. Even if it isn't a "big picture" trade, it definitely still deserves criticism. I follow the minors pretty closely and had Williams in that tier with Conley/Urena/Flores/Nicolino/etc... who could compete for a lower end rotation spot within the next year. This trade just took one of those guys away and left us with what appears to be a worse pitcher at a far lower level in the minors.
  18. Trevor Williams was far closer to major league ready than Richard Mitchell is. Williams had already pitched a few starts in AAA and put up a really good ERA in short time there. Williams' career trajectory reminded me of Adam Conley's. Probably nothing more than a #5 starter down the line, but he's only 23 and would've been in contention with a few other people down the line for a rotation spot. Richard Mitchell is 20 years old and hasn't pitched above the Gulf Coast League. He's generally had as many walks allowed as strikeouts and has a career 65 walks/75 strikeouts. I haven't seen him pitch and his career sample size is small, but we basically traded away another potential #5 pitcher who, with a good start next season, could've seen some starts by June, for a guy who is at best three and a half years away from the majors and hasn't shown any signs of brilliance in the low level he's pitched in. This trade looks awful. Anybody who looks at Williams stats should know the whole picture with him. He had an awful month of May with a 6.23 ERA, but every other month he posted... May: 6.23 ERA. 30 1/3 IP April/June-August: 3.22 ERA. 86 2/3 IP He also pitched 14 innings and had a 2.57 ERA in New Orleans. This makes no sense. We traded for a worse player much further away from being major league ready.
  19. Seriously, I don't get how Das being honest, whether that be optimistic or pessimistic, makes him a bad fan. Blindly agreeing with everything a front office tells you and taking it for gospel is more of a sign of a bad fan. Poor performance and a poorly run organization deserves to be criticized. There were obvious flaws with this season and many that came before it, and they all deserve to be criticized. The fact the Marlins continue to make the same garbage mistakes and are looking at managers like Admin Bowa and Manny Acta just tells you that things will just never change until somebody runs the Marlins and embraces sabermetrics to the fullest. While I love Dee, his abilities are due for drop offs given hits tend to stop dropping in spouts during a season. I'd like more of the Shin-Soo Choo types or whatever and focus on things beyond basic counting stats.
  20. I don't see why it's wrong to criticize the moves of a front office that hasn't produced a team with a winning record since 2009. Six straight seasons with more losses than wins is unacceptable and worthy of immense criticism. Sure Dee turned out right, but giving up valuable pieces in the trade was a sign of a greater issue, which is the Marlins undervaluing their own players. Look around the league and you'll find guys that we gave up on doing well for other teams. There's a problem with management, ownership, coaching, everything. I might be a fan of the team, but that doesn't mean I have to be blind to the fact that I root for a team that has been mismanaged for years. I said at the start of the season that I wished the Marlins did a rebuild more like how the Mets did it, hiring an analytics guy in the front office and building around great pitching. If the Marlins front office is still afraid of new age statistics and out of the box thinking, that is a damn good explanation for why this team is in the poor shape that it is now.
  21. Definitely traded low on Hernandez. 24 years old posting a .830+ OPS and hitting almost as well as Gordon. Dee obviously brings the advantage out in the field and on the base paths, but I understand mostly what the writer is trying to say. I think the issue is that the Marlins highly underrated Hernandez and didn't see him as a core part of the future when they should've. Many on this board and forum were calling for to be traded due to poor performance in only 40 AB's with the major league squad. It's interesting that both Heaney and Hernandez were both traded when their value was low and we traded for Gordon when his value was sky high. It's worked out well enough for us that we shouldn't cry over it, but there's a reason Andrew Friedman is who he is and why Dan Jennings is likely out of a job soon. Just completely different levels when it comes to their abilities to evaluate players.
  22. Trade: A.J Ramos DFA: Jeff Mathis Extend: Marcell Ozuna Acquire: Jordan Zimmermann I'll explain each one quickly. Ramos is easy in that he's coming off a career year, relievers are highly volatile (as we've seen many times), and while I am a fan of Ramos and have been since he was pitching in the minors, he is replaceable. I think that most of us agree that if he can stay healthy, Capps would be able to take over and succeed in a closer role if called upon. Plus Ramos is 29 and begins the arbitration process next season, meaning a decent pay upgrade. He's proven highly consistent during his Marlins tenure, but we've learned from Cishek that you hold onto a player like that too long and suddenly you're forced (or at least the Marlins felt like they were) to sell low on a top tier closer. Jeff Mathis is obvious. He had 14 hits last season. For reference, Bryce Harper had 14 hits in a seven game stretch this season. Mathis does have plus defense, but the only reason I can imagine him needing to be held onto is that old "veteran presence" stuff and the fact that Jose pitches well with him behind the plate, although I think Jose would pitch well with his grandmother back there. Marcell Ozuna is an interesting pick in that the consensus seems to be that he is going to be traded this offseason. He started off horribly, missed a team practice and got sent down to the minors. That seems to be what many people, including Jeffrey Loria, seem to think about his season. His agent is Scott Boras, making it damn near impossible to negotiate a reasonable contract with Ozuna, and to top it all off Ozuna has started to build a reputation for some laziness and poor attitude. However, Ozuna has been performing very well since being sent down to the minors. He was hitting down in AAA, and he's posted an OPS of .852 in the month of September with the major league squad. Given the now tense relationship between Ozuna and the Marlins, there is very very very little chance that an extension would even be considered at this point. If the Marlins even went up to him offering an extension, he and Boras would likely slam the door in Loria's face. However, if there was ever a time to cash in on Ozuna, it is now. His performance this year is likely not indicative of future performance. He's still just 24 years old, coming off a poor year in the majors. If you could somehow convince him to take a long term deal and secure him and his family financially, you'd be able to get him for a really nice discount compared to what we would've needed to offer last offseason. Jordan Zimmermann is the obvious guy to go after in my opinion. This is his worst year since his rookie year with the Nats in 2010. However, he's still put up a 3.66 ERA with 200+ IP. His numbers have been hindered by a high number of HR's this year. However, his peripherals his entire career have been incredibly consistent, meaning that we're very likely to get the pitcher we signed up to get. Outside of maybe possible injury, I don't see a Zimmermann signing turning out completely sour. He reminds me a lot of what we had when we signed Mark Buehrle. You're going to get 200 innings, an ERA no higher than the mid 3's, and somebody who will be there for you the entire season. In my eyes, Zimmermann is the safest best to succeed for the most reasonable price in this offseason's pitching class. I don't think the question should be about if we should go after him. I think we have to and we will. The question is whether Loria will be willing to fight in a bidding war for a guy who isn't all that marketable and likely doesn't have potential to be an ace like his 2014 season might suggest. He is a solid #2 (very good #3 on a playoff team), which is perfect for hat this team needs right now. If takes 6/7 years and $80-100 million+ to get him, you have to do it. He's proven himself consistent and should be able to perform the way he has as he moves up in age.
  23. Samardzija is going to be at a discount price this offseason. Take out those god awful games and consider a move back to the National League and I think he'd be a successful #2 again. I can imagine him taking a 1/2 year deal in kind of a "show me" kind of way. For us to succeed we need to find some value players. Samardzija's peripherals still suggest he's a decent pitcher and he still regularly goes deep into starts. I truly believe whoever signs him this offseason will be very happy. As for Zimmermann, I definitely expect to be outbid and not get him. But I don't expect him to command too crazy of a price tag and he's a hell of a pitcher when he doesn't give up home runs. These are just the two I've decided are value picks this year as opposed to just projecting the top tier guys who other teams will throw the bank at. I also think both guys are #2 pitchers when they are at their best. Get them, match them with Koehler and whoever wins that 5th rotation spot out of the mess of #5 starters we have, and I think we're a lot closer to a .500+ record than we were this year.
  24. Little of A, little of B. We underperformed all year and we're overperforming now. When performing as expected I'd say this is a .500 to slightly below .500 team. Without an upgraded rotation, the team just reeks of average (Hell even with an upgraded rotation it still does).

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.