Everything posted by dim
- Scott McGough Called Up
-
Scott McGough Called Up
Wouldn't exactly call that a win. Traded Hanley at his lowest value. Traded Eo at a somewhat low value. Got a #5 starter/long reliever in Phelps, a past his prime 3B in Prado, and a guy whose MLB ceiling seems to be a Sam Dyson type. Hanley isn't exactly lighting the world on fire right now, but it 100% stands that the move reeks of a salary purge more than an attempt to improve the team's future. That's a big problem with a lot of moves this team has done the last decade or so.
-
Scott McGough Called Up
Well that's a nice statement. Hey, here's a thought. Maybe you shouldn't comment on Wittgren if you haven't actually followed any of his minor league career. His numbers have warranted a call up since May. He deserves a call up well before the AAAA players who shouldn't have any legitimate shot of making a major league bullpen next season. This isn't stat "nerds" (which is an awful phrase in and of itself), it's people who actually pay attention to the team and want the best players getting opportunities at the big league level seeing garbage players get opportunities before a player who actually has a legitimate future in a major league bullpen (and imo a closer at that). I have a feeling Wittgren is coming up as a September call up, which is fine given the season's a wash anyway. But there's legitimate reason for people to make jokes every time somebody gets the call over Wittgren. He's a college tested closer with 200+ IP under his belt, a 2.23 ERA and a stellar season this year. There's a reason he gets some hype. He's pretty good.
- 8-19 post game
-
Should the Marlins bring back Ichiro next season?
I mean it was the first time since 2013. Ichiro's cool, but lets hold off on writing his Hall of Fame Speech just yet... Wait...he's a first ballot hall of famer. Well shit.
-
Phelps to DL, Erik Cordier up
I agree. Sounds like it comes from a name generator. But I said the same thing about Cole Gilliespie so yeah.
-
8/12 Red Sox @ Marlins
I'm here for JT. He'll strikeout like all disappointments this season.
-
Kike Hernandez would have been a great UT player for the Marlins
Yes. I watch wrestling. Help still needed.
-
Kike Hernandez would have been a great UT player for the Marlins
Wow... You sir need help.
-
Kike Hernandez would have been a great UT player for the Marlins
-
Kike Hernandez would have been a great UT player for the Marlins
It's not about having an opinion, it's about backing it up. You say you think they won't amount to anything, but you don't say WHY? All the numbers in their minor and major league opportunities suggest that they're both at worst really top notch utility options on a good team, and at best potential starter options at catcher, 2nd base, or shortstop. You're allowed to think they'll amount to nothing, but there actually has to be substance in forming that opinion. I also still doubt the Dodgers "settled" for Heaney. They probably used the "we want Nicolino" talks as leverage to get the Marlins to value Heaney as less. It makes all the sense in the world for the Dodgers to get Miami to think they want Nicolino and take Heaney, the clearly better pitcher, off their hands for a greater return.
-
Kike Hernandez would have been a great UT player for the Marlins
He's 23 years old, has been playing professional ball since 2009, posted a near .900 OPS in AAA at age 22, and has already had this kind of success in the majors. I don't know if he's an .850 OPS guy year in and year out, but he's definitely got some real ability to hit that the Marlins completely undervalued after the Houston trade. He seems to be a more contact oriented Derek Dietrich kind of player, which is really valuable and a player who can OPS above .750 on a regular basis. Lets not just snub our noses at a 23 year old performing at a high level in the majors because we refuse to believe we traded on him far too early.
-
Kike Hernandez would have been a great UT player for the Marlins
Oh that's horse manure Admin. Given that our bench is one of the worst in baseball along with a worst in baseball team, but Barnes and Kike, who have the ability to play multiple positions and have produced high caliber OPS' in upper echelon's of the minor leagues are incredibly valuable to any team. Andrew Friedman knew that specifically and targeted them in a potential trade. He knew exactly what he was getting. Look, we wanted a second baseman because we were working with Donovan Solano and saw how much Dee could hit. The front office, from all rumors, valued Nicolino over Heaney (which never made sense and still doesn't). Friedman knew that Heaney's value was lower than it was previously and used it as a means to get some other legitimate prospects from the Marlins in the deal. It's wrong to say the Marlins were robbed in the trade given that Dee has produced far more for us at 2nd base than we've had at the position since Luis Castillo was here. I also don't think Barnes and Hernandez are deal breakers for a big impact player, but good GM's do whatever they can to hold onto undervalued minor league depth like them. The problem is down the line great starting pitching is always more valuable than good starting hitters. There's a solid chance of Heaney being a better pitcher down the line than Gordon a hitter, but for the now the trade is sort of a win/win. If at any point Barnes/Hernandez contribute significantly (which they already are and will in the future), this trade begins to favor the Dodgers a lot more. While Howie Kendrick hasn't been awful, I'm sure they wish now that they held onto Heaney instead. Anyway the trade in hindsight isn't awful. At the time it wasn't great, but it wasn't god awful. But to say Barnes and Kike aren't important players, ESPECIALLY since both guys would rank in the top 5 of Marlins prospects if they were still here today is just plain wrong Admin.
-
How would you improve this team in the offseason?
Everyone hates when the Marlins go and sell low and buy high, yet the biggest name I hear people wanting is Kazmir. Yeah, Kazmir's been absolutely great this year. But that great number means he'll make top top top dollar in free agency. This season has been an absolute breakout from what he's been doing recently. He hasn't thrown for 200 innings since 2007. He'll probably make near $100 million this offseason while Samardzija is likely looking at a one year "prove it" deal with a national league team in a pitcher friendly park. Kazmir's going to go to one of the top teams with the most money in the baseball world. I respect and understand that. We can't and shouldn't be trying to attain these players. Samardzija is similar to the Latos deal we did this season. Yes, the Latos deal didn't work out, but I'd do that trade over again 100 times because there was a significant chance of him becoming a #2 starter caliber player again. I don't believe Samardzija has the same injury concerns that Latos has, so this move would be more likely to pay off, AND we wouldn't be giving up long term flexibility or prospects to get him. It makes all the sense in the world to me.
-
How would you improve this team in the offseason?
Samardzija's value will never be lower than this season. For us to compete, this team needs to get value in our free agent signings. Samardzija is the perfect kind of signing for a team like us this offseason. Samardzija has six starts where he's given up 5 ER or more, 4 starts of allowing 7 ER or more, with two of them being in his last two starts. Yes, that absolutely sucks and shows he's having a Ricky Nolasco season. But on the other hand, 19 of his 23 starts have been 6 innings or more, 16!!!! starts of 7 innings or more. The biggest thing we lack on the current team is guys who can go deep into games regularly. Samardzija can do that without any issue. He could very well suck if we sign him, but he's the kind of guy we need to take chances on. He'd come at a reasonable cost after a season like this. A move to the National League will probably do wonders for him, and he has the potential to be that #2 we need.
-
Baseball life after Marlins 2015
Oh you are just the worst kind of fan. I'm not even giving a real response to this.
-
2015 Positives
Yeah, I'll admit I'm certainly not the best person to judge Realmuto since I haven't watched the team regularly for at least a month now. I followed Realmuto closely as he progressed through the minors and thought I had a pretty good feel for the type of prospect he was. Definitely felt like he needed a little more time in AAA, but his defense was certainly top notch from what I saw when he got called up. Looking up and seeing that he's posted .750+ OPS' the last two months makes me feel better about everything, but like you said I'm not sure how sustainable it is. Realmuto was always an up and down hitter even during his minor league career and never projected as a top tier long term starter. I still feel confident that this team needs to acquire an established catcher if they have any tiny hope of contending next season, but I'm fully prepared to go into next season with Realmuto and let him prove himself the first few months. If it were up to me, I'd shore up C, 1B, and 3B in the offseason (I'd love to trade Hech at his peak value, but I've accepted a long time ago he'll be here forever). I still like the outfield of Yelich/Ozuna/Stanton, and Gordon is good at 2B. Everywhere else I'd look to upgrade and not settle for what we have currently. This team needs help at those positions, with the bench (we have easily the worst depth in baseball), the starting rotation needs to be shored up health wise and in the #3-5 spots, and we need a new manager obviously. Oh, and the minor leagues needs to be completely rebuilt (which means great drafts are a MUST the next few years). Big, big problems that aren't easily fixed.
-
2015 Positives
In terms of the long term future of the team, Hech was probably the best positive to have this season. Based on WAR he's one of the top 5 shortstop's in the National League. I'm not even asking THAT of him long term, so if he could produced seasons like this regularly he has an Alex Gonzalez style spot on this team for a few years. Other than that, it gets tough. Capps as mentioned already, Ramos as well. Sam Dyson trade was a positive gain. Justin Bour emerging as a possible platoon guy next season and Dietrich hitting like a major league caliber starter. I understand the Realmuto praise given his decent defense and a little bat, but I think it's more of an effect of "at least he's not Salty" than people realize. He's not in the top 20 MLB catchers and likely shouldn't be starting if we actually want to finish a season over .500 in the future. Yelich started the season as a huge negative and has slowly built himself back up into a positive. Amazing he's still just 23 years old so I have to mention locking him down while we still could was another positive. Other than that there are way too many negatives about the current and future team to mention. The positives I mentioned aren't enough to prop up a winning ballclub, and the negatives are a big enough problem that we're a half season of under .500 baseball in 2016 away from warranting a complete fire sale. For me that includes anybody not named Stanton and Yelich (yes that includes Fernandez since there's no chance in hell we'll be able to re-sign him by 2019).
-
Baseball life after Marlins 2015
I know it's in fashion to say "aw f*ck the Mets lol", but I'm rooting for them since they're giving me a real 2003 Marlins vibe. Built around great starting pitching and defense, a now well run organization with some real fun players and a winning attitude. I understand the stupidity of "oh, they're our rivals we should hate them grr", but I just can't. The Mets are what I hope the Marlins use as a model for success. They literally started with the same "build around Matt Harvey and David Wright" formula that we say (build around Jose and Stanton). They found some random gems (deGrom, Colon), did amazing to trade a guy at his top value (Dickey for d'Arnaud and Syndergaard), spent in free agency efficiently (Granderson on a great deal after an injury plagued season). They built through the draft, free agency, and trade. Basically doing everything that needs to be done to build a winning team. I have absolutely no reason to dislike the Mets other than the fact that they're the Mets. I want the Marlins to be far more like the Mets.
-
Jose has shoulder stiffness
Is that supposed to be some kind of comfort about the future of this team? Sure, I know we're not the worst team in baseball when completely healthy. But right now we're the worst team in baseball, and this is pretty close to the team we're going to field next season barring huge free agent signings. And the minors doesn't have any top prospects coming through anytime within the next four years. There is a real, long term problem with this team.
-
Which Marlin Do You F'ing Hate The Most???
Jeremy Hermida. It will always be Jeremy Hermida.
-
Jose has shoulder stiffness
I agree with Spike too 100%. Can't use the whole "but injuries happened we coulda been a playoff team aaah". There was an obvious lack of depth at the start of the year. They gutted the minors to go for mostly rentals and it backfired. Now, there really isn't a plan B unless they want to stick with an MLB worst team again next year and see if things will go different this time around or gut the team. Yes that means everybody not named stanton and Fernandez. There is no right answer at the moment.
-
8/8 post game
This is the worst team in baseball. We have the worst minor leagues in baseball. As I've said since late May, there's a long term problem with this team considering the unwillingness to spend in free agency. We don't have the pieces to acquire players via trades, and we don't have the minor league system to build from within, so if there's even a hope to compete in the future, it's gonna have to be with the current players and free agents. Loria won't pay the top tier free agents long term, so that leaves us with the current players, who are producing like the worst team in baseball (yeah injuries and such, but even without injuries this is an under .500 team). I don't know how you would go about fixing this team. There's no easy solution to this mess.
-
Should the fences be moved in?
I voted yes. I think there'll come a point down the line where hitters don't sign with us unless we extremely overpay because their numbers are guaranteed to hit a steep decline when they come here (especially power hitters). Obviously guys like Stanton and such will have good numbers here regardless of the park, but we've seen guys like Salty, Jones, Morse, Morrison, Coghlan, etc... just nosedive in numbers when they play at Marlins Park. Sure there's outliers, but the truth is if you are a power hitting free agent and are getting offered similar deals from the Marlins and say the Phillies, that player will be more likely to go to Philly if they're looking to play for that next contract. I think the really good pitchers will break through regardless of the park (The Jose's and Alvarez's of the world will do fine. Everybody else eh). I think it's also important from a marketing perspective to move the fences in. Giving Stanton a more hitter friendly park could propel him to a 45-50 home run a season level (barring injuries obviously). Stanton is a potential 600 home run guy, but playing a ton of games at Marlins Park is going to cost him a couple home runs that could be potential milestones. Especially with the All Star Game being held in 2017 here, there's incentive to move the fences in, hope Stanton pulls out a 30+ home run first half, and use it as a means to market Miami as a place to come and become an elite hitter in the future.
-
Dombrowski Released By Tigers
It's not a Billy Beane thing, it is just common sense. Baseball seasons are over 162 games. You judge your players on what they can give you over that duration. A team can win 130 games, and the star pitchers have off nights and suddenly you're eliminated in the first round. History shows in baseball that the best team doesn't always make the World Series let alone win it. Hell, there's a solid chance the Marlins weren't really the best team in baseball in '03, but we put together a good team and things worked out in our favor. The sign of a good GM is consistency in winning and making the playoffs. Anything beyond that is literally just a bonus. By the way, all our bitching about Jennings and whoever as manager and the Royals literally went to the World Series last year with one of the worst managers in baseball and are winning again this year with him. There's so much crap that fans complain about that really just doesn't matter.