Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

dim

Members
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by dim

  1. As for the topic of Chapman, I have no problem with the Marlins being in the race. The price for Chapman fell significantly after the domestic violence allegations, and Chapman would've been a huge player to get even on a one year rental. He's one of the best closers in the league, and while the allegations made against him are awful in nature, they have no bearing on his play on the field or his role in the locker room. I think it's fair to say that outside of Kolek/Naylor we didn't have any prospects that would've intrigued the Reds. But the truth is I would've been willing to trade anybody in our current farm system outside of Naylor to get Chapman for the season. Hell, even if we completely suck next year then Chapman just becomes trade bait at the deadline and we could end up recovering prospects when his value builds itself back up in July.
  2. At this point I believe it's commonly assumed the decision to take Kolek over Rodon was because of money reasons (Rodon was asking for #1 overall pick money at the time, represented by Scott Boras, whom we've had issues with during the Jose/Ozuna negotiations), as well as health reasons. I feel like people casually forget that Rodon had clearly regressed his final year at NC State and was throwing around 130 pitches a game. The coach at NC State was clearly milking every bit they could out of Rodon and it was hurting him. The last thing people forget is that Kolek was a hell of a prospect in his own right. Nobody had a 100 MPH+ fastball in their arsenal in this draft outside of him, his high school ERA was something like 0.49 and he didn't walk many people at all, signaling no issues with control. Sure, we overlooked the fact that his secondary pitches weren't even close to defined yet, but at 18 years old there seemed plenty of time to develop them. There still is time. I was on the Rodon over Kolek train at the time, but people seem to forget how close the decision actually was at the time. There was still a solid chance of Rodon being damaged goods, and Kolek becoming the next Jose Fernandez. The decision was one that will hurt this franchise for a long time given our tight budgets, but it is one that countless other GMs would've made I believe.
  3. Well it's all a lie. The guy Al Jazeera got all their info from was a pharmacist who caught onto the fact that they had got one of his clients to become a kind of secret informant who was recording every conversation they had. Therefore, he started giving the guy BS information mentioning names of players who have nothing to do with him to see whether this info would get passed along. And it did... From everything I've read this feels like a poorly executed report by Al Jazeera who relied on very few sources, ran with the information they got and could very easily be getting sued for defamation of character from multiple players soon enough.
  4. I really believe they are and that you are 100% correct that new TV deals are playing a big part in that. Marlins are still on a terrible TV contract and likely feel they don't have the funds to compete. The only problem is that they've been crying poverty for years. I feel that if you cry poverty for so long like Loria/Samson have, you shouldn't be running a major league team. Seems to be the general consensus.
  5. The Marlins haven't gotten anybody because the market rate is so much higher than it has ever been. Guys who would've gotten $8-10 million a year just a few years ago are getting $15 million a year and more. Guys like Samardzija are getting far more money than they deserve because teams are willing to spend more. The Marlins are being incredibly hesitant to really enter the market because of this, and that makes me believe they are going to leave this offseason with somebody like Cliff Lee. One year deals that don't have any long term risk and are for players looking to rebound or are getting up in age. In the past I wouldn't be complaining about the Marlins not entering this free agency. So many pitchers are getting paid far more than their numbers warrant. However, the Marlins haven't drafted well, don't have the trade pieces to get a pitcher from another team, and have given away the potential young pitchers they did have for short term options (Prado, Latos) or players who serve other needs (Gordon). These decisions have left the Marlins with two options this offseason. Spend on one of those pitchers getting higher than their worth and hope they grow into a potential #2 starter, or stay pat with the mediocrity we have and win 70 games next year. I feel they've made their decision.
  6. Exactly. It isn't just "not spending money" that's the issue. The poor drafting and trades where we give up the few good prospects we had for players who aren't here anymore have led us to our current predicament. They needed to spend the money just to make up for the mess they've made. I'm pretty sure at this rate the front office knows that they can't spend the money, don't have the prospects to call up, and can't trade to get cheap players on some other team. Basically, the team is sitting on a 70 to 75 win team but praying for Cosart/Nicolino/Conley to magically go from #5 starters to #3's, that the lineup plays to the best of their expectations, that AJ Ramos can continue his success as closer, oh, and that this all happens with no major injuries. So basically, it's going to be a 70 to 75 win season.
  7. Because Valdespin isn't good. He hasn't been good for quite some time.
  8. dim replied to Erick's topic in Sports
    Gardenhoser?
  9. At the moment, our rotation stands next season as... Fernandez/Koehler/Cosart/Nicolino/Phelps with Urena/Flores/Hand on standby. That is awful. Take out Koehler and we have a Urena/Flores/Hand in the starting rotation. Sure it's likely we sign somebody (at this point we'll get the 1 year contract scraps), but the truth is without MAJOR breakthrough seasons by Cosart and Nicolino (because we know what we have in Phelps/Koehler), this team is absolutely F'ed in the A next season.
  10. Again, if we had decent starting pitcher options to replace him then fine. But we're working with Cosart, Urena, Nicolino, Conley, etc...who are all decidedly less reliable than Koehler has been for us. Even if there's an incredibly high likelihood of Koehler being rocked (and we've been waiting for two years), we aren't in a position to move him to the bullpen now. That's just dumb. If we improve the rotation through signings and have a full rotation without him, then fine do it. But we don't have that luxury. He has to be in the rotation because the alternative is making Koehler a bullpen guy and giving Pineyro a starting rotation spot out of Spring Training.
  11. We don't have any starters. Why the hell would we create less starters?
  12. I'm guessing it was a typical JJ Abrams movie (and I love JJ Abrams. Cloverfield defined a genre imo and Super 8 has become underrated over time. Plus Lost is my favorite show ever). Basically, I'm saying there was a ton of action, letting you see the plot instead of saying it, some very complicated and introspective characters, some dry-ish but funny humor thrown in, and a cliffhanger at the end that leaves you wanting more (and sometimes annoyed that he does it nearly every friggin time). That being said I'm assuming its a fun movie but probably a little thin from time to time in the plot.
  13. dim replied to Admin's topic in Miami Marlins
    Yeah I don't want Napoli in the field. Also last year he was worse than Bour at the plate. I feel confident in saying he'll never put up those 2013/2014 numbers again. Cleveland knew what they were doing with a 1 year deal. See if he still has it...if not it isn't the worst thing in the world.
  14. It really shouldn't be surprising that the Marlins haven't entered the market. We were looking for pitchers, the market is much higher than its ever been (Cueto got over $20 million per year, look at the Samardzija deal. It's a crazy world), plus we weren't ever going to spend over $100 million for a pitcher. We refused to go over $80 million for Shields last offseason and that market was reasonable. I honestly don't see us getting anybody in the market other than a 1 year, cellar dweller players who don't have the pick of the litter. My last hope is get Chen and maybe Lee for a 1 year deal, but at this point there isn't a whole lot of solid choices left.
  15. Carl Pavano has the personality of a raisin. I'm pretty sure his voice can put the Energizer bunny to sleep. Please no on Pavano.
  16. I've said it previously but get Dontrelle Willis. He already did coverage for Fox during the World Series. Casual Marlins fans know who he is and he's well spoken for. Seems like a natural fit.
  17. I don't think we'll pay what Gio is gonna get in 2017.
  18. dim replied to Admin's topic in Sports
    Just wait to see what Henderson Alvarez gets.
  19. dim replied to Admin's topic in Sports
    Also he got less than expected. Given the current market I wouldn't say he got "a lot". Could make the argument that he got far less than his worth with an inflating free agent market (the same inflating market that has led the Marlins to sign abso-freaking-lutely nobody so far).
  20. dim replied to Admin's topic in Sports
    There's already a Heyward thread. Hate to tell you but it comes off like click bait when you don't put it in that thread.
  21. Appreciate the sarcastic response. And I wouldn't call it an essay as much as actually having an opinion with a willingness to back it up, something you seem to lack based on these past few responses.
  22. And he should explain himself first before calling other people pricks.
  23. [uSER=13657]@Arpenschplat[/uSER] You want Admin to explain his rationale so much when he's done it multiple times. I haven't heard a single argument from you on why we should keep Jose other than "blah blah blah can't hear you Jose's the greatest". Throw some numbers out there. Back up your stance with some facts or even an opinion with a reason behind it. I've stated my opinion before, but I'll state it again. A good team finds a way to keep Jose forever. He's a generational talent at just 23 years old. Unfortunately, a combination of poor drafting, poor free agent signings, and just unwillingness to spend enough money now/over the last three years has left this team with an incomplete major league roster and the worst farm system in baseball outside of the Angels. Even with Jose on this team, we're #2-5 starters away from even competing. With Loria not throwing out the checkbook and no prospects even close to a #2 starter in our farm system (or prospects good enough to trade to get one), we're stuck at the moment. So the choices seem to be either to try with this current team that seems destined to win 70 to 75 games next season, or go for something different. As Admin pointed out, Jose wants big money down the line and is represented by Scott Boras. He'll never re-sign in Miami, so at the latest we have Jose until 2018. In the bigger picture, Jose already has a bit of an injury history. One more significant injury and that trade value of his takes a giant plummet. When looking at things from a vacuum, We'll never get a better return for a single player than the #2 and #5 prospects in baseball (Seager, Urias), a top caliber outfielder and #13th overall prospect at the start of 2015 (Joc Pederson), and whatever else we get. Those three guys are a huge place to start again. Seager fills the long term gap at third and has potential to be a franchise guy (he hit nearly a 1.000 OPS to start his major league career last year), Urias is 19 years old and already has impressive numbers in AA. And Joc Pederson, bad ending notwithstanding, showed more potential than just about any young outfielder in baseball last year. Add to this that we are eventually going to trade Ozuna for a starting pitcher (and probably Prado for something since he wouldn't have a role on the team with a trade like this), and those are some big holes filled. I personally would rather take a chance on something like this then keep at doing the same thing, wasting Jose Fernandez's prime years on losing teams. Let him go somewhere he can win and we can get the Dodgers rebuild effort that they'll never need.
  24. The Jose stuff leaking similar to the Marcell Ozuna stuff leaking feels intentional to me. Again, they may be telling everybody including people who work for the team that he isn't on the block, but it feels like they put him out their to gauge interest. It'll take a lot, but I feel like the ultimate goal is to trade him. At this point the team just has to decide what they want to do moving forward. I think they're just saying they want the moon while waiting for the right offer to come their way from the Dodgers. I see it taking Urias, Pederson, and three good but lower end prospects like Holmes, Peraza, and Lee to get this thing done.
  25. Putting him on the block in the first place makes a statement. You can say "oh, teams are calling they didn't make him available", but the volume of all these talks and the recent rumors regarding Jose makes it clear the Marlins are looking for a way to get him out of Miami. They don't want to deal with Boras in future contract negotiations plain and simple.

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.