Everything posted by dim
-
Where Do We Go From Here?
Thus why I said a trade is more likely. Still, Shields on five years makes it 0% chance of Fernandez being re-signed. At least with the extra $20 million there's a 5% chance instead. I'll take that.
-
Giancarlo is a judge for Miss Universe
He's gone Hollywood
-
Where Do We Go From Here?
Jose Fernandez's contract will become an issue after the 2019 season (he'll be a free agent). At four years we get Shields off the books before having to worry about possibly handing him a mammoth deal (although more likely is having to trade him). At the very least four years gives us more flexibility in our future decision making than five years does.
-
Where Do We Go From Here?
According to reports, the front office wants Shields but Loria is not sure he wants to pay him. What a sack of shit. That's pretty much what I expected. If it's a four year deal at something like $80 million to $85 million I think I'll be fine with it (as long as they don't backload the contract like crazy), but anything at five years and over $100 million and I want no part in it. Shields being paid $20 million+ as he's getting closer and closer to 40 years old scares me a lot. Although Loria can obviously be cheap, I think this is a matter of us only needing to be in the market on Shields if the price tag makes sense. Doesn't seem like Loria has the financials to be giving him $100 million+, but at $80 million it makes at least a little more sense. I just can't get over how much I hate the idea of giving a 33 year old a four or five year contract. All common sense for me says that Shields hit his four year plateau from 2010 to 2014 and there's a chance that he hits his decline soon and hard. If the signing wouldn't impede on our ability to sign other key pieces long term (Yelich/Ozuna/Fernandez/Cosart/Alvarez), then fine sign him. But if that money will force Loria to cut budget in other places, than screw Shields and that deal.
-
South Beach-iro! Marlins sign Ichiro
WOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO Even for just the nostalgia factor it's pretty cool to sign him. He's also great insurance in case an injury happens to Stanton or either Ozuna/Yelich underperform for whatever reason.
-
Don Kelly signed
I have no idea why but Tigers fans love him, similar to how Lombardozzi is loved by Nats fans and how we used to have a love affair with Donnie Murphy. Minor league deals can never be bad.
- Fourth Outfielder
-
Fangraphs Farm Evaluation
I don't know why an eventually MLB (or minor league) caliber player would get "a lot of meatballs" in high school. If they're MLB caliber, they are quite a lot better than the high school competition and get intentionally walked or thrown around a lot. I'm sure even guys in the minors with bad walk rates have a super high OBP in high school. This isn't really a good example, but when I saw Rizzo when he played at MSD High he got thrown around a lot because teams knew he was a threat. I'm sure even the bad major league players were thrown around just because there's just that much of a talent disparity between your worst major leaguer and best high schooler.
-
Dan Haren
I think it means they are still willing to trade him but he'll report if they don't instead of retiring. Just a guess on my part. I think the only reason they wanted to trade him was because he was unwilling to play for us. The plan seemed to be from the front office that they wanted Haren first and foremost for next season. Looking at how the rotation matches up, that line of thinking makes sense. Haren would put him as the #4 in the rotation and Koehler at #5 to start the year, with Phelps relegated to the bench and useful if any pitcher gets injured or sucks. Without Haren it's Koehler and Phelps to start the year with Brad Hand as the contingency plan. As long Haren doesn't let his "missing home" ruin his pitching next year, then he adds to the team. While it's pretty unlikely, hopefully he's more 2011 Haren than 2012/2013/2014 Haren. He was a pretty top tier pitcher before getting old and hitting his decline stage.
-
Dan Haren
So hypothetical scenario where Haren actually plays for us, our rotation becomes Alvarez Latos Cosart Haren Koehler Gotta believe that rotation puts up better results than Alvarez/Latos/Cosart/Koehler/Phelps. I was cool with Haren retiring under the assumption that we were going to get that 5th starting pitcher who is a capable #3 within the league. Unfortunately the best we got after adding Latos was Phelps (who isn't a terrible option, just not the perfect one). Gotta believe that if Haren plays his best he could post a mid 3 ERA for the team, which makes him a decent #3 starter. Biggest question is whether he'll half ass the season, deals with emotional/psychological issues/etc... if he were to pitch here in Miami as opposed to somewhere else. Probably not the best idea to bank on Haren in the rotation next season for us. I personally think the report by Frisaro is the Marlins leaking to the media to try and drive up Haren's price tag or force a west coast team's to feel a little panic and pull the trigger on a trade.
-
Fangraphs Farm Evaluation
I also see they forgot a couple names I think can turn into top 10 Marlins prospects very soon. Mason Davis, our 19th round pick this past draft, absolutely demolished Batavia in his time there. Yes obviously it's not even Greensboro yet and he's a college player at that, but if you've seen some tapes on him he's got a really smooth swing, can hit from both sides of the plate, and shows above average defense at 2B with an ability to play SS in the future, and has a solid Preston Wilson style ability to steal bases. His college numbers suggest to me that he's a player who has a solid hit tool but a lack of power and a lack of plate discipline. He showed both of those things at Batavia, but obviously it's a decent step up to Greensboro and an even bigger step up to Jupiter after that. Not calling him a top prospect now, but he's got some real five tool raw ability that if mentored properly could make him a threat in the minors. Other guy to follow is Ben Holmes, aka the guy Ben Wetzler from Oregon State, aka that guy who got screwed over by the Phillies. 5th Rounder in 2013, after the f*ck up with the Phillies goes back to school, posts a 12-1 record with an ERA under 1 for the season. He got better and better every season he was at Oregon State. He has your basic fastball/slider/changeup combination that he uses effectively, throwing in the low 90s area. The biggest reason teams were scared of Wetzler were mostly character related stuff. Got suspended five games for drunkenly walking into the wrong house, the agent incident, dumb nitpicky things that can obviously change. When you look at his body of work you could see him being a late first or second round talent but fell to the 9th round. He was pretty good in Batavia in his short time with a 2.92 ERA, and Greensboro will be a big test. He's one of a few college pitchers that we drafted this past year that could really be interesting this year.
-
Fangraphs Farm Evaluation
Yeah the farm is incredibly weak after the trades. I don't remember our farm system being this bad since I started watching the team in 2000. To be fair though the farm wasn't all that strong before the trades either. It just took a bottom 12 minor league system in MLB and turned it into bottom 3.
-
Hall of Fame Voting.
I mixed up Delgado and Edgar. Ha! That was a dumb one. Still true they hate DH's though.
-
Hall of Fame Voting.
Irked that Carlos Delgado got a one-and-done. Not saying he should be in the Hall, but to only get 21 votes total, that's terrible. Hall of Fame voters hate hate HATE designated hitters. Amazing how good a hitter Frank Thomas had to be to get in like he did. Just look side by side with a guy who has been inducted into the Hall of Fame in Jim Rice, and Delgado across the board is a much better hitter. Damn near 500 home runs, over 1000 walks, 99 RBI's or more ten times in his career. Hell even in a past his prime season Delgado produced 38 homers and 115 RBI's for the Mets. Definitely deserved better treatment than the voters gave him.
-
Hall of Fame Voting.
I was off by one Piazza boo.
-
Where Do We Go From Here?
I think it's more of the simple fact that 220 innings of 3.20 ERA (What Shields produced last year) is better than 65 innings of 3.17 ERA (What Cishek did last year). It's a hell of a lot easier to find somebody who can fill in and pitch the 9th inning effectively like Cishek than to find somebody who can pitch the 1st-8th inning just as effectively. Put Ramos or Capps in at Cishek's spot and there's a chance we get similar numbers as Cishek produced. Put Hand/Koehler/Phelps in the spot that Shields would occupy and you don't get nearly the production Shields delivers. This is not me advocating for the trade. I'm not in favor of paying mid 30 year olds $20 million+ a year long term, so I'm 100% in favor of passing on Shields. But if the money equals itself out (with Haren's $10 million in retirement hedge funds and the $7 million or $8 million Cishek gets in arbitration), you get close to what Shields will command in free agency.
-
Fourth Outfielder
Just as a baseball fan I'd rather Ichiro go somewhere where he can get daily at bats and reach the 3000 hit mark before he retires. We don't offer that kind of opportunity. Yeah Ichiro shouldn't be starting anymore, but he deserves the chance to get 3000 hits and secure his future spot in the HOF.
-
2012 Trade narrative
Apologies for that. Started off as a simple post and somehow went on many different tangents. Basically TL;DR Marlins good; Blue Jays bad; but could've been better without Loria holding team back.
-
2012 Trade narrative
I think in retrospect the trade worked out. Josh Johnson busted out. Mark Buehrle is a very good pitcher but was a short term solution for a team that needed to really start thinking long term. Jose Reyes has had his fair share of injuries and is on the wrong side of 30 for a speedy slap swinging style hitter. John Buck was not a very good player at the time of the trade and still isn't, and you can find a Bonifacio style player any day on the waiver wire scraps. In the end it we traded Bonifacio and JJ at their near peak values (Bonfacio's peak value was after 2011, JJ after 2011), Buehrle and Reyes remain the only real "useful" players left for the Blue Jays and while Buehrle's deal seems to be fair given his production in the AL, Jose Reyes seems like he's going to be an overpay in the coming years. For the Marlins they ended up getting solid value. The trade return was hurt by the Marlins front office overvaluing two particular players: Adeiny Hechavarria and Jeff Mathis. Mathis was the piece that nearly held up the trade entirely, and at the time Hech was a near top 100 prospect even though all statistics indicated the hitting would never really materialize. Henderson Alvarez has become the real jewel of the trade. Put up ace caliber numbers this past season and made the All Star team at 24 years old. His ability to be at least a mid 3 ERA's kind of pitcher long term seems pretty good, and he's going into this upcoming season as our #1 or 2. When you do a trade you always want to get the best player/value in it. I don't know if the Marlins thought he would become the best guy in the deal when it was made, but in the end Alvarez is the best value in the deal, given his service time, age, stats, etc... I'll quickly glance over Escobar since he was traded for without any real intention of playing here, and thus became Dietrich, who is a decent player but needed proper development to have a chance of becoming a possible starting 2nd baseman. The Marlins seem to have mismanaged him following the Martinez incident, and he doesn't appear to be in the team's long term plans anymore. Still he's decent depth and should likely be on the Marlins bench as a utility hitter or possible replacement for poor play or injury by June. Jake Marisnick may have been the guy the Marlins were most excited to see in the trade. Five tool player with a cannon for an arm in the outfield and great closing speed, with in the gaps power and a solid base stealing record. After seeing him play in the majors for the Marlins and even his latter minor league stuff you could tell he was just too raw at the plate and needed a few more years in the minors and some good hitting coaches to get the right approach. Even now he's just 23 years old and has over 300 AB's in the majors, which is something most hitters that age can't say. His defense will always make him valuable for some team with good hitters already littered throughout their lineup, but the Marlins knew that building a winning team meant getting some better pitching at the deadline and possibly selling a little low on Marisnick and Moran (although it's possible to see it as trading before their value drops tremendously and teams realize their value doesn't equal their former pedigree). In the end Marisnick in part became Cosart/Wates/Hernandez, with Hernandez in part becoming Dee Gordon. In the grand scheme of things I will view Marisnick in terms of the trade value he brought, and in a series of trades he contribute at least in part towards the team eventually getting its starting 2nd baseman and #3 starting pitcher at the moment. While it's not exactly the big value and potential breakout the Marlins hoped when trading for Marisnick, it's good that he at least didn't bust and become nothing to us. Anthony Desclafani was a nice pitcher but doesn't have much of a future in a major league starting rotation. He'll likely transition back into a middle of the bullpen role given his previous experience closing at Florida and will probably be very good at it. At the time of the trade Desclafani seemed like a bit of a thrown in player given his one season in A ball and a previous closer, but he really morphed into a respectable pitching prospect. In the end Desclafani and Chad Wallach (who I liked but just a year ago was a 5th round draft pick) turned into a season of Mat Latos this year. Given Latos' previous numbers and age it seems like a small gamble with a potential (and imo likely) high reward if the injury bug stays away. Lastly is Justin Nicolino, who is a solid pitching prospect but also a very confusing one. Doesn't strike out guys, is still highly regarded, but doesn't walk people either and has learned not to give up runs. He's had a few starts here and there where he has god awful outings, but he's fairly consistent on a game to game basis and has gotten but thus far on his average stuff. Given the park the Marlins play at he should be a fine #5 starter candidate for the 2016 season. In the end of the Blue Jays got two aging starts in the backburner of their career and getting paid like stars. The Marlins got, in terms of immediate production, a #2 or 3 starter in Alvarez, a mildly below average starting SS in Hechavarria, and a backup catcher in Mathis, with guys like Marisnick and Desclafani putting in games and non nondescript games for the Marlins over the last few years. Inadvertently the trade also helped lead to us eventually getting Dee Gordon, Mat Latos, Jarred Cosart, and Derek Dietrich. Again, decent pieces but nothing that stands out as players who help get teams into the postseason. At the end of the day you look back at the trade and know that the Marlins came out on top, but it wasn't game changing more as it was a building towards the future style trade like it was said to be at the end (well, other than as a fire sale). The only real breakout star of the trade was Alvarez, but the trade helped us build towards a better team moving forward. It definitely sacrificed the present (aka 2012/2013/2014). I'm not sure if the team could've or wouldn't have made the playoffs if they didn't trade off all those pieces in 2012 such as Hanley, Infante, Sanchez, etc... But its obvious that the business model was flawed and for our organization wasn't sustainable. The current model is much better. If they spend some money, it's on guys with short term deals like Morse, Latos, hell even though it didn't work out Jones wasn't so bad since all these deals were only for one or two years. Trading for guys under team control like Gordon and Cosart are how you build sustainable winners. The model in 2012 was to win immediately and win big, but unfortunately it was set up to handicap the team into long term deals with Bell for 3 years, Buehrle for 4 and Reyes for 6. If the team didn't try to get out of those deals after the first year we very easily would've been stuck with them and with a mediocre team for big money for a prolonged period of time. Loria wouldn't have been happy, the front office wouldn't have been happy, the fans wouldn't have been happy, nobody would've been happy. The front office, including Beinfest before getting fired, mostly did the best they could do given the circumstances they've been given. It's incredibly hard to field a good team with the payroll restrictions currently given, and the one time the team was given free reign with the checkbook Jeffrey Loria exerted major influence in getting us to sign players. I'm not sure the front office targets Jose Reyes or Heath Bell if Loria didn't push for it so heavily. The trade with the Blue Jays is partly a symbol of the right business model. It's getting rid of inefficiencies that currently exist within the team and turning them into profitable assets. They got Alvarez at a low-ish value and he's blossomed into an All Star. Marisnick and Nicolino were great pieces to trade for at the time and both could still very easily blossom into stars themselves. The only real negative I can say in hindsight about the trade is not being able to get Noah Syndergaard or Travis d'Arnaud along with Alvarez/Marisnick/Nicolino and instead getting Mathis/Escobar/Hechavarria. Given the value of Josh Johnson/Jose Reyes/Mark Buehrle/Emilio Bonifacio at the time of the trade, I feel very confident in saying we should've been able to net Syndergaard or d'Arnaud along with Alvarez/Marisnick/Nicolino. The only reason we didn't get Syndergaard or d'Arnaud is frustratingly that Loria wouldn't take on enough (or much of any) salary, and thus the return on prospects was lower. Getting d'Arnaud in that trade wouldn't negated the need to sign Saltlamacchia and in retrospect would've saved Loria even more money, so it's even more frustrating. I know I've turned this into a novel and it's strayed away from the original point, but the point is the trade was a good one, and even if at the time it was viewed (and rightfully so) as a fire sale, in retrospect it was more of a return to proper team management given the confines the organization is run under. Loria is a big reason the team screwed up so badly in the 2012 season, and his stinginess again after the fact was a big reason this trade is good rather than great in my eyes. If the return wasn't Alvarez/Marisnick/Nicolino/Escobar/Mathis/Hechavarria but rather d'Arnaud/Alvarez/Marisnick/Nicolino, I'd feel a hell of a lot better, and given the fact d'Arnaud was traded with Syndgaard for basically R.A Dickey, I don't see why Josh Johnson's value back in 2012 alone couldn't have netted us one of the two at the very least.
-
Dan Haren
I wish we would grow some ball and sign Max Scherzer... If you want to be paying old past his prime Max Scherzer $20-25 million a year in his age 35 to 38 years at the backend of a seven or eight year contract, by all means show us your bank account and donate that money to Loria and we'll have Scherzer right now. But no sane team is giving Scherzer the long term deal he's looking for because they all know how stupid it will be later on. Whichever team ends up giving him that deal will have the financial means to overcome that irrationality later (Cubs/Yankees/Red Sox kind of teams) and are always in win now mode. While you could say our front office has shown that they're in win now mode, we don't have the money to be giving a quarter of our future overall payroll to a soon to be past his prime Max Scherzer.
-
Dan Haren
Well duh. He didn't want to play here. The Marlins thinking they could convince him to want to play here was stupid (although they did the trade knowing the chances of this happening were more likely than not). And the rotation is fine if not a bit questionable. I like Eovaldi but he got us a pretty sizable upgrade at 3B in Prado. The trade with Haren was really for Dee Gordon and most of the prospects given away were for Gordon, with the rest thrown in so the Dodgers would take on Haren's salary. This was the scenario we all anticipated. If we get anything for Haren from the Angels, Padres, or whatever West Coast team would want him, even if it's just some single A arms, then great.e If he retires and we get nothing, so be it. Next season we're going in with Alvarez/Latos/Cosart/Koehler and one of Phelps/Hand/Crow starting off the season as the #5 and rotating based on a variety of factors (injuries, under performance, etc...). I view Jose Fernandez this year as pretty much being the best Trade Deadline acquisition any team will make. I think to be a playoff caliber team, we'll have to stay at least around 5 to 7 games over .500 when the Trade Deadline hits. Can we be that much over .500 relying on that rotation mentioned above for four months of the season? Alvarez and Latos should certainly be fine, and while Cosart is a question mark if he's even half as good as last year he's a perfect #3. Add to that if Koehler and the #5 can post mid 4 ERA's, with our offense hopefully improved we could be in good shape come late July. Look. I'm not calling it a perfect situation. The front office didn't build a perfectly balanced roster and it took nearly the entirety of our minor league system to get it. But the team is definitely improved.
-
Hall of Fame Voting.
Johnson Martinez Biggio Piazza Smoltz These are the five guys I see getting in, with Bagwell being the closest on the outside looking in.
-
2015 lineup
Gordon Yelich Stanton Morse Prado Ozuna Salty Hech Pitcher I don't understand Prado 5th here. If he's not 1 or 2, better off at 6/7 with this team. Balance imo. Speed at 1, Contact ability and good OBP at 2, power bats at 3/4, Good contact ability at 5 (I didn't want 3 hitters back to back to back with high strikeout rates), back to a power bat at 6, then obvious Salty/Hech at 7/8. I just feel good with Prado there. No issue with Ozuna at 5 and Prado at 6, that works for me too. I just want to spread out the lineup where we're not going potentially too top heavy (although there's really no scenario that happens). Like I've said before, most of these lineup arguments won't make much of a difference in terms of run production in the end, rather it's just a matter of personal preference.
-
2015 lineup
Gordon Yelich Stanton Morse Prado Ozuna Salty Hech Pitcher
-
Where Do We Go From Here?
Yeah we'd all love Gordon to post an OBP of .350+, but he likely won't. However we have nobody like him on the team with the speed to bunt for a hit to start off any game, then steal a base and create a RISP opportunity early in every game. I just hate putting Gordon anywhere but leadoff. That's just saying "hey, you know that BIG thing we traded you for and know you can bring to the team? Yeah, let's put you somewhere in the lineup we're we won't let you do that". If he could turn into prime Juan Pierre when he was posting mid to high .300 OBP's that would be greaaaaaaaat