Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

30plus

Members
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by 30plus

  1. There's a good chance you'll see a lefty matchup of Mark Hendrickson (FLA) Vs. Matt Chico (WSH) I'm not sure about Chico because their rotation hasn't taken shape yet, but he did start on Saturday. Depending on how it pans out, you might see Perez or Lohse from Washington. Chico is still probably the better bet though. Lohse is on the Cardinals. My mistake, I meant to say Perez or Lannan with the odds in favor of Chico getting the start.
  2. I doubt he will be back, at least not this season. I always root for Hurk, but its clear it will take him a while to develop into a big league pitcher. He's always an option in the bullpen if one of our guys go down. Unless that happens, I don't see him rejoining the club for a while, especially when Mitre and Anibel return in June, there won't be many spots left.
  3. sorry if this has already been covered in this thread but is Wes likely to feature at all in todays (Sunday) game against the pirates? The Miami Herald said he'd be arriving around game time, so he will be there, but I don't know that he'll be used. He'll be landing at 2pm. WES HAS ARRIVED!!!! OMG!!!! A CAREER .265 HITTER HAS ARRIVED!!! THE DIVISION IS OURS!!!
  4. Dontrelle is the perfect exemplar for all that is wrong with the Tigers. Outside of Zoolander the starters just won't be consistent enough to compete with the division, much less the AL. (Cleveland's starters, anyone?). And as troubling as the starters are, that's the least of their worries. The bullpen is full of the usual suspects, a'la Cliffhanger Jones and China Syndrome Grilli. You got to be scared when hopes of bullpen improvement hinge upon Zumaya and Rodney, who appear to be made out of porcelain. Plus, Dombrowski should of realized the minute he moved into his office in CoPa that outslugging people ain't gonna work in the AL, especially when you play half of your games in a cornfield. 2nd highest payroll in the league, and they aren't gonna finish in the same zip code as CLE, NYY or BOS, let alone sniff the playoffs. I agree that the Tigers need to figure alot of things out, but I'm not ready to write them off yet. Let's not forget that this is a lineup that has 4 guys who have been in batting races as recently as 07 (Cabrera, Renteria, Ordonez, Polanco) with one of them having won a title. If you take their averages from 07 they've combined to hit .335+ between the 4 of them. They got off to a rough start offensively but with a lineup like that, don't expect it to last long. When those bats come alive, its gonna be raining base hits. This shouldn't be a team that has to outslugg people to win. With the kind of quality hitters they have its not like the're depending on the long ball to bail them out. They are veterans who can play small ball and hit with RISP. The bullpen is probably their main weakness, its the reason they will have to battle for a playoff spot. After they got Cabrera and Willis it seemed like everyone was picking them to go to the WS. I don't doubt that they can do that, but alot of things will have to fall into place and the division won't be handed to them.
  5. We've been outscored 19-31 but we're 2-0 in 1 run games! :thumbup 14 of those 19 runs coming via the home run, so I would imagine we're in the top 5 in the league, if not the majors.
  6. There's a good chance you'll see a lefty matchup of Mark Hendrickson (FLA) Vs. Matt Chico (WSH) I'm not sure about Chico because their rotation hasn't taken shape yet, but he did start on Saturday. Depending on how it pans out, you might see Perez or Lohse from Washington. Chico is still probably the better bet though.
  7. Actually Hoover will be optioned/DFAd when Rabelo is ready. No reason for us to carry 3 catchers. You're right, I forgot about him. Then the obvious move to make when Hermida returns would be to send Andino down, and we keep Carroll. :thumbup Do you have a man crush on Carrol? Andino is the only guy on the roster who can backup Hanley, because Amezaga is being used to platoon in CF. Hanley has played all but one inning so far. He doesn't necessarily need a regular back-up as Hermida or Ross might need in Center. The only situation where he would need a back-up is if we wanted to give him a breather in a blow-out game in late innings. Amezega would be brought in from CF to play short, and Carroll or Ross would take over CF. Not to mention Ross would be getting 30-40% of the starts out there in Center, making Amezega an option off the bench. It makes alot more sense to retain Carroll than it would Andino, considering how often each would be used. And to answer your question, no I don't have a man crush on Carroll. I'm just one of those crazy people who values keeping the more important player. I think a Garbage Man quote will fit nicely here - Gonna go kill myself now. Carroll couldn't hit water if he fell out of a boat. We have enough guys who swing and miss....we don't need another one. and Andino is much better? Just because he's started the season 2 for 3 doesn't make him a proven bat. Not that I'm making a case for Carroll offensively, its not like he or Andino would remain on the team because of their bats. They are both defensive substitutes. Considering Carroll can back up all outfield positions, he would be used alot more than Andino who will be rotting away on the bench. Uggla and Ramirez rarely miss a game and we have 2 guys who can play third. Carroll also gives us the option of having an extra guy to go play CF in the rare situation that Amezega needs to be brought in to back-up Uggla or Hanley. He also becomes the direct back-up to Hermida. Where do you figure Andino gets any playing time in all that? And, this is thinking long-term, when Maybin joins the club Amezega becomes a complete back-up rather than a platoon in center. He becomes the immediate back-up to Hanley and Uggla, and Carroll and Ross back-up Center and Right. It makes alot more sense to carry Carroll long-term rather than Andino, who will recieve a warm butt on the bench. Andino has a .214 BA, .261 OBP, and .321 SLG in 84 ABs, which sucks. Carroll has a .175 BA, .217 OBP, and .228 SLG in 57 ABs, which sucks more. In addition to that, Carrol has struck out 18 times, two more than Andino's 16. In addition to that, you talk about long term, and when Maybin comes up. By the time Maybin comes up, De Aza will probably be back and both Andino and Carroll will be in AAA. I'm not arguing who has the better bat, its clear they both suck. The point is that Carroll will be needed more than Andino over the next 4-6 weeks as a defensive replacement. Nobody has come up with anything to say that Andino will be used more. Their value is not in their bats, its in their versatility and how much each will be used. As for De Aza returning, that won't be for at least another 6 weeks. Hermida will return in a few days and in between that time the more valuable one to keep is Carroll. If he's sent down when De Aza is called up then that's fair enough. The fact is it makes more sense to keep Carroll over Andino until that happens.
  8. Actually Hoover will be optioned/DFAd when Rabelo is ready. No reason for us to carry 3 catchers. You're right, I forgot about him. Then the obvious move to make when Hermida returns would be to send Andino down, and we keep Carroll. :thumbup Do you have a man crush on Carrol? Andino is the only guy on the roster who can backup Hanley, because Amezaga is being used to platoon in CF. Hanley has played all but one inning so far. He doesn't necessarily need a regular back-up as Hermida or Ross might need in Center. The only situation where he would need a back-up is if we wanted to give him a breather in a blow-out game in late innings. Amezega would be brought in from CF to play short, and Carroll or Ross would take over CF. Not to mention Ross would be getting 30-40% of the starts out there in Center, making Amezega an option off the bench. It makes alot more sense to retain Carroll than it would Andino, considering how often each would be used. And to answer your question, no I don't have a man crush on Carroll. I'm just one of those crazy people who values keeping the more important player. I think a Garbage Man quote will fit nicely here - Gonna go kill myself now. Carroll couldn't hit water if he fell out of a boat. We have enough guys who swing and miss....we don't need another one. and Andino is much better? Just because he's started the season 2 for 3 doesn't make him a proven bat. Not that I'm making a case for Carroll offensively, its not like he or Andino would remain on the team because of their bats. They are both defensive substitutes. Considering Carroll can back up all outfield positions, he would be used alot more than Andino who will be rotting away on the bench. Uggla and Ramirez rarely miss a game and we have 2 guys who can play third. Carroll also gives us the option of having an extra guy to go play CF in the rare situation that Amezega needs to be brought in to back-up Uggla or Hanley. He also becomes the direct back-up to Hermida. Where do you figure Andino gets any playing time in all that? And, this is thinking long-term, when Maybin joins the club Amezega becomes a complete back-up rather than a platoon in center. He becomes the immediate back-up to Hanley and Uggla, and Carroll and Ross back-up Center and Right. It makes alot more sense to carry Carroll long-term rather than Andino, who will recieve a warm butt on the bench. Damn it, can somebody give me a real reason for why Andino should remain on the club over Carroll?
  9. Actually Hoover will be optioned/DFAd when Rabelo is ready. No reason for us to carry 3 catchers. You're right, I forgot about him. Then the obvious move to make when Hermida returns would be to send Andino down, and we keep Carroll. :thumbup Do you have a man crush on Carrol? Andino is the only guy on the roster who can backup Hanley, because Amezaga is being used to platoon in CF. Hanley has played all but one inning so far. He doesn't necessarily need a regular back-up as Hermida or Ross might need in Center. The only situation where he would need a back-up is if we wanted to give him a breather in a blow-out game in late innings. Amezega would be brought in from CF to play short, and Carroll or Ross would take over CF. Not to mention Ross would be getting 30-40% of the starts out there in Center, making Amezega an option off the bench. It makes alot more sense to retain Carroll than it would Andino, considering how often each would be used. And to answer your question, no I don't have a man crush on Carroll. I'm just one of those crazy people who values keeping the more important player. I think a Garbage Man quote will fit nicely here - Gonna go kill myself now.
  10. By the way, I really think we are turning into one of the better teams in the NL East. Dude, we just took two from the Pirates, the same team that hasn't had a winning season in 16 years. Did you miss the two losses to the Mets ? :blink: Especially that 3rd game ? We looked like a little league team next to the Mets. This team is what it is, a team that can strive to be .500 at best. :confused I was speaking about our roster our bullpen is great, starters can be good, and our lineup can produce a lot of runs... if we get hot at the right times... Don't give yourself false hopes. Aquiring Helms didn't all of a sudden give us a deep roster. He might, might make a difference of a couple more hits off the bench. That's all.
  11. Actually Hoover will be optioned/DFAd when Rabelo is ready. No reason for us to carry 3 catchers. You're right, I forgot about him. Then the obvious move to make when Hermida returns would be to send Andino down, and we keep Carroll. :thumbup
  12. Ultimately this means Carroll will get sent down once Rabelo returns. :confused I hope that isn't the case, he's been solid so far and I prefer him as the fourth outfielder to an Amezega, especially backing up RF.
  13. I've got nothing strong against Wes Helms (after all, I was a bit upset to see him go after 2006), but why is everyone here so excited to see him back? His 2007 was rather abysmal. Never seen so many people get so excited over a mediocre player like Helms. Maybe its all we got.... In saying that, Helms is probably an upgrade over Wood off the bench if he can do something close to what he did in 06. I don't think he will platoon on a regular basis, but he'll be a regular pinch hitter and a spot starter.
  14. IT IS WES HELMS!!!!!!! Keep it in your pants.....Its only Wes Helms.
  15. Liked the job he did, but with Hermida coming back it had to be done. I believe this means Carroll and Andino will remain with the club? One of them will have to be sent down with Hermida coming up, I would guess Andino. I'm not too familiar with the roster status, but isn't Hermida the reason Wood was designated? A move in advance for his return. Then when Rabelo returns, Andino is sent down. Edit: Never mind, just saw that we got Helms.
  16. Liked the job he did, but with Hermida coming back it had to be done. I believe this means Carroll and Andino will remain with the club?
  17. Did he come out of the game with an injury? They mentioned something about an injury or something on FOX. I think it was the fourth inning when the trainer and everybody came out to look at him. He stayed in the game so he either convinced them he was fine or it wasn't anything serious. The reason he got pulled in the sixth was because of the way he was pitching, not because of injury.
  18. While I think this whole topic was silly to discuss when brought up in this thread as it still now just an update: Miller gave up 5 ER on 8 H in 4.1 IP in his first start. Dontrelle was pulled from his first start a few minutes ago, after having thrown 5 IP of no hit baseball. Was pulled in the 6th with no outs after giving up 2 BB and then 1 run on the the first hit, and RBI double by Thome. He did have some walks earlier in the game as well though. He walked a career high 7 batters and barely through half his pitches for strikes. The two guys he left on base also scored after he got pulled. And sadly, that still makes it a better outing than Miller had. 3ER on 1H and 7BB in 5IP vs 5ER on 8H and 2BB in 4.1IP including 1 HR. Yes but Willis has been pitching in the big leagues for 5 years...he doesn't have an excuse for not throwing strikes. Besides, you can't compare 2 pitchers based on their season debuts. Let alone a rookie who still has to figure things out compared to an established major league pitcher.
  19. While I think this whole topic was silly to discuss when brought up in this thread as it still now just an update: Miller gave up 5 ER on 8 H in 4.1 IP in his first start. Dontrelle was pulled from his first start a few minutes ago, after having thrown 5 IP of no hit baseball. Was pulled in the 6th with no outs after giving up 2 BB and then 1 run on the the first hit, and RBI double by Thome. He did have some walks earlier in the game as well though. He walked a career high 7 batters and barely threw half his pitches for strikes. The two guys he left on base also scored after he got pulled.
  20. Willis line - 5 IP, 1 H, 3 R, 7 walks, 0 K's on 89 pitches (46 strikes). You knew those walks were going to come back to bite him. He got away with 5 of them until the 6th when Thome made them hurt. By the way, those 7 walks a career high for him.
  21. As far as my opinion goes, it has nothing to do with the first 3 games. Forget about the first 3 games. Do you disagree with my opinion that we have the worst starting rotation in MLB. If so, please tell me who you think is worse. Or my thought that next year, when we're hopefuly healthier, we'll have a decent middle of the road starting rotation, perhaps better than average. hell i think there are 2 teams in our own division with worst starting pitching in the phillies and nationals... we have the talent...now the guys need to grow into their talent... as where the phils and nats have virtually nothing aside from maybe the possibility of brett myers putting his game together this year and maybe a pretty good cole hamels... A pretty good Cole Hamels? What a stupid thing to say. Guy is better than anyone in our organization will probably ever be, including Andrew Miller- who hasn't thrown strikes since middle school. throwing 95+ doesn't make up for an inability to put it over the plate. I will take Hamels' changeup and ability to throw strikes over Miller's fastball and complete inability to throw a strike any time. Some of you have no idea what the word, "good" actually means. Moron. I know it sucks with everyone ganging up on you and all, but take it easy. Nah, it doesn't suck at all. I don't expect the homers to think logically or realistically. It is nice being able to form an opinion that isn't based on nothing. It doesn't suck at all. :thumbup realistic? sure maybe...but you are far from logical...very far Not sure what the hell you mean by that. My opinions are not based on the first three games of the season. They are based on the fact that Mark Hendrickson is not good and is going to be facing other teams' number 1 and 2 starters until he loses his spot. Rick Vanden Hurk does not belong in a MLB starting rotation with his 2 pitches and inability to throw either for strikes consistently. Andrew Miller has always had a problem with his control, going back to his highschool days- this isn't something new he is struggling with. Scott Olsen is our only major league quality pitcher and I have no problem with him being in the rotation, really. I'm actually looking forward to seeing Olsen perform this year. Ricky Nolasco always finds a way to have an inning in which he blows up, and he will be a very good reliever and spot starter for a long time, I think. He doesn't seem to be capable of starting every five days though. I have reasons for my negative opinions, they aren't just formulated based on the Mets kicking our ass yesterday. I have said from the beginning of Spring Training that the guys who have a future with this team should not be called up until they are READY. Having Andrew Miller and Rick Vanden Hurk in the rotation does nothing positive for anyone at this point. The bullpen can't go 5 innings every night, and the offense can't be trying to score 8 runs every night just to have a chance to win. We need guys who can throw strikes, and I don't see why we should be letting these young punks get knocked around up here when we have guys we can bring up who may not be part of the future, but can't possibly do any worse. I would rather have Chris Seddon and Daniel Barone (who both suck terribly but can throw strikes) up here and let Andrew Miller go learn to throw the ball over the plate in New Mexico, along with Hurk. I love Vanden Hurk's curveball, but he needs so much work. Having them work out their problems up here is a waste of time for everyone. And our offense is pretty average without Cabrera in it, and below average without Hermida. If Hermida can perform the way I think he can when he returns, then I think we will be somewhere in the middle of the NL, maybe a little better. I would like to see how Uggla performs in the 5th spot in the order, but Freddi seems hellbent on leaving him to bat 2nd. Mike Jacobs is the only position player I don't really like. He seems to have gotten a little better defensively, but he still has that really long swing and bad plate discipline. We have no better option though, unless they decide to stick Luis Gonzalez in there permanantly. I haven't formed an opinion about Cantu yet, and he is the guy I was hoping they'd go out ang get along with McPherson, so we will see what happens. He made some nice plays a couple nights ago. I am not completely negative, but I don't see how anyone can sit there and think everything is going to magically fall into place. ...and yet, with EVERYTHING you just said, being "realistic," we are 1-2 with 159 games left. The rest...is unpredictable, therefore, what you stated is an opinion (although, it could be true, it isn't yet...). So much for you being "realistic." :thumbup Look, I'm not going to argue with a 16 year old kid about anything. Of course it is an opinion, you fool. What the hell else would it be? I guess you think you are being clever with the little thumbup there, but I never said that what I say is the law around here or anywhere for that matter. My opinion should mean nothing to anyone who disagrees with me. You keep telling me that I am wrong, the same way I think you are wrong. You are doing the same thing as I am, but taking a different stance. In the end, yes, we will see how it plays out. I was simply stating my reasons for the pessimism, and if you find no validity in my reasons, that is fine. Sorry I am spoiling your good time and that you can't kiss this team's ass with the other happy fans, unfettered. Just try and understand what I am writing before accusing me of acclaiming myself master of the baseball universe. touche, Garbage man....tocuhe. I have absolutely nothing to do with this argument, but I just enjoy reading your posts. I love how when 5 people gang up on you they can't come up with anything of substance to say to go along with their baseless arguments.
  22. -Our starting pitching combined for a whopping total of 12 1/3 innings to go with 14 runs allowed on 21 hits. The bullpen was taxed with 15 2/3 innings in the first 3 games of the season, averaging more innings per game than the starters. -6 of our 7 runs came via the long ball. We were outscored 24-7. Nothing wrong with home runs, but they shouldn't be the main source of a team's production. -We made 2 errors (Treanor, Vandenhurk) but other than that the defense looked sharp. Both Hanley and Cantu made some nice plays. Still, the weaknesses are obvious in the outfield without a legit defensive center fielder. -Amezega was unleashed. Nobody said our starting pitching would be good, but I don't think it will be nearly as bad as it has been through the first 3 games. The return of Anibel and Mitre in June will help things considerably. Still, it might be a while before Miller or Vandenhurk see the elusive seventh inning. Defense was one of the bright spots. I must admit, all the talk about how the Marlins were working on improving this spring didn't have me convinced. If the first series is any indication, we've improved drastically from last year. Not saying we're average yet but we won't finish in the bottom 3 in the league. Home runs are only going to get you so far. We out-homered the Mets 4-2 yet they scored over three times as many runs as we did. It could be an ugly trend if the offense has to depend on the majority of their runs coming from the long ball. Yes the walk-off was great and everything, but it doesn't happen everyday. We need to learn how to hit with runners in scoring position and play small ball if we want a shot at 70 wins. The bullpen is one of the best in the league. Regardless of how good you are, when you have to throw 12 innings on back to back games with no rest, there are going to be struggles as we saw tonight. They still held their own and did a good job under the circumstances. As the year goes on, and hopefully the starting pitching improves, the bullpen will look as good on paper as they do in talent.
  23. AL East- Red Sox AL Central- Tigers AL West- Angels AL Wildcard- Mariners NL East- Mets NL Central- Cubs NL West- Diamondbacks NL Wildcard- Braves AL Champions- Red Sox NL Champions- Mets WS Winners- Mets
  24. here we go again!! im sure this injury is gonna linger the whole year as usual. Robert Andino was called up to take his spot. Hermida and Rabelo better be back on April 5th when they are eligible. id wouldve rather seen gomez stay up and keep alfredo in the infield. It's looking unlikely that Rabelo will be back by April 5th. Hermida is a more realistic shot to be back by then, but even his status is uncertain. I thought the whole reason we didn't want Andino with the ball club was we didn't want him rotting on the bench when he could play everyday down in the minors. With Amezega likely to split time with Ross in Centerfield, Andino becomes the main back-up infielder.
  25. Hermida defintely appears to be "fragile," I only hope his defense improves , otherwise Tommy Hutton will probably run down from the booth and smack Hermida lol...I remember him being really pissed off at Hermida last year when he dropped a routine fly ball..said something to the likes of "a major leaguer needs to catch that ball, Jeremy should be embarressed".

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.