Everything posted by 30plus
-
Something to chat about... Re: Cantu.
I think Uggla would not be much better at third than Cantu is, but Cantu will be much worse than Uggla is at second. Considering 2nd is the more important defense posistion, it'd be better to have Uggla at second. Based on what? Its no secret that Uggla has a stronger throwing arm and that the majority of Cantu's errors have been poor throws. I'm not saying Cantu is necessarily a defensive upgrade over Uggla (who is definitely an underrated defender) at second but based on his track record he will commit less errors from that position. Note that Cantu's career fielding percentage at third is around the .916 area as compared to the low .970's at second base. There is a big enough sample size with a big enough difference between the totals to show you that he is better suited to play second base. Not sure what you have to back up your assertion that Cantu will be "much worse" than Uggla at second when there is a difference of about 10 points in their career fielding percentages at the position. There is nothing to indicate that Uggla, who came up playing third base in the minors, would not do a better job than Cantu at third. Ultimately you're getting the same defense from second base while receiving a significant upgrade at third by getting Cantu out of there. Claiming that Cantu would do a much worse job than Uggla at second is completely baseless.
-
Question about where to bat Hanley?
1,2, and 4 are all lefties Splitting up left handed hitters is overrated. You put people in the line up where they are best suited. In this case, I would still bat Willingham fourth when he comes back. In any case, Jones would be getting starts against right handed pitchers, so back to back lefties isn't exactly a disadvantage. And Hanley isn't going anywhere anytime soon. They will stick with him in the 3 hole as long as the offense keeps producing.
-
Something to chat about... Re: Cantu.
And to address the person who thought of switching Cantu and Uggla in the field, what's the point? Uggla's offense at second is that of a great third baseman. Cantu's numbers at third are that of an above average second baseman. It all evens out. What do their offensive numbers in correlation with their positions have to do with anything? The point I was making was that the team's defense would improve as a result from a positional switch. Uggla has played some third base in the minors and Cantu has played more games at second base at the major league level while putting up better defensive numbers from second. Alot of his errors have been accounted for from poor throws so I was suggesting a move to second would result in easier throws and less errors. I don't remember mentioning anything about matching their offensive numbers with the appropriate positions they should play on the field. It has to do with the idea that Cantu will cost the team less errors from second base while Uggla has shown the ability to play third in the past. At least try reading my post before saying my argument is pointless.
-
Roles in the bullpen?
Kensing and his 7.2 ERA in his last six appearances in the 8th? No thanks. Pinto, Nelson, Gregg please. Right and let's just ignore his 0.87 ERA through his first 9 appearences. But no, you're right, we should make the judgement based on his last six appearences only. Btw, Miller has 2 starts to lower his ERA another 19 points for the sig bet. What sig bet, my I ask? I bet Benched that Miller would have his ERA under 6 within 4 weeks of his start against the Padres, which was 2 starts ago. It was three starts, not four weeks. It was three weeks, which translated into 4 starts. Do you remember what the old thread was so we can bring it up? I remember you planned it out and wrote down all the teams he would start against during the 3 weeks, which was 4 teams.
-
Roles in the bullpen?
Kensing and his 7.2 ERA in his last six appearances in the 8th? No thanks. Pinto, Nelson, Gregg please. Right and let's just ignore his 0.87 ERA through his first 9 appearences. But no, you're right, we should make the judgement based on his last six appearences only. Btw, Miller has 2 starts to lower his ERA another 19 points for the sig bet. What sig bet, my I ask? I bet Benched that Miller would have his ERA under 6 within 4 weeks of his start against the Padres, which was 2 starts ago.
-
Roles in the bullpen?
Kensing and his 7.2 ERA in his last six appearances in the 8th? No thanks. Pinto, Nelson, Gregg please. Right and let's just ignore his 0.87 ERA through his first 9 appearences. But no, you're right, we should make the judgement based on his last six appearences only. Btw, Miller has 2 starts to lower his ERA another 19 points for the sig bet.
-
Jacque Jones is a done deal
I think overall he will be a nice addition coming off the bench. With Gonzo and Amezega starting regularly, we didn't have a left-handed bat on the bench so this should open up some options. I wonder if he'll replace Alfredo in the platoon with Cody or if he'll just serve as a pinch-hitter/back-up.
-
Roles in the bullpen?
7th - Pinto/Lindstrom (depending on match-ups and would also use them as a combination) 8th - Kensing 9th - Gregg (If I must)
-
Marlins uniform/color change?
I wouldn't mind something like that, has an aquatic feel to it.
-
Hanley stats ?
It would be interesting to see Uggla's numbers since the move. Excluding the leadoff spot, I would bet every spot in the lineup has been more productive since the move, especially the bottom of the order. For some reason, people who were critical of the move when it was first made had a hard time seeing what it did for the rest of the lineup. Wonder what happened to those people.....don't hear a word out of them now... :mis2
-
Something to chat about... Re: Cantu.
.272/.330/.426 with 5 home runs and 17 RBIs. All things considered, a .330 OBP is not terrible from your 6th hitter. That said, his production, at it's current pace, won't even get close to the numbers he put up in 2005. If he continues on this pace, he'll finish with 19 home runs and about 66 RBI's. I'm not demanding he should drive in 117 like he did in 05, but you would like to see him finish with 75-85 RBI's to say he was a productive enough to accept a mediocre OPS.
-
Something to chat about... Re: Cantu.
From what I've seen, and I haven't check his stats or even if there are easily accessible stats on this, but my sense is, my guess is, of the nine errors at least six and maybe seven are throwing errors. It's no secret, it's been reported and discussed widely that his arm is ailing from the long throws. It's one thing and okay to complain about someone's defensive skills, but it's another if it's common knowledge he's hurt. Just from memory, it does seem like the majority of his errors have been bad throws. That kind of ties back to the idea that he will improve defensively from having to make shorter, easier throws from second base.
-
Something to chat about... Re: Cantu.
I've been toying with this idea in my head for a while. Because Cantu has been decent at the plate (and he deserves credit for that much), I doubt McPhearson will be called up any time soon. Unless, like penguino says, he goes into a terrible slump and his average dips into the .230 area. I've been playing with the idea of a position swap between Cantu and Uggla. I don't expect that it will actually happen nor do I think it necessarily should, but hear me out. Cantu has been concievabley worse than Cabrera at third and Uggla played there for a good part of his minor league career. I don't know how well he can play third, but honestly he can't be any worse than Cantu. As for Cantu, his defensive numbers at second were average in his tenure with Tampa and it's probably more of a natural position for him. This might be thinking a little far ahead, but putting Cantu at second as a temporary solution frees up the position for Coghlan when he is ready. Without Uggla blocking him, the team will be encouraged to bring him up and it also makes the idea of signing Uggla realistic. An infield core of Uggla, Hanley, Coghlan, and Jacobs sounds more than decent. This is all just speculation because I don't know how Uggla will peform at third without being familiar with him in the minors. When it comes to Cantu at second, it's reasonable to assume he will play at about the same level as Uggla defensively from that position, thus cutting back on his error total. Edit: Just read another thread where Marlins2003 suggested the same thing. I guess other people have had the same thought about a possible swap but I wonder if it has occurred to Fredi.
-
What does everyone think about...
I'd rather see Nolasco go to the pen and Badenhop sent down. Nolasco seems to be hit harder the second time through the line-up. H emay be more efffecting in shorter appearances. Badenhop needs some work in the minors. Miller seems to be improving, I'd leave him where he is. I've never been a big fan of Nolasco and I'm still inclined to think he is destined for the bullpen. Unlike Miller and Badenhop, we've seen a fair bit of Nolsco and he hasn't impressed. However, his ERA is not terrible right now and he has been the equivalent of a mediocre number 5 starter. For now, keep him in the rotation until a better option is available or he can't keep it together, in which case swap in Waechter.
-
What does everyone think about...
I think it's certainly worth one start, especially considering how Miller and Badenhop can't seem to get it done. Where have you been through Miller's past few starts? He's been fine... ad he's been getting better, everyone has the itchy trigger finger when it comes to these guys... :banghead Exactly. How many people were calling for Miller to be demoted 4 starts ago? You have to use patience with these guys and allow them to learn while they pitch at the big league level. I think the organization has handled the rotation perfectly under the circumstances. If Badenhop has another rough outing his next time out, I garuntee there will be shouts of AA or bullpen assignment and a demand of Weachter for the rotation. Exercise some patience, you don't have to make a drastic move every time something goes wrong.
-
So, are you doing your job?
Just for argument's sake, here's Hanley's numbers as compared to Reyes and Rollins so far this season: Rollins - .276/.300/.500 3 HR 9 RBI 9 R 4 2B 0 3B 2 SB Reyes - .264/.331/.426 2 HR 14 RBI 22 R 8 2B 5 3B 12 SB The Beast - .325/.412/.556 9 HR 23 RBI 34 R 6 2B 1 3B 13 SB I know its early and everything, but come on......is there any doubt who should start? Hanley completely outclasses them in almost every offensive category. I have confidence that the fans will get it right this time, especially with Hanley getting the coverage he did from the signing. Mets fans and Phillies fans have absolutely no argument here. They can just stare with envy at Hanley's numbers and come to terms with the fact that he is the best SS in the majors right now. Even while their lips are still fresh with the taste of overrated ass, Mets fans are probably going to have to acknowledge Hanley and his utter dominance among NL shortstops.
-
Justin Miller
I noticed that as well. Its strange considering how many times Fredi depended on him last year....I think he just likes Kensing/Pinto when we're up (our 2 best relievers) and Tank/Lindstrom when we're down. Miller needs to see more work and Weachter needs some rest along with Tank.
-
Jake
Once we can get both Willingham and Jake back in the lineup, we'll be looking at something like this: 1. Amezega/Ross 2. Hermida 3. Hanley 4. Jacobs 5. Uggla 6. Willingham 7. Cantu 8. Rabelo/Treanor Considering we won 7 in a row, without either of those guys, its encouraging when you look at the lineup with them in it. Willingham/Cantu/Treanor/Rabelo = production out of the bottom of the order. Then you think of the kind of power you're getting from the 3-5 spots....
-
It's about time to get Amezaga out of the lineup
I don't understand Fredi. Cody Ross starts getting on base...and then...POOF....here's Alfredo back again. Treanor starts hitting the baseball, and then...POOF......here's Rabelo again. Plus, Rabelo's defense is not so great, nor is his game calling. Can we stop rewarding people's success by benching them??? Treanor is not a starting catcher. Unfortunately neither is Rabelo but the team seems to show more confidence in him getting the majority of the starts. Being that Treanor is a streaky hitter, and is in one of his hot streaks, he has his average up above .280 while Rabelo took an 0-3 tonight bringing him down to .229. If I were Fredi, I would try and give Treanor a couple starts in a row to see if he can keep up the production and then just return to Rabelo once Treanor's bat inevitabley cools off. As for Amezega's slump, Fredi is going to stick with him against right-handers almost regardless of his batting average. Unless Ross starts proving something in his starts and begins to consistently get on base then I doubt Fredi will make any kind of move, atleast not until De Aza returns.
- Pitchers who are free agents after this season
-
5/10 Postgame thread
Miller looks like he's finally finding his groove and was excellent for 7 innings. Also encouraging to see Tankersly and Lindstrom toss scorless innings, being the only two guys in our bullpen who have experienced early struggles. I think the Uggla-haters have been effectively silenced. You know who you are. Hanley hitting over .415 out of the 3 hole after tonight's game. And surprise, the team is winning with him there. Perhaps the people who couldn't see this when the move was finally made can now understand why he brings balance to the lineup from there. The move has not only improved Hanley's numbers, but has improved the entire team's offense. Also nice to see Ross and Helms showing some power. If they can maintain it, it will be nice to have some right-handed power bats off the bench once our other guys return.
-
Now that Hanley is (theoretically) signed
If we have the offensive core of Hermida, Uggla, and Jacobs retained and intact entering the 2011 season, I'll be satisfied. I like the idea of moving Danny to 3rd with Coghlan coming up. I am also a huge Willingham fan, when he stays healthy he is a 100+ RBI guy. However, Marlins2003 makes a good point about his nagging back injuries. They don't seem like the type of thing that will work itself out, surgery might be the only solution. If he can put up 480+ AB's this season it will be encouraging, but won't have me convinced. As far as pitching goes, lock up Olsen and a few bullepen guys. I've never really cared for Nolasco but he might work out in the bullpen or atleast get us a prospect or two. Anibel and JJ need to be locked up as well.
-
Padres realease Jim Edmonds
The Marlins could use him...a solid veteran presence for the clubhouse to go with a respectable .178 average. The young guys could learn alot from him and you never know, he could turn out to have a comeback year with us. :thumbup :banghead
-
5/8 Postgame thread
How about giving Freddi Gonzalez some credit? Seems like no one ever does. Ever since he put this new lineup together...we're 5-1. Also, how about a sweep without our best clutch hitter in the lineup (Willingham)? And winning, smoothly, tonight without Willingham AND Mike Jacobs? :thumbup Give Fredi some credit? What is he some kind of baseball mastermind because he made the obvious lineup move that half the people on this board were calling for since before the season started? I guess I deserve some credit then too. Don't forget that the only reason he made the move was because of Willingham's injury. Had Josh not gone down, we'd be looking at an identical lineup. Any moron with a shred of common sense would have made the same move in his situation. If he is such a genius, and knew this lineup would result in a winning formula, then what took him so long to make the change? The amusing thing is I haven't heard a word from the "Keep Hanley at leadoff" advocates now that the team is winning with him in the 3 hole and he has 7 hits in his last 11 AB's out of there. Now if the team had gone 2-5 over their last 7 games, the I told you so's would be raining down and Fredi would be a moron for making the shift. It seems like managers are given way too much blame when their team loses and way too much credit when their team wins, but that's just my opinion. Don't forget that its the players out there who are winning the ball game, not Fredi with his "masterful" baseball insight. While I agree that Fredi has improved as a manager since 07, he still has alot to prove to me before I even consider him an average manager.
-
Miguel Cabrera misses the Marlins
i can definately see him finishing off his career with the fish or even returning in his "twilight" baseball years Cabrera will only be 34 when his contract with Detroit is up. Who knows what kind of team the Marlins will have 8 years from now? Not trying to look too far ahead here, just saying Miggy will probably still have 4 productive years in which he averages 25+ homers and 90+ RBI left in him once his contract with Detroit is up. Alot of teams wouldn't mind a productive veteran bat like that in the 6 hole. Would be nice to see him hit number 500 as a Marlin, the team he came up with and carried for 4 and a half years. Chances are he will go to the HOF as a Tiger, but he will always have his origins and legacy with Miami.