Everything posted by 30plus
-
Dunn or Abreu?
Why on Earth are people so high on Griffey? He's old and slow and would be a huge liability in our rather large outfield. Generally your fourth outfielder should at least be competent at defense. Yet we signed Gonzo last year. In all honesty, I'm starting to accept the idea that Gibbons might be it in terms of outfield acquisitions this offseason. If that is the case, I'm hoping Dallas takes a few flyballs before spring training starts.
-
Dunn or Abreu?
I want to know who you guys want to cut off the 13 position player roster we have Baker, Rabelo, G. Sanchez, Uggla, Hanley, Cantu, Amezaga, McPherson, Bonifacio, Helms, Maybin, Hermida, and Ross in order to bring in a legitimate 4th outfielder. Rabelo for Griffey? Not a bad trade off, eh? Not an option as we need a back-up catcher; that's regardless if its Rabelo ( :| ) or someone else. Let Bonifacio spend a year in New Orleans (that is if we sign a 4th outfielder) and possibly get a call up in September.
-
Dunn or Abreu?
I want to know who you guys want to cut off the 13 position player roster we have Baker, Rabelo, G. Sanchez, Uggla, Hanley, Cantu, Amezaga, McPherson, Bonifacio, Helms, Maybin, Hermida, and Ross in order to bring in a legitimate 4th outfielder. Since the Marlins have four 1B/3B players, I imagine one of those will have to go. It won't be Helms and his brand new contract, and it won't be Cantu unless he's traded, which I think is still a possibility. So, as MP already suggested, it will most likely be a battle during ST between McPherson and Sanchez to see who gets the final roster spot. If I had to pick one, I would want to see Gaby stay and let Dallas go. I disagree. Gaby Sanchez, from everything that has been said by the organization, is the frontrunner to win the first base job. The final spot will be a battle between Dallas and Bonifacio. It basically comes down to a choice between speed/defense or power coming off your bench. Considering Dallas is out of options, and releasing him for nothing is pointless, I would say he likely has the edge. He also offers insurance if Gaby falters and provides a power left-handed bat off the bench, which is something we are lacking. The only way I see Bonifacio making the team out of ST is if we fail to sign an additional outfielder and the team has confidence in letting McDallas and Amezega handle that role. To answer the question, I would have Bonifacio cut out of the above thirteen in order to make room for a legitimate 4th outfielder.
-
This was when I became a baseball (Marlins) fan.
I know who Andy Bernard is, but I don't get why he was reference here. Also, fun fact: Ed Helms who plays Bernard is actually the cousin of our very own Wes Helms. That's very cool about Ed Helms. Maybe because Andy has anger management issues, and so did those Cubs fans? FTR I want to see Andy + Oscar as a couple - that'd be hilarious and perfect. I think the "wing man" episode is the closest we'll come to seeing them as a couple. I don't understand the reference either, unless he's trying to say that the voice in the video sounds like Andy when he sings?
-
Anibal
Before the injury he had a tremendous upside, since the comeback last season he looked shaky. He needs to build up arm strength and might need to pitch out of the pen to do so. I also feel he's getting lumped in with other rookie pitchers that have thrown no-hitters and little success after that, this season should be able to prove either way if he was just a flash in the pan. Arm strength isn't the issue with Anibal. If anything, he was throwing harder since his return last year than he was back in 2006. The problem is Anibal is a finesse guy, and when he was lacking control with his off speed pitches last year, he was forced to rely on that fastball.
-
Manny Turns Down Dodgers' Second Offer
Will guys like Manny eventually take the best available offer so they can be on an Opening Day roster and play ball, or if no deal matches their demands, could there be the possibility of them sitting out part of the season? This has been a very strange offseason. Even with the economy's effect on baseball, I think most people expected Manny to be signed by early January at the latest. I'd have to think at some point, despite any "shortcomings" on an offer, Manny is going to have to settle. Its obvious he's holding out on a multi-year deal for roughly 20 million per year but spring training is less than two weeks away.
-
Ok now I'm pretty sure DLC does get a 4th option year (Nevermind I
This will make camp competition pretty interesting for the 5th RHP slot. If this turns out to be legit, then that spot is pretty much up for grabs. I suppose Tucker and Ceda have the most to gain from this now that Delgado and DLC don't have the upper hand.
-
Ok now I'm pretty sure DLC does get a 4th option year (Nevermind I
If both Delgado and DLC have that extra option then it seems the 7th slot in the pen will be up for grabs in ST (unless I'm forgetting another pitcher in our system who is out of options). I'm fine with that as it means more competition and an even playing field.
-
More than 2 dozens Marlins are already in Jupiter Training
Shows that the young guys have good work ethic. I only hope they take it easy and don't tire themselves out before spring training starts.
-
Pudge, we hardly knew thee
I really don't think Pudge is an upgrade. I firmly feel that Baker is our staring C. no matter what. Pudge would have been the back-up/platoon against LHP. You can say what you want about Rabelo getting the short stick last season, but there's no way Pudge isn't a better option than him.
-
Hermida signs for 2.25 million
And all these one-year deals are scaring me... What did you expect?
-
Marlins find slim pickings behind plate
We're not getting Pudge for the league minimum. I'm usually not critical of ownership because I'm aware of the financial constraints, but this is ridiculous. If you want quality, open up your wallets a little bit. There's working with what you have, and then there's just plain cheapness.
-
McPherson signs
After reading all these posts I agree Helms was a bad signing b/c McDallas, Gaby & Cantu are compatable platoon partners and Boni was a bad trade now but when Almezaga is gone thats who's gonna take his spot. If Gibbons flops then we still need another LH OF. Unless we are completly retarted during arby he won't be gone for a copuple of years and his replacement would be either Raynor Cousins or even Stanton and less likley in the utility spot Andino I would be very suprised if AA is with the Marlins in 2010. Other than having to pay arby to him for the third time, the organization would have no way to justify that horrible trade by letting Bonifacio sit in the minors. It also makes no sense to have Bonifaco and Amezaga on the same bench.
-
Opening day game time?
Olsen v. Nolasco :mis2
-
Getting some love on MLB network
I like to see all the love we deserve but I'm worried about injuries to those top guys. I'm not as worried because we have a deep pitching well but I see one of these guys getting hurt. That isn't entirely true. Our rotation has enormous potential, but beyond our 1-5 there's nothing but question marks. Sean West is the best pitching prospect in the organization and the best case scenario for him is to crack the rotation by 2010. In any case, we're in serious trouble if somebody goes down with injury or doesn't pan out. This is where signing a guy like Pavano as an insurance policy might have paid off. Alot of people don't seem to realize that depth in starting pitching is one of our weak points right now. The reason we have such a potent minor league system is because of our positional depth.
-
What's your ringtone?
"Double Vision" by Foreigner
-
Who do You want to sign/trade for as the Marlins 4th Outfielder
As much as I would have liked him on this team, it's time to forget about Anderson. It isn't happening. My suspicions were confirmed: he's not at the point where he's willing to accept a bench/platoon role, especially after coming off a year like he just had. http://mlb.mlb.com/news/article.jsp?ymd=20...8&fext=.jsp
-
McPherson signs
Still gonna have to battle Bonifacio for a roster spot. I'd give Emilio the slight edge because of his defensive abilities. 100% incorrect. McPherson is a lock. Bonifacio can be optioned to AAA. This. Dallas could be huge for us off the bench, if he's willing to take that role. A power lefty bat off the bench is a huge asset, and its the type of bat we are seriously lacking. He's also the best option within the organization to take over at third if Gaby doesn't pan out at first. My guess is Bonifacio will be a September call up. Once we decline to give Amezaga arby in 2010, Bonifacio steps in as the replacement. Wrong. And you were questioning someone else for lack of reasoning?
-
McPherson signs
Still gonna have to battle Bonifacio for a roster spot. I'd give Emilio the slight edge because of his defensive abilities. 100% incorrect. McPherson is a lock. Bonifacio can be optioned to AAA. This. Dallas could be huge for us off the bench, if he's willing to take that role. A power lefty bat off the bench is a huge asset, and its the type of bat we are seriously lacking. He's also the best option within the organization to take over at third if Gaby doesn't pan out at first. My guess is Bonifacio will be a September call up. Once we decline to give Amezaga arby in 2010, Bonifacio steps in as the replacement.
-
Orlando Cabrera?
Chicago dude here. This guy gets bagged on way too much, Cabrera is a good player. Not a star player, but solid. He IS a good defender and an average bat. You could do a lot worse. However, I agree that it's not the best move for the Marlins with what they already have. Whoever mentioned Joe Crede is right on. It's a risk in terms of health. But he can be had for a one year deal, and probably comes cheaper than Cabrera. If healthy, Crede is a top-notch 3B who can hit 25 dingers and give you 75 RBI. Crede almost seems like a no-brainer for the Marlins. We are crowded enough at the corners as it is. We don't have the luxury of picking up a guy like Crede, nor do we need to. Cabrera makes even less sense. By all indications, Gaby Sanchez is going to have the opportunity to win the first base job in spring training. His main competition, and seemingly the odd man out, is McPherson. If Gaby wins the job outright, my hopes are that we can retain Dallas for the bench, especially if we're unable to sign a left-handed hitting outfielder before the offseason is over.
-
Getting some love on MLB network
Al did call Volstad a power arm, but other than that he described the rest of the rotation fairly accurately. Good to see us getting some praise from a network that isn't obsessed with the Mets and Phillies whenever the NL East is brought up.
-
Garrett Anderson
MLBTR would have us believe that Anderson may not make an MLB roster and Pudge may be a spring-training invitee. In that case, I can't find any reason whatsoever why the marlins can't/shouldn't gobble both of them up. I can't think of two guys who, under the circumstances and limitations, are better fits for our two remaining holes on the roster. But like fanofthefish noted, it boils down to cost. Every day we don't sign these guys, the cheaper they get. The tradeoff is every day we don't sign them means other teams have time to mobilize and present their offers. MLBTR is way off when assessing their value. Pudge is still widely considered a plus defender and Anderson hit near .300 to finish out the year (including a .356 average in September). Not to mention all their "veteran presence" value, if you're into that. There is no reason why the Marlins shouldn't seriously consider signing both of these guys. It's a matter of their ability to do so.
-
Garrett Anderson
Getting back to the topic here... Is there even a garuntee that Anderson would accept a bench role? Personally, I think he would be great as the 4th OF just like I think McPherson would benefit us as a corner back-up/left-handed bat off the bench. I can't say if either would be willing to occupy those roles though. Anderson is coming off a pretty solid year in which he drove in 84 runs while compiling over 580 PA. Only two years ago he put up an OPS in the low .800's. You could make the argument that the guy has a productive year or two left in him before having to accept a bench role. However, if mlbtraderumors is to be considered a reliable source, and interest in him is fairly low, then the possibility of acquiring him goes up significantly. I like the insurance he gives in backing up our OF, and his production would certainly equal Gonzo's, if not excede it.
-
Marlins ask Dodgers about Jones?
The way I see it is we have two big holes right now: Back-up catcher and fourth outfielder. Jones would be a solid addition and would close up one of those holes. Defensively, he's going to be well above average and he's a better option than Carroll if one of Ross/Maybin/Hermida don't pan out or go down with injury. Offensively, he's never going to hit 50 homers again but if he can put up a mid-700 OPS with plus defense then I'm satisfied with him as the fourth outfielder. The biggest question is whether he's willing to play here or not, and for a 1 year deal which will pay him less than 3 mil with incentives included. I don't think he's receded to the point where he would consider a MILB contract, but he certainly shouldn't be expecting multi-year offers from anyone. That said, there are probably five or more teams out there that are interested in one year deals and are more attractive to him salary wise than the Fish. I really doubt salary will be the question. It will be playing time. He'll go somewhere we he can start. If he makes 3m here as a back up, he's not going to make much next season. If he makes 500k with Atlanta or co, and produces again, he'll be in line for another fat contract. He's already making a ton of cash this season, he'll likely go to the place where he has the best chance of getting regular playing time. I'd attach one caveat here. If he believes that he may play poorly this year and never be good again, then he would, acting rationally, just take the largest guaranteed contract (regardless of other factors). Otherwise the playing time is an obvious consideration. This is a good point. We're obviously not in Andrew's head but when a player recedes as far as he has (literally a fall from super stardom to a struggling bench player), he's bound to question his own abilities. To what extent he questions them could be the determining factor as to where he signs. If he feels he can be a productive starter again, he's going to go somewhere where he's garunteed 500 PA (provided he stays productive). Barring any trades that would change the dynamics of our outfield, we wouldn't be able to give him that garuntee. If the largest contract is what he is after, assuming he would accept a bench role, we would still have difficulty signing him because of our financial constraints.
-
Marlins ask Dodgers about Jones?
The way I see it is we have two big holes right now: Back-up catcher and fourth outfielder. Jones would be a solid addition and would close up one of those holes. Defensively, he's going to be well above average and he's a better option than Carroll if one of Ross/Maybin/Hermida don't pan out or go down with injury. Offensively, he's never going to hit 50 homers again but if he can put up a mid-700 OPS with plus defense then I'm satisfied with him as the fourth outfielder. The biggest question is whether he's willing to play here or not, and for a 1 year deal which will pay him less than 3 mil with incentives included. I don't think he's receded to the point where he would consider a MILB contract, but he certainly shouldn't be expecting multi-year offers from anyone. That said, there are probably five or more teams out there that are interested in one year deals and are more attractive to him salary wise than the Fish. I really doubt salary will be the question. It will be playing time. He'll go somewhere we he can start. If he makes 3m here as a back up, he's not going to make much next season. If he makes 500k with Atlanta or co, and produces again, he'll be in line for another fat contract. He's already making a ton of cash this season, he'll likely go to the place where he has the best chance of getting regular playing time. Another reason why I don't see him signing here. I can't see the FO trading away one of Ross or Hermida to open up a corner for Jones, which would be a huge risk. What I meant was the biggest question was whether he would be willing to play here as a fourth outfielder in addition to a low salary. After reading the MLB thread, I can see why salary (atleast for this year) isn't a major concern for him. Unless we trade Ross or Hermida, other low-budget teams are still going to look more attractive to him in terms of playing time.