Everything posted by 30plus
- Call me crazy- Call up Stanton
-
Opening Day 2012
Personally, I'd be surprised if Hanley is our SS. Not saying he won't be with the club. Where do you think he might be? Outfield. IMO he lacks the concentration, discipline and fundamentals to be a great infielder. He does make some great circus plays, but unfortunately some of his plays that should be routine end up looking like circus plays. There was talk about this recently in the Sun-Sentinel and on this forum. Comparisons were made to A. Soriano, who used to play 2nd for the Yanks (and the Rangers, I think) He's been solid defensively this year. He's made all the routine plays and it seems like almost all his throws hit Cantu in the chest, unlike previous years.
-
Problems
Is nobody else having trouble with the signature line limit? I tried reducing my sig to 5 lines like it says but the error message still popped up. I even reduced it to 4 lines but got the same message. Try now. Appears to be fine now.
-
Problems
Is nobody else having trouble with the signature line limit? I tried reducing my sig to 5 lines like it says but the error message still popped up. I even reduced it to 4 lines but got the same message.
-
Carroll To AAA
I was expecting Martinez to be sent down but with the struggles of the rotation I'm guessing the team preferred to carry an extra arm in the pen.
-
General Cameron Maybin Discussion
If anyone is a "Golden Boy" on this team, it's Bonifacio. You'd have to be completely blind not to notice the affection the FO has had for him from the very start. In his case, it's based on nothing. At least with the other proclaimed golden boys, there's basis for favor. BGB = Board Golden Boy You would have to be completely blind not to see the potential and the improvement while the BGBs have displayed nothing. And yes the FO is showing some trust in him. And it has been paying off. Keep watching. And learning. Future HOFer? Sincerely doubt that. Future face of this franchise? Ditto. But very good player that fills a role for a few more years on this team? Definetly. Bank on it. Potenitial and improvement? Not to continue this trend, but you would have to be completely blind not to notice the amount of times that his abysmal numbers have been brought up on the board since the first week of the season. In what way has the FO trust in him been paying off? He's bloomed nicely into one of the worst leadoff hitters in baseball. Getting a couple hits here and there doesn't cancel out the whole picture. As for the BGBs, I have two words: track records. That's a whole lot more than one can say for Bonifacio. It gets to point where it seems as if people defend Bonifacio solely because others aren't optimisitic about him. There is no doubt somebody is completely blind. Keep "watching." What does that mean? Do you have an actual point to disprove my assessment of Bonifacio or does "keep watching" sum up your rebuttal?
-
General Cameron Maybin Discussion
If anyone is a "Golden Boy" on this team, it's Bonifacio. You'd have to be completely blind not to notice the affection the FO has had for him from the very start. In his case, it's based on nothing. At least with the other proclaimed golden boys, there's basis for favor. BGB = Board Golden Boy You would have to be completely blind not to see the potential and the improvement while the BGBs have displayed nothing. And yes the FO is showing some trust in him. And it has been paying off. Keep watching. And learning. Future HOFer? Sincerely doubt that. Future face of this franchise? Ditto. But very good player that fills a role for a few more years on this team? Definetly. Bank on it. Potenitial and improvement? Not to continue this trend, but you would have to be completely blind not to notice the amount of times that his abysmal numbers have been brought up on the board since the first week of the season. In what way has the FO trust in him been paying off? He's bloomed nicely into one of the worst leadoff hitters in baseball. Getting a couple hits here and there doesn't cancel out the whole picture. As for the BGBs, I have two words: track records. That's a whole lot more than one can say for Bonifacio. It gets to point where it seems as if people defend Bonifacio solely because others aren't optimisitic about him.
-
General Cameron Maybin Discussion
If anyone is a "Golden Boy" on this team, it's Bonifacio. You'd have to be completely blind not to notice the affection the FO has had for him from the very start. In his case, it's based on nothing. At least with the other proclaimed golden boys, there's basis for favor.
-
Johnson Complains Of Weak Shoulder
If this is spillover from Colorado, I'll take it as good news as opposed to something serious.
- 2009 Adopt-A-Marlin Draft
- 2009 Adopt-A-Marlin Draft
- 2009 Adopt-A-Marlin Draft
-
Tuesday's Starter - John Koronka?
Would much rather stretch out one of Meyer/Badenhop, suffer through a couple games of 3-4 IP, then 4-5 IP, because we need a starter for atleast 2 months, very possibly all season. Rich had an interesting tidbit on Meyer this season, that Wiley taught him a cut fastball this ST. Sound familiar, Ricky Nolasco last year? I'm not saying Meyer is going to go put up a Ricky year but his stats this year have been GREAT (13.1 IP, 14 Ks, just 3 walks, 1 hr), actually doing better against RHB than LHB and does not have drastic splits in the minors. He is an extreme FB pitcher, going to give up XBHs. Stamina would be my biggest concern with Meyer. Also, he's been very good in short spurts out of the pen and, without a sure lefty in the wings, would be risky to try and replace. In any case he pitched in the game today. With Maybin being sent down, the 5th starter probably won't come out of the pen.
-
All Signs Point to Maybin Being Sent Down
I don't think it could be any more clear after this game that Maybin doesn't belong in the majors right now. I still think the team completely screwed up by falling in love with Bonifacio when Maybin was an obvious choice to bat leadoff if he was gonna be on the major league team at all. Just another reason why I don't feel bad for not having watched a lot of these games this year. This. The unwarranted infatuation with Bonifacio all through the offseason and into spring training was enough to make up for his inferior numbers. I remember a point during the offseason when there were two or three articles a week coming out and commending Bonifacio before he had done anything. I still have trouble letting a move that horrible go. I'm not excusing Maybin's performance this year, but you can't tell me he wasn't affected by the 8-hole and being passed over for leadoff by a future utility man when he had clearly earned it.
-
All Signs Point to Maybin Being Sent Down
BTW, after his straight 3rd game on the bench, it's pretty obvious he's going down when they call up Ani's replacement. What if we end up sliding one of our LR options from the pen to the rotation for Tuesday? We could continue carrying an extra man on the bench until Miller returns on the 16th. At this point, I don't see how anyone in AAA is a better option than Badenhop. Perhaps it would be delaying the inevitable with Maybin, but it still allows us to carry an extra man while giving the FO more time to look at Coghlan and decide who to send down. If that was the plan, I don't think that Maybin would be seeing so much bench. True. Starting Amezaga over Maybin against a left hander wasn't a good sign either. It will be interesting to see who they call up although I still feel Badenhop is the best option from within the organization.
-
All Signs Point to Maybin Being Sent Down
BTW, after his straight 3rd game on the bench, it's pretty obvious he's going down when they call up Ani's replacement. What if we end up sliding one of our LR options from the pen to the rotation for Tuesday? We could continue carrying an extra man on the bench until Miller returns on the 16th. At this point, I don't see how anyone in AAA is a better option than Badenhop. Perhaps it would be delaying the inevitable with Maybin, but it still allows us to carry an extra man while giving the FO more time to look at Coghlan and decide who to send down.
- 2009 Adopt-A-Marlin Draft
-
5/7 Post Game
Someone has to be reserved as the back-up middle infielder. Amezaga would be a better option in the outfield in the proposed situation so Boni is the middle infielder by default.
-
5/7 Post Game
Bonifacio should be on the bench. We know that. But for some reason, Fredi won't listen. Please tell me who you would get rid of on the bench to make room for Bonifacio. The thing about rosters is they tend to have a 25-man limit. Brett Carrol. So Amezaga and Gload become your reserve outfielders. You lose flexibility with Gload because he would have to play a more prominent role in the outfield. Helms becomes the only option at the corners. The defense in the outfield also takes a hit without Carrol and your pinch hitting options are about the same. I would rather demote Bonifacio than keep him on the bench. Though I suppose you could make a case for grooming him into his future role.
-
Fredi Gonzalez
I was one of his biggest critics in 07. Each year he has improved and you can't blame him for the slumping offense. If anything, he's handled the bullpen very well this year compared to previous years.
-
5/7 Post Game
Bonifacio should be on the bench. We know that. But for some reason, Fredi won't listen. Please tell me who you would get rid of on the bench to make room for Bonifacio. The thing about rosters is they tend to have a 25-man limit.
-
5/7 Post Game
Maybin has nothing to learn in AAA. He needs to see MLB pitching. He'll be fine. Growing pains, my friend. Growing pains. I agree with this post. I do think that Bonifaciout needs to be relegated to the bench, though. Maybin has the potential to be a star outfielder. Bonifacio's ceiling is probably Dave Krynzel (as an infielder) Plus plus speed, plus defense...that's it. Terrible bat, terrible plate discipline. While Coghlan has been tearing it up, you don't want to thrust him into a role that demands production immediately while starting his arbitration clock early. If he's still hitting the ball well in June, then you seriously consider pulling the trigger. As for right now, we're in a bit of a predicament. I couldn't disagree more. Coghlan is exactly what this team needs right now. Arbi clock? He's 24- what are we waiting for? Coghlan has career minor league numbers of 154 walks and 147 K's.....you can't tell me the Marlins don't need a hitter like this batting 2nd to show Maybin, Bonifacio, Uggla, and even Ross how to hit? He stole 34 bases last season and is 9 out of 10 this year. 13 extra base hits in just 92 ABs this year. He's 24- let's try to catch lightning in a bottle and give him a shot. He's much better than Bonfacio and has been a better prospect his entire career. First of all, arbi clocks will always be a major consideration with this team when calling up our young prospects. Especially those who factor into the long-term plans of the team such as a Coghlan. His age has nothing to do with his arbitration clock. Do you honestly think he's going to come up here and teach our established position players how to hit? We're talking about a guy who hasn't played one game at the major league level. This was just a ridiculous thing to say. Second of all, I hope you weren't actually using minor league stolen base numbers to support your argument. Coghlan's line has vastly improved in the last week. He struggled in April and even still we're talking about a sample size of just over 100 PA. Nobody is saying Bonifacio even comes close to Coghlan as a prospect as this is not relevant to the discussion. If Coghlan can keep it up another month or so, and Bonifacio continues to struggle, then you consider making the move. And even then expecting him become our 2-hole hitter when we have Baker is stretching it to say the least.
-
5/7 Post Game
the thing thats makes me mad is that the Marlins are doing nothing to make any changes. What moves do you think they should make?
-
5/7 Post Game
Maybin has nothing to learn in AAA. He needs to see MLB pitching. He'll be fine. Growing pains, my friend. Growing pains. I agree with this post. I do think that Bonifaciout needs to be relegated to the bench, though. Maybin has the potential to be a star outfielder. Bonifacio's ceiling is probably Dave Krynzel (as an infielder) Plus plus speed, plus defense...that's it. Terrible bat, terrible plate discipline. There's no room for Bonifacio on the bench. How do you propose that would work? You basically have two options if Bonifacio continues to struggle. Either demote him or move him down in the lineup. The problem is Fredi can't justify such a move with Maybin getting on base at a .289 clip as the only legitamite option to take over at leadoff. While Coghlan has been tearing it up, you don't want to thrust him into a role that demands production immediately while starting his arbitration clock early. If he's still hitting the ball well in June, then you seriously consider pulling the trigger. As for right now, we're in a bit of a predicament. Not to make excuses for Maybin, but you wonder where his numbers would be had he started the season in the leadoff spot. But the organizational-wide infatuation with Bonifacio apparently won out against Maybin's superior numbers in spring and successful call-up last September.
-
Dan Meyer. Can he be our #5 for now?
To show it out Miller is making a start at AA on the 10th. He will then be starting on our team on the 15th. May 7-JJ 8-Nolasco 9-Volstad 10-Anibal (Miller starts in AA) 11-offday 12-JJ 13-Nolasco 14-Volstad 15-Miller Sanchez is starting on the 7th. JJ starts on the 9th, and Volstad starts on the 10th. Then it starts again with Sanchez on the 12th. I prefer the idea of the four-man rotation as opposed to inserting Badenhop or Meyer for one start.