Everything posted by EricWiener
-
A few Marlins tidbits.....
We can do worse than have Dawson, or Perez for that matter, talk to guys about hitting
-
Robert Andino
I think Uggla's rating is proof enough. Agreed. Obviously if you are citing Uggla as an above average 2B, you've never watched Uggla play. I've got nothing against stats in baseball, but some things (namely fielding) can be discerned through simple observation. That's not really true, but with the sad state of affairs regarding defensive stats, it is probably as valid as looking at the inherently flaws stats. Uggla is a decent 2B defensive player, but he isn't going to win any gold gloves.
-
Why the hate on Uggla?
:thumbup LOL
-
Robert Andino
You're absolutely right. I really think Hanley may have struggled a lot in Boston. He does best when he is free to go out there and play his game and in Boston he would have faced a different type of pressure than he has in Florida. His struggles last year in the third spot are a good example of the fact that he is a guy who does better when the pressure isn't on. I wish all our hitters would "struggle" like that
-
Why the hate on Uggla?
Just to clarify - I'm not all about batting average. I just thought bobbob's comment that there are "plenty of guys who can hit .240 and be way more valuable than the guys hitting .350" is BS and cannot be backed up historically outside of maybe a few random anomalies. It was obviously hyperbole. But .270 vs. .320 is easy to demonstrate.
-
Why the hate on Uggla?
I never said anything about ba correlating to runs scored.......... I thought the game was about scoring / preventing runs.
-
Why the hate on Uggla?
Except OPS isn't all that good and there's a lot of things that affect it. Projecting a player based soley off OPS is a horrible idea. I'm not saying baa is some amazing stat but calling it useless it just as false as calling it the best. Batting average has all of the flaws of OPS and none of the advantages. It is useless. It is an antiquated relic of a time before the game was understood, or even measured - it was created in an attempt to measure the game. It represents the cubit of baseball, there is just so much more to go with nowadays. So yes, it is useless. There are other things to consider with a player (base running, defense, etc) but those are not hitting stats. OPS is pretty consistent to runs scored, batting average has little relationship. Last years MLB stats show that the top 8 OPS teams are the top 8 run scoring teams in each league. No such correlation exists among BA leaders.
-
Why the hate on Uggla?
Batting average is not a valuable stat. It tells you nothing of merit. OBP and SLG cover it much better, and one doesn't have to go all SABR and pull out WARP or OWP or RC/27 when one uses the OPS components. There are players that have an mediocre or even 'bad' batting average but who have a great OPS. These are valuable players. There are players that have a good batting average, and do not have even a good OPS. Those are not valuable players. Just go to OPS and skip the middleman.
-
Robert Andino
And BP's metric is the most retarded feilding stat of all time, even more retarded than fielding percent. all good fielding metrics show that uggla was neutral in '06 and one of the worst in '07 There are no good fielding metrics.
-
The best Marlins lineup idea ever!
So me and PWG were reading everyone's post, and we decided to use the information you have all provided us to build the perfect lineup! Here it goes. Frustrated much?
-
Carroll sent to AAA...Hermida activated
Anyone taking bets on how long til Jeremy "Body of Glass" Hermida goes back on the DL ? :whistle Carroll is back in less than a month. I'm tired of waiting for this dude to "break out". We need to cut our losses and move on. Cut our losses on a player that is this young and this good? "This good" ? Really ? Tell me...... Jeremy Hermida : 245 games 27 HRs Dan Uggla : 320 games 60 HR's And Dan Uggla is not in any shape or form a "great player" but just adaquate. Defensively he's actually a liability. Hermida has had 3+ seasons to prove he was worth the high draft choice and in my opinion he has fallen quite a bit short. Time to move on..... :cool First, Uggla is far in excess of adequate, top 20% of 2B, and not a defensive liability. Second, Hermida hasn't even had 2 full seasons to prove anything, much less 3+. Is there a dumbest post of the year for the Lurry's? If so, I've got a nomination. Nope, he just beat himself in the same thread.
-
Carroll sent to AAA...Hermida activated
Anyone taking bets on how long til Jeremy "Body of Glass" Hermida goes back on the DL ? :whistle Carroll is back in less than a month. I'm tired of waiting for this dude to "break out". We need to cut our losses and move on. Cut our losses on a player that is this young and this good?
-
Why the hate on Uggla?
The most K's in MLB + a mediocre .OBP DO NOT = a 2nd hitter, sorry. Not to mention, he has average speed, to say the least. Can we hit him 6th, please (Freddi)? He should certainly not hit 2nd.
-
Why the hate on Uggla?
Only downfall to Uggla is that he strikeouts alot, but as he matures, he will gain much more patience at the plate and this can be scary to even the best pitchers in the game. It all comes with youth and goes as the years pass by. I would like to point out that Uggla walked 68 times last season. Once (and I do mean once, not if) he gets his BA up to .275-.280 he will easily be a .350 OBP player.
-
Why the hate on Uggla?
And to add to that... Let's say the game is tied in the bottom of the ninth, and there is a runner on third with 1 out. The batter hit's a fly ball to right field, the runner tags up, scores a run, and wins the ballgame. So...How do sacrifice flies "not correlate to either wins or runs"? Because the just don't. For every situation that you just described, there are multiple examples of getting only 1 run out of bases loaded no outs / 1 out rather than 2-5. If you put ranking in SF/SH against runs and wins, you will find no positive correlation at all. In fact some seasons you can easily find an inverse relationship. Even last season, the National League playoff teams did not see a relationship between SH/SF and success.
-
Why the hate on Uggla?
[and no...bunting, sac flies and productive outs are not overrated...they are the difference between winning and losing close games more than their fair share of the time, you CANNOT sit back and wait for the homerun all the freakin time, especially not in our park... SH/SF do not correlate to either wins or runs. We also don't have to sit back and wait for the HR when we could just enjoy any non-out. Take any of your bunt the man over from first situations, then identify the one what isn't better with a walk or hit.
-
Why the hate on Uggla?
Slugging can be affected by your position in the lineup. Batting average is totally independent of all of that. BA is your ability to hit. It is your Batting Average. Batting average is much more comprehensive of a stat than slugging. And OBP can, to an extent, depend on who the pitcher was. It's a good stat, but there are too many variables to make it more important than BA. Slugging is not affected by lineup any more than BA or OBP are. OBP is affected by the pitcher in the same manner that BA and SLG are. Batting average does not, in any way, reflect the run creating potential of the player in question.
-
Carroll sent to AAA...Hermida activated
Boy, I'm not looking forward to the .350 SLG out of a De Aza Amezaga platoon. That would be awful. That isn't the platoon plan anyhow, so rest easy.
-
Why the hate on Uggla?
What does it matter which one (hitting or walking) involves more skill? The point of baseball is scoring more runs than your opponent, and in order to score runs, you have to make the least amount of outs as possible, which is why OBP is such an important stat. OBP tells us the rate at which a player DOES NOT make an out. Batting average doesn't do that. That's not to say Batting Average is "meaningless", just OBP is more "meaningful". Slugging is how many bases you advance other runners, OBP is how often you do not make an out. So what does Batting Average have to do with anything?
-
Robert Andino
Uggla is an .800 OPS 2B... there just aren't that many of those and frankly you guys that want to get rid of him are just plain dumb.
-
Why the hate on Uggla?
Uggla is not suited to the #2 spot, but he is an outstanding hitter. He walks a lot, has tons of power, and is not a bad defensive player. The hate on Uggla is largely based upon worthless stats such as Strikeouts and Batting Average. Sorry, I was just curious as to how batting average was a worthless stat? Because OBP is inherently your ability to score and SLG is inherently your ability to drive in runs. Batting average is merely how many hits one gets out of a fraction of one's plate appearances.
-
Why the hate on Uggla?
Uggla is not suited to the #2 spot, but he is an outstanding hitter. He walks a lot, has tons of power, and is not a bad defensive player. The hate on Uggla is largely based upon worthless stats such as Strikeouts and Batting Average.
-
Robert Andino
Holy crap guys, it is game #7. I think he needs to stay with the team at least until DeAza comes back because our IF utility guy is starting vs. RHP.
-
WOW...we've allowed 40 runs in 6 games.
Yep I saw that myself this morning Runs Scored : 21 Runs Allowed : 40 I think once we start to balance out the lineup, then maybe the strikeouts will go down. Strikeouts are irrelevant. The huge run disparity is due to being creamed in three of the games due to pitching problems. This is no kind of representative sample at all. We lost by 25 runs total in our 3 losses and only won by 6 in our 3 wins. If it were the other way around there would be complaints about how we can't win the 1 run games.
-
Vanden Hurk sent down
RVH is promising, just not yet ready. He has 3 pitches already, he just needs to work on hitting targets with them. He is one of the 11 or 12 guys that could be part of a great Marlins rotation in the next couple of years. I am keen to see how Badenhop does.