Everything posted by EricWiener
-
Is MLK's dream reality?
It's not good enough though, I personally won't be happy until I can share an opinion about a minority race without the fear of being labeled racist unless I actually am racist. If you are sharing an opinion about a race, then you are dangerously close to racism because value judgments based upon superficial physical appearance factors can easily lead to discrimination.
-
Is MLK's dream reality?
MLK would be pretty happy, if you ask me. People like Al Sharpton have the ability to freely act like a jackass if they want. Surely, the system ain't perfect. But it's a far cry from what it was before MLK. Never been a fan of this argument. It's better than before doesn't make it good. Better than before, will be better tomorrow. It is all we can have and all we can strive for.
-
Yoenis Cespedes to Athletics
http://blogs.sun-sen...-aquariums.html “He wants 35 starts,� Johnson said. “He’s ready for a full season.� I didn't know JJ referred to himself in the third person. Always seemed like such a humble guy. Yeah, Sampson actually said that, not Johnson.
-
New Stadium Pics
The 4 presets cycle - Preset 1 is 6:00pm and preset 4 is 5:45
-
7 y/o girl told she can't play on baseball team, mom cries sexism
The team is moving to an all-male league. Just move her to another little league team.
- The Official Giancarlo Stanton Man Crush Thread
- The Official Giancarlo Stanton Man Crush Thread
-
New Stadium Pics
Hanley and Stanton could get a few as well. Cespedes, too, assuming we get him. Not even Mike Stanton can get an infield hit on a ball that clears the fence.
-
Reyes Baseball Card
I think cards are a good way to preserve the memory of the moore obscure players. I was more into it for that; I wasn't seeking out the "valuable" cards. Then the best thing to do would be to buy the complete annual sets
-
Women share first kiss at US Navy ship's return
If the 14th Amendment is so broad then what behavior can the government ban / regulate? Can we make distinctions based upon age? Genetic relation? Can we prevent people from using marriage contracts for business purposes? Would there be such a thing as marriage fraud as relates to immigration? The government can ban/regulate almost anything under current Commerce Clause jurisprudence, hence why my super-Conservative Constitutional Law professor begrudgingly conceded that Obamacare is likely Constitutional. But, you can't typically discriminate within those regulations, subject to sufficient justification under the proper test, i.e. rational basis review, intermediate scrutiny, or strict scrutiny. Your post seems to be conflating what the government can regulate generally and how it can structure those regulations relative to certain groups of people. They can ban illegal drugs, but they can't do so only toward women, for example. I will not make any high-sounding protestations to 'sanctity' - I will just talk about what is, and what was, in American society and the societies that American society primarily descends from. Marriage under (most) current law, long-standing precedent and societal tradition is the legal bonding of a man and a woman. Structuring the legal and social construct of marriage to include persons of the same gender is a departure from the traditional definition set by our society. Although there is nothing wrong with setting aside tradition when warranted, to indicate that our government's founding document demands it is dubious at best. If the 14th Amendment means everything that the last 40 years of judicial activism has indicated, then the 19th Amendment was needless. The government has a 220+ year history of granting privileges based upon arbitrary factors - the arbitrary factors that have been deemed undesirable have been prohibited by the US Constitution by amendment (race, gender for voting, age beyond 18 for voting, financial capacity).
-
Women share first kiss at US Navy ship's return
If the 14th Amendment is so broad then what behavior can the government ban / regulate? Can we make distinctions based upon age? Genetic relation? Can we prevent people from using marriage contracts for business purposes? Would there be such a thing as marriage fraud as relates to immigration?
-
Women share first kiss at US Navy ship's return
Gender-based discrimination is still not sexual-orientation based discrimination, I disagree, but I suppose that's open for interpretation. Also, when you say 1961 Civil Rights act, what are you referring to? The non-typo 1964 Civil Rights Act :dancehead
-
Women share first kiss at US Navy ship's return
Gender-based discrimination is still not sexual-orientation based discrimination, and the US Constitution has a gender-specific amendment as well. US v. Virginia also hinged upon the fact that VMI accepted Federal funds and thus was subject to the equal protection clause. A private institution is only required to permit members of all races (per the 1961 Civil Rights act), there is no requirement that mandates admission of both genders. Given that it was necessary to amend the Constitution to require states to provide the absolute fundamental right of a representative government (voting) to women indicates that the states possessed the capacity and legal authority to deny that right to citizens of the United States - for arbitrary reasons - in the first place. The 14th Amendment argument is the strongest one used for judicial activism of all sorts - but there is judicial precedent that denies rights to American Citizens for a wide range of causes - criminal conviction, residence, mental illness, sexual-orientation, height, weight, physical capacity, etc. I am not a lawyer, and I have had lawyers tell me my understanding is pretty strong, and I have had lawyers tell me that my understanding is fundamentally flawed. Take it for what it is worth. In my experience, when the court acts in a heavy handed way, without a clear expression from the Constitution, battle lines are drawn. In many cases the judge acts with the best of intent in order to correct a perceived injustice, but if left alone the issue would resolve itself within a generation - without the lingering political distraction of organized resistance from folks that feel persecuted but the courts "tyranny." As it is, most young people do not really care about the sexual-orientation of their fellow citizens. As time passes, today's youth will be tomorrow's voting majority.
-
Women share first kiss at US Navy ship's return
Ok. But you condescendingly referred me to the constitution when referring to the difference between race-based discrimination vs. gender-based discrimination. So what is it that I'm supposed to be looking for that makes one legally (if not morally, to paraphrase you) acceptable while the other is not? I'm honestly not arguing right now. I'm really hoping you can explain what you're referring to, because it's not clear to me. Because race is specifically mentioned in the US Constitution, and a denial of access to rights and privileges due to race is prohibited therein and per judicial precedent dating from the moment of passage of the 14th amendment race is specifically what it was referring to. Frankly, if advocacy groups were not playing a zero sum game, same-sex marriage would be a reality in all but the most stubborn states. Divorcing (pardon the pun) the term from the desired rights would get civil union legislation through most state assemblies. Visitation, taxation and property rights are really the core of marriage law and few people would want to deny a person the right to visit their loved one in the hospital, nor to prohibit the inheritance of shared property, etc.
-
Women share first kiss at US Navy ship's return
Im not sure I see where in the Constitution there can be that distinction made between gender-based discrimination for contract rights and race-based. From a legal standpoint. Can you spell it out for me? The governance of Contracts is not a power granted to the Federal government. It is why contract law is different in every state, and why marriage law is different in every state.
-
2012: Race for the Republican Nomination
No, he's not. But I'd rather have my viewpoints or more of the same. Plus, I value social ideals more than I value economic ideals. I value the idea that social ideals are immediately discarded once the economic clusterf*** calls survival into question.
-
Women share first kiss at US Navy ship's return
I don't see the difference. One may learn that race appears in my amendments, but "sexual orientation" does not. I can accept, and even agree with, a morale equivalence, but the legal equivalence is not present. I happen to think that it is not the Federal Government's role to dictate to the states what constitutes marriage, and that beyond property and parental rights/responsibilities the states should not even get involved in marriage. Also, the idea that DOMA is remotely constitutional is laughable. Marriages should carry over from state to state, changing residence should not automatically dispel responsibilities under the law. At most, for interstate interaction at least one of the participants in the marriage contract (agreement relating to rights of property, inheritance, and child custody) needs to be a resident of the state in which the contract is enacted. This is not unlike other contracts where the applicable state is one of the signing parties' state of record.
-
Women share first kiss at US Navy ship's return
This is why libertarian argument fall flat on their face: they're all for states' rights and a weak central government, until people correctly point out that we tried that with the Articles of Confederation and it was a disaster. That is not the Libertarian position at all. We have a Constitution, if we follow it, we will be fine. As for same-sex marriage being the same as interracial marriage, it is not. Homosexuals have the exact same right of heterosexuals to marry any person of the opposite sex that they want to - assuming that the person is also willing. Although the government should not use its power to deny homosexual couples the same property and inheritance rights as heterosexual couples does not mean that is cannot use its power in such a way. On can make an argument - one that has yet to have been carried in jurisprudence though the highest appeal - that the equal protection clause should be construed to permit same-sex marriage. I do not hold to that position because: 1) it is a distinct activity in style and 2) the issue will resolve itself democratically in society within a generation. Almost all the "civil rights" complaints are solved by old people dying off and taking their outdated prejudices with them.
-
2011-12 NFL Thread
They're running a 4-3 next year. Actually, they are going to run a hybrid. Too bad Taylor is old and retired. He is exactly the kind of athlete that could be a DE on one down in a 4-3 and an OLB on the next down in a 3-4
-
2012: Race for the Republican Nomination
Paul is capable of taking enough caucuses and Sanctorum enough bible belt states to perhaps prevent a majority - but I doubt it. I was pretty confident this sh*t was over after New Hampshire. Newt lives by the debate, if he is going to lose them then he is done.
-
Heading to see the Marlins...from Scotland!
if you are willing to pay a lot you should be able to get seats on stub hub - but I would expect that you will pay upwards of 4 - 5 times face value so tickets under $100 would not be close, but supposedly there are no bad seats in the new stadium and even upper deck seats should be superior to some lower bowl seats at Dolphin's Stadium
-
2012: Race for the Republican Nomination
This just in - GOP candidates say Obama is doing a poor job!
-
New Stadium Pics
I want to see how the marlins look. Like strong, sexy men. Ghey
-
Prince Fielder to Tigers
Cabrera to 3B? Who is their DH? Isn't Inge still under contract?
-
Prince Fielder to Tigers
At last, I no longer have to hear people pretending that we are in the running for Prince.