If you could brink back 1 of these former Marlins

[Bazooka]

yeah i'm bored... so in a fantasy world, if you could pick one of these Marlins to join this team, which one do you think would help us the most? a week ago i would've said Renteria (cause he's probably my all time favorite marlin) but man it would be nice to have Pudge on this team, or Urbina out of the pen. but i'll pick Pudge.

[miami15]

I dislike Pudge, now atleast, but he's the only one of these guys anywhere near his prime, other than Renteria, so its an easy choice.

[CapeFish]

El Ni?o!

[Bazooka]

I dislike Pudge, now atleast, but he's the only one of these guys anywhere near his prime, so its an easy choice.

what about Renteria? i think he's in his prime

[NirvanaNole]

Edgar. Gonzo is great at D, but he is one of the worst hitters I have EVER seen at the major league level. :blink:

[Guest Juanky]

Edgar Renteria, for sure. He is the best player up there, plays at our weakest position, and is arguably not only the best SS in the NL but the most underrated player in the bigs today.

[Prime Time]

Where is Cliff Floyd/Derrek Lee on that list? I would probably choose Edgar Renteria or Pudge. Most likely Pudge.

[Bazooka]

I didn't put Lee on the list because Choi is outplaying him (so far) so i didn't think he would help this team more then Pudge, Edgar or any of the pitchers, (and you would have to sit Choi) can't belive i forgot about Cliff though, i guess you would have to replace Conine.

[farmer_fran]

That's easy. Edgar.

[miami15]

I dislike Pudge, now atleast, but he's the only one of these guys anywhere near his prime, so its an easy choice.

what about Renteria? i think he's in his prime Yeah I saw Edgar but I didn't think of him. Its a toss up between Renteria and Pudge, imo.

[Marlins Phenom]

Edgar or Gary...

[DaGreatOne]

El Nino for sure. He would be a tremendous upgrade over Gonzalez, hitting wise and hes defintely on par defensive wise.

 

But that wont happen.

 

Unless...

 

hes is a free agent and were getting a stadium.....

 

:shifty

[BIG Z]

Edgar

[Ramp]

Renteria, no questions asked

[rferry]

Matt Turner

[Bazooka]

i forgot about Mika Piazza

[Nugget]

Where's Gary Sheffield?

[Beinfest4Prez]

Even though I like AGon, I liked Renteria better.

[Bazooka]

Where's Gary Sheffield?

he's on there. he's got one vote

[Nugget]

Well...... Where's Chris Hammond?

[Nugget]

OR Rob Nen!

[miami15]

Well...... Where's Chris Hammond?

Yeah, I would've also liked to see Preston, Floyd, and DLee. Nah, who in their right mind would voted DLee?

[Bazooka]

yeah... Preston i thought about after it was too late (can't edit now) I wouldn't pick him over sheff though, and definatly not over Renteria or Pudge. I didn't put Nen on cause he's injured now and not sure when he's comming back, Hammond would've been another good choice, though i would take some of the pitchers on that list before him.

[Mephisto]

kevin millar

[Das Texan]

Renteria if you are talking about an everyday player.

 

 

 

i also wouldnt mind having an arm or two back, especially to shore up that pen.