Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Billy Koch

Featured Replies

Boy I hope a change of scenery does it for Koch because he has always been "iffy". He's overpaid only because he throws hard which doesn't mean a damn thing if you can't throw it over the plate. Jack will have a heart attack!

Koch was awful with Toronto!

c'mon is this really the trade everybody was waiting 4....this guy is damaged goods,hope rosie can do to him what he did to benitez...

Here is my spin on this deal:

 

White Sox give up a servicable major league reliever and the cash to pay for him for a second/third tier minor leaguer that the Marlins would never use.

Exactly. And we still got Wilson down on the farm. Beinfest ROBBED the White Sox.

 

And remember, you dont all of a sudden lose the talent. Koch is getting 9+Ks per nine innings. Pitching in our park and in the NL - who really hasnt seen Koch - is going to help him make an immediate impact.

 

Right now, Benitez & Koch > Urbina & Looper.

 

Sick... :thumbup

ALL YOU NEED TO KNOW (From the Herald today):

 

Beinfest said he began discussing the trade with White Sox general manager Ken Williams on Tuesday and completed the deal during Thursday's game. In Valdez, the Marlins gave up a top infield prospect, but one unlikely to crack the majors soon with Alex Gonzalez at shortstop.

 

The Marlins also received what Beinfest termed ''a significant amount of cash.'' Williams said the White Sox would pick up ''more than half'' -- from $2 million to $2.5 million -- of Koch's salary. Koch is signed through this season, after which he becomes arbitration-eligible.

 

To make room for Koch, the Marlins optioned reliever Mike Neu to Triple A Albuquerque, N.M.

Here is my spin on this deal:

 

White Sox give up a servicable major league reliever and the cash to pay for him for a second/third tier minor leaguer that the Marlins would never use.

As a lifetime White Sox fan, I think that you're right on the money. A big part of the reason why Koch was unsuccessful in Chicago was the fact that Keith Foulke was hugely popular among both fans and teammates and when the Sox traded Foulke for Koch, Koch was massively resented. Even before he threw his 1st pitch in a MLB game for the Sox, he was probably the Sox player who the fans hated the most and they really went after him every time he got on the mound. In other words, Koch was in a situation in which he was subjected to far more pressure than other closers were, and being a closer is a high pressure spot as it is.

 

 

For what its worth, if Marlins fans and players alike embrace Koch and cut him some slack, I can easily see Koch becoming the comeback player of the season. Even if he does not fully regain his pre-White Sox form, the Marlins have clearly gotten the best end of the deal.

 

 

For Sox fans, this is a depressing deal. Even more depressing is those of us who feel this way are not allowed to post our thoughts on the matter on the main Sox fansite forum at whitesoxinteractive.com because the moderators there are really trolls in disguise who take the position that you either agree with them or don't post at "their" forum. In other words, if you are a Sox fan like myself who believe that the Marlins have (A) gotten the best end of this deal and (B) have a very good management team that is solidly committed to winning, you have to post your opinions elsewhere because the troll-moderators at WSI will not allow disagreement with their pre-ordained beliefs. Exactly. Great post.

 

And, to be truthful, this board used to work very similarly as I was once banned from here. So, keep your head up.

right about the numbers JL...

 

from the Sentinel

Koch is in the last season of a two-year, $10.625 million deal. He is owed about $3.9 million of his 2004 salary, with the White Sox agreeing to pay more than half of that figure, according to Chicago GM Ken Williams.

 

Sox are paying 2 to 2.5 of the 3.9 he's still owed. So Florida's paying him between somewhere between 1.4 to 1.9 million for him.

 

Valdez was only a year younger than Alex and the way Alex is hitting right now he's reminding us that when he gets going he can be above average offensively, as well as giving gold glove defense.

Some of the Chi Sox fans (on WSI) are sayin they could Cut Valdez right now, and still get the better end of the deal.

 

They probably remember what he did in chicago and not what he did with the A's... thats ignorance

 

I like the deal personally.

Here is my spin on this deal:

 

White Sox give up a servicable major league reliever and the cash to pay for him for a second/third tier minor leaguer that the Marlins would never use.

I agree to a point.

 

I'm not disapointed about this deal, but looks like we will be paying close to 2 millions for Koch.

 

Why didn't we spent that money at the begining of the season for a decent arm? I love Fox, but he has have a long history of injuries.

I'm a long-time Sox fan, and I thought I'd throw in my 2-cents worth. I have a different view than crector, though his comments were interesting. I, like most Sox fans, am quite relieved and happy to see Koch depart. (Quite frankly, that's one reason crector's comments were interesting; it is hard to hear any objections, though I'm sure there are some people that share his view.)

 

My reaction is that this looks like a good deal for both teams, although I don't know a lot about the SS you sent us. We could use some depth in infield positions in our system. All signs indicate that we have a closer in Takatsu. It would have been very difficult for Koch to continue here. He struggled so much last year. The best guess that I've heard is that the heavy use in Oakland the previous year had taken its toll. Billy had shown signs at times this year of regaining the form he displayed in Oakland. His speed was creeping back up, and I think that, through his struggles, he has been developing his pitching skills. From what I hear, your park is more of a pitchers' park than ours, and that should help. (A roof was installed over our top seats during the off season, and that appears to have -- unexpectedly -- helped the hitters.)

 

The one warning that I will give you is that you can anticipate that Koch will probably keep you on the edge of your seat in close games. I remember that was the comment that an Oakland fan posted on our board White Sox Interactive when he came to Chicago. While it can drive you crazy as a fan, it is not as negative as it might sound. He just seems to pitch better when he has men on base.

For almost the entire time he was with the White Sox, Billy Koch took a toll on my stomach lining. I had a hard time recognizing him as the same guy who pitched for the A's and Jays. Maybe that's evidence enough he was never meant to be a good fit with us. I do know Billy was given every opportunity by the Sox staff (if not the Sox fans). The chemistry was never right.

 

I've always admired Billy's attitude and I'll miss it with the Sox. For one thing, he was one of our better-spoken players in terms of the press. He never, ever shifted blame for his own shortcomings. If he had it coming, he stood there and took it. A veteran-laden team like the White Sox can get prima-donnaish at times, and Koch stood out as someone who didn't make excuses.

 

If only he could have translated that into getting batters out...

 

I truly hope Billy catches on with you guys. Seems a good fit. The Marlins have done a good job with other rehab "projects," and the NL's a little kinder to pitchers in general. For all the Sox fans saying they'd gladly taken a bag of baseballs in trade for him... that may not be shortsighted (again, we *did* try), but it is rude. I'd personally like to see them eat those baseballs. So good luck.

I think the comparison for this transaction should be chad fox of last year rather than UUU. Fox was pretty much unwanted when he was released and turned into an integral part of the Championship run. I have great confidence in Beinfest but the key to this transaction is Wayne Rosenthal. Rosenthal has shown a great ability to get pitchers to perform at their best. Valdez was a nice player but not a key part of our future. $1.5 million is reasonable money for a set-up guy. Where do we lose.

 

Most importantly this shows again that ownership is serious about winning and paying the price. The people in this community that still criticise this ownership group are just plain fools.

 

BTW, hopefully Williams and Beinfest talked about scenarios once the Sox are out of it. How about Conine, Stokes and a decent minor league pitcher for Magglio and $$$.

BTW, hopefully Williams and Beinfest talked about scenarios once the Sox are out of it. How about Conine, Stokes and a decent minor league pitcher for Magglio and $$$.

don't start with that

 

for some odd reason, i just have this feeling that they wouldn't do that trade

Billy will shine.........u will see, he will be a McKeon FAV, and will get along with everyone especially RED, welcome Koch home, he lives in florida........he will be more confortable, that is trouble for everyone else.......Ken Williams u r a fool.....valdez ur good, but billy was a steal!

I think the comparison for this transaction should be chad fox of last year rather than UUU. Fox was pretty much unwanted when he was released and turned into an integral part of the Championship run.

Right on target! We are not asking Koch to come in here and take away Benitez's job like Urbina did. He is coming here to just set up. There must be a difference in his mindset that he knows he is the set up guy because that is what the team needs him for, not because he failed as a closer. One of the reasons Fox was so successful here last year was because he could never be a closer in his career (see Milwaukee, Boston) and consistently lost his job. Once here, he knew he wasn't the closer and that takes pressure off. Hopefully the same thing will happen to Koch.

$1.5 million is reasonable money for a set-up guy. Where do we lose.

 

 

I could be wrong here, but if Chad Fox does not play this year which it doesn't sound good wouldn't the Marlins get insurance on his salary which was around a million making this deal make even more sense.

$1.5 million is reasonable money for a set-up guy. Where do we lose.

 

 

I could be wrong here, but if Chad Fox does not play this year which it doesn't sound good wouldn't the Marlins get insurance on his salary which was around a million making this deal make even more sense. that would make a hell of a lot of sense

dont you guys remember last year when he got uggy he had a high era and you all didnt like the trade at First? This seems to happen every time with you guys, and you never learn you should give people a chance and then judge them.

dont you guys remember last year when he got uggy he had a high era and you all didnt like the trade at First? This seems to happen every time with you guys, and you never learn you should give people a chance and then judge them.

I for one am willing to take a wait and see attitude.

 

He has the goods, it's really whether or not he can regain the control.

actually i am more reminded of Chad Fox....he was awful for the BoSox and look what he did here...

 

likewise....Benitez....a lot of peeps thought he wouldn't be great....he is spectacular......we have been hitting with our bullpen aquisitions....when we go out and get a guy, he seems to be good

 

beinfest has earned my trust and this seems like a smart move, i mean, we are talking about a guy in Koch who has great stuff......this is going to work out great

i think there's another consideration here - Billy Koch has pitched in the American League his entire career. As we've seen with Roger Clemens, there is a benefit to be gained from facing hitters for the first time in a new league. Though this won't last forever, it might give Koch a nice boost at the outset.

Since he has lost his so many MPH on his fastball, I hope Rosenthal can teach him how to use his command.

You can think him, Mesa, Plesac, Wendell and especially Bowa for your little parade.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.