February 1, 200521 yr COMPLETE player, as in there's nothing he can't do. Vlad is great, but he won't steal 40 bases. 674263[/snapback] He can. 674264[/snapback] The guy has a degenerative back condition, he's not stealing 40 bases. It doesn't matter if he can, the point is he won't. And I wouldn't be surprised to see him moved to DH sooner or later either. 674266[/snapback] Vladimir Guerrero is the most complete player in the game. Period. When Beltran come anywhere near the numbers Guerrero puts up, give me a call. 674275[/snapback] What is it you can't grasp about the most COMPLETE? Vlad is a better player, no arguments; but Beltran does EVERYTHING well. He's got 30+ HR Power, He can hit in the .290 range, he can play gold glove defense, and steal 40 bases a season. Now look at Vlad, He's offensively superior, he can hit .300+ and 40+ HRs a season, but he's not as good on the bae paths (15SBs last year and declining), he's not as good defensively as Beltran. Beltran does everything at least average, Vlad does as a few things expectionally well. Both are great players, Beltran is more COMPLETE.
February 1, 200521 yr COMPLETE player, as in there's nothing he can't do. Vlad is great, but he won't steal 40 bases. 674263[/snapback] He can. 674264[/snapback] The guy has a degenerative back condition, he's not stealing 40 bases. It doesn't matter if he can, the point is he won't. And I wouldn't be surprised to see him moved to DH sooner or later either. 674266[/snapback] Vladimir Guerrero is the most complete player in the game. Period. When Beltran come anywhere near the numbers Guerrero puts up, give me a call. 674275[/snapback] What is it you can't grasp about the most COMPLETE? Vlad is a better player, no arguments; but Beltran does EVERYTHING well. He's got 30+ HR Power, He can hit in the .290 range, he can play gold glove defense, and steal 40 bases a season. Now look at Vlad, He's offensively superior, he can hit .300+ and 40+ HRs a season, but he's not as good on the bae paths (15SBs last year and declining), he's not as good defensively as Beltran. Beltran does everything at least average, Vlad does as a few things expectionally well. Both are great players, Beltran is more COMPLETE. 674357[/snapback] WHO CARES anyone in their right mind would take Vladdy. Why need to steal a base when you can hit more 2B's and HR's? Anything he doesn't have he makes up with his bat.
February 1, 200521 yr WHO CARES anyone in their right mind would take Vladdy. Why need to steal a base when you can hit more 2B's and HR's? Anything he doesn't have he makes up with his bat. 674363[/snapback] I honestly didn't think it was possible, but you're a bigger idiot than he is.
February 1, 200521 yr THe Delgado pick-up is way more important that the mets getting Betran cause Delgado gets the Marlins into the playoffs and Beltran and the Big Money Ballers will be home in october...
February 1, 200521 yr easy, hands down. we became a waaay better team just cuz of this little change. no wait, huge change. we have a shot at the playoffs cuz of this guy. our offense became way better. we are just an overall better team.
February 1, 200521 yr Hudson, because his contract is peanuts for a guy of his talent, and the Braves gave up garbage to get him...none of the guys will ever be near the quality they gave up. Thomas? The "center-piece" of the deal is a fourth outfielder on good teams...
February 1, 200521 yr You should have made this poll excluding Delgado, because it's pretty obvious that 99.99999% of everyone on here will vote Delgado and results will be skewed.
February 2, 200521 yr hudson + mazzone= total destruction that's the best move doesn't mean they're the best team though :shifty
February 2, 200521 yr You expect unbias answers on this board, Marlins turned from okay to World series threat obvious Marlins but no point in a pole imo
February 2, 200521 yr Delgado signing. I'm not being biased, I just think that this signing helps us more than any other signing helped any other team. Delgado was the missing piece. The rest of the teams have alot of holes. Mets (bullpen), nationals (Starting pitching), Phillies (bullpen), Braves (almost everything)
February 2, 200521 yr Thomas? The "center-piece" of the deal is a fourth outfielder on good teams... 674504[/snapback] Thomas is a stud, blazing speed, gold glove defense good OBP, hits for a lot of extra base hits. And if he gains some more power, wow. Juan Cruz is a future closer, and Dan Meyer is a stud pitching prospect. The A's didn't just give Hudson away.
February 2, 200521 yr Beltran is the best move. He is clutch offensively and amazingly defensively...
February 2, 200521 yr Delgado signing. I'm not being biased, I just think that this signing helps us more than any other signing helped any other team. Delgado was the missing piece. The rest of the teams have alot of holes. Mets (bullpen), nationals (Starting pitching), Phillies (bullpen), Braves (almost everything) 674711[/snapback] Wagner, Worrel, Madsen, Cormier isnt good enough?
February 2, 200521 yr Thomas?? The "center-piece" of the deal is a fourth outfielder on good teams... 674504[/snapback] Thomas is a stud, blazing speed, gold glove defense good OBP, hits for a lot of extra base hits. And if he gains some more power, wow. Juan Cruz is a future closer, and Dan Meyer is a stud pitching prospect. The A's didn't just give Hudson away. 674723[/snapback] A "stud?" Here's what baseball america says of him (at the time of the trade): Thomas, 25, was a surprise contributor to the Braves' 13th consecutive division title in 2004. A 19th-round pick out of Western Carolina in 2000, he did little in the minors before coming on at Double-A Greenville at the end of 2003. He carried that momentum into last season, hitting .358/.416/.535 with four homers and 32 RBIs in 61 games at Triple-A Richmond to earn a callup. Thomas filled a need as a platoon left fielder for Atlanta, batting .288/.368/.445 with seven homers and 31 RBIs in 83 games. Whether he can repeat that performance remains to be seen, but he's an athletic outfielder who laces line drives to the gaps and shows plus speed on the bases. He has better range and arm strength than most left fielders. He could platoon with Eric Byrnes at that position for Oakland. And that "stud" Meyer has a career record of 19-19. Sorry, but the Braves got the better of the two A's pitchers (Hudson over Mulder) and the Cardinals ended up giving more for Mulder. The only "stud" that the A's can really claim to have gotten came from the Cards...Daric Barton.
February 2, 200521 yr Vlad is better then Beltran but Beltran is the more complete player....I would take Beltran though....
February 2, 200521 yr My top three: 1. Marlins sign Delgado 2. Braves trade for Hudson 3. Mets sign Beltran
February 2, 200521 yr You should have made this poll excluding Delgado, because it's pretty obvious that 99.99999% of everyone on here will vote Delgado and results will be skewed. 674565[/snapback] Accord check your PM, you dork. And to answer the question: Carlos Delgado is OBVIOUSLY the best move. Taking into consideration our limited payroll, and our obvious need for a lefty, Carlos has filled one of the only voids in our roster. The Mets still have many holes, and signing another right-handed slugger isn't going to put them over the top. Pedro is washed up (or about to be), and I personally think their best pick up was Doug M. Braves got Hudson, yes. But you can't say getting a player that only plays once every 5 days is a huge asset. Phillies and Nationals should be disqualified from major league baseball. (except Jim Thome, he can stay) Delgado all the way, baby.
February 3, 200521 yr Thomas?? The "center-piece" of the deal is a fourth outfielder on good teams... 674504[/snapback] Thomas is a stud, blazing speed, gold glove defense good OBP, hits for a lot of extra base hits. And if he gains some more power, wow. Juan Cruz is a future closer, and Dan Meyer is a stud pitching prospect. The A's didn't just give Hudson away. 674723[/snapback] A "stud?" Here's what baseball america says of him (at the time of the trade): Thomas, 25, was a surprise contributor to the Braves' 13th consecutive division title in 2004. A 19th-round pick out of Western Carolina in 2000, he did little in the minors before coming on at Double-A Greenville at the end of 2003. He carried that momentum into last season, hitting .358/.416/.535 with four homers and 32 RBIs in 61 games at Triple-A Richmond to earn a callup. Thomas filled a need as a platoon left fielder for Atlanta, batting .288/.368/.445 with seven homers and 31 RBIs in 83 games. Whether he can repeat that performance remains to be seen, but he's an athletic outfielder who laces line drives to the gaps and shows plus speed on the bases. He has better range and arm strength than most left fielders. He could platoon with Eric Byrnes at that position for Oakland. And that "stud" Meyer has a career record of 19-19. Sorry, but the Braves got the better of the two A's pitchers (Hudson over Mulder) and the Cardinals ended up giving more for Mulder. The only "stud" that the A's can really claim to have gotten came from the Cards...Daric Barton. 674910[/snapback] I don't see any reason why he can't duplicate last years season. I'm not saying Thomas is going to be great but I think he'll be a solid starter for the A's for a long time. Juan Cruz was lights out for the Braves last year, and W/L record proves nothing about Meyer.
February 3, 200521 yr MARLINS=Best record in MLB :notworthy 675713[/snapback] No way, there still not better than Boston, NY, STL probably not even Atlanta you can't count them out gain can you.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.