Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Besides Delgado which player would hurt the most

Featured Replies

I'm split between Cabrera and Mota.... an offensive superstar (or at least soon-to-be) or the bullpen's anchor... really tough to decide for now, so for the time being, Ill plead the 5th on this one...

Beckett or Burnett without a doubt. We don't really have many, if any Major League ready pitchers ready to go right now.

 

Lo Duca would be a pretty big too as well unless somehow Willingham somehow learned to catch over the winter.

 

JP, I think, could easily be replaced especially if we hang onto Enc.

Cabrera and Lowell.

 

Maybe Beckett and Burnett, although after last year that may be a case in their favor.

 

Last on the list is probably Pierre (1. Castillo 2. LoDuca 6. Conine 7. Encarnacion effectively replaces JP's contributions [/i]on the field[/i]) or Encarnacion.

Pitching keeps us in games

pitching wins games

Pitching most important

 

Beckett or Burnett would hurt the most.

Cabrera, but Gonzalez is also up there because no one can play SS near the level he can defensively, and we all know how important defense at that position.

 

Pierre's semi-replaceable, so is Castillo (but not both at the same time), Cabrera could fill in for Lowell, and Conine/Encarnacion are insurance there. LoDuca's important, but he's now our 6-hole hitter, not our 2/3 hole guy.

 

And the rotation is important, but offense wins in the regular season...pitching only really matters in the playoffs.

 

If 2003 showed me anything, it's that pitching is only important at the right time...we went with an injured Beckett and Burnett for most of 2003, but Beckett was healthy in the playoffs, and that's all that mattered.

  • Author

Cabrera, but Gonzalez is also up there because no one can play SS near the level he can defensively, and we all know how important defense at that position.

 

Pierre's semi-replaceable, so is Castillo (but not both at the same time), Cabrera could fill in for Lowell, and Conine/Encarnacion are insurance there. LoDuca's important, but he's now our 6-hole hitter, not our 2/3 hole guy.

 

And the rotation is important, but offense wins in the regular season...pitching only really matters in the playoffs.

If 2003 showed me anything, it's that pitching is only important at the right time...we went with an injured Beckett and Burnett for most of 2003, but Beckett was healthy in the playoffs, and that's all that mattered.

676876[/snapback]

:blink: see Orioles, Earlier Rangers...

I Honestly don't think that losing a Starting Pitcher will hurt the Marlins that much, in 2003 we lost Burnett for the whole season, and Beckett for considerable amount of time and still won the World Series. :D

 

This is because our offense was extremely efficent and our closer was established (more so in the 2nd half), even last year we lost Beckett and Burnett for considerable time and still finished with a respectable record. But last year our offense was.... well anemic at times.

 

I think Losing Cabrera, Lowell, or our best reliever will hurt us the most, because now we are not a team at the mercy of our pitching, this year we can actually score the runs to keep us in it.

Cabrera, but Gonzalez is also up there because no one can play SS near the level he can defensively, and we all know how important defense at that position.

 

Pierre's semi-replaceable, so is Castillo (but not both at the same time), Cabrera could fill in for Lowell, and Conine/Encarnacion are insurance there.? LoDuca's important, but he's now our 6-hole hitter, not our 2/3 hole guy.

 

And the rotation is important, but offense wins in the regular season...pitching only really matters in the playoffs.

If 2003 showed me anything, it's that pitching is only important at the right time...we went with an injured Beckett and Burnett for most of 2003, but Beckett was healthy in the playoffs, and that's all that mattered.

676876[/snapback]

:blink: see Orioles, Earlier Rangers...

676880[/snapback]

Offense and adequate pitching depth wins in the regular season. Because of the off-days and small margin for error, front-line pitchers and defense become important in the postseason.

Burnett, he's in a contract year, he doesn't have any nagging injury signs from last year unlike Beckett, so if he gets injured there is still a chance that Beckett gets injured...

I can't disagree that Miggy is the guy you don't want to see out of the lineup, but that said, Juan Pierre is the engine that runs the Fish. If anyone saw the encore game earlier this week it was a good reminder of how important JP is to this team.

 

Getting JP (and Castillo) on base early is the key to the success of the guys batting 3-4-5. Maybe one day Beinfest will decide to build the team differently but until then you have to have your head examined to conjure up a lineup without JP.

I can't disagree that Miggy is the guy you don't want to see out of the lineup, but that said, Juan Pierre is the engine that runs the Fish. If anyone saw the encore game earlier this week it was a good reminder of how important JP is to this team.

 

Getting JP (and Castillo) on base early is the key to the success of the guys batting 3-4-5. Maybe one day Beinfest will decide to build the team differently but until then you have to have your head examined to conjure up a lineup without JP.

677084[/snapback]

i agree :notworthy :notworthy :notworthy :notworthy :thumbup

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.