Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Gathright Update (2/18)

Featured Replies

Pierre was NEVER CRAPPY!!

 

Agreed. Neither is he a MVP or a player who provides less on-field (or off-field, some might reason to argue) value than what many, including those in decision-making roles with other MLB teams, suggest that he does. As Bill James once said, people tend to overrate specialists in baseball. They see the 40-homerun hitter, 100mph fastball pitchers or speedsters and ignore all their faults, whatever they might be. Pierre's for instance were his defense, arm, power and ability to walk. He's a solid role player. Not a star. Not a franchise player.

 

You know who else is not a future franchise player or a star? Gathright. That's why we shouldn't trade for him. I'm not saying we shouldn't have or invest in solid role players, but they are easily attainable. We shouldn't be beating down Tampa or anyone's door for one right now, let alone if we'd be giving up a player of better talent. If it's July and need to shore up a position for a race at the playoffs in this or future seasons, overpaying for a role player is expected. But right now it's not needed. Right now, the only need for Gathright is to suit someone or person's fetish for a fast player, exciting player or existing major leaguer. Frankly, we have greater ambitions than that. Almost all of us want a future World Series champion. Giving up a potential Cy Young Award candidate (heck, even a competitive team's #2-3 starter) for someone who at their best will be an empty .300 hitter is not going to help us toward our goal.

 

Eric Reed is a runner like Gathright? I've never seen anyone faster in a baseball uniform than Gathright.

 

From what I've read, Gathright may beat Reed on a track, but between the foul lines Reed utilizes his speed better. And isn't that what counts?

And I will not support a team that dumps such talent as those two. They have the highest possible talent in major league baseball.

 

 

Would you have said the same thing about losing Beckett or Burnett?

 

Unless something changes on the stadium front, I wouldn't count either Willis or Cabrera being on the club as the approach free agency.

I think something will change on the stadium front within 4 years, if not here than elsewhere, but you make an excellent point. Everything the club can and will do is temporary.

Another thing if Reed struggles and the Marlins dont pick anyone else up and Alejandro De Aza is doing good at AA look for him to get the call to take over at CF and the lead off spot.

Gathright is a poor man's Pierre...I agree they were ready to railroad Pierre out of town on a subpar season where in almost 600 at bats he had 45 K's...Gathright just about doubled that in a third of at bats...Gathright arm isn't great either and guess what Pierre can track down about anything in CF...I say if We want a CF We should look elsewhere...How about Lou Terrero? He isn't getting a chance with Taveras there...I am inttrigued about Chris Roberson from the Phillie Organization

 

Chris Roberson: Individual Stats (Batting)

Team From To G AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI TB BB SO SB CS OBP SLG AVG

Reading Phillies 04/07 09/05 139 553 90 172 24 8 15 70 257 40 112 34 14 .365 .465 .311

 

 

Too many SO but appears to do everything well

You know who else is not a future franchise player or a star? Gathright. That's why we shouldn't trade for him. I'm not saying we shouldn't have or invest in solid role players, but they are easily attainable. We shouldn't be beating down Tampa or anyone's door for one right now, let alone if we'd be giving up a player of better talent. If it's July and need to shore up a position for a race at the playoffs in this or future seasons, overpaying for a role player is expected. But right now it's not needed. Right now, the only need for Gathright is to suit someone or person's fetish for a fast player, exciting player or existing major leaguer. Frankly, we have greater ambitions than that. Almost all of us want a future World Series champion. Giving up a potential Cy Young Award candidate (heck, even a competitive team's #2-3 starter) for someone who at their best will be an empty .300 hitter is not going to help us toward our goal.

 

 

Well by the way things have transpired it certainly Admin Beinfest shares your sentiments as well...

 

:monkes

Scouting Report

Gathright is a player of extremes. He is so fast that Baseball America called him the fastest player in baseball last year. He makes contact, has hit for a high average at the AA level, and has shown a great eye at the plate. He has the skills of a prototypical lead-off hitter in the major leagues.

 

The problem is simple. He has zero power, which makes him a one-dimensional hitter. Pitchers at the advanced levels will challenge him resulting in fewer walks. Already we have signs of this as his walk rate was cut by more than half when he went from A+ to AA. That places a greater emphasis on him hitting for a high average. He is a slap hitter, so whether those slap hits will constitute a high average will be the entire story.

 

That scouting report held true in '04 as Gathright was able to hit for a high average in the upper levels, but also saw his walk rate and BB/SO rate drop significantly from his low level numbers. The Rays want him to work on making more consistent contact, and with Delmon Young about to pass Gathright for playing time, he could be used as trade bait. He also could be a very nice, cheap 4th OF on the major-league team in '05.

Eric Reed is a runner like Gathright? I've never seen anyone faster in a baseball uniform than Gathright.

 

 

have you seen Reed play?

 

 

just curious.

No.

Geez, two year old unatributed so-called scouting reports (read, some fantasy geek who probably was the waterboy for his high school team) really make me want to change my mind about Gathright.

Scouting Report

Gathright is a player of extremes. He is so fast that Baseball America called him the fastest player in baseball last year. He makes contact, has hit for a high average at the AA level, and has shown a great eye at the plate. He has the skills of a prototypical lead-off hitter in the major leagues.

 

The problem is simple. He has zero power, which makes him a one-dimensional hitter. Pitchers at the advanced levels will challenge him resulting in fewer walks. Already we have signs of this as his walk rate was cut by more than half when he went from A+ to AA. That places a greater emphasis on him hitting for a high average. He is a slap hitter, so whether those slap hits will constitute a high average will be the entire story.

 

That scouting report held true in '04 as Gathright was able to hit for a high average in the upper levels, but also saw his walk rate and BB/SO rate drop significantly from his low level numbers. The Rays want him to work on making more consistent contact, and with Delmon Young about to pass Gathright for playing time, he could be used as trade bait. He also could be a very nice, cheap 4th OF on the major-league team in '05.

 

 

:thumbdown

 

Do your homework and realize that was a 2004 scouting report and no longer holds any relevance. Cumulatively in 2005, Gathright increased his BB rate and stolen base %, and decreased his K rate. He did this all between AAA/MLB, when he was supposed to fail against tougher pitching. He also hit for more power then he ever did in the past, with his highest yearly slugging percentage of .378. His previous high (2003 in single A) was .365, and he achieved that with a .334 batting average. Joey hit .291 between AAA/MLB last year, meaning, his rise in slugging is very significant because he achieved it with 15 less hits in relatively equal AB. This guy is coming into his own as a gap doubles hitters, and it's not going to be a shock when he hits 40+ doubles and triples yearly at the big league level. Not superstar levels of extra base hits and certainly not a lot of HR, if any, but it's not like he is powerless which is his reputation. The only knock from 2005 is the drop in batting average. .334 in 2003, .321 in 2004, .291 (.305 AAA, .276 MLB) in 2005. I believe it's natural for a rookies batting average to drop off as he moves up levels. You can use this stat decline and cite he will never be more then a .276 MLB hitter if you want, but I like to look at that increased BB/decreased K rate at higher levels, increased slugging, and think the average will catch up to his peripheral stats. I use this same argument with Hanley, who improved in a number of areas last year even if his average dropped.

 

Gathright will probably be able to do something like .280/.335/.375, 50+ SB at a good % at bare minimum in 2006 , with tolerable (slightly below) average defense. There is ceratinly room to grow into .300/.360/.400 type guy, same steals and defense. You never know, but I think he is not Tike Redman. He could be a perfect compliment to the 4 sluggers manning the corner positions, and Hanley. I guess it all depends if Beinfest eventually caves and moves Olsen (future Doug Davis, not Cy Young type. Still a great player, but not Santana), or if Tampa will eventually settle for Johnson, Nolasco, or one of the 2nd tier SP prospects. Someone mentioning Petit is absolutely laughable also. If they won't give Olsen, giving up Petit is an even worse trade to this organization. They took Petit over Milledge, and Lasting is certainly above Gathright on the young CF food chain. Regardless, I'd like to see the Marlins get him. I think he's going to be a good baseball player, and Gathright-Hanley could be a pretty nice 1-2 combo starting in 2007. To compare them to the combo we just had, I think JP/Castillo have the OBP potential on Gathright/Hanley which is very important in those lineup spots, but I think Gathright/Hanley's OBP will be respectable and not a liability, they will have a greater SB quantity at a better/more beneficial %, and more power (slugging). Eric Reed sucks and will never hit, so does Abercrombie, and Aguila is a 4th OF at best. Gathright fits the profile perfectly.

 

Also, someone mentioned De Aza being a CF candidate.... someone is looking at PECOTA. That system sure does like him as a young hitter, but he is atleast 1-2 full years away. His defensive projections are about as poor as Willinghams (catcher) at their respective positions. That's really bad. He needs to work on that, and build on his 05 with a solid year in AA. Nice sleeper prospect that could easily be a top 3 position prospect in the organization come the end of the season.

Why not lock up young studs Cabrera and Willis, who avoided arbitration with a one-year, $4.35 million contract, to long-term deals? As team President David Samson pointed out at FanFest last weekend, the Marlins would rather pay for performance than projections, even if it costs more in the long run.

 

I have no problem with this part. Players play harder when they're playing for their contract. Please see: 2003. Mike Lowell was "locked up," and look what happened.

 

So you'd be fine with them hitting the open market?

 

Lowell isn't in the same league as Cabrera.

 

Willis I'm OK with for the next few years doing a pay for performance system, but Cabrera needs to be locked up Pujols style.

 

Why would Miguel Cabrera sign anything beyond his arbitration years right now anyway? That's not a good move for him, especially signing with this franchise right now.

 

And Albert Pujols got 14 million dollars. Why should we pay Miguel that kind of money right now when we don't have to. If we have any kind of stadium deal in place when it comes time to lock him up, we will. If we don't, we won't.

Scouting Report

Gathright is a player of extremes. He is so fast that Baseball America called him the fastest player in baseball last year. He makes contact, has hit for a high average at the AA level, and has shown a great eye at the plate. He has the skills of a prototypical lead-off hitter in the major leagues.

 

The problem is simple. He has zero power, which makes him a one-dimensional hitter. Pitchers at the advanced levels will challenge him resulting in fewer walks. Already we have signs of this as his walk rate was cut by more than half when he went from A+ to AA. That places a greater emphasis on him hitting for a high average. He is a slap hitter, so whether those slap hits will constitute a high average will be the entire story.

 

That scouting report held true in '04 as Gathright was able to hit for a high average in the upper levels, but also saw his walk rate and BB/SO rate drop significantly from his low level numbers. The Rays want him to work on making more consistent contact, and with Delmon Young about to pass Gathright for playing time, he could be used as trade bait. He also could be a very nice, cheap 4th OF on the major-league team in '05.

 

 

Do your homework and realize that was a 2004 scouting report and no longer holds any relevance. Cumulatively in 2005, Gathright increased his BB rate and stolen base %, and decreased his K rate. He did this all between AAA/MLB, when he was supposed to fail against tougher pitching. He also hit for more power then he ever did in the past, with his highest yearly slugging percentage of .378. His previous high (2003 in single A) was .365, and he achieved that with a .334 batting average. Joey hit .291 between AAA/MLB last year, meaning, his rise in slugging is very significant because he achieved it with 15 less hits in relatively equal AB. This guy is coming into his own as a gap doubles hitters, and it's not going to be a shock when he hits 40+ doubles and triples yearly at the big league level. Not superstar levels of extra base hits and certainly not a lot of HR, if any, but it's not like he is powerless which is his reputation. The only knock from 2005 is the drop in batting average. .334 in 2003, .321 in 2004, .291 (.305 AAA, .276 MLB) in 2005. I believe it's natural for a rookies batting average to drop off as he moves up levels. You can use this stat decline and cite he will never be more then a .276 MLB hitter if you want, but I like to look at that increased BB/decreased K rate at higher levels, increased slugging, and think the average will catch up to his peripheral stats. I use this same argument with Hanley, who improved in a number of areas last year even if his average dropped.

 

Gathright will probably be able to do something like .280/.335/.375, 50+ SB at a good % at bare minimum in 2006 , with tolerable (slightly below) average defense. There is ceratinly room to grow into .300/.360/.400 type guy, same steals and defense. You never know, but I think he is not Tike Redman. He could be a perfect compliment to the 4 sluggers manning the corner positions, and Hanley. I guess it all depends if Beinfest eventually caves and moves Olsen (future Doug Davis, not Cy Young type. Still a great player, but not Santana), or if Tampa will eventually settle for Johnson, Nolasco, or one of the 2nd tier SP prospects. Someone mentioning Petit is absolutely laughable also. If they won't give Olsen, giving up Petit is an even worse trade to this organization. They took Petit over Milledge, and Lasting is certainly above Gathright on the young CF food chain. Regardless, I'd like to see the Marlins get him. I think he's going to be a good baseball player, and Gathright-Hanley could be a pretty nice 1-2 combo starting in 2007. To compare them to the combo we just had, I think JP/Castillo have the OBP potential on Gathright/Hanley which is very important in those lineup spots, but I think Gathright/Hanley's OBP will be respectable and not a liability, they will have a greater SB quantity at a better/more beneficial %, and more power (slugging). Eric Reed sucks and will never hit, so does Abercrombie, and Aguila is a 4th OF at best. Gathright fits the profile perfectly.

 

Also, someone mentioned De Aza being a CF candidate.... someone is looking at PECOTA. That system sure does like him as a young hitter, but he is atleast 1-2 full years away. His defensive projections are about as poor as Willinghams (catcher) at their respective positions. That's really bad. He needs to work on that, and build on his 05 with a solid year in AA. Nice sleeper prospect that could easily be a top 3 position prospect in the organization come the end of the season.

 

:goodpost

 

 

Hey Lou, what's your take on the CF battle in Detroit between Granderson & Nook Logan? Would you prefer either of those two over Joey G? Domborowski has been a good trading partner in the past...

 

:mischief2

Hi lou i wanna thankyou for your insight I wanna state that I just put that profile out there as a perspective of what to expect from Gathright...It was the most recent report I could find if you have any others that you have encountered. i would love to see them ...Some people have indicated that there is an ellitist hierachy to this forum and it appears that your commentary reference to my posting did have negative tone in fact it seemed snobbish and condescending I surely hope that that is my misinterpretation and not the original intent...I always try to keep an open mind in these forums I hope that people are encouraged to participate and freely express their thoughts and perspectives and can just have fun

Hi lou i wanna thankyou for your insight I wanna state that I just put that profile out there as a perspective of what to expect from Gathright...It was the most recent report I could find if you have any others that you have encountered. i would love to see them ...Some people have indicated that there is an ellitist hierachy to this forum and it appears that your commentary reference to my posting did have negative tone in fact it seemed snobbish and condescending I surely hope that that is my misinterpretation and not the original intent...I always try to keep an open mind in these forums I hope that people are encouraged to participate and freely express their thoughts and perspectives and can just have fun

 

 

My posts typically come off like that because I'm just a very defensive person in general, but it's nothing personal. It's just my 'argumentative/debate' style in writing. I'm sure this is not the last time I will apologize around here because of it, but I do apologize if you think I'm a jerk. After reading it, the start was a little harsh. Maybe I shouldn't do forums at 5:00am coming home from bar hopping. ha.

:goodpost

 

Hey Lou, what's your take on the CF battle in Detroit between Granderson & Nook Logan? Would you prefer either of those two over Joey G? Domborowski has been a good trading partner in the past...

 

:mischief2

 

 

This is easy, Granderson by a HUGE HUGE HUGE margin. I'm just going to quickly summarize minor/major league careers then go age wise year-year because it's really obvious who is going to be the better baseball player now, and longterm.

 

Nook Logan Minors 1969 AB, .261/.319/.338, 167/438 BB/K, 197/59 SB

Nook Logan Majors 445 AB, .264/.316/.338, 34/76 BB/K, 31/8 SB

 

Logan is 26, and at this point has a lot (450+ AB) of MLB experience. It just doesn't seem like he has any sort of ceiling besides being a bench outfielder. He never hit anywhere in the minors, and he continued this in his MLB stint so far. PECOTA ranks him as an above average defensive CF, and coupled with his speed, he seems like a great 5th OF for spot AB, pinch running, and defense.

 

Granderson Minors 1595 AB, .300/.383/.495, 197/350 BB/K, 55/23 SB

Granderson Majors 187 AB, .267/.315/.476, 13/51 BB/K, 1/1 SB

 

Granderson is turning 25 before opening day. He has hit for better average at every professional level then Logan, BB more at every level, K's less, hits for an outrageous amount of more power, but doesn't have the SB speed of Logan. PECOTA ranks Granderson as the best defensive CF in baseball also, although I have serious doubts he is actually the best . (I checked A. Jones, Kotsay, and J. Reed's rankings, and amazingly that system believes Granderson ranks higher). At a minimum, that tells me he is certainly an above average defender and won't hurt you in that department. The only question I have with Granderson is the strikeouts. He whiffed an awful lot in his MLB stint, but that might be because he is just young and adjusting. Some guys like Geoff Jenkins can whiff 150 times a year and stay productive, but we'll see if Granderson can cut the K's a little bit and make that average go north 15-20 points at a minimum. I think he's going to be a quality MLB player for a long time.

 

I prefer Granderson over Gathright by epic proportions, but I would take Gathright over Logan by an almost equally sizeable margin. I'd take Logan over Reed also if he cost nothing in a trade. I don't think Reed will ever hit MLB pitching, but he'll be great to watch in CF defensively. Granderson could provide a .280/.350/.500 batting line, with 15+ SB at a 70% clip, from CF with excellent defense. That's like Grady Sizemore. Andrew Jones career line is .263/.342/.503. (note, I'm not saying Granderson is the next A. Jones because Jones hit the big leagues much younger, and now has apparently crossed the line into superstardom with his HR last year. It's just a baseline comparison). Granderson is probably a future all-star contending CF. Gathright is more of a solid MLB starter, that needs the right team with multiple sluggers already in place (see Marlins) to become a great complimentary player, while Logan and Reed are low ceiling bench types that'll probably be out of the bigs before their 30th birthday.

 

I guess your idea was, why not trade with Detroit? Well, if they are stupid enough to trade Granderson, go for it. I don't think anyone here would have a problem trading Olsen for him. I don't see that happening though. He is going to be a building block position player for Detroit. He'll start in CF. This "open competition" in Detroit is just to not hand Granderson the CF job, and give Logan some incentive. There is no way they actually bench Granderson for that guy. No way. That's like saying there is open competition in RF between Aguila and Hermida.

  • Author

Why not lock up young studs Cabrera and Willis, who avoided arbitration with a one-year, $4.35 million contract, to long-term deals? As team President David Samson pointed out at FanFest last weekend, the Marlins would rather pay for performance than projections, even if it costs more in the long run.

 

I have no problem with this part. Players play harder when they're playing for their contract. Please see: 2003. Mike Lowell was "locked up," and look what happened.

 

So you'd be fine with them hitting the open market?

 

Lowell isn't in the same league as Cabrera.

 

Willis I'm OK with for the next few years doing a pay for performance system, but Cabrera needs to be locked up Pujols style.

 

Why would Miguel Cabrera sign anything beyond his arbitration years right now anyway? That's not a good move for him, especially signing with this franchise right now.

 

And Albert Pujols got 14 million dollars. Why should we pay Miguel that kind of money right now when we don't have to. If we have any kind of stadium deal in place when it comes time to lock him up, we will. If we don't, we won't.

 

Cabrera would signe beyond his arbitration years because of one word: security.

 

He's a father now, he's got his own family to support and his extended family. He knows his talent is a gift and he'd gladly sign a 6 or 7 year contract (only taking away 2 free agent years) for a little less than he may be worth to act as substantial insurance against future injury. Cabrera would be hard pressed to turn it down, and the Marlins would be stupid to not offer it.

Why not lock up young studs Cabrera and Willis, who avoided arbitration with a one-year, $4.35 million contract, to long-term deals? As team President David Samson pointed out at FanFest last weekend, the Marlins would rather pay for performance than projections, even if it costs more in the long run.

 

I have no problem with this part. Players play harder when they're playing for their contract. Please see: 2003. Mike Lowell was "locked up," and look what happened.

 

So you'd be fine with them hitting the open market?

 

Lowell isn't in the same league as Cabrera.

 

Willis I'm OK with for the next few years doing a pay for performance system, but Cabrera needs to be locked up Pujols style.

 

Why would Miguel Cabrera sign anything beyond his arbitration years right now anyway? That's not a good move for him, especially signing with this franchise right now.

 

And Albert Pujols got 14 million dollars. Why should we pay Miguel that kind of money right now when we don't have to. If we have any kind of stadium deal in place when it comes time to lock him up, we will. If we don't, we won't.

 

Cabrera would signe beyond his arbitration years because of one word: security.

 

He's a father now, he's got his own family to support and his extended family. He knows his talent is a gift and he'd gladly sign a 6 or 7 year contract (only taking away 2 free agent years) for a little less than he may be worth to act as substantial insurance against future injury. Cabrera would be hard pressed to turn it down, and the Marlins would be stupid to not offer it.

 

Well, we can agree to disagree.

 

I personally think you'd have to be a moron to sign with this organization long term in its present state.

 

And that's not me ripping the organization or anything, I'm not one of those guys. But, the future of the franchise is in serious question and locking yourself out of a chance to get out of a potentially bad situation is not good business.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.