Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Scott O. vs. Joe G.

Featured Replies

yeah I'm sure Girardi won't talk about it. He likes to keep things in-house.

 

 

Sorry, but once it's seen by the public it's no longer "in-house." Who the hell does Girardi think he is...Bobby Knight???? If he's not suspended for manhandling Olsen, it's a bad example. And Girardi does a segment for kids on FSN?? Great thing for a kid to see on the news.

 

Only two people could disclipine me...my parents. If I was Olsen and Girardi laid a hand on me, as Pat Travers would say, "Boom Boom Out Go The Lights."

 

You talk...not touch. Shame that Joey Pitbull doesn't realize that...

 

 

Erm...

 

Never mind :plain

 

 

hahahha manhandling? Please.

 

I'd hate to see what you think of a real fight where punches are thrown.

 

I like the move from Joe. He has shown he isn't going to take any sh*t from the young guys on this team and if they aren't getting the message than he isn't afraid to yell/send em to Albequerque.

 

 

Evidently Joey Pitbull has never heard of the Lenny Randle/Frank Lucchesi story from 1976 or '77.

 

Great message...grab a player. Steinbrenner must be happy at that, as is Bobby Knight...

 

And yeah, I have been in real fights...I've lost more than I won, but I didn't back down. If I was Olsen, the instant Girardi laid a hand on me...BOOM! Talk, yes. Criticize, yes. Touch...all rules go out the door.

 

Leyland didn't take crap either, but he didn't grab.

 

Bit touchy, ain't we?

It's inappropriate to touch your player and publicly embarrass him in that manner.

 

I don't care who you are or what your message is.

 

What is inappropriate is players behavior today. Joe is from the catchers school ala Carlton Fisk and others who know how the game is played and how its not. He made his point the way he knew how. The embarrassment is that he had to do it in the first place.

Maybe if some manager had grabbed AJ Burnett like that early in his career he wouldn't have turned into the person he became.

  • Author

Was was Joe supposed to say *in a sweet voice* "Oh Scotty. Come over here I need to talk to you about your attitude and how you are not focusing". It wasnt like he GRABBED him and threw him across the room. Joe just pulled him over to the side. There is nothing wrong with what he did. He is the boss. These guys need to respect him and listen to him.

Was was Joe supposed to say *in a sweet voice* "Oh Scotty. Come over here I need to talk to you about your attitude and how you are not focusing". It wasnt like he GRABBED him and threw him across the room. Joe just pulled him over to the side. There is nothing wrong with what he did. He is the boss. These guys need to respect him and listen to him.

 

 

I don't respect anal-retentive control freaks like Joey Pitbull. Managers with that style usually don't last long. See Vern Rapp or Bobby Winkles as examples.

 

Within the past 30 years, grabbing a player has become an invitation for disaster. Ask Bobby Knight. Anybody remember Woody Hayes' last act as Ohio State's football coach?

It's inappropriate to touch your player and publicly embarrass him in that manner.

 

I don't care who you are or what your message is.

 

 

 

The good news is that when you become manager you will be able to set some type of "No touching players rule"

 

 

Was was Joe supposed to say *in a sweet voice* "Oh Scotty. Come over here I need to talk to you about your attitude and how you are not focusing". It wasnt like he GRABBED him and threw him across the room. Joe just pulled him over to the side. There is nothing wrong with what he did. He is the boss. These guys need to respect him and listen to him.

 

 

I don't respect anal-retentive control freaks like Joey Pitbull. Managers with that style usually don't last long. See Vern Rapp or Bobby Winkles as examples.

 

Within the past 30 years, grabbing a player has become an invitation for disaster. Ask Bobby Knight. Anybody remember Woody Hayes' last act as Ohio State's football coach?

 

 

Little sore at ex-Yankees are ya SDL RedSoxFan??????? Are you the inventor of the highly inappropriate term, Joey Pitbull???

It's inappropriate to touch your player and publicly embarrass him in that manner.

 

I don't care who you are or what your message is.

 

 

 

The good news is that when you become manager you will be able to set some type of "No touching players rule"

 

 

Was was Joe supposed to say *in a sweet voice* "Oh Scotty. Come over here I need to talk to you about your attitude and how you are not focusing". It wasnt like he GRABBED him and threw him across the room. Joe just pulled him over to the side. There is nothing wrong with what he did. He is the boss. These guys need to respect him and listen to him.

 

 

I don't respect anal-retentive control freaks like Joey Pitbull. Managers with that style usually don't last long. See Vern Rapp or Bobby Winkles as examples.

 

Within the past 30 years, grabbing a player has become an invitation for disaster. Ask Bobby Knight. Anybody remember Woody Hayes' last act as Ohio State's football coach?

 

 

Little sore at ex-Yankees are ya SDL RedSoxFan??????? Are you the inventor of the highly inappropriate term, Joey Pitbull???

 

Actually, there is one ex-Yankee I admire very highly, Jim Bouton. I'm more than a little sore at current Yankees...

 

Leave us face it, Girardi does look like he could be onThe Sopranos as a hitman, hence the term "Joey Pitbull." He looks like a pit bull.

 

As for inventing the term... http://tbsports.net/columns/levison/060306...alter_clone.htm

:whylink

 

It's inappropriate to touch your player and publicly embarrass him in that manner.

 

I don't care who you are or what your message is.

 

 

 

The good news is that when you become manager you will be able to set some type of "No touching players rule"

 

 

Was was Joe supposed to say *in a sweet voice* "Oh Scotty. Come over here I need to talk to you about your attitude and how you are not focusing". It wasnt like he GRABBED him and threw him across the room. Joe just pulled him over to the side. There is nothing wrong with what he did. He is the boss. These guys need to respect him and listen to him.

 

 

I don't respect anal-retentive control freaks like Joey Pitbull. Managers with that style usually don't last long. See Vern Rapp or Bobby Winkles as examples.

 

Within the past 30 years, grabbing a player has become an invitation for disaster. Ask Bobby Knight. Anybody remember Woody Hayes' last act as Ohio State's football coach?

 

 

Little sore at ex-Yankees are ya SDL RedSoxFan??????? Are you the inventor of the highly inappropriate term, Joey Pitbull???

 

Actually, there is one ex-Yankee I admire very highly, Jim Bouton. I'm more than a little sore at current Yankees...

 

Leave us face it, Girardi does look like he could be onThe Sopranos as a hitman, hence the term "Joey Pitbull." He looks like a pit bull.

 

As for inventing the term... http://tbsports.net/columns/levison/060306...alter_clone.htm

 

 

:whylink

 

I get the feeling the author of that article either A) Lost a lot of $ on a late inning Girardi RBI double or B) He is still in Junior High.

Little sore at ex-Yankees are ya SDL RedSoxFan??????? Are you the inventor of the highly inappropriate term, Joey Pitbull???

 

When I think of some of the managers the Red Sox have had, Dick Williams and Ralph Houk specifically, it's a bit funny to be lectured on appropriate managerial behavior by a Boston fan.

Little sore at ex-Yankees are ya SDL RedSoxFan??????? Are you the inventor of the highly inappropriate term, Joey Pitbull???

 

When I think of some of the managers the Red Sox have had, Dick Williams and Ralph Houk specifically, it's a bit funny to be lectured on appropriate managerial behavior by a Boston fan.

 

Say what you will about Williams and Houk, but unlike Joey Pitbull, they weren't concerned if a player had a mustache. And if you remember, Williams quit managing the A's after what Finley did to Mike Andrews. Would Girardi have done that? Also, I don't recall either guy manhandling a player.

 

By the way, both Williams and Houk won championships their first year managing in the bigs. And yes, I know that Houk had the great Yankee dynasty he inherited from Stengel. On the other hand, Williams inherited a 9th place squad from Billy Herman and the '67 team was given a 100-1 shot. Taking the Cards to 7 in the '67 Series wasn't too shabby.

Some people are acting like this is a big deal, Olsen has a reputation of a bad attitude and is acting like a young punk. I'm sure Giradi had good reason for what he did.

Was was Joe supposed to say *in a sweet voice* "Oh Scotty. Come over here I need to talk to you about your attitude and how you are not focusing". It wasnt like he GRABBED him and threw him across the room. Joe just pulled him over to the side. There is nothing wrong with what he did. He is the boss. These guys need to respect him and listen to him.

 

 

You make a lot of sense Holly

I remember a Josh Beckett interview from 2003 where Josh was asked about getting yelled at by Jack McKeon on a particular occasion. He answered "...sometimes I need someone to talk to me like that and he was right." He then added "I wouldn't have blamed him if he took me over his knee and spanked me."

 

I remember this distinctly because my friend and I were watching the interview and thought it was hilarious that Josh said that in his deadpan way. Obviously he didn't get spanked but the fact that he said it, acknowledged he was wrong and understood the concept of authority and discipline made me think Josh was growing up.

 

We don't know all that went on with Olsen and what made Girardi react that way. In any case, it's not like he got paddled in public or anything so extreme. Bottom line is if you don't wish to be treated like a child then you shouldn't behave like one. I feel pretty certain that when these young players treat each other, the manager and their staff with respect they will be respected in return. In the meantime, I don't think Scott Olsen is going to be traumatized by this incident.

Was was Joe supposed to say *in a sweet voice* "Oh Scotty. Come over here I need to talk to you about your attitude and how you are not focusing". It wasnt like he GRABBED him and threw him across the room. Joe just pulled him over to the side. There is nothing wrong with what he did. He is the boss. These guys need to respect him and listen to him.

 

 

You make a lot of sense Holly

 

Must be the "new" way of doing things. Look where it got Bobby Knight and Woody Hayes. If Bobby Knight wasn't Bobby Knight, he'd still be out of work.

 

Leyland & McKeon didn't manhandle players and they did pretty well with the Marlins...

Was was Joe supposed to say *in a sweet voice* "Oh Scotty. Come over here I need to talk to you about your attitude and how you are not focusing". It wasnt like he GRABBED him and threw him across the room. Joe just pulled him over to the side. There is nothing wrong with what he did. He is the boss. These guys need to respect him and listen to him.

 

 

You make a lot of sense Holly

 

Must be the "new" way of doing things. Look where it got Bobby Knight and Woody Hayes. If Bobby Knight wasn't Bobby Knight, he'd still be out of work.

 

Leyland & McKeon didn't manhandle players and they did pretty well with the Marlins...

To compare this to Bobby Knight is quite a stretch.

Was was Joe supposed to say *in a sweet voice* "Oh Scotty. Come over here I need to talk to you about your attitude and how you are not focusing". It wasnt like he GRABBED him and threw him across the room. Joe just pulled him over to the side. There is nothing wrong with what he did. He is the boss. These guys need to respect him and listen to him.

 

 

You make a lot of sense Holly

 

Must be the "new" way of doing things. Look where it got Bobby Knight and Woody Hayes. If Bobby Knight wasn't Bobby Knight, he'd still be out of work.

 

Leyland & McKeon didn't manhandle players and they did pretty well with the Marlins...

To compare this to Bobby Knight is quite a stretch.

 

Bottom Line:

 

Don't touch a player.

Little sore at ex-Yankees are ya SDL RedSoxFan??????? Are you the inventor of the highly inappropriate term, Joey Pitbull???

 

When I think of some of the managers the Red Sox have had, Dick Williams and Ralph Houk specifically, it's a bit funny to be lectured on appropriate managerial behavior by a Boston fan.

 

Say what you will about Williams and Houk, but unlike Joey Pitbull, they weren't concerned if a player had a mustache. And if you remember, Williams quit managing the A's after what Finley did to Mike Andrews. Would Girardi have done that? Also, I don't recall either guy manhandling a player.

 

By the way, both Williams and Houk won championships their first year managing in the bigs. And yes, I know that Houk had the great Yankee dynasty he inherited from Stengel. On the other hand, Williams inherited a 9th place squad from Billy Herman and the '67 team was given a 100-1 shot. Taking the Cards to 7 in the '67 Series wasn't too shabby.

 

If that's manhandling then you and I have a very different definiton of that word. He grabbed his shirt.

Little sore at ex-Yankees are ya SDL RedSoxFan??????? Are you the inventor of the highly inappropriate term, Joey Pitbull???

 

When I think of some of the managers the Red Sox have had, Dick Williams and Ralph Houk specifically, it's a bit funny to be lectured on appropriate managerial behavior by a Boston fan.

 

Say what you will about Williams and Houk, but unlike Joey Pitbull, they weren't concerned if a player had a mustache. And if you remember, Williams quit managing the A's after what Finley did to Mike Andrews. Would Girardi have done that? Also, I don't recall either guy manhandling a player.

 

By the way, both Williams and Houk won championships their first year managing in the bigs. And yes, I know that Houk had the great Yankee dynasty he inherited from Stengel. On the other hand, Williams inherited a 9th place squad from Billy Herman and the '67 team was given a 100-1 shot. Taking the Cards to 7 in the '67 Series wasn't too shabby.

 

If that's manhandling then you and I have a very different definiton of that word. He grabbed his shirt.

 

A young kid seeing that on TV...he'll think it's OK for him to grab other kids' shirts...

 

And Joey Pitbull claims his college education taught him how to work with people? Riiiiiiiight...

A young kid seeing that on TV...he'll think it's OK for him to grab other kids' shirts...

 

And Joey Pitbull claims his college education taught him how to work with people? Riiiiiiiight...

 

 

Are you kidding me? Think of it another way, a kid sees Olsen not get reprimanded and he thinks that his talent alone allows him to act like a punk. Besides, how many kids grow up thinking "I want to be a manager when I grow up"? Compare that to the number of little leaguers hoping to become pitchers. Which action sends the wrong message to more people?

 

I have absolutely no problem with what Girardi did. This is professional sports, not a freaking tea party. It's a physical game, and sometimes coaches may need to get a little physical to send a message to their players. End of story. Obviously, Olsen got the message. Had Girardi taken your advice, I'm sure Olsen would've ignored it just like he has probably ignored the same message from every coach he's had.

 

I'm sure a civil approach is preferred, but sometimes it's just not effective. No offense to any ball players, but alot of professional baseball players are complete idiots outside of that batters box or pitcher's mound. Many players develop huge egos, especially touted pitching prospects. Pitchers can singlehandedly influence a game more than any player. If you're good, that can get you real cocky and lead you to think that you always know best. Fact of the matter is, they don't. For better or for worse, that's the coaches job, and it may take a shirt pull or two to wake some of these young kids up to that reality.

 

As for "Joey Pitbull's" actions, Olsen isn't working in some cubicle, he's a baseball player. It comes with the job. Deal with it.

 

BTW You mentioned Bobby Knight. And how he "wouldn't be where he's at if he wasn't Bobby Knight." Not defending what the guy did, but he probably wouldn't have been so succesful as a basketball coach either. (Soon to be winningest coach in college basketball history). He was an abusive, hard ass, but he was a successful, national championship trophy hoisting, abusive, hard ass. Alot of professional athletes are willing to take years off their lives by taking steroids to win games. Tell me one athlete who would not put up with Bobby Knight's crap for a season in exchange for a national championship?

  • Author

Are you kidding me? Think of it another way, a kid sees Olsen not get reprimanded and he thinks that his talent alone allows him to act like a punk. Besides, how many kids grow up thinking "I want to be a manager when I grow up"? Compare that to the number of little leaguers hoping to become pitchers. Which action sends the wrong message to more people?

 

I have absolutely no problem with what Girardi did. This is professional sports, not a freaking tea party. It's a physical game, and sometimes coaches may need to get a little physical to send a message to their players. End of story. Obviously, Olsen got the message. Had Girardi taken your advice, I'm sure Olsen would've ignored it just like he has probably ignored the same message from every coach he's had.

 

I'm sure a civil approach is preferred, but sometimes it's just not effective. No offense to any ball players, but alot of professional baseball players are complete idiots outside of that batters box or pitcher's mound. Many players develop huge egos, especially touted pitching prospects. Pitchers can singlehandedly influence a game more than any player. If you're good, that can get you real cocky and lead you to think that you always know best. Fact of the matter is, they don't. For better or for worse, that's the coaches job, and it may take a shirt pull or two to wake some of these young kids up to that reality.

 

As for "Joey Pitbull's" actions, Olsen isn't working in some cubicle, he's a baseball player. It comes with the job. Deal with it.

 

BTW You mentioned Bobby Knight. And how he "wouldn't be where he's at if he wasn't Bobby Knight." Not defending what the guy did, but he probably wouldn't have been so succesful as a basketball coach either. (Soon to be winningest coach in college basketball history). He was an abusive, hard ass, but he was a successful, national championship trophy hoisting, abusive, hard ass. Alot of professional athletes are willing to take years off their lives by taking steroids to win games. Tell me one athlete who would not put up with Bobby Knight's crap for a season in exchange for a national championship?

 

:lol

 

I agree with you here.

If Joe really grabbed his shirt, threw him to the wall and pinned him in a corner then I would have a problem with it. Some of these guys need this.

To compare this to Bobby Knight is quite a stretch.

 

 

Excatly.

 

Red Sox guy, you seem to have some beef with Joe Girardi other than this incident. I can sense something else, what gives ? Is it because he was a Yankee ?

A boss should NEVER grab an employee. Joe Girardi was wrong and owes Olsen a public apology. That being said, Scott Olsen better grow up fast.

He/she can't possibly feel this strongly about such a girly incident. I think he's/she's just arguing for the sake of arguing, being that it's him/her against all of us and that probably empowers him/her a bit. Or maybe he/she has a "touch" complex. Bottom line: It's best to ignore him/her.

A boss should NEVER grab an employee. Joe Girardi was wrong and owes Olsen a public apology. That being said, Scott Olsen better grow up fast.

 

 

 

You have to be kidding me. Hey, this is not a cozy office job we're talking about. This is physical labor with millions of dollars at stake. If a boss feels the need to pull a guy by his shirt (pulled by his shirt!? god forbid!) and give him some well deserved criticism, then so be it. If Olsen doesn't like it, he can always go to the safe confines of an 8 to 5 office job, where he can be assured that nobody will ever touch him.

I cant believe I just wasted 3 minutes of my life reading anything redsox fan wrote after his first post on this thread ! :banghead

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.