Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Scott O. vs. Joe G.

Featured Replies

I cant believe I just wasted 3 minutes of my life reading anything redsox fan wrote after his first post on this thread ! :banghead

 

 

 

I cant believe how cool your avatar is!

 

:bump

 

 

 

:respect

A young kid seeing that on TV...he'll think it's OK for him to grab other kids' shirts...

 

And Joey Pitbull claims his college education taught him how to work with people? Riiiiiiiight...

 

 

Are you kidding me? Think of it another way, a kid sees Olsen not get reprimanded and he thinks that his talent alone allows him to act like a punk. Besides, how many kids grow up thinking "I want to be a manager when I grow up"? Compare that to the number of little leaguers hoping to become pitchers. Which action sends the wrong message to more people?

 

I have absolutely no problem with what Girardi did. This is professional sports, not a freaking tea party. It's a physical game, and sometimes coaches may need to get a little physical to send a message to their players. End of story. Obviously, Olsen got the message. Had Girardi taken your advice, I'm sure Olsen would've ignored it just like he has probably ignored the same message from every coach he's had.

 

I'm sure a civil approach is preferred, but sometimes it's just not effective. No offense to any ball players, but alot of professional baseball players are complete idiots outside of that batters box or pitcher's mound. Many players develop huge egos, especially touted pitching prospects. Pitchers can singlehandedly influence a game more than any player. If you're good, that can get you real cocky and lead you to think that you always know best. Fact of the matter is, they don't. For better or for worse, that's the coaches job, and it may take a shirt pull or two to wake some of these young kids up to that reality.

 

As for "Joey Pitbull's" actions, Olsen isn't working in some cubicle, he's a baseball player. It comes with the job. Deal with it.

 

BTW You mentioned Bobby Knight. And how he "wouldn't be where he's at if he wasn't Bobby Knight." Not defending what the guy did, but he probably wouldn't have been so succesful as a basketball coach either. (Soon to be winningest coach in college basketball history). He was an abusive, hard ass, but he was a successful, national championship trophy hoisting, abusive, hard ass. Alot of professional athletes are willing to take years off their lives by taking steroids to win games. Tell me one athlete who would not put up with Bobby Knight's crap for a season in exchange for a national championship?

 

Admin Bird.

To compare this to Bobby Knight is quite a stretch.

 

 

Excatly.

 

Red Sox guy, you seem to have some beef with Joe Girardi other than this incident. I can sense something else, what gives ? Is it because he was a Yankee ?

 

I don't dislike Willie Randolph.

 

I just don't like control-freaks who focus on personal freedoms that have no effect on performance. Girardi is one.

A boss should NEVER grab an employee. Joe Girardi was wrong and owes Olsen a public apology. That being said, Scott Olsen better grow up fast.

 

Do you know the diffrence between an actual job and a sport that involves media and attention?

 

 

 

 

To compare this to Bobby Knight is quite a stretch.

 

 

Excatly.

 

Red Sox guy, you seem to have some beef with Joe Girardi other than this incident. I can sense something else, what gives ? Is it because he was a Yankee ?

 

I don't dislike Willie Randolph.

 

I just don't like control-freaks who focus on personal freedoms that have no effect on performance. Girardi is one.

Did you know Olsen has an attitude problem at times? did you not read what I said before? Giardi WAS justified in what he did. If one of your players under the age of 24 started mouthing off at an ump, do you think this would lead to good things in the future of this player and how other people viewed him? Giardi is trying to keep class to this young team.

 

It's like raising a children at times, they are all rooks and have no veteran to actually look up too. thats like allowing a five year old kid to cuss out his teacher and just watch it happen. They play the sport well, they are in the majors, just cause they can drive and are older then 21 does not mean they are mature in the sport and know they should act up on every ump.

A boss should NEVER grab an employee. Joe Girardi was wrong and owes Olsen a public apology. That being said, Scott Olsen better grow up fast.

 

 

Exactly.

 

Anbother way to look at it is that Joey Pitbull is a teacher of sorts and Olsen is a pupil. Teachers grabbing students? What message is THAT to a kid watching?

 

My wife is a teacher and tells me what Girardi did was wrong as well.

A boss should NEVER grab an employee. Joe Girardi was wrong and owes Olsen a public apology. That being said, Scott Olsen better grow up fast.

 

 

Exactly.

 

Anbother way to look at it is that Joey Pitbull is a teacher of sorts and Olsen is a pupil. Teachers grabbing students? What message is THAT to a kid watching?

 

My wife is a teacher and tells me what Girardi did was wrong as well.

 

People who are saying what he did was wrong are funny people. There are no cubicles and no 11 year old girls in the classroom.

 

I have a question...there has to be someone in here who was in the armed forces...If your ranking officer grabbed you by the shirt what would you do?

 

nothing because it is a part of the job to make you better.

 

Girardi was playing sargeant out there and he has every right to do it.

A boss should NEVER grab an employee. Joe Girardi was wrong and owes Olsen a public apology. That being said, Scott Olsen better grow up fast.

 

Do you know the diffrence between an actual job and a sport that involves media and attention?

 

 

 

 

To compare this to Bobby Knight is quite a stretch.

 

 

Excatly.

 

Red Sox guy, you seem to have some beef with Joe Girardi other than this incident. I can sense something else, what gives ? Is it because he was a Yankee ?

 

I don't dislike Willie Randolph.

 

I just don't like control-freaks who focus on personal freedoms that have no effect on performance. Girardi is one.

Did you know Olsen has an attitude problem at times? did you not read what I said before? Giardi WAS justified in what he did. If one of your players under the age of 24 started mouthing off at an ump, do you think this would lead to good things in the future of this player and how other people viewed him? Giardi is trying to keep class to this young team.

 

It's like raising a children at times, they are all rooks and have no veteran to actually look up too. thats like allowing a five year old kid to cuss out his teacher and just watch it happen. They play the sport well, they are in the majors, just cause they can drive and are older then 21 does not mean they are mature in the sport and know they should act up on every ump.

 

You know, Carl "The Clubhouse Cancer" Everett is the perfect encyclopedia description of "attitude problem" Even Jimy Williams never grabbed him or anything. Yeah, I know that Everett and Girardi would have literally destroyed each other. Yep..must be OK to grab a student. Seems that normally teachers get docked for that.

 

If Girardi had a brain, he'd have let Olsen cool down a bit before talking to him, not grabbing him.

 

Girardi bringing class to the franchise? USMC grooming standards? No wonder we got Beckett and Lowell...

 

I'd say championships are class. Leyland and McKeon brought class to the franchise.

 

 

 

A boss should NEVER grab an employee. Joe Girardi was wrong and owes Olsen a public apology. That being said, Scott Olsen better grow up fast.

 

 

Exactly.

 

Anbother way to look at it is that Joey Pitbull is a teacher of sorts and Olsen is a pupil. Teachers grabbing students? What message is THAT to a kid watching?

 

My wife is a teacher and tells me what Girardi did was wrong as well.

 

People who are saying what he did was wrong are funny people. There are no cubicles and no 11 year old girls in the classroom.

 

I have a question...there has to be someone in here who was in the armed forces...If your ranking officer grabbed you by the shirt what would you do?

 

nothing because it is a part of the job to make you better.

 

Girardi was playing sargeant out there and he has every right to do it.

 

 

News Flash!

 

The Marlins aren't the USMC!

 

Too bad Joey Pitbull thinks they are. I'm willing to bet that Girardi wanted to be in the military but was probably 4-F (most jocks are, believe it or not) so he becomes a DI when he becomes a manager. Playing DI may work in the USMC, but not with a baseball team

 

If I was Olsen, I'd grow a mustache right now...

Have you ever played Baseball before?

 

Everyone is different and some people need to be grabbed to get their attention.

 

It's not a big deal seriously. It's funny that when this happens in football no one says anything but yet a slight grab of the shirt and the boards go bonkers.

 

 

OH and if Olsen grew a mustache he would no longer be playing for the Marlins because either A) Suspended and/or B) Traded

 

Everyone is expendable simple as that.

I'd say championships are class. Leyland and McKeon brought class to the franchise.

 

This whole child/teacher analogy to professional athletes/coaches is a bit of a stretch but using Leyland as an example is odd. He went after Barry Bonds in Pittsburgh and would have tried to tear him apart, had no chance, but was so angry that a number of people had to separate them. Hmm, wonder if the Tuna should be told to take "nice" classes in Dallas. Now now Terrell, when you are bad it makes me feel unhappy, etc etc-spare me.

OH and if Olsen grew a mustache he would no longer be playing for the Marlins because either A) Suspended and/or B) Traded

 

Everyone is expendable simple as that.

 

 

 

A) Watch the Players Association file a grievance so fast, Joey Pitbull's head will spin.

 

The names Vern Rapp and Al Hrabosky ring any history bells?

 

B) I'd take him in Fenway in a second.

OH and if Olsen grew a mustache he would no longer be playing for the Marlins because either A) Suspended and/or B) Traded

 

Everyone is expendable simple as that.

 

 

 

A) Watch the Players Association file a grievance so fast, Joey Pitbull's head will spin.

 

The names Vern Rapp and Al Hrabosky ring any history bells?

 

B) I'd take him in Fenway in a second.

 

I love how no one says anything about the Yanks all being shaved. Probably why Boston has a problem with it or something :lol

 

But yea if he grew a mustache I will assure he would not be on this team.

OH and if Olsen grew a mustache he would no longer be playing for the Marlins because either A) Suspended and/or B) Traded

 

Everyone is expendable simple as that.

 

 

 

A) Watch the Players Association file a grievance so fast, Joey Pitbull's head will spin.

 

The names Vern Rapp and Al Hrabosky ring any history bells?

 

B) I'd take him in Fenway in a second.

 

I love how no one says anything about the Yanks all being shaved. Probably why Boston has a problem with it or something :lol

 

But yea if he grew a mustache I will assure he would not be on this team.

 

As much as I dislike the Yankees, they do allow mustaches, unless Ron Guidry and Tony Pena have been drinking chocolate milk and not wiping their upper lips.

 

Wonder if Girardi would have demanded to be traded from the '72 A's...?

 

 

Like I said...I'd take Olsen on the Sox...

OH and if Olsen grew a mustache he would no longer be playing for the Marlins because either A) Suspended and/or B) Traded

 

Everyone is expendable simple as that.

 

 

 

A) Watch the Players Association file a grievance so fast, Joey Pitbull's head will spin.

 

The names Vern Rapp and Al Hrabosky ring any history bells?

 

B) I'd take him in Fenway in a second.

Actually what would happen to Olsen is he'd be demoted, which may happen anyways when Martinez, German and Mitre are healthy. Olsen has plenty of options left. He doesn't do what he's told, adios.

 

And this idea that the Player's Association would intercede is just bulls***, plain and simple. Donald Fehr may be the chief steroid/drug enabler in the game but he knows where to pick his fights and he isn't going to war over an underachieving rookie's moustache.

OH and if Olsen grew a mustache he would no longer be playing for the Marlins because either A) Suspended and/or B) Traded

 

Everyone is expendable simple as that.

 

 

 

A) Watch the Players Association file a grievance so fast, Joey Pitbull's head will spin.

 

The names Vern Rapp and Al Hrabosky ring any history bells?

 

B) I'd take him in Fenway in a second.

Actually what would happen to Olsen is he'd be demoted, which may happen anyways when Martinez, German and Mitre are healthy. Olsen has plenty of options left. He doesn't do what he's told, adios.

 

And this idea that the Player's Association would intercede is just bulls***, plain and simple. Donald Fehr may be the chief steroid/drug enabler in the game but he knows where to pick his fights and he isn't going to war over an underachieving rookie's moustache.

 

See Bobby Tolan v The Reds and Al Hrabosky v Vern Rapp

No major league team can be forced to keep a player on it's 25 man roster who hasn't the required service time and/or available options.

 

Sorry but Hrabosky had seven or eight years of service time. The two are simply not comparable. Ditto Tolan.

No major league team can be forced to keep a player on it's 25 man roster who hasn't the required service time and/or available options.

 

Sorry but Hrabosky had seven or eight years of service time. The two are simply not comparable. Ditto Tolan.

 

 

Ummm...service time wasn't the point I was referring to here...

  • Author

If I hear the term Joey Pitbull again Im going to lose my lunch.

 

 

I agree. I am reading through this thread and I am thinking... Is the thread about Olsen and Joe or what?

I just love these new members (you know and We know who you are)who bird dog a topic and feel they have to respond to EVERY single post that disagrees with their opinion. Its an opinion remember the old saying what opinions are like? If a topic bothers you this damn much please go write a rambling blog about on your own website.

Girardi uses 'abrupt' measures

By Joe Capozzi

 

Palm Beach Post Staff Writer

 

Thursday, May 25, 2006

 

MIAMI GARDENS ? The Marlins defeated the Cubs in the bottom of the ninth inning Tuesday night, but the most memorable play wasn't Mike Jacobs' two-out, game-winning hit.

 

ESPN repeatedly showed manager Joe Girardi grabbing pitcher Scott Olsen by the jersey after the third inning and pulling him to the corner of the dugout for a chewing-out.

 

Girardi said it was his way of getting Olsen's attention after the pitcher became upset with umpire Bruce Froemming.

 

Because Olsen apparently took too long to get to the mound to open the third inning, Froemming only let him throw seven warm-up pitches instead of the usual eight.

 

When Olsen returned to the dugout after the inning, still complaining about Froemming, Girardi literally took matters into his own hands.

 

"I'm going to do things a different way sometimes,'' Girardi said Wednesday. "Sometimes I'm just going to go up and say, 'You know what? You've got to focus.' And sometimes I'm going to be abrupt and make sure I have their attention. I just grabbed him by the shirt and pulled him aside: 'Let's not get caught up with what happened. Make sure you're focused.' "

 

The Marlins think Olsen, who allowed four runs in five innings, will be more successful if he concentrates more on the team he is facing. "I understand him being upset, but that can't rule your evening,'' Girardi said. "Your energy has to be channeled at getting the hitters out and not on anything else. You've got to be able to turn the page.''

 

http://www.palmbeachpost.com/marlins/conte...notes_0625.html

  • Author

I'm going to do things a different way sometimes,'' Girardi said Wednesday. "Sometimes I'm just going to go up and say, 'You know what? You've got to focus.' And sometimes I'm going to be abrupt and make sure I have their attention. I just grabbed him by the shirt and pulled him aside: 'Let's not get caught up with what happened. Make sure you're focused.'

 

I agree with what Joe said. Some guys need to be told differently. Olsen is young and he 'might' have an attitude problem. A guy like Moe will probably be treated completely different.

I know from experience if someone tells you in a sweet/normal voice not to do something you probably won't take it seriously. But if someone was firm with you I bet you would act differently and think they were serious.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.